Phys · general-medicine
Cultural Competence and Indigenous Health (ANZ Context)
Also known as cultural safety · cultural competence · cultural awareness · Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health · First Nations health · Indigenous health · Maori health · Te Whare Tapa Wha · Treaty of Waitangi · Whanau Ora · Closing the Gap · rheumatic heart disease · acute rheumatic fever · Sorry Business · Stolen Generations · Aboriginal Health Worker · social determinants of health
Consultant-physician-depth guide to cultural safety, cultural competence and the health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples (Australia) and Maori (New Zealand) for FRACP DWE and DCE — the cultural safety framework (cultural awareness vs cultural competence vs cultural safety, with safety defined by the patient), the social determinants of health and the legacy of colonisation, the life-expectancy gap and the burden of disease (rheumatic heart disease, chronic kidney disease, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, mental health, chronic otitis media, scabies and skin sores), the ARF and RHD prevention pathway (primary prevention with Strep A management, secondary prevention with benzathine penicillin G IM every 3 to 4 weeks per RHD Australia 2020 guideline), the Maori health frameworks (Te Whare Tapa Wha, the Treaty of Waitangi principles of partnership participation and protection, Whanau Ora), the National Agreement on Closing the Gap, the RACP curriculum requirements, and the practical clinical approaches to culturally safe care — involving Aboriginal Health Workers, using professional interpreters, respecting Sorry Business, understanding kinship, building trust, and reflecting on one's own cultural identity and power.
On this page & tools
Your progress
Saved locally on this device.
Practise this topic
Target exams
Red flags
Opening: why this page matters
You are a physician registrar on a general medical ward. A 48-year-old Aboriginal woman from a remote community is admitted with decompensated heart failure from rheumatic mitral stenosis. She also has type 2 diabetes with an HbA1c of 84 mmol/mol, stage 3B chronic kidney disease, chronic otitis media with conductive hearing loss, and depression. She is 800 km from home, has not seen an Aboriginal Health Worker, and the team has labelled her "non-compliant" because she missed two benzathine penicillin injections. She is one of many. [1]
The health disparities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples in Australia and New Zealand are among the largest in the developed world. The life-expectancy gap for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples is approximately 8 years for males and 7.5 years for females, driven by cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic kidney disease, respiratory disease, cancer and mental illness. For Maori, the gap is approximately 7 years. These are preventable gaps, rooted in the social determinants of health and the legacy of colonisation, and they fall squarely within the physician's professional duty. [1]
This page gives you the cultural safety framework, the epidemiology, the key clinical conditions, the Maori health frameworks, and the practical approaches to care that you need for the FRACP DWE and DCE, and for the MRCP and ABIM equivalents. The RACP requires all physician trainees to demonstrate cultural competence — this is not optional, and it is not soft. It is core clinical practice. [1]
The cultural safety framework: awareness, competence and safety
The three concepts are not the same
The examiner will test whether you can distinguish three terms that are often conflated. [1]
Cultural awareness is the knowledge that other cultures exist and differ from your own. It is factual and passive. A clinician who has done cultural awareness training knows that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have a distinct cultural identity, that Sorry Business relates to death, that kinship systems exist. This is necessary but insufficient. [1]
Cultural competence is the set of attitudes, skills and knowledge that enable a clinician to work effectively with people of cultures different from their own. It includes the ability to communicate across cultures, to use interpreters, to involve Aboriginal Health Workers, and to adapt clinical practice. It is active and skills-based. [1]
Cultural safety is the endpoint, and it is defined by the patient, not the clinician. The encounter is culturally safe when the patient feels that their cultural identity has been respected, that the power imbalance inherent in the clinical relationship has been acknowledged and addressed, and that they have not been diminished by the interaction. The concept originated with Maori nurse educator Irihapeti Ramsden and is now embedded in the Australian and New Zealand health systems through the Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care and the Nursing Council of New Zealand. [1]
The critical distinction: a clinician can be culturally aware and culturally competent and still deliver culturally unsafe care, if they have not reflected on their own cultural identity, their own biases, and the power they hold. Cultural safety requires self-reflection on power. [1]
Self-reflection on cultural identity and power
The physician occupies a position of institutional power — the expertise, the hospital, the authority to admit, investigate, sedate and discharge. Many Indigenous patients carry a personal or family history of that power being used against them: forced removal of children (the Stolen Generations), involuntary treatment, experimental research without consent, everyday racism in the waiting room and the ward. [1]
Cultural safety asks the physician to name this power imbalance, to share decision-making, to be transparent about what is being done and why, and to work as a partner rather than an authority figure. The question is not "do I know about this patient's culture?" but "what does this patient experience when they meet me?" [1]
What cultural safety looks like at the bedside
In every encounter, the culturally safe physician: [1]
- Acknowledges Country (if known) and introduces themselves and their role
- Asks how the patient wishes to be identified (Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, First Nations, by their nation or language group)
- Offers the involvement of an Aboriginal Health Worker or Liaison Officer
- Uses a professional interpreter if there is any language barrier — never a family member, and never a child
- Takes a social history that illuminates the social determinants
- Considers the patient's distance from home and community in every plan
- Uses plain language and the teach-back method to confirm understanding
- Respects silence and a slower pace
- Is aware of Sorry Business, men's and women's business, and kinship obligations
- Reflects after the encounter on their own assumptions [1]
Social determinants and the legacy of colonisation
The causal chain
The health disparities are not random. They follow a causal chain that the physician must understand to treat the cause, not just the symptom. [1]
Colonisation — dispossession of land, suppression of language and culture, forced removal of children, institutionalisation and systemic racism — produced the social determinants that drive contemporary disease: overcrowded housing, unemployment, low income, limited education, food insecurity, poor access to clean water and functioning health hardware (washing machines, showers, safe food storage), and geographic isolation from health services. [1]
These social determinants produce the disease burden: group A streptococcal skin and throat infection in overcrowded houses drives acute rheumatic fever and post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis; food insecurity and a Western diet drive obesity and type 2 diabetes; smoking (at higher rates in Indigenous populations) drives cardiovascular and respiratory disease; chronic stress, racism and intergenerational trauma drive mental illness and substance use. [1]
Intergenerational trauma
The Stolen Generations — Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children forcibly removed from their families under assimilation policies from the early twentieth century through the 1970s — and their descendants carry a measurable burden of chronic disease, mental illness, substance use, and disconnection from culture and family. The physician who takes a family history must be alert to this history, because it shapes the patient's relationship with the health system and their capacity to engage with care. A patient whose grandmother was taken by the welfare system may reasonably fear that engaging with a hospital social worker will result in their own children being removed. [1]
The burden of disease: what the physician sees
Life expectancy
The gap in life expectancy between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and non-Indigenous Australians is approximately 8 years for males and 7.5 years for females (AIHW). For Maori, the gap is approximately 7 years. The National Agreement on Closing the Gap (2020) set a target to close the life-expectancy gap within a generation (by 2031); as of the most recent data, this target is not on track. [1]
The five conditions that drive the gap
The physician working with Indigenous patients will encounter the following conditions with a frequency and at an age that should prompt structured, early, aggressive management. They are the diseases of the long case and the MCQ. [1]
Rheumatic heart disease: the sentinel disease of disadvantage
Why it matters
Acute rheumatic fever (ARF) and rheumatic heart disease (RHD) are virtually eliminated in non-Indigenous Australians. In Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, particularly in remote communities of northern and central Australia, the incidence of ARF is among the highest reported globally. Indigenous Australians are approximately 15 times more likely to develop RHD than non-Indigenous Australians, and the death rate from RHD is up to 20 times higher. Indigenous Australians with RHD die on average in their mid-thirties; non-Indigenous Australians with RHD in their sixties. [1]
Pathophysiology in brief
Group A streptococcus (Strep A, also called GAS) pharyngitis (and possibly skin infection) triggers an autoimmune response in genetically susceptible individuals. The antibodies cross-react with host tissues (molecular mimicry), causing acute rheumatic fever — a systemic inflammatory illness affecting the heart, joints, skin, brain and subcutaneous tissue. Recurrent ARF causes cumulative damage to the cardiac valves, particularly the mitral valve (regurgitation progressing to stenosis) and the aortic valve. The damaged valves cause heart failure, atrial fibrillation, stroke, infective endocarditis and premature death. [1]
The prevention pathway
Primary prevention. Treat Strep A pharyngitis promptly with a single intramuscular dose of benzathine penicillin G (or a 10-day course of oral phenoxymethylpenicillin) to prevent the first episode of ARF. The challenge in remote communities is that many sore throats are not brought to medical attention, and the infrastructure for throat swabbing and treatment may be limited. [1]
Secondary prevention. After a confirmed episode of ARF, or in established RHD, give benzathine penicillin G 1.2 million units (900 mg) intramuscularly every 28 days (the standard interval in Australia, per the RHD Australia 2020 guideline, with a 21-day option for high-risk or breakthrough cases). Continue for a minimum of 10 years after the last ARF episode or until age 21 (whichever is longer) for ARF without carditis; for ARF with carditis (mild mitral regurgitation) until 10 years after the last episode or until age 21; for ARF with carditis (moderate to severe) or established RHD, until age 35 to 40 or longer. Adherence of at least 80 per cent of scheduled doses is the threshold for adequate protection; below 40 per cent is clinically equivalent to no prophylaxis. [1]
The revised Jones criteria for high-risk populations
The 2020 RHD Australia guideline uses the revised Jones criteria with specific, lower thresholds for high-risk populations (which includes Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples). In high-risk populations, the diagnosis of ARF can be made with: [1]
- Two major criteria, or one major plus two minor criteria, plus evidence of preceding Strep A infection
- Major criteria include carditis (clinical or subclinical on echocardiography), polyarthritis (or monoarthritis or polyarthralgia in high-risk populations), chorea, erythema marginatum, and subcutaneous nodules
- Minor criteria include fever, elevated ESR or CRP, prolonged PR interval, and (in high-risk populations) monoarthritis or polyarthralgia as a minor criterion [1]
The key point for the exam: in high-risk populations, the threshold for diagnosis is lower, subclinical carditis on echocardiography counts, and monoarthritis or polyarthralgia can substitute for polyarthritis. Missing the diagnosis means missing the opportunity for secondary prophylaxis and allowing recurrent ARF to destroy the valves. [1]
The practical challenges
The physician on the ward will encounter the patient who has missed injections, has absconded, has developed breakthrough ARF despite prophylaxis, or has presented late with established RHD and heart failure. The response is not to attribute blame but to address the system — the nurse-led penicillin program, the register and recall system, the transport and access barriers, the cultural safety of the injection service, and the patient's understanding of why the injection matters. [1]
Chronic kidney disease: the silent multiplier
The burden
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander adults have approximately double the prevalence of CKD compared with non-Indigenous Australians (an estimated 19 per cent of First Nations adults have biomedical signs of CKD). The incidence of end-stage kidney disease requiring dialysis or transplant is approximately 5 times higher overall and up to 20 times higher in very remote areas. CKD coexists with diabetes and cardiovascular disease in a cluster that accelerates each condition. [1]
The clinical approach
Screen annually from age 18 (or younger if risk factors are present): eGFR and urine albumin-to-creatinine ratio (ACR). An ACR above 3 mg/mmol indicates albuminuria; above 30 mg/mmol indicates clinically significant albuminuria warranting renin-angiotensin system blockade. [1]
Manage the diabetic or hypertensive patient with CKD aggressively: ACE inhibitor or ARB for albuminuria (titrated to maximum tolerated dose, monitoring potassium and creatinine), SGLT2 inhibitor for renal and cardiovascular protection (dapagliflozin or empagliflozin, dose-limited by eGFR), glycaemic control, blood pressure control (target below 130/80 if albuminuria), lipid management, and smoking cessation. [1]
Prepare for renal replacement therapy early. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients are less likely to be referred for transplant assessment and more likely to remain on facility-based haemodialysis. The physician's role is to ensure equitable referral for transplant, to discuss home-based modalities (peritoneal dialysis, home haemodialysis) that allow the patient to remain on country, and to involve the Indigenous kidney care services that exist in some jurisdictions. [1]
Type 2 diabetes: earlier, harder, faster
The clinical reality
Type 2 diabetes in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples presents earlier (often in the third or fourth decade), at lower BMI thresholds, and with more rapid progression to complications (diabetic kidney disease, retinopathy, neuropathy, diabetic foot, cardiovascular disease). The physician who applies the non-Indigenous timeline of "diabetes at 50, complications at 65" will be decades too late. [1]
Management principles
Start with metformin at diagnosis (dose-adjusted for eGFR). Add an SGLT2 inhibitor early for cardiovascular and renal protection. Consider GLP-1 receptor agonists for additional cardiovascular benefit and weight management. Intensify to insulin when oral agents fail to achieve target (HbA1c generally 53 to 58 mmol/mol, individualised). Screen annually for retinopathy (fundal photography through an outreach or telehealth service), nephropathy (eGFR and ACR), neuropathy (foot examination), and cardiovascular risk. Manage the diabetic foot aggressively — multidisciplinary foot clinic, offloading, debridement, antibiotics, and revascularisation where indicated. [1]
Integrate the diabetes care with the community-controlled health service, the diabetes educator, the dietitian, and the Aboriginal Health Worker. A management plan developed without the patient's community is a plan that will not be followed. [1]
Cardiovascular disease: earlier onset, higher mortality
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples experience cardiovascular disease at younger ages and with higher case fatality than non-Indigenous Australians. The contributors include the higher prevalence of conventional risk factors (smoking, diabetes, hypertension, CKD, obesity), the burden of RHD, and the social determinants (stress, racism, limited access to acute care). [1]
Assess cardiovascular risk from age 18 (not 35 as for the general population) using a validated tool. Recognise that the Framingham-based Australian Absolute Cardiovascular Disease Risk Calculator may underestimate risk in Indigenous patients, and that any patient with diabetes and microalbuminuria, established CKD, or prior RHD is automatically high-risk. Manage risk factors aggressively: statin therapy for high-risk patients (regardless of baseline LDL), blood pressure control, smoking cessation (culturally appropriate programs), and glycaemic control. [1]
Mental health, suicide and substance use
Mental illness, substance use and suicide are major contributors to the Indigenous burden of disease and to the life-expectancy gap (particularly through the loss of young adults). Suicide rates are approximately double those of non-Indigenous Australians, and the rates are highest in young people and in remote communities. [1]
The physician must ask about depression, anxiety, substance use and suicidal ideation directly and respectfully. Use culturally appropriate screening (the Kessler K5 or K10, adapted for Indigenous use). Recognise that distress may be expressed somatically or through cultural idioms that the standard instruments do not capture. Involve the Indigenous mental health worker, the community-controlled health service, and the social and emotional wellbeing team. When prescribing psychotropic medication, start low and go slow, consider comorbidities and substance use, and monitor for emergent suicidality. [1]
Otitis media, scabies and skin sores: the diseases of childhood that shape a life
Chronic suppurative otitis media
Chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) — persistent middle-ear infection with tympanic membrane perforation and discharge — is endemic in Aboriginal children in remote communities, with prevalence far exceeding the World Health Organization threshold that defines a public health problem (greater than 4 per cent). The consequences are conductive hearing loss (often bilateral and persistent from infancy through school years), speech and language delay, educational underachievement, and social and behavioural difficulties that persist into adulthood. [1]
Management requires dry mopping (ear toilet), topical antibiotic-steroid drops (after specialist assessment, and only if the tympanic membrane is perforated), systemic antibiotics for acute exacerbation, audiometric assessment, and ENT referral for consideration of tympanoplasty. Prevention — through improved housing, reduced overcrowding, smoking cessation, vaccination (pneumococcal, Haemophilus influenzae type b) — is as important as treatment. [1]
Scabies and skin sores
Scabies (caused by the mite Sarcoptes scabiei) and impetigo (caused by Strep pyogenes or Staph aureus) are endemic in remote Aboriginal communities, with prevalence of scabies around 20 to 30 per cent and impetigo up to 70 per cent in some studies. The conditions are "normalised" — so common that they are not recognised as abnormal by children, families, and sometimes health providers — which leads to under-treatment. [1]
The complications are serious: secondary bacterial infection can progress to cellulitis, abscess, sepsis, invasive Strep pyogenes disease, and post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis (causing acute kidney injury, hypertension, haematuria). There is a plausible (though debated) link between Strep A skin infection and acute rheumatic fever. [1]
Management: treat the individual (permethrin 5 per cent cream, or oral ivermectin 200 micrograms per kilogram), treat all household and close contacts simultaneously (because reinfestation is the rule when only the index case is treated), and treat secondary bacterial infection (single-dose intramuscular benzathine penicillin for Strep pyogenes impetigo, or oral antibiotics). Mass drug administration with ivermectin or permethrin, combined with environmental health measures (washing machines, functioning showers, reduced overcrowding), has been shown to reduce prevalence in community-led programs. [1]
Maori health: the New Zealand context
If you work in New Zealand, or see Maori patients in Australian hospitals, you must know the specific frameworks. Do not apply a generic "Indigenous health" lens; the Maori context has its own structures, grounded in the Treaty of Waitangi. [1]
Te Whare Tapa Wha (Sir Mason Durie, 1984)
Te Whare Tapa Wha (the four-sided house) is the foundational Maori health model. It frames health as requiring balance across four dimensions, each a wall of the meeting house (wharenui): [1]
- Te taha tinana (physical health) — the body, its growth, development and care. This is the dimension the biomedical physician knows best.
- Te taha hinengaro (mental and emotional health) — thoughts, feelings, the ability to communicate. Mind and body are inseparable.
- Te taha whanau (family and social health) — the extended family and community. The individual draws strength from and has obligations to the collective.
- Te taha wairua (spiritual health) — connection to heritage, values, beliefs, the land and the unseen. Often considered the foundation. [1]
If any wall is damaged, the house is unstable. The physician who assesses only taha tinana misses three dimensions. The model is applied in the clinical encounter by asking about whanau, wairua, and the patient's emotional state, and by designing a plan that supports the whole person. [1]
The Treaty of Waitangi (Te Tiriti o Waitangi, 1840)
The Treaty is the founding constitutional document of New Zealand and the basis for the Crown's (government's) relationship with Maori. In health, three principles are applied: [1]
- Partnership — Maori and the Crown working together at all levels of the health system, including governance, planning and service delivery.
- Participation — Maori involved at all levels of the health workforce and in decisions about their own care.
- Protection — ensuring Maori enjoy at least the same level of health as non-Maori, and safeguarding Maori cultural concepts, values and practices. [1]
These principles are operationalised through He Korowai Oranga (the Maori Health Strategy) and monitored through the Waitangi Tribunal and the health equity machinery of the NZ health system. The physician's role is to work in partnership (with Maori health workers, Maori governance), to enable participation (involving whanau, connecting to Maori services), and to protect (advocating for equitable outcomes, respecting cultural practice). [1]
Whanau Ora
Whanau Ora is a family-centred model of service delivery. A whanau ora navigator (kaiarahi) works with the whanau to identify their goals and coordinates the health, education and social services they need. It shifts the model from the individual patient with a disease to the family with a life. The physician supports this by making the whanau part of the care plan, by accepting that decisions may be made collectively, and by connecting the patient to the whanau ora service. [1]
Maori health disparities
Maori life expectancy is approximately 7 years below non-Maori. The gap is driven by cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cancer, respiratory disease and suicide. Maori are over-represented in RHD (though at lower rates than Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples). The social determinants (housing, income, education, racism, colonisation) are structurally similar. [1]
Closing the Gap: the national strategy
The National Agreement on Closing the Gap (2020) is a partnership between all Australian governments and the Coalition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peak Organisations. It established 19 socio-economic targets across life expectancy, healthy birthweight, children thriving in the early years, education, employment, housing, and the overarching priority of shared decision-making. [1]
Key targets relevant to the physician: [1]
- Close the gap in life expectancy within a generation (by 2031) — currently not on track
- Healthy birthweight (babies born of healthy birthweight) — on track in some measures
- Children thriving in their first five years — mixed
- Education targets (school attendance, Year 12 attainment) — mixed
- Employment — not on track
- Housing (increase the proportion of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people living in appropriately sized, not overcrowded housing) — partially on track [1]
The physician contributes to Closing the Gap not through any single act but through the accumulation of culturally safe, evidence-based, equitable care delivered in partnership with patients, families and community-controlled services. The individual clinical encounter — the diagnosis of ARF, the prescription of secondary prophylaxis, the referral for transplant, the management of diabetes, the response to self-discharge — is where the national strategy meets the patient. [1]
Practical clinical approaches
Involve the Aboriginal Health Worker and Liaison Officer
The Aboriginal Health Worker and the Aboriginal Liaison Officer are trained health professionals who bridge the cultural and linguistic gap between the patient and the health system. They know the patient and the community. They can advocate for the patient, explain the medical plan in culturally appropriate terms, and explain the patient's perspective to the team. Involve them from the outset of the admission, not as a last resort when the patient has already disengaged. [1]
Use a professional interpreter
If there is any language barrier, use a professional interpreter — in person, by phone, or by video. Never use a family member (especially a child) as an interpreter. Using a family member breaches confidentiality, distorts the message (the family member may filter or change the information), places an unacceptable burden on the family member, and is a failure of cultural safety. The Aboriginal Health Worker who speaks the patient's language is a valuable cultural and linguistic resource, but the physician should clarify the worker's role (cultural broker versus interpreter) and use a professional interpreter for formal medical consent. [1]
Respect Sorry Business
Sorry Business is the cultural practice and period of mourning following a death in the community. Practices vary by community and may include not using the name of the deceased person (or images), gathering for extended periods, observing silence, deferring non-urgent medical appointments, and specific protocols around the body and the funeral. The physician who is unaware of Sorry Business may misinterpret a patient's absence from a clinic as disengagement, or may inadvertently cause distress by using a deceased person's name. Ask the patient or the Aboriginal Health Worker about Sorry Business and respect the practices. [1]
Understand kinship and men's and women's business
Kinship systems in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures define relationships, obligations and roles in ways that differ from the Western nuclear family. Decisions about health care may be made collectively, with input from specific family members based on kinship. Men's business and women's business refer to cultural knowledge, practices and health matters that are gender-specific; a male patient may prefer a male examiner for certain matters, and a female patient may prefer a female examiner. Ask, respect and accommodate. [1]
Consider distance and remoteness
A patient who has travelled 800 km for specialist care may not be able to return for a follow-up appointment next week. The treatment plan must account for distance — can the care be delivered in the community, via telehealth, through an outreach specialist service, through the Aboriginal Medical Service, or through a shared-care arrangement? A plan that requires the patient to travel repeatedly to a distant centre is a plan that will fail. [1]
Take a social history
Ask: Where are you from? Who is at home with you? How is the housing? What do you do for work? How far did you come to get here? Has anything made it hard to get to appointments? Has anything happened in the health system before that made it hard to trust us? Listen for the story behind the disease. Use the information to build a plan that fits the patient's reality. [1]
The RACP curriculum requirement
The RACP requires all physician trainees to demonstrate cultural competence as part of the Professional Practice domain. This includes: [1]
- Understanding the health status of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and Maori
- Reflecting on one's own cultural identity and biases
- Providing culturally safe care
- Knowledge of the impact of colonisation and racism on health
- Working effectively with Aboriginal Health Workers and community-controlled health services [1]
This is assessed through the DWE (in the Professional Practice component of the written examination) and the DCE (in the long case, the short case, and the communication elements). A candidate who demonstrates excellent biomedical knowledge but fails to address the cultural and social dimensions of an Indigenous patient's care will not pass. [1]
DCE long case: how to present the Indigenous patient
The opening statement (SASPOP)
"This is a 48-year-old Aboriginal woman from a remote community in the Northern Territory, a homemaker, presenting with decompensated heart failure from rheumatic mitral stenosis, with comorbid type 2 diabetes, chronic kidney disease stage 3B, chronic otitis media with hearing loss, and depression." [1]
The problem list
- Decompensated heart failure secondary to rheumatic mitral stenosis
- Type 2 diabetes mellitus (HbA1c 84 mmol/mol) with suboptimal control [1]3. Chronic kidney disease stage 3B (eGFR 38) with albuminuria
- Chronic suppurative otitis media with bilateral conductive hearing loss
- Depression (under-treated)
- Suboptimal adherence to secondary penicillin prophylaxis for RHD
- Social and cultural context: 800 km from home, no Aboriginal Health Worker involved, history of disengagement from health services, housing overcrowding [1]
The integrated plan
For each problem, state the immediate management, the definitive management, and the culturally safe follow-up plan that involves the Aboriginal Medical Service, the specialist outreach team, the Aboriginal Health Worker, and the patient and family. Address the social determinants (housing referral through the environmental health worker, transport assistance through the patient assistance travel scheme). Demonstrate insight into why this patient has this burden of disease at this age, and what the physician will do differently to earn this patient's trust. [1]
DCE short case and communication station
The cardiovascular examination in an Indigenous patient
Explain what you are going to do and why. Ask permission before touching. Be aware of gender preferences (men's and women's business). Observe for the stigmata of RHD (mitral facies, raised JVP, displaced apex beat, diastolic thrill, murmurs of mitral stenosis and regurgitation, signs of heart failure). Present the findings with the differential (rheumatic versus degenerative versus congenital) and the plan (echocardiography, secondary prophylaxis if RHD confirmed, involvement of the Aboriginal Health Worker, follow-up through the outreach service). [1]
The communication station
Describe the encounter: the setting (private, adequate time, Aboriginal Health Worker present if the patient wished), the techniques (acknowledging Country, plain language, teach-back, open questions, respect for silence), the social and cultural information gathered (home, family, distance, barriers to care), the plan explained and confirmed, the follow-up arranged, and the reflection on your own assumptions and what you would do differently next time. [1]
Common exam traps
The disease-in-isolation trap. Treating the RHD, the diabetes and the CKD as three separate problems rather than one story of cumulative disadvantage. The examiner is testing whether you see the whole patient and the social determinants. [1]
The cultural awareness equals cultural safety trap. Knowing facts about the culture is not the same as the patient feeling safe. Cultural safety requires self-reflection on power. A candidate who lists cultural facts but does not reflect on their own position will not score well. [1]
The family-interpreter trap. Using a family member (especially a child) as an interpreter is always wrong. A professional interpreter must be used. [1]
The wrong penicillin trap. The correct agent is benzathine penicillin G (Bicillin-LA), every 28 days, deep intramuscular. The combination procaine-benzathine product (Bicillin-C) is different. Monthly (as in 4 to 5 weeks) allows drift and sub-therapeutic levels. [1]
The equal-means-equitable trap. Treating every patient identically perpetuates inequality. Equitable care means directing additional resources and adapting the model of care to the patient's circumstances. [1]
The generic-Indigenous trap. Do not apply the Australian Aboriginal framework to a Maori patient without naming the Treaty of Waitangi, Te Whare Tapa Wha and Whanau Ora. The frameworks are specific and must be named correctly. [1]
The blame-the-patient trap. Self-discharge, missed appointments and "non-compliance" are signals that the system has failed, not that the patient has failed. The response is to ask why and address the cause. [1]
Key points for the registrar
- Cultural safety is defined by the patient. It requires self-reflection on your own cultural identity, biases and power.
- The health disparities are rooted in the social determinants and the legacy of colonisation. Treat the cause, not just the symptom.
- RHD is the sentinel disease. Know the prevention pathway: primary (treat Strep A), secondary (benzathine penicillin G every 28 days), the revised Jones criteria for high-risk populations, and the RHD Australia 2020 guideline.
- CKD, diabetes and cardiovascular disease cluster and accelerate. Screen early, manage aggressively, and prepare for renal replacement therapy planning.
- Involve the Aboriginal Health Worker. Use a professional interpreter. Respect Sorry Business. Consider distance and community in every plan.
- For Maori patients, apply Te Whare Tapa Wha (four dimensions), the Treaty principles (partnership, participation, protection) and Whanau Ora (family-centred care).
- Closing the Gap is the national strategy. The physician contributes through every culturally safe, evidence-based, equitable clinical encounter. [1]
References
- [1]Katzenellenbogen JM, Bond-Smith D, Seth RJ, et al. Contemporary Incidence and Prevalence of Rheumatic Fever and Rheumatic Heart Disease in Australia Using Linked Data: The Case for Policy Change J Am Heart Assoc, 2020.PMID 32924748
- [2]Cannon JW, Karkhidze T, Tungu M, et al Improving primary care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people with rheumatic heart disease: What can I do? Aust J Gen Pract, 2022.PMID 36451330
- [3]Truong M, Gibbs A, Paradies Y, et al Systematic review of Indigenous cultural safety training interventions for healthcare professionals in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States BMJ Open, 2023.PMID 37793931
- [4]Bowen AC, Carapetis JR, Currie BJ, et al Skin infections in Australian Aboriginal children: a narrative review Med J Aust, 2020.PMID 31630410
- [5]Yeoh DK, Bowen AC, Carapetis JR. Are scabies and impetigo normalised? A cross-sectional comparative study of hospitalised children in northern Australia assessing clinical recognition and treatment of skin infections PLoS Negl Trop Dis, 2017.PMID 28671945
- [6]Loczenski CL, Bowen AC, Carapetis JR, et al Scabies and risk of skin sores in remote Australian Aboriginal communities: A self-controlled case series study PLoS Negl Trop Dis, 2018.PMID 30044780
- [7]Dunlop WA, et al. Characteristics and outcomes of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients with dialysis-dependent kidney disease in Australian intensive care units Intern Med J, 2022.PMID 33012108
- [8]Kairuz CA, Casanelia LM, Stowers K, et al Healthcare professionals' cultural safety practices for indigenous peoples in the acute care setting - a scoping review Contemp Nurse, 2023.PMID 37864826