Near-Drowning
Hypoxia is the primary cause of death - start rescue breathing immediately, even before checking for a pulse... ACEM Fellowship Written, ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Clinical board
A visual summary of the highest-yield teaching signals on this page.
Urgent signals
Safety-critical features pulled from the topic metadata.
- Immersion time > 25 minutes
- No return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) at scene
- Asystole on presentation
- Fixed dilated pupils
Exam focus
Current exam surfaces linked to this topic.
- ACEM Fellowship Written
- ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Linked comparisons
Differentials and adjacent topics worth opening next.
- Cardiac Arrest Paediatric
- Accidental Hypothermia
Editorial and exam context
Quick Answer
One-liner: Drowning is a process of respiratory impairment from submersion/immersion in liquid; immediate priority is reversing hypoxemia through rescue breathing and CPR, with ongoing management focusing on pulmonary, neurological, and systemic complications.
30-second summary: Near-drowning (non-fatal drowning) is defined as survival after submersion, with outcomes ranging from complete recovery to severe neurologic injury. The primary pathophysiology is hypoxemia, whether from laryngospasm ("dry drowning"
- obsolete term) or aspiration ("wet drowning"). Immersion time is the most important prognostic factor: below 5 minutes has high survival, 10-25 minutes carries significant risk, and greater than 25 minutes is rarely survivable except in very cold water. Immediate resuscitation with rescue breathing takes priority over pulse checks. Hypothermia can be neuroprotective if rapid (cold water submersion), requiring continued resuscitation until rewarming to 32-34°C. Complications include ARDS, secondary pneumonia, hypoxic brain injury, and multi-organ dysfunction. Australian epidemiology shows children 0-4 years have highest incidence, with Indigenous children 2-3 times higher drowning rates.
ACEM Exam Focus
Primary Exam Relevance
- Anatomy: Laryngeal anatomy, laryngospasm reflex, pulmonary surfactant distribution, alveolar-capillary membrane
- Physiology: Hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction, surfactant function, V/Q mismatch, hypothermia-induced metabolic changes, diving reflex
- Pharmacology: No specific drowning antidotes; sedatives for intubated patients, antibiotics for secondary infection
Fellowship Exam Relevance
- Written: Drowning classification, pathophysiology (surfactant washout, alveolar-capillary injury), hypothermia management, prognostication (immersion time, ROSC, initial rhythm), complications (ARDS, pneumonia, hypoxic brain injury), Szpilman drowning grades
- OSCE: Resuscitation station (ABCDE approach, hypothermia management), Communication station (family education about prognosis), Procedure station (intubation and ventilation strategies)
- Key domains tested: Medical Expert (resuscitation, management), Collaborator (team leadership, retrieval), Professional (futility discussions, cultural safety)
Key Points
The 5 things you MUST know:
- Hypoxia is the primary cause of death - start rescue breathing immediately, even before checking for a pulse
- Immersion time is the most important prognostic factor - below 5 min excellent, 5-10 min moderate, 10-25 min poor, greater than 25 min rare survival
- Continue CPR until warm - in hypothermic drowning, resuscitate until core temperature reaches 32-34°C ("no one is dead until they are warm and dead")
- "Dry" vs "wet" drowning is obsolete - 85-90% of victims aspirate water; hypoxemia is the common pathway
- Indigenous children have 2-3x higher drowning rates - cultural safety and water safety education are essential
Epidemiology
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence (Australia) | 3.5 per 100,000/year | [1] |
| Global mortality | 236,000 deaths/year (WHO) | [2] |
| Peak age groups | 0-4 years, 15-24 years | [3] |
| Male:Female ratio | 3:1 (children), 2:1 (adults) | [4] |
| Hospitalized mortality | 6-10% | [5] |
| Full neurological recovery | 65-75% of survivors | [6] |
| Permanent neurologic injury | 5-15% of survivors | [7] |
Australian/NZ Specific
- Annual drowning deaths: ~280 per year in Australia, ~90 per year in NZ
- Leading locations: Rivers (27%), Beaches (24%), Swimming pools (15%) [8]
- Peak season: November-February (summer months)
- Children 0-4 years: 4.5 per 100,000 (highest incidence), most common in home swimming pools
- Indigenous children: 2.5-3x higher drowning rates compared to non-Indigenous [9]
- Māori children (NZ): 2-2.5x higher drowning rates compared to non-Māori [10]
- Rural/remote: 1.8x higher drowning rates, related to unattended water bodies and delayed rescue
Pathophysiology
Mechanism
Drowning is a process of respiratory impairment from submersion or immersion in liquid, leading to hypoxia. The sequence is:
- Breath-holding: Voluntary or involuntary upon submersion
- Hypercapnia: CO₂ accumulation as PaCO₂ rises
- Involuntary gasping: As PaCO₂ rises above 50-55 mmHg and PaO₂ falls
- Laryngospasm or aspiration: Water contact with larynx triggers protective reflex
- Hypoxemia: Inadequate oxygen delivery to tissues
- Cardiac arrhythmias: Hypoxia-induced myocardial depression, eventually asystole
Pathophysiological Pathways
Submersion → Breath-hold → Hypercapnia/Hypoxia → Gasping →
│
├─→ Laryngospasm (10-15% at autopsy) → Hypoxia without aspiration ("dry" drowning)
│
└─→ Aspiration (85-90%) → Surfactant washout → Alveolar collapse → V/Q mismatch → Hypoxia
↓
Alveolar-capillary injury → Pulmonary edema → ARDS → Respiratory failure
Key Pathophysiological Processes
1. Surfactant Destruction
- Water (fresh or salt) washes out pulmonary surfactant
- Small amounts (1-3 mL/kg) sufficient to cause significant surfactant loss
- Loss of surfactant → alveolar collapse (atelectasis) → decreased lung compliance
- Result: V/Q mismatch, intrapulmonary shunting, refractory hypoxemia
2. Alveolar-Capillary Membrane Injury
- Aspirated fluid triggers inflammatory cascade
- Direct chemical injury to type I and II pneumocytes
- Increased capillary permeability → non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema
- Fluid-filled alveoli further impair gas exchange
3. Fresh Water vs. Salt Water (Clinical Management Identical)
| Feature | Fresh Water (Hypotonic) | Salt Water (Hypertonic) |
|---|---|---|
| Electrolyte effects | Hypervolemia, hemodilution, hypokalemia (minor) | Hypovolemia, hemoconcentration, hypernatremia (minor) |
| Fluid shifts | Rapid absorption into circulation | Draws fluid from vasculature into alveoli |
| Clinical impact | Surfactant washout dominates | Pulmonary edema dominates |
Note: In practice, the clinical presentation and management are identical for both types. [11]
4. Laryngospasm ("Dry Drowning")
- Reflex closure of vocal cords triggered by water contact
- Prevents water entry but also prevents oxygenation
- Historically thought to cause death without water in lungs (10-15% at autopsy)
- Modern consensus: "dry" lungs at autopsy may be due to water absorption or post-mortem changes; true laryngospasm death likely rare
- WHO and ILCOR have abandoned "dry vs wet" terminology - simply "drowning" (fatal or non-fatal) [12]
5. Diving Reflex (Protective in Cold Water)
- Bradycardia, peripheral vasoconstriction, apnea
- Most prominent in children and mammals
- Reduces cerebral oxygen consumption
- Shunts blood to heart and brain
- Contributes to "miracle" survivals in cold water submersions [13]
6. Hypoxic Brain Injury
- Cerebral metabolic rate for O₂: ~3.5 mL/100g/min
- Hypoxia leads to anaerobic metabolism → ATP depletion → cellular failure
- Neuronal death begins within 4-6 minutes of complete hypoxia
- Cold water (rapid cooling) can extend tolerance to 10-15 minutes in children
Why It Matters Clinically
Understanding the pathophysiology guides management:
- Immediate rescue breathing reverses hypoxemia, the primary cause of death
- Ventilation priority over circulation - chest compressions alone ineffective without oxygenation
- Lung-protective ventilation - alveoli are damaged, avoid high pressures
- Antibiotics not prophylactic - initial injury is chemical/mechanical, not infectious
- Hypothermia considerations - differentiate between protective rapid cooling vs. indicator of prolonged submersion
Clinical Approach
Recognition
Drowning should be suspected in any patient with:
- History of submersion or immersion in water (any duration)
- Rescue from water by bystanders or emergency services
- Found unresponsive near water bodies
- Respiratory distress or arrest after water exposure
Triggers for emergency activation: Submersion greater than 1 minute, altered mental status, respiratory distress, cardiac arrest
Initial Assessment
Primary Survey
IMMEDIATE ACTIONS (DO NOT DELAY):
- Remove from water safely (do not become a victim)
- If unresponsive: CALL FOR HELP, START RESCUE BREATHING IMMEDIATELY
- Check breathing (look, listen, feel for 10 seconds) - if absent: start rescue breaths
- Check carotid pulse (10 seconds) - if absent: start full CPR
- Remove wet clothing, dry patient, prevent heat loss
-
A: Airway
- Cervical spine immobilization only if high-risk mechanism (diving, trauma, fall into water)
- Head tilt-chin lift unless cervical spine injury suspected
- Suction oropharynx to remove foreign material (vomitus, algae, debris)
- Oropharyngeal airway if GCS below 8 (no gag reflex)
-
B: Breathing
- Assess respiratory rate, effort, work of breathing
- "Auscultate: rales, wheeze, decreased breath sounds, crackles"
- "Pulse oximetry: may be inaccurate due to hypothermia"
- "Supplemental oxygen: 15 L/min via non-rebreather mask (if breathing)"
-
C: Circulation
- Check pulses (carotid, femoral) - may be weak/thready
- Capillary refill time (greater than 4 seconds suggests hypovolemia/hypothermia)
- "Blood pressure: may be low due to hypovolemia or cardiac depression"
- "Cardiac monitoring: arrhythmias common (sinus bradycardia, AFib, asystole)"
- Obtain IV access (preferably two large-bore lines)
-
D: Disability
- GCS score on arrival
- "Pupils: size, symmetry, reactivity (fixed/dilated = poor prognostic sign)"
- Motor response, verbal response, eye opening
- "Check for hypothermia: shivering, altered mental status"
-
E: Exposure/Environment
- Remove all wet clothing immediately
- Dry thoroughly, prevent heat loss
- Check core temperature (rectal or esophageal probe preferred)
- Look for signs of trauma (bruising, lacerations from water rescue)
- Check for signs of envenomation if in Australian waters (jellyfish stings, snake bites)
History
Key Questions
| Question | Significance |
|---|---|
| What was the immersion time? | Most important prognostic factor |
| Water temperature? | Cold water (below 5°C) = neuroprotective potential; warm water = worse prognosis |
| Was there loss of consciousness? | Indicates severity |
| Was water aspirated? (coughing, choking) | Indicates aspiration risk |
| How long until CPR started? | Bystander CPR improves outcomes |
| Any co-ingestion? (alcohol, drugs) | Contributing factor |
| Medical history? (seizures, cardiac, developmental delay) | May explain submersion |
| Activity at time of drowning? (swimming, diving, boating) | Mechanism of injury |
Red Flag Symptoms
Critical Presentation:
- Immersion time greater than 25 minutes (rare survival unless very cold water)
- Asystole on presentation
- Fixed dilated pupils
- No return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) after 30 minutes of CPR
- Severe metabolic acidosis (pH below 7.0, bicarbonate below 10)
- Core temperature below 28°C with prolonged immersion
- Witnessed trauma (diving, fall) - cervical spine injury risk
Examination
General Inspection
- Wet clothing, hypothermia (shivering, confusion, pale/cool skin)
- Respiratory distress: tachypnea, accessory muscle use, nasal flaring
- Evidence of trauma: bruising, lacerations, deformities
- Foamy pulmonary edema (may be pink-frothy sputum)
Specific Findings
| System | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Respiratory | Tachypnea, rales, crackles, wheeze | Surfactant washout, pulmonary edema, ARDS |
| Cardiovascular | Bradycardia (cold water), hypotension | Hypothermia, hypovolemia, myocardial depression |
| Neurological | Coma, seizures, decerebrate posturing | Hypoxic brain injury severity |
| Abdominal | Distension, absent bowel sounds | Gastric aspiration, gut edema |
| Skin | Cyanosis, cold, clammy | Hypothermia, hypoxemia |
Investigations
Immediate (Resus Bay)
| Test | Purpose | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| 12-lead ECG | Assess for arrhythmias, QT prolongation | Sinus bradycardia (cold water), arrhythmias |
| Arterial Blood Gas | Assess acid-base status, oxygenation | Metabolic acidosis, hypoxemia, hypercarbia |
| Chest X-ray | Assess for pulmonary edema, aspiration | Bilateral infiltrates (worse in dependent zones), ARDS pattern |
| Point-of-Care Glucose | Rule out hypoglycemia (differential for AMS) | May be low or normal |
| Core Temperature | Determine hypothermia severity | below 28°C = severe, 28-32°C = moderate, 32-35°C = mild |
| Blood Group and Screen | Prepare for potential transfusion | May be needed for massive transfusion |
Standard ED Workup
| Test | Indication | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Full Blood Count | All patients | Anemia (hemodilution), leukocytosis (stress) |
| Electrolytes, Urea, Creatinine | All patients | Electrolyte disturbances (hypokalemia in freshwater, hypernatremia in saltwater), AKI |
| Liver Function Tests | All patients | Hepatic injury from hypoxia |
| Coagulation Profile | All patients | Coagulopathy from hypothermia/DIC |
| Troponin | Suspected cardiac involvement | Myocardial injury from hypoxia |
| Serum Toxicology | Suspected ingestion | Alcohol, drugs, toxins |
| CT Brain | GCS below 8, trauma suspected, focal neuro deficits | Cerebral edema, hypoxic injury, intracranial hemorrhage |
Advanced/Specialist
| Test | Indication | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| CT Chest | Suspected aspiration of foreign bodies, trauma | Tertiary centres |
| Bronchoscopy | Suspected airway foreign body, massive aspiration | Tertiary centres |
| EEG | Seizures, unexplained coma | Tertiary centres |
| MRI Brain | Detailed neuro assessment (prognostication) | Tertiary centres |
| Echocardiography | Cardiac function assessment, exclusion of structural heart disease | Tertiary centres |
Point-of-Care Ultrasound
POCUS is valuable in drowning assessment:
-
Lung Ultrasound:
- B-lines (comet tails) = pulmonary edema (surfactant washout, ARDS)
- Consolidation = aspiration pneumonia
- Pleural effusion (rare in drowning)
-
Cardiac Ultrasound:
- Assess cardiac function (myocardial depression from hypoxia)
- Wall motion abnormalities
- Confirm cardiac activity in cardiac arrest
-
Abdominal Ultrasound:
- Gastric distension (aspiration of water)
- Assess for ascites (rare)
Management
Immediate Management (First 10 minutes)
1. REMOVE FROM WATER (safety first)
2. CALL FOR HELP (activate Code Blue if needed)
3. START RESCUE BREATHING IMMEDIATELY (do not delay for pulse check)
4. CHECK PULSE (10 seconds), start full CPR if absent
5. SUPPLEMENTARY OXYGEN (15 L/min via non-rebreather)
6. REMOVE WET CLOTHING, DRY, PREVENT HEAT LOSS
7. INSERT OROPHARYNGEAL AIRWAY (if GCS below 8)
8. OBTAIN IV ACCESS (two large-bore lines)
9. MONITOR: ECG, SpO2, BP, temperature
10. PREPARE FOR INTUBATION (respiratory failure, GCS below 8)
Resuscitation
Airway
Indications for Intubation:
- GCS below 8
- Severe respiratory distress (respiratory rate greater than 30, accessory muscle use)
- Hypoxemia despite supplemental oxygen (SpO2 below 92% on 15 L/min)
- Inability to protect airway (vomiting, aspiration)
- Severe pulmonary edema/ARDS
Rapid Sequence Intubation (RSI):
- Pre-oxygenation: 100% O₂ for 3-5 minutes (if not vomiting)
- Induction: Ketamine 1-2 mg/kg IV (hemodynamically stable, preserves airway reflexes) OR Etomidate 0.3 mg/kg IV
- Paralysis: Rocuronium 1.2 mg/kg IV OR Suxamethonium 1-2 mg/kg IV
- Post-intubation: Confirm placement (ETCO₂ waveform, chest rise, auscultation)
Cervical Spine Considerations:
- Immobilize if high-risk mechanism (diving, fall into water, trauma)
- Apply cervical collar in-line with airway management
- Consider manual in-line stabilization during intubation
Breathing
Initial Ventilator Settings:
- Mode: Pressure-controlled ventilation (PCV) or Volume-controlled ventilation (VCV)
- Target tidal volume: 6-8 mL/kg (ideal body weight) - lung-protective
- FiO₂: Start 100%, titrate to SpO2 94-98%
- PEEP: 5-10 cm H₂O (recruit alveoli, improve oxygenation)
- Inspiratory pressure limit: ≤30 cm H₂O (prevent barotrauma)
- I:E ratio: 1:2
- Respiratory rate: 12-16 breaths/min
Lung-Protective Ventilation:
- Aim for plateau pressure below 30 cm H₂O
- Permissive hypercapnia (PaCO₂ 50-80 mmHg) if needed to limit pressures
- High PEEP (up to 15 cm H₂O) for ARDS
- Recruitment maneuvers if refractory hypoxemia
Proning (severe ARDS):
- Consider for PaO₂/FiO₂ below 100 despite optimal ventilation
- Improves V/Q matching in dependent lung zones
- Prone for 16-18 hours daily
Circulation
Hemodynamic Support:
- IV fluids: Crystalloid bolus (10-20 mL/kg) for hypotension
- Vasopressors if hypotension persists:
- Norepinephrine 0.05-0.5 mcg/kg/min IV (first-line)
- Epinephrine 0.01-0.1 mcg/kg/min IV (severe myocardial depression)
- Inotropes if cardiac dysfunction:
- Dobutamine 2-20 mcg/kg/min IV (cardiac dysfunction, low CO)
Management of Hypothermia:
| Temperature Category | Core Temp | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Mild | 32-35°C | Passive external warming, remove wet clothing, blankets |
| Moderate | 28-32°C | Active external warming (forced-air warming blankets), warmed IV fluids |
| Severe | below 28°C | Active rewarming + internal rewarming (warm peritoneal lavage, ECMO if available) |
Rewarming Techniques:
- Passive: Remove wet clothing, dry patient, insulate with blankets, increase ambient temperature
- Active External: Forced-air warming blankets (Bair Hugger), radiant warmers
- Active Internal (severe hypothermia):
- Warmed IV fluids (40-42°C) - 10-20 mL/kg boluses
- Warm peritoneal lavage (dialysate warmed to 40-42°C)
- Thoracic lavage (via chest tubes)
- Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) - definitive for severe hypothermia with cardiac arrest
Special Consideration in Cardiac Arrest with Hypothermia:
- "No one is dead until they are warm and dead"
- Continue CPR until core temperature ≥32-34°C
- Reduce drug intervals (every 6-8 minutes) due to slowed metabolism
- Defibrillation: first shock as normal, subsequent shocks after 2°C temperature increments above 30°C
- Epinephrine: 1 mg IV every 6-8 minutes (vs. 3-5 minutes in normothermia)
- Consider termination of resuscitation only after achieving core temperature 32-34°C and no ROSC
Medications
| Drug | Dose | Route | Timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oxygen | 15 L/min | Non-rebreather mask | Immediate | Titrate to SpO2 94-98% |
| Ketamine | 1-2 mg/kg | IV | RSI | Preserves airway reflexes, cardiovascular stable |
| Etomidate | 0.3 mg/kg | IV | RSI | Hemodynamically stable, consider adrenal suppression |
| Rocuronium | 1.2 mg/kg | IV | RSI | Long-acting paralysis |
| Suxamethonium | 1-2 mg/kg | IV | RSI | Short-acting, avoid with hyperkalemia |
| Norepinephrine | 0.05-0.5 mcg/kg/min | IV infusion | Persistent hypotension | First-line vasopressor |
| Epinephrine | 1 mg IV (cardiac arrest) | IV bolus | CPR | Every 6-8 min in hypothermia |
| Antibiotics | Ceftriaxone 2g IV q24h | IV | Proven infection | NOT prophylactic |
| Furosemide | 20-40 mg IV | IV | Pulmonary edema | Consider if fluid overload |
Paediatric Dosing
| Drug | Dose | Max | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ketamine | 1-2 mg/kg | 100 mg | Safe in children |
| Etomidate | 0.3 mg/kg | 20 mg | Consider adrenal suppression in pediatric sepsis |
| Rocuronium | 1.2 mg/kg | 100 mg | Age-appropriate sizing |
| Norepinephrine | 0.05-0.1 mcg/kg/min | 2 mcg/kg/min | Start low, titrate |
| Ceftriaxone | 50-75 mg/kg | 2 g | Daily for pneumonia |
Ongoing Management
After Initial Stabilization:
-
Ventilation Management:
- Continue lung-protective ventilation
- Daily sedation holds, spontaneous breathing trials
- Wean PEEP gradually as lung compliance improves
- Extubation criteria: SpO2 greater than 94% on FiO2 ≤0.4, PEEP ≤5 cm H₂O, GCS greater than 8
-
Neurological Monitoring:
- Daily GCS assessment
- EEG for subclinical seizures (30% of comatose drowning survivors)
- Consider therapeutic hypothermia for comatose survivors (32-36°C for 24h)
-
Fluid Management:
- Restrictive fluid strategy (euvolemia)
- Daily fluid balance, target negative or neutral
- Diuretics if pulmonary edema persists
-
Antibiotics:
- NOT prophylactic
- Start if clinical signs of infection (fever greater than 38.5°C, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates, leukocytosis)
- Broad-spectrum initially, then culture-directed:
- Ceftriaxone 2g IV q24h (covers community organisms)
- Add Vancomycin if MRSA suspected (healthcare exposure)
- Consider Aztreonam for Pseudomonas (freshwater aspiration)
- Consider Doxycycline for Vibrio (saltwater aspiration)
-
ECMO Considerations:
- Indications: Refractory hypoxemia despite optimal ventilation, PaO2/FiO2 below 80, severe ARDS
- VV-ECMO for respiratory failure
- VA-ECMO for cardiac failure or combined cardiorespiratory failure
- Discuss early with tertiary centre (within 6-12 hours of presentation)
Definitive Care
ICU Admission Criteria:
- Respiratory failure requiring intubation
- GCS below 8 or deteriorating neurological status
- Hemodynamic instability requiring vasopressors
- Severe hypothermia (below 32°C)
- ARDS requiring advanced ventilation (high PEEP, proning)
- Comorbidities (seizure disorder, cardiac disease)
Observation Admission Criteria:
- Asymptomatic patients with immersion time below 5 minutes
- Normal examination, normal SpO2 on room air
- No hypoxemia on ABG
- Normal CXR
- Minimum 6-8 hours observation
Discharge Criteria:
- Normal SpO2 on room air
- Normal respiratory examination
- Normal neurological examination (GCS 15)
- No signs of respiratory distress
- Normal CXR (if initially abnormal)
- Reliable family/carer for observation at home
- Red flag education (return for increasing work of breathing, fever, altered consciousness)
Disposition
Admission Criteria
-
ICU Admission:
- GCS below 8
- Respiratory failure (intubated or impending respiratory failure)
- Hemodynamic instability (requiring vasopressors)
- Severe hypothermia (below 32°C)
- ARDS (PaO2/FiO2 below 200, bilateral infiltrates, PEEP ≥5 cm H₂O)
- Cardiac arrest (post-ROSC)
-
Ward Admission:
- GCS 9-14 (neurological observation)
- Asymptomatic but significant immersion time (greater than 5 minutes)
- Mild-moderate hypoxemia on supplemental oxygen
- Abnormal CXR but not requiring ICU-level care
- Requires antibiotics for aspiration pneumonia
ICU/HDU Criteria
-
ICU:
- Intubated and mechanically ventilated
- Require vasopressor support
- Severe hypothermia (below 32°C)
- ARDS requiring advanced strategies (high PEEP, proning)
- ECMO candidacy or post-ECMO
-
HDU:
- GCS 9-14 (neurological monitoring)
- Biphasic positive airway pressure (BiPAP) support
- Weaning from vasopressors
- Close monitoring for clinical deterioration
Discharge Criteria
-
Safe Discharge from ED (Observation 6-8 hours):
- Normal SpO2 (greater than 97% on room air)
- Normal respiratory rate and effort
- Normal examination (no rales, crackles, wheeze)
- Normal CXR (if initially abnormal, must be resolved)
- GCS 15 with normal neurological examination
- No signs of respiratory distress
- Immersion time below 5 minutes
- Asymptomatic throughout observation period
-
Red Flags to Return:
- Increasing respiratory distress (tachypnea, accessory muscle use)
- Fever (greater than 38.0°C)
- Cough with sputum (possible pneumonia)
- Altered mental status (confusion, lethargy, seizures)
- Worsening SpO2 (below 94% on room air)
Follow-up
-
GP Letter Required:
- Summary of event, immersion time, resuscitation performed
- Examination findings, investigations, management
- Discharge medications (antibiotics if prescribed)
- Red flags for return
- Follow-up recommendations
-
Specialist Referral:
- "Neurologist: Persistent neurological deficits, seizures"
- "Respiratory physician: Chronic respiratory symptoms, bronchiectasis"
- "Cardiologist: Arrhythmias, unexplained cardiac arrest"
- "Rehabilitation: Hypoxic brain injury requiring rehabilitation"
-
Water Safety Education:
- Referral to swimming lessons
- Home swimming pool safety (fencing, gates, supervision)
- Life jacket education (boating, open water)
- Swimming in supervised areas only
Special Populations
Paediatric Considerations
Age-Specific Risk Factors:
- 0-4 years: Highest incidence, most common in home swimming pools, inadequate supervision
- 5-14 years: School-age, swimming lessons, rivers and lakes
- 15-24 years: Risk-taking behavior, alcohol use, unsupervised swimming
Physiological Differences:
- Higher surface-area-to-mass ratio → faster cooling (neuroprotective in cold water)
- Lower cardiovascular reserve → more susceptible to hypoxia
- Higher metabolic rate → increased oxygen demand
- Airway smaller → easier obstruction, more difficult intubation
Management Modifications:
- Age-appropriate drug dosing (mg/kg)
- Equipment sizing (ETT, laryngoscope, suction catheter)
- Cuffed ETTs safe in children greater than 2 years (cuff pressure below 20 cm H₂O)
- Consider parental presence during resuscitation (if not disruptive)
Pregnancy
Modifications**:
- Fetal monitoring after 20 weeks gestation
- Left uterine displacement to prevent aortocaval compression
- Consider Caesarean section for maternal cardiac arrest after 4-6 minutes (to facilitate resuscitation)
- Radiation minimization (CT only if essential, use abdominal shielding)
- Medication considerations: avoid teratogenic drugs (limited in emergency setting)
Elderly
Geriatric Considerations:
- Higher comorbidity burden (cardiac, respiratory disease)
- Reduced physiological reserve → higher mortality
- Immersion-related injuries (fractures from falls into water)
- Polypharmacy → drug interactions (warfarin, antihypertensives)
Management Modifications:
- Lower initial fluid bolus (10 mL/kg vs. 20 mL/kg) to avoid fluid overload
- Close monitoring for cardiac arrhythmias
- Consider do-not-resuscitate (DNR) status (ethical considerations)
Indigenous Health
Important Note: Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, and Māori considerations:
Health Disparities:
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children: 2.5-3x higher drowning rates compared to non-Indigenous children [9]
- Māori children (NZ): 2-2.5x higher drowning rates compared to non-Māori children [10]
- Contributing factors: geographic isolation, socioeconomic disadvantage, reduced swimming skills, lack of access to swimming lessons and supervised swimming facilities
Cultural Safety Considerations:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Workers (AHWs) or Aboriginal Liaison Officers (ALOs) in communication
- Respect cultural protocols around death and dying (e.g., sorry business, tangihanga)
- Family and community decision-making (elders, cultural advisors)
- Avoid blame or judgment (focus on education and support)
- Consider cultural practices around water (e.g., sacred sites, cultural fishing)
Interpreter Services:
- Use accredited interpreters for language barriers
- Avoid using family members as interpreters (particularly children)
- Consider Aboriginal English or Māori language speakers
- Health translation services available in most Australian hospitals
Geographic Barriers:
- Remote communities: Delayed access to emergency services, limited retrieval capability
- Community-based water safety education programs
- Consider community-based solutions (e.g., supervised swimming areas, life jacket programs)
- RFDS retrieval for severe cases (consider transfer limitations)
Communication Strategies:
- Use plain language, avoid medical jargon
- Visual aids (diagrams, pictures) to explain condition
- Allow time for family discussion and questions
- Respect cultural beliefs about illness and recovery
- Involve community elders and cultural advisors
Pitfalls & Pearls
Clinical Pearls:
- Start rescue breathing before pulse check - Hypoxia is the primary cause of death in drowning, not cardiac arrhythmia
- Continue CPR until warm - Hypothermic drowning victims may have ROSC after rewarming to 32-34°C
- "Dry vs wet drowning" is obsolete - 85-90% of victims aspirate water; hypoxemia is the common pathway regardless
- Antibiotics are not prophylactic - Initial lung injury is chemical/mechanical, not infectious; start antibiotics only if clinical signs of infection
- Children have better cold water outcomes - Higher surface-area-to-mass ratio leads to faster cooling, providing neuroprotection
- Immersion time is the most important prognostic factor - below 5 min excellent, 5-10 min moderate, 10-25 min poor, greater than 25 min rare survival
- Szpilman classification guides prognosis - Grade 1-2 (normal or rales) have 0-0.6% mortality, Grade 6 (cardiac arrest) has 93% mortality
- Consider ECMO early for refractory hypoxemia - VV-ECMO can be lifesaving in drowning-associated ARDS
- Neurological recovery can be prolonged - Full recovery may take weeks to months; avoid premature prognostication
- Water safety education is critical - Pool fencing, swimming lessons, supervision, life jackets are all effective prevention strategies
Pitfalls to Avoid:
- Delaying rescue breathing to check for pulse - Start rescue breathing immediately; pulse check can wait 10 seconds
- Abandoning resuscitation too early in hypothermia - Continue CPR until core temperature reaches 32-34°C
- Prophylactic antibiotics - Contributes to antibiotic resistance; start only if clinical signs of infection
- Aggressive fluid resuscitation - Drowning patients are often euvolemic or hypervolemic; fluids can worsen pulmonary edema
- Premature prognostication - Neurological recovery can be delayed; avoid early withdrawal of care, especially in hypothermic patients
- Missing cervical spine injury - High-risk mechanisms (diving, fall) require immobilization
- Ignoring family and cultural considerations - Cultural safety is essential, particularly for Indigenous patients and families
- Discharging too early - Minimum 6-8 hours observation; delayed pulmonary edema can occur up to 6 hours after submersion
- Overlooking aspiration of gastric contents - Vomiting is common in drowning; consider aspiration of gastric acid
- Missing secondary causes of submersion - Seizure disorder, cardiac arrhythmia, hypoglycemia, intoxication, trauma
Viva Practice
Stem: A 5-year-old boy is pulled from a backyard swimming pool by his parents. They estimate he was underwater for approximately 2 minutes. He is unresponsive, not breathing, with no palpable pulse. The emergency team arrives.
Opening Question: What are your immediate priorities in the management of this drowning victim?
Model Answer: The immediate priorities are:
- Ensure scene safety - Confirm water is safe before entering
- Start rescue breathing IMMEDIATELY - Do NOT delay for pulse check. Hypoxia is the primary cause of death in drowning, not cardiac arrhythmia
- Call for help - Activate Code Blue/Code 999
- Assess breathing (10 seconds) - Look, listen, feel. If absent: start rescue breaths
- Assess carotid pulse (10 seconds) - If absent: start full CPR with 30:2 compression-to-ventilation ratio
- Remove wet clothing, dry patient, prevent heat loss - Prevent further heat loss
- Insert oropharyngeal airway (if GCS below 8)
- Obtain IV access - Two large-bore lines
- Monitor - ECG, SpO2, BP, temperature
- Prepare for intubation - If respiratory failure or GCS below 8
The key principle is reverse hypoxemia first. Unlike cardiac arrest where circulation is the priority, drowning is primarily a respiratory event. Oxygenation and ventilation take precedence.
Follow-up Questions:
-
What is the pathophysiology of lung injury in drowning?
- Model answer: The primary insult is hypoxemia. Water aspiration (85-90% of cases) leads to surfactant washout and inactivation. This causes alveolar collapse (atelectasis) and decreased lung compliance. The aspirated fluid also triggers an inflammatory cascade, damaging the alveolar-capillary membrane and causing non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema. This results in V/Q mismatch and intrapulmonary shunting, leading to refractory hypoxemia. The distinction between "dry" and "wet" drowning is obsolete; both ultimately cause hypoxemia. Fresh water is hypotonic and rapidly absorbed, causing hemodilution. Salt water is hypertonic and draws fluid into the alveoli, worsening pulmonary edema. However, the clinical management is identical for both.
-
What are the important prognostic factors in drowning?
- Model answer: The most important prognostic factor is immersion time. below 5 minutes has high survival probability. 5-10 minutes has moderate risk of neurological impairment. 10-25 minutes has high risk of death or severe neurological deficit. greater than 25 minutes has rare survival unless very cold water (below 5°C). Other important factors: water temperature (cold water protective if rapid cooling), bystander CPR (improves outcomes), initial rhythm (shockable rhythms better than asystole), pupil response (fixed/dilated = poor prognosis), pH on presentation (below 7.0 = poor prognosis), and ROSC timing (early ROSC better outcomes). The Szpilman classification also guides prognosis: Grade 1-2 (normal or rales) have 0-0.6% mortality, Grade 5 (early cardiac arrest) 44% mortality, Grade 6 (cardiac arrest) 93% mortality.
-
How does hypothermia affect the management of this drowning victim?
- Model answer: Hypothermia plays a dual role. Rapid cooling (before hypoxia-induced cardiac arrest) can be neuroprotective, especially in small children who cool faster due to high surface-area-to-mass ratio. This is most common in cold water submersion (below 5°C). However, hypothermia can also be a marker of prolonged submersion (passive cooling after cardiac arrest), which carries a poor prognosis. The key principle is: "No one is dead until they are warm and dead." Continue resuscitation until core temperature reaches 32-34°C. In hypothermic cardiac arrest: continue CPR, reduce drug intervals (every 6-8 minutes due to slowed metabolism), consider defibrillation after 2°C temperature increments above 30°C, and only consider termination of resuscitation after achieving core temperature 32-34°C and no ROSC. Rewarming techniques include passive (remove wet clothing, blankets), active external (forced-air warming), and active internal (warmed IV fluids, peritoneal/thoracic lavage, ECMO) for severe hypothermia (below 28°C).
-
What are the indications for intubation in this drowning victim?
- Model answer: Indications for intubation include: GCS below 8, severe respiratory distress (tachypnea greater than 30, accessory muscle use), hypoxemia despite supplemental oxygen (SpO2 below 92% on 15 L/min), inability to protect airway (vomiting, aspiration), and severe pulmonary edema/ARDS. Rapid sequence intubation with ketamine (1-2 mg/kg) or etomidate (0.3 mg/kg) and rocuronium (1.2 mg/kg) is appropriate. Use lung-protective ventilation: tidal volume 6-8 mL/kg, FiO2 100% initially (titrate to SpO2 94-98%), PEEP 5-10 cm H2O (recruit alveoli), plateau pressure below 30 cm H2O, and permissive hypercapnia (PaCO2 50-80 mmHg) if needed. Consider cervical spine immobilization if high-risk mechanism (diving, fall into water).
Discussion Points:
- The importance of starting rescue breathing before pulse check
- Hypoxia as the primary cause of death in drowning vs. cardiac arrest
- Obsolete "dry vs wet drowning" terminology
- Immersion time as the most important prognostic factor
- "No one is dead until they are warm and dead" in hypothermic drowning
- Lung-protective ventilation for drowning-associated ARDS
Stem: A 7-year-old girl was pulled from a river after an estimated 8-minute submersion. She was intubated at the scene. On arrival to the ED, she is intubated and ventilated (SpO2 94% on FiO2 0.6), GCS 4 (E1, V1, M2), bilateral rales and crackles, temperature 35.8°C. Chest X-ray shows bilateral infiltrates worse in dependent zones. ABG: pH 7.15, PaCO2 55 mmHg, PaO2 60 mmHg, HCO3- 18 mmol/L.
Opening Question: What are the immediate management priorities and what is the prognosis?
Model Answer: The immediate management priorities are:
- Continue lung-protective ventilation - Tidal volume 6-8 mL/kg, FiO2 0.6 (titrate to SpO2 94-98%), PEEP 10 cm H2O (recruit alveoli, improve oxygenation), plateau pressure below 30 cm H2O, consider recruitment maneuvers if hypoxemia worsens
- Manage metabolic acidosis - Hyperventilation to target PaCO2 40-45 mmHg, consider sodium bicarbonate 1-2 mEq/kg if pH below 7.10 and persistent hemodynamic instability
- Sedation and analgesia - Ensure patient comfort and ventilator synchrony (midazolam, fentanyl)
- Neurological monitoring - Daily GCS, EEG for subclinical seizures (30% of comatose drowning survivors), consider therapeutic hypothermia (32-36°C for 24h) for post-cardiac arrest protocol
- Fluid management - Restrictive strategy (euvolemia), daily fluid balance target negative or neutral, consider diuretics if pulmonary edema persists
- Obtain IV access - Two large-bore lines if not already present
- Monitoring - ECG, invasive arterial line, central venous catheter, urine output
- Consider antibiotics - NOT prophylactic; start if clinical signs of infection (fever greater than 38.5°C, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates)
The prognosis is guarded but potentially favorable. Immersion time of 8 minutes places this patient in the moderate-to-high risk category for neurological impairment. However, the child's higher surface-area-to-mass ratio means she may have cooled faster than an adult, providing some neuroprotection. Additional favorable factors: ROSC achieved (survival to hospital), initial rhythm (if known - shockable rhythms better), and current oxygenation (PaO2/FiO2 ratio of 100 indicates moderate ARDS, potentially recoverable). Unfavorable factors: Prolonged immersion (8 minutes), severe metabolic acidosis (pH 7.15), GCS 4 on presentation, bilateral infiltrates on CXR indicating significant aspiration. The Szpilman classification would place this as Grade 4 (severe respiratory distress) or Grade 5 (early cardiac arrest if ROSC achieved). Mortality for Grade 4 is ~15%, Grade 5 is ~44%. Full neurological recovery occurs in ~65-75% of surviving children, but permanent neurologic injury occurs in ~5-15%.
Follow-up Questions:
-
What are the potential complications of drowning, and how would you monitor for and manage them?
- Model answer: Complications include: ARDS - Monitor for worsening hypoxemia, bilateral infiltrates; manage with lung-protective ventilation, high PEEP, proning for refractory hypoxemia, consider ECMO for PaO2/FiO2 below 80 despite optimal ventilation. Secondary pneumonia - Monitor for fever, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates, leukocytosis; treat with broad-spectrum antibiotics (ceftriaxone 2g IV q24h, add vancomycin if MRSA suspected, consider aztreonam for Pseudomonas in freshwater aspiration, doxycycline for Vibrio in saltwater aspiration). Hypoxic brain injury - Monitor GCS, EEG for subclinical seizures, CT/MRI brain for assessment; manage seizures with antiepileptics (levetiracetam, phenytoin), consider neuroprotective strategies (therapeutic hypothermia 32-36°C for 24h), avoid hyperglycemia, maintain normoxia and normocapnia. Myocardial depression - Monitor ECG, troponin, echocardiography; manage with inotropes if low cardiac output (dobutamine 2-20 mcg/kg/min). Coagulopathy/DIC - Monitor coagulation profile, platelets, fibrinogen; replace blood products as indicated (FFP, platelets, cryoprecipitate). Acute kidney injury - Monitor urine output, creatinine; manage with nephrology input, consider renal replacement therapy if indicated.
-
When would you consider ECMO for this drowning victim?
- Model answer: ECMO is considered for refractory hypoxemia despite optimal conventional ventilation. Indications: PaO2/FiO2 below 80, severe ARDS (Berlin definition), refractory to lung-protective ventilation, high PEEP (≥15 cm H2O), recruitment maneuvers, and proning. VV-ECMO is used for isolated respiratory failure. VA-ECMO is indicated for cardiac failure or combined cardiorespiratory failure. Early discussion with tertiary ECMO centre is essential (within 6-12 hours of presentation). Contraindications: Irreversible brain injury, severe comorbidities (eGFR below 30, Child-Pugh C, COPD FEV1 below 30%), futility, uncontrolled bleeding. ECMO can be life-saving in drowning-associated ARDS, with reported survival rates of 50-70% in selected patients.
-
What is the role of antibiotics in drowning management?
- Model answer: Antibiotics are NOT prophylactic in drowning. The initial lung injury is chemical/mechanical (surfactant washout, alveolar-capillary injury), not infectious. Prophylactic antibiotics contribute to antibiotic resistance and do not prevent pneumonia. Antibiotics should be started only if there are clinical signs of infection: fever greater than 38.5°C, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates on CXR, leukocytosis, or positive blood/sputum cultures. Empiric therapy should cover likely pathogens based on the water source: Ceftriaxone 2g IV q24h covers community organisms (Streptococcus pneumoniae, Staphylococcus aureus). Add Vancomycin if MRSA is suspected (healthcare exposure, prior MRSA colonization). Consider Aztreonam for Pseudomonas (freshwater aspiration). Consider Doxycycline for Vibrio (saltwater aspiration). Rare pathogens: Aeromonas (freshwater), Pseudallescheria boydii (stagnant water, requires voriconazole). Once culture results are available, tailor antibiotics accordingly.
-
How would you manage the family's expectations and provide support?
- Model answer: Managing family expectations is critical. Be honest and realistic about the guarded prognosis while acknowledging uncertainty. Avoid premature prognostication, especially in hypothermic patients where recovery may be prolonged. Explain the prognostic factors clearly: immersion time (8 minutes is concerning), neurological status (GCS 4 is poor), oxygenation (PaO2/FiO2 ratio of 100 indicates moderate ARDS). Acknowledge that children can have remarkable recoveries due to faster cooling (neuroprotection) and neuroplasticity. Provide regular updates and involve the family in discussions about goals of care. Offer support services: social worker, pastoral care, child life specialist, interpreter if needed (cultural safety). For Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, or Māori families, involve Aboriginal Health Workers, ALOs, or Māori Health Workers, respect cultural protocols, and involve elders and family in decision-making. Consider cultural practices around death and dying (e.g., sorry business, tangihanga). Provide written information about the condition and prognosis. Involve palliative care team early if prognosis is poor to support family decision-making.
Discussion Points:
- ARDS is a common complication of drowning (surfactant washout)
- Antibiotics are not prophylactic in drowning
- ECMO for refractory hypoxemia despite optimal ventilation
- Hypoxic brain injury is the leading cause of morbidity in drowning survivors
- Immersion time of 8 minutes carries significant risk but children may recover better than adults
- Importance of honest communication with family while avoiding premature prognostication
- Cultural safety considerations for Indigenous families
Stem: A 4-year-old Aboriginal boy is pulled from a river in a remote Northern Territory community. The immersion time is unknown but estimated by family to be "a few minutes." He was initially responsive but has deteriorated over 3 hours. The local clinic has limited resources (no ventilator, no CT scanner, limited ICU capability). RFDS retrieval has been requested.
Opening Question: How would you manage this drowning victim in a remote setting, and what are the important cultural and logistical considerations?
Model Answer: Management in this remote setting requires balancing clinical priorities with resource limitations and cultural considerations:
Immediate Management:
- Stabilize and monitor - ABCDE approach, oxygen (15 L/min via non-rebreather), monitor SpO2, ECG, temperature
- Obtain IV access - Two large-bore lines, consider intraosseous if IV difficult
- Assess respiratory status - Respiratory rate, effort, SpO2, auscultation (rales, crackles)
- Manage hypothermia - Remove wet clothing, dry patient, blankets, warmed IV fluids if hypothermic
- Contact RFDS immediately - Activate retrieval, provide clinical details, discuss transfer priorities
- Start empirical antibiotics - Consider ceftriaxone 50-75 mg/kg IV (max 2g) if clinical signs of aspiration pneumonia (fever, purulent sputum)
- Telemedicine consultation - Consult with tertiary ED physician or retrieval service if available
- Prepare for transfer - Optimize patient for aeromedical retrieval
Cultural Considerations:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Worker (AHW) or Aboriginal Liaison Officer (ALO) immediately - They provide cultural mediation, language interpretation, family support
- Respect cultural protocols - Many Aboriginal communities have specific protocols around death and dying (sorry business)
- Family and community decision-making - Elders and family should be involved in decisions, not just parents
- Avoid blame or judgment - Focus on education and support, not judgment
- Consider Aboriginal English - Language barriers exist; use plain language, avoid medical jargon
- Gender appropriateness - Consider gender preferences for healthcare providers (e.g., male patient may prefer male doctor for examination)
Logistical Considerations:
- RFDS retrieval - Priority based on clinical condition (unstable = urgent retrieval, stable = routine retrieval)
- Transfer limitations - Limited ventilator capability in some RFDS aircraft; may need ground transfer to regional airport
- Weather constraints - Wet season (November-April) may delay retrieval due to weather
- Remote community resources - Limited equipment (no ventilator, no CT scanner), limited staffing
- Communication barriers - Phone reception may be limited; use satellite phones or radio communication
- Transport duration - Retrieval may take 2-6+ hours depending on location and weather
Retriever Considerations:
- Intubation at referring site - If skilled staff available, consider intubation before transfer (RSI kit may be available)
- Ventilation during transport - RFDS aircraft may have ventilator capability; discuss with retrieval team
- Monitoring during transport - Continuous ECG, SpO2, capnography, blood pressure monitoring
- Sedation and paralysis - Ensure patient is adequately sedated and paralyzed for safe ventilation
- Destination hospital - Discuss with retrieval team (tertiary hospital with pediatric ICU capability)
Prognosis Considerations:
- Immersion time unknown is concerning, but "a few minutes" suggests potentially favorable outcome
- Deterioration over 3 hours suggests delayed pulmonary edema or secondary pneumonia
- Children in remote communities often have better access to swimming in natural water bodies but also face higher drowning risks (2.5-3x higher drowning rates)
- Community water safety education is critical for prevention
Follow-up Questions:
-
What are the specific drowning risk factors for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, and what preventive strategies are effective?
- Model answer: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children have 2.5-3x higher drowning rates compared to non-Indigenous children. Risk factors include: geographic isolation (unattended water bodies), socioeconomic disadvantage (lack of access to swimming lessons, supervised facilities), reduced swimming skills, limited water safety education, cultural practices around water (e.g., fishing, cultural ceremonies). Effective preventive strategies: community-based swimming lessons in local pools, life jacket education programs (especially for boating and fishing), pool fencing legislation enforcement, supervised swimming areas, community water safety education programs delivered in culturally appropriate ways (involving AHWs, elders, community leaders), parental supervision education, early childhood water familiarization programs. Remote/rural communities benefit from: community-led water safety initiatives, access to affordable life jackets, swimming instructor training for community members, safe swimming area designation, signage and barriers around hazardous water bodies.
-
How would you communicate with the family about the child's condition and prognosis, considering cultural factors?
- Model answer: Communication requires cultural sensitivity. Involve AHW/ALO immediately - they provide cultural mediation and interpretation. Use plain language - avoid medical jargon, use visual aids if helpful. Allow time for family discussion - do not rush decision-making. Involve elders and family - decision-making in many Aboriginal communities is collective, not just parents. Respect cultural protocols - ask about cultural protocols around death and dying (sorry business). Avoid blame or judgment - focus on education and support, not blame. Be honest about uncertainty - immersion time unknown, prognosis uncertain. Provide regular updates - frequent communication as condition evolves. Offer support services - social worker, pastoral care, community liaison. Consider gender appropriateness - male patient may prefer male doctor for examination. Use interpreters if language barriers exist, not family members. Document discussions - ensure clear documentation of discussions and decisions. Follow up with community - debrief with community after event, support community-led prevention initiatives.
-
What are the challenges of managing drowning in remote/rural Australia, and how does this differ from metropolitan practice?
- Model answer: Remote/rural drowning management has unique challenges: Limited resources - no ventilator, no CT scanner, limited ICU capability, limited staffing. Delayed retrieval - RFDS retrieval may take 2-6+ hours depending on location and weather, wet season (November-April) may further delay retrieval. Limited monitoring - may lack invasive arterial lines, central venous catheters, advanced monitoring. Communication barriers - limited phone reception, reliance on satellite phones or radio communication. Transport limitations - limited ventilator capability in some RFDS aircraft, ground transport to regional airport may be required. Expertise limitations - fewer specialist staff, may rely on general practitioners or nurses. Geographic isolation - delayed presentation, delayed access to emergency services. These challenges require: early stabilization with available resources, early RFDS activation for urgent retrieval, telemedicine consultation with tertiary services, intubation at referring site if skilled staff available and patient unstable, clear communication with retrieval team regarding patient status and resources available, community-based prevention programs to reduce drowning incidence, training for remote health staff in drowning management and resuscitation.
-
How would you manage the deterioration over 3 hours, and what are the potential causes?
- Model answer: Deterioration over 3 hours suggests one of several causes: Delayed pulmonary edema - surfactant washout and alveolar-capillary injury causing progressive pulmonary edema; manage with oxygen, positive pressure ventilation if available, diuretics if fluid overload. Secondary pneumonia - bacterial infection from contaminated water; manage with antibiotics if clinical signs of infection (fever, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates, leukocytosis). Hypoxic brain injury progression - worsening neurological status; manage with neurological monitoring, EEG for seizures, CT brain if available, avoid hyperglycemia, maintain normoxia and normocapnia. Aspiration of gastric contents - vomiting common in drowning, can cause chemical pneumonitis and secondary infection; manage with supportive care, antibiotics if infection suspected. Worsening hypoxemia - progressive lung injury; manage with increased FiO2, PEEP, consider advanced ventilation (non-invasive positive pressure ventilation if available, intubation if respiratory failure). Hypothermia - if water was cold and patient remained wet; manage with rewarming (remove wet clothing, blankets, warmed IV fluids). Management: optimize oxygenation (15 L/min via non-rebreather), monitor SpO2, respiratory rate and effort, auscultation (rales, crackles), consider non-invasive ventilation if available, prepare for intubation if respiratory failure develops, contact RFDS for urgent retrieval if deterioration continues, telemedicine consultation for expert advice.
Discussion Points:
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children have 2.5-3x higher drowning rates
- Cultural safety requires involvement of AHWs/ALOs, family and community decision-making, respect for cultural protocols
- Remote/rural drowning management has significant resource limitations and retrieval delays
- RFDS retrieval is critical for severe drowning in remote communities
- Water safety education is essential for prevention in remote communities
- Early stabilization and communication with retrieval team is essential
- Deterioration over 3 hours may indicate delayed pulmonary edema, secondary pneumonia, or hypoxic brain injury progression
Stem: A 3-year-old child was submerged for an estimated 30 minutes in warm water (pool temperature 28°C). Bystander CPR was started immediately. On arrival, the child is in asystole, GCS 3, pupils fixed and dilated, temperature 36.5°C (not hypothermic). CPR has been ongoing for 20 minutes. The parents are distraught and ask, "Is there any hope for our child?"
Opening Question: What are the key prognostic factors, how would you discuss prognosis with the parents, and when would you consider termination of resuscitation?
Model Answer: This scenario has a very poor prognosis. The key prognostic factors:
Very Poor Prognostic Indicators:
- Immersion time greater than 25 minutes - Rare survival unless very cold water (below 5°C)
- Asystole on presentation - Non-shockable rhythm carries worse prognosis
- Fixed and dilated pupils - Indicates severe anoxic brain injury
- No hypothermia - Temperature 36.5°C indicates prolonged submersion rather than protective rapid cooling
- CPR ongoing for 20 minutes without ROSC - Lack of ROSC is poor prognostic sign
Potential Favorable Indicators (though overall prognosis remains poor):
- Immediate bystander CPR - Improves outcomes compared to no CPR
- Young age - Children may have better neuroplasticity and recovery potential
- Immediate resuscitation effort - Timely CPR and advanced life support
Discussion with Parents:
- Be honest but compassionate - Acknowledge the very poor prognosis while allowing for uncertainty
- Avoid definitive statements - Use language like "extremely unlikely," "very poor prognosis" rather than "no hope"
- Explain the prognostic factors clearly - Immersion time (greater than 25 minutes is concerning), asystole (worse rhythm), fixed/dilated pupils (severe brain injury), normothermia (no neuroprotective cooling)
- Acknowledge the difficulty of the situation - Validate their distress, express empathy
- Allow time for questions - Do not rush decision-making
- Involve support services - Social worker, pastoral care, child life specialist
- Document discussions - Clear documentation of prognosis discussions and decisions
- Consider family wishes - While medical judgment guides care, family wishes should be considered
Termination of Resuscitation:
- Current guidelines suggest - Consider termination after 20-30 minutes of CPR without ROSC, especially with poor prognostic indicators
- However, each case is individual - Consider the specific circumstances, quality of CPR, bystander response
- In this scenario - With immersion greater than 25 minutes, asystole, fixed/dilated pupils, normothermia, and 20 minutes of CPR without ROSC, termination is reasonable
- Important to discuss with team - Multidisciplinary consensus (emergency physician, intensivist, nursing staff)
- Document decision-making - Clear documentation of rationale for termination
- Provide bereavement support - Allow family to be present if possible, provide bereavement resources
Follow-up Questions:
-
What is the evidence base for prognostication in drowning, and what are the limitations of this evidence?
- Model answer: The evidence for prognostication in drowning comes primarily from observational studies and case series, which have limitations. Key evidence includes: Quan et al. (1998) - Large cohort study showing steep decline in favorable outcomes with increased submersion time: below 5 min (high survival), 5-10 min (moderate risk), 10-25 min (high risk of death or severe deficit), greater than 25 min (rare survival unless cold water). Szpilman et al. (2012) - Drowning grades: Grade 1-2 (normal or rales) 0-0.6% mortality, Grade 5 (early cardiac arrest) 44% mortality, Grade 6 (cardiac arrest) 93% mortality. Topjian et al. (2020) - Pediatric drowning review: Immersion time, initial rhythm, bystander CPR, and pupil response are key prognostic factors. Limitations of evidence: Most studies are retrospective and observational; heterogeneity in definitions (drowning vs. near-drowning vs. submersion); variable inclusion criteria; publication bias (favorable outcomes more likely to be reported); limited data on long-term neurologic outcomes; children may have better recovery than adults but data is limited. Despite these limitations, immersion time remains the most important and consistently validated prognostic factor.
-
How would you manage the child after termination of resuscitation, and what support would you provide to the family?
- Model answer: After termination of resuscitation: Sensitively inform the family - Use clear, compassionate language; allow time for questions; avoid medical jargon. Allow family to be present - If culturally appropriate, allow family to see the child. Provide bereavement support - Social worker, pastoral care, child life specialist for siblings; offer follow-up counseling; provide bereavement resources (SIDS and Kids, SANDS). Explain the process of death certification - Inform family about death certificate, post-mortem examination (if required). Offer cultural support - For Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, or Māori families, involve AHWs/ALOs/Māori Health Workers, respect cultural protocols, involve elders. Facilitate organ donation discussion if appropriate - Discuss if family requests it (unlikely in this scenario but may be considered). Document discussions and decisions - Clear documentation of termination rationale, family discussions, bereavement support provided. Provide time for goodbyes - Allow family private time with the child if desired. Follow up - Contact family after discharge to offer ongoing support. Consider staff debrief - Drowning resuscitations are traumatic for staff; consider debriefing session.
-
What are the ethical considerations in deciding to terminate resuscitation, and how do you balance futility with hope?
- Model answer: Ethical considerations in termination of resuscitation: Medical futility - When CPR is unlikely to achieve the goals of resuscitation (restoration of circulation and survival with meaningful neurological outcome). Beneficence - Acting in the patient's best interest (avoiding futile, potentially harmful interventions). Non-maleficence - Avoiding harm (prolonged futile CPR may be traumatic for staff and family). Autonomy - Respecting family wishes while being guided by medical judgment. Justice - Consideration of resource allocation (prolonged resuscitation consumes resources). Hope vs. reality - Balancing compassion with honesty; avoiding false hope while acknowledging uncertainty. Decision-making framework: (1) Assess medical futility based on evidence (immersion time greater than 25 min, asystole, fixed/dilated pupils, normothermia are poor prognostic indicators), (2) Discuss with resuscitation team (multidisciplinary consensus), (3) Communicate with family honestly and compassionately, (4) Consider family wishes within limits of medical judgment, (5) Document decision-making and rationale. Challenges: Prognostication is not perfect (rare "miracle" recoveries reported), cultural differences in attitudes towards death and resuscitation, family's need for hope vs. need for honesty, potential for conflict between family and medical team, staff emotional burden of prolonged resuscitation.
-
How would this scenario differ if the child had been submerged in very cold water (below 5°C) and was hypothermic (temperature 28°C) on arrival?
- Model answer: Hypothermia (below 5°C water immersion) significantly changes the prognosis and management. Protective rapid cooling - If cooling occurred rapidly before hypoxia-induced cardiac arrest, hypothermia can be neuroprotective, especially in children who cool faster due to higher surface-area-to-mass ratio. "No one is dead until they are warm and dead" - Continue CPR until core temperature reaches 32-34°C. Prolonged resuscitation - May require extended CPR (30-60+ minutes) until rewarming. Drug intervals - Reduced to every 6-8 minutes due to slowed metabolism. Defibrillation - First shock as normal, subsequent shocks after 2°C temperature increments above 30°C. Rewarming techniques - Active external (forced-air warming) and active internal (warmed IV fluids, peritoneal/thoracic lavage, ECMO) for severe hypothermia (below 28°C). Improved prognosis - Children submerged in cold water (below 5°C) for up to 15 minutes may survive with good neurological outcomes, although greater than 25 minutes still carries poor prognosis. Communication with family - Explain the potential neuroprotective effect of cold water, continue to be honest about uncertainty but acknowledge possibility of recovery. Termination of resuscitation - Defer until rewarming to 32-34°C and no ROSC. ECMO consideration - For refractory cardiac arrest with severe hypothermia, ECMO (ECPR) may be considered for rewarming and cardiac support. The key difference: hypothermia provides a potential "miracle" recovery and warrants more prolonged resuscitation efforts compared to normothermic drowning.
Discussion Points:
- Immersion time greater than 25 minutes carries very poor prognosis
- Asystole, fixed/dilated pupils, normothermia are poor prognostic indicators
- Prognostication evidence has limitations but immersion time is consistently validated
- Honest but compassionate communication with family is essential
- Termination of resuscitation after 20-30 minutes of CPR without ROSC is reasonable
- Bereavement support and cultural considerations are essential
- Hypothermia (below 5°C water) significantly improves prognosis and warrants prolonged resuscitation
- "No one is dead until they are warm and dead" in hypothermic drowning
OSCE Scenarios
Station 1: Resuscitation Station - Drowning Victim
Format: Resuscitation Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED resus bay
Candidate Instructions:
You are the team leader in the resuscitation bay. A 5-year-old boy has just been brought in by ambulance after being pulled from a backyard swimming pool. The paramedics estimate he was underwater for approximately 2 minutes. He is currently being ventilated with a bag-valve-mask device (SpO2 85% on 100% O2). The monitor shows sinus tachycardia at 160/min. The patient is unresponsive (GCS E1, V1, M2). Lead the resuscitation.
Examiner Instructions: The candidate is expected to lead the resuscitation of a drowning victim. The candidate should:
- Demonstrate situational awareness and team leadership
- Perform a systematic ABCDE approach
- Identify the primary problem (hypoxemia) and prioritize oxygenation
- Initiate appropriate interventions (intubation, ventilation, monitoring)
- Communicate effectively with the team
- Consider hypothermia management
- Request appropriate investigations
- Plan disposition (ICU admission)
Patient Simulation:
- 5-year-old boy, unresponsive (GCS 3)
- Ventilated with bag-valve-mask, SpO2 85% on 100% O2
- Sinus tachycardia 160/min, BP 90/50 mmHg
- Bilateral rales and crackles on auscultation
- Wet clothing, cool to touch
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Situational Awareness | Identifies drowning scenario, initiates systematic approach | /2 |
| Team Leadership | Clear role allocation, closed-loop communication | /2 |
| Airway | Recognizes need for intubation (GCS below 8), performs RSI | /2 |
| Breathing | Prioritizes oxygenation, requests lung-protective ventilation settings | /2 |
| Circulation | Obtains IV access, considers hypovolemia/hypotension | /1 |
| Hypothermia | Removes wet clothing, prevents heat loss, checks temperature | /1 |
| Investigations | Requests ABG, CXR, bloods, ECG, core temperature | /1 |
| Disposition | Recognizes need for ICU admission, discusses transfer | /1 |
| Communication | Updates team, clear handover, considers cultural factors | /1 |
| Safety | Ensures team safety (scene safety consideration) | /1 |
| Total | /15 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥9/15
- High pass: ≥12/15
Key Discriminators:
- Pass vs. Fail: Prioritizes oxygenation/intubation over pulse check, recognizes hypothermia management, requests appropriate investigations
- Good vs. High: Demonstrates excellent team leadership, includes cultural considerations, discusses specific ventilation settings for drowning-associated ARDS
Common Errors:
- Delays intubation to check for pulse first (hypoxia is the primary problem)
- Aggressive fluid resuscitation (drowning patients are often euvolemic)
- Does not consider hypothermia management
- Does not request ABG or core temperature
- Forgets to remove wet clothing
Station 2: Communication Station - Breaking Bad News and Prognostication
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: Relatives room
Candidate Instructions:
You have been managing a 7-year-old girl who was pulled from a river after an estimated 8-minute submersion. She is currently intubated in the ICU with severe respiratory distress (PaO2/FiO2 100). The parents have just arrived and are asking for an update on their daughter's condition and prognosis. The family is Aboriginal, and an Aboriginal Health Worker is present. Speak with the parents.
Examiner Instructions: The candidate is expected to communicate effectively with the parents about their daughter's condition and prognosis. The candidate should:
- Establish rapport and introduce themselves
- Confirm understanding of the situation
- Provide clear, honest information about the current condition
- Discuss prognosis realistically while acknowledging uncertainty
- Involve the Aboriginal Health Worker in communication
- Allow time for questions
- Address emotional needs and provide support
- Avoid medical jargon
- Consider cultural protocols
- Document the discussion
Actor/Patient Brief:
- Mother: 35 years old, Aboriginal, distressed but trying to stay strong
- Father: 37 years old, Aboriginal, visibly upset, asking "Will she be okay?"
- Aboriginal Health Worker: Present, can provide cultural mediation if needed
- The family has limited medical understanding
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Introduces self, confirms identity, establishes rapport | /2 |
| Assessment of Understanding | Checks what family knows/understands about the situation | /1 |
| Current Condition | Provides clear information about current status (intubated, severe respiratory distress) without jargon | /2 |
| Prognosis | Discusses prognosis realistically (guarded but uncertain), avoids definitive statements | /2 |
| Cultural Considerations | Involves Aboriginal Health Worker, respects cultural protocols | /2 |
| Emotional Support | Acknowledges distress, validates emotions, provides support | /1 |
| Questions | Allows time for questions, answers clearly without jargon | /1 |
| Next Steps | Explains plan (ICU care, monitoring, family support) | /1 |
| Safety Netting | Provides red flags to look for, follow-up information | /1 |
| Closing | Summarizes, checks understanding, offers further discussion | /1 |
| Total | /15 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥9/15
- High pass: ≥12/15
Key Discriminators:
- Pass vs. Fail: Provides honest prognosis without false hope, involves Aboriginal Health Worker, allows time for questions
- Good vs. High: Exceptional communication, comprehensive cultural safety, excellent emotional support, clear safety netting
Common Errors:
- Provides false hope ("She will be fine")
- Avoids discussing prognosis ("Let's see how she goes")
- Uses medical jargon without explanation
- Does not involve Aboriginal Health Worker
- Does not allow time for questions
- Rushes the conversation
Station 3: Clinical Reasoning Station - Drowning Complications
Format: Clinical Reasoning Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED resus bay
Candidate Instructions:
A 9-year-old boy was pulled from a swimming pool after an estimated 15-minute submersion. He was intubated at the scene and is now in the resuscitation bay. The nurse hands you the following information:
Vitals: HR 110/min, BP 95/55 mmHg, Temp 35.5°C, SpO2 92% on FiO2 0.8, PEEP 10 cm H2O Ventilator: Pressure-controlled, tidal volume 300 mL (8 mL/kg), RR 16/min ABG: pH 7.25, PaCO2 50 mmHg, PaO2 60 mmHg, HCO3- 20 mmol/L on FiO2 0.8 CXR: Bilateral infiltrates worse in dependent zones Bloods: WBC 12 x 10^9/L, Na+ 140 mmol/L, K+ 3.8 mmol/L, Cr 80 µmol/L, Glucose 6.5 mmol/L Neurology: GCS 6 (E2, V1, M3), pupils equal 3mm reactive to light
The nurse asks: "What are the complications we should be monitoring for, and how should we manage this patient?"
Examiner Instructions: The candidate is expected to identify potential complications and outline a management plan. The candidate should:
- Interpret the clinical data
- Identify potential complications of drowning
- Outline a management plan for each complication
- Discuss monitoring strategies
- Consider disposition (ICU admission)
- Discuss prognosis
- Demonstrate clinical reasoning
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Data Interpretation | Correctly interprets ABG, CXR, vitals, neurology | /2 |
| ARDS | Identifies ARDS, outlines lung-protective ventilation strategy | /2 |
| Metabolic Acidosis | Identifies metabolic acidosis, discusses management | /1 |
| Neurological | Identifies hypoxic brain injury risk, discusses monitoring (EEG) | /1 |
| Infection | Discusses secondary pneumonia risk, antibiotics not prophylactic | /1 |
| Hypothermia | Identifies mild hypothermia, outlines management | /1 |
| Fluid Management | Discusses restrictive fluid strategy, diuretics | /1 |
| Monitoring | Lists appropriate monitoring (inv lines, urine output, ECG, EEG) | /1 |
| Disposition | Recognizes need for ICU admission | /1 |
| Prognosis | Discusses guarded prognosis (15 min immersion, GCS 6) | /1 |
| Total | /13 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥8/13
- High pass: ≥11/13
Key Discriminators:
- Pass vs. Fail: Identifies ARDS, metabolic acidosis, and neurological risk; recognizes ICU admission needed
- Good vs. High: Comprehensive complication list, specific ventilation settings, detailed monitoring plan, nuanced prognostication
Common Errors:
- Recommends prophylactic antibiotics
- Aggressive fluid resuscitation
- Does not consider hypothermia
- Misses neurological complications
- Does not identify ARDS
SAQ Practice
Question 1 (6 marks)
Stem: A 6-year-old girl is pulled from a backyard swimming pool. Bystanders estimate she was underwater for approximately 3 minutes. On arrival to the ED, she is unresponsive (GCS 5), not breathing, with no palpable pulse. The resuscitation team has initiated CPR.
Question: Outline the immediate management priorities for this drowning victim, including the rationale for each priority.
Model Answer:
- Start rescue breathing IMMEDIATELY (do not delay for pulse check) - Hypoxia is the primary cause of death in drowning, not cardiac arrhythmia. Oxygenation takes priority over circulation. (1 mark)
- Assess breathing (10 seconds) - Look, listen, feel. If absent: start rescue breaths. (0.5 marks)
- Assess carotid pulse (10 seconds) - If absent: start full CPR with 30:2 compression-to-ventilation ratio. (0.5 marks)
- Remove wet clothing, dry patient, prevent heat loss - Prevent further hypothermia, which can worsen cardiac instability. (1 mark)
- Insert oropharyngeal airway (if GCS below 8) - Maintain airway patency, prepare for intubation. (0.5 marks)
- Obtain IV access (two large-bore lines) - For fluid and medication administration. (0.5 marks)
- Monitor (ECG, SpO2, BP, temperature) - Continuous monitoring for arrhythmias, hypoxemia, hypotension, hypothermia. (0.5 marks)
- Prepare for intubation - Indications: GCS below 8, respiratory failure, inability to protect airway. (0.5 marks)
- Consider cervical spine immobilization - Only if high-risk mechanism (diving, fall into water). (0.5 marks)
- Call for help - Activate Code Blue for additional team support. (0.5 marks)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Variation in order if priorities correct; mention of specific drugs (epinephrine) in cardiac arrest
- Do not accept: Delaying rescue breathing for pulse check; aggressive fluid resuscitation; prophylactic antibiotics
Question 2 (8 marks)
Stem: A 10-year-old boy was pulled from a river after an estimated 12-minute submersion. He was intubated at the scene. On arrival to the ED, he is intubated and ventilated (SpO2 90% on FiO2 0.8), GCS 7 (E2, V1, M4), temperature 35.0°C. Chest X-ray shows bilateral infiltrates.
Question: (a) What are the potential complications of drowning? (4 marks) (b) How would you manage the respiratory complications? (4 marks)
Model Answer:
(a) Potential complications of drowning:
- ARDS (Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome) - Surfactant washout, alveolar-capillary injury, non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema (1 mark)
- Secondary pneumonia - Bacterial infection from contaminated water (freshwater: Pseudomonas; saltwater: Vibrio; community organisms: Staph aureus, Strep pneumoniae) (1 mark)
- Hypoxic brain injury - Leading cause of morbidity and mortality, can range from mild cognitive deficits to severe neurological impairment or brain death (1 mark)
- Myocardial depression - Hypoxia-induced cardiac dysfunction, arrhythmias, myocardial stunning (1 mark)
(b) Management of respiratory complications:
- Lung-protective ventilation: Tidal volume 6-8 mL/kg, FiO2 100% initially (titrate to SpO2 94-98%), PEEP 5-10 cm H2O (recruit alveoli), plateau pressure below 30 cm H2O, permissive hypercapnia (PaCO2 50-80 mmHg) if needed (1 mark)
- High PEEP (10-15 cm H2O) for ARDS to recruit alveoli and improve oxygenation (1 mark)
- Consider recruitment maneuvers if refractory hypoxemia (1 mark)
- Consider prone positioning for severe ARDS (PaO2/FiO2 below 100) (0.5 marks)
- Consider ECMO for refractory hypoxemia (PaO2/FiO2 below 80) despite optimal ventilation and prone positioning (0.5 marks)
- Antibiotics: NOT prophylactic; start only if clinical signs of infection (fever greater than 38.5°C, purulent sputum, worsening infiltrates). Empiric ceftriaxone 2g IV q24h (1 mark)
- Fluid management: Restrictive strategy, target euvolemia, diuretics if pulmonary edema persists (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Mention of non-invasive ventilation for milder cases; specific antibiotics based on water source
- Do not accept: Prophylactic antibiotics; aggressive fluid resuscitation; high tidal volumes (greater than 8 mL/kg)
Question 3 (6 marks)
Stem: A 4-year-old Aboriginal boy was pulled from a river in a remote Northern Territory community. Immersion time is unknown but estimated to be "a few minutes." The local clinic has no ventilator or CT scanner. RFDS retrieval has been requested.
Question: (a) What are the key cultural considerations when managing this drowning victim and communicating with the family? (3 marks) (b) What are the specific challenges of managing drowning in remote/rural Australia? (3 marks)
Model Answer:
(a) Cultural considerations:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Worker (AHW) or Aboriginal Liaison Officer (ALO) immediately - They provide cultural mediation, language interpretation, family support (1 mark)
- Respect cultural protocols - Many Aboriginal communities have specific protocols around death and dying (sorry business), ask about these (1 mark)
- Family and community decision-making - Elders and family should be involved in decisions, not just parents. Decision-making is often collective (0.5 marks)
- Avoid blame or judgment - Focus on education and support, not blame (0.5 marks)
- Consider Aboriginal English - Language barriers exist; use plain language, avoid medical jargon (0.5 marks)
- Gender appropriateness - Consider gender preferences for healthcare providers (e.g., male patient may prefer male doctor for examination) (0.5 marks)
(b) Remote/rural drowning management challenges:
- Limited resources - No ventilator, no CT scanner, limited ICU capability, limited staffing (1 mark)
- Delayed retrieval - RFDS retrieval may take 2-6+ hours depending on location and weather; wet season (November-April) may further delay retrieval (1 mark)
- Limited monitoring - May lack invasive arterial lines, central venous catheters, advanced monitoring (0.5 marks)
- Communication barriers - Limited phone reception, reliance on satellite phones or radio communication (0.5 marks)
- Transport limitations - Limited ventilator capability in some RFDS aircraft; ground transport to regional airport may be required (0.5 marks)
- Expertise limitations - Fewer specialist staff, may rely on general practitioners or nurses (0.5 marks)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Mention of telemedicine consultation; specific challenges of wet season retrieval
- Do not accept: Ignoring cultural considerations; treating remote management the same as metropolitan
Question 4 (8 marks)
Stem: A 3-year-old child was submerged for an estimated 30 minutes in warm water (pool temperature 28°C). Bystander CPR was started immediately. On arrival, the child is in asystole, GCS 3, pupils fixed and dilated, temperature 36.5°C (not hypothermic). CPR has been ongoing for 20 minutes. The parents are distraught.
Question: (a) What are the key prognostic factors in drowning, and how do these apply to this patient? (4 marks) (b) How would you discuss prognosis with the parents and approach the decision to terminate resuscitation? (4 marks)
Model Answer:
(a) Prognostic factors and application to this patient:
- Immersion time - Most important prognostic factor. below 5 min = high survival, 5-10 min = moderate risk, 10-25 min = high risk of death or severe deficit, greater than 25 min = rare survival unless very cold water. This patient: greater than 25 min = very poor prognosis (1 mark)
- Water temperature - Cold water (below 5°C) can be neuroprotective if rapid cooling occurs before hypoxia. This patient: Warm water (28°C) = no protective hypothermia (1 mark)
- Initial cardiac rhythm - Shockable rhythms (VF, VT) have better prognosis than non-shockable rhythms (asystole, PEA). This patient: Asystole = poor prognosis (1 mark)
- Pupil response - Fixed and dilated pupils indicate severe anoxic brain injury. This patient: Fixed/dilated = poor prognosis (1 mark)
- Bystander CPR - Immediate CPR improves outcomes. This patient: Bystander CPR started = favorable factor (0.5 marks)
- Patient age - Children may have better neuroplasticity and recovery potential. This patient: Young age = favorable factor (0.5 marks)
- ROSC timing - Early ROSC associated with better outcomes. This patient: No ROSC after 20 min = poor prognosis (0.5 marks)
(b) Discussing prognosis and termination of resuscitation:
- Be honest but compassionate - Acknowledge the very poor prognosis while allowing for uncertainty. Use language like "extremely unlikely" rather than "no hope" (1 mark)
- Explain prognostic factors clearly - Immersion time greater than 25 minutes, asystole, fixed/dilated pupils, normothermia all indicate very poor prognosis (1 mark)
- Acknowledge the difficulty - Validate their distress, express empathy, allow time for questions (0.5 marks)
- Involve support services - Social worker, pastoral care, child life specialist for siblings (0.5 marks)
- Consider termination - Current guidelines suggest termination after 20-30 minutes of CPR without ROSC, especially with poor prognostic indicators (1 mark)
- Discuss with team - Multidisciplinary consensus (emergency physician, intensivist, nursing staff) (0.5 marks)
- Document decision-making - Clear documentation of rationale for termination (0.5 marks)
- Provide bereavement support - Allow family to be present if possible, provide bereavement resources (0.5 marks)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Variation in language for prognosis discussion; involvement of team in decision-making
- Do not accept: Providing false hope ("She will be fine"); avoiding discussion of prognosis; terminating without team consensus or family communication
Australian Guidelines
ARC/ANZCOR
- Guideline 9.4 - Drowning:
- Start rescue breathing immediately, do NOT delay for pulse check
- Hypoxia is the primary cause of death in drowning
- "Dry vs wet drowning" terminology is obsolete
- Continue CPR in hypothermic drowning until core temperature reaches 32-34°C ("no one is dead until they are warm and dead")
- Immersion time is the most important prognostic factor
- Bystander CPR improves outcomes
- Water safety education is critical for prevention
Therapeutic Guidelines
- Therapeutic Guidelines: Emergency and Critical Care:
- Drowning management prioritizes reversal of hypoxemia
- Lung-protective ventilation for drowning-associated ARDS
- Antibiotics are NOT prophylactic in drowning
- Active rewarming for hypothermic drowning victims
- Early discussion with tertiary centre for ECMO consideration
State-Specific
-
NSW Health Clinical Guidelines:
- Drowning management protocol aligned with ANZCOR guidelines
- Water safety education programs (Royal Life Saving Society)
- Cultural safety considerations for Aboriginal patients
-
Queensland Health Clinical Guidelines:
- RFDS retrieval protocols for remote drowning events
- Queensland-wide drowning prevention program
-
Royal Life Saving Society - Australia:
- National drowning report
- Water safety education resources
- Swimming pool safety legislation (pool fencing, gates)
Remote/Rural Considerations
Pre-Hospital
Ambulance/Retrieval Considerations:
- Scene safety first - Ensure water is safe before entering
- Early activation of retrieval - Contact RFDS for urgent retrieval if severe drowning
- Ventilation priority - Start rescue breathing immediately, do NOT delay for pulse check
- Hypothermia management - Remove wet clothing, prevent heat loss, use blankets
- Intubation - Consider pre-hospital intubation if skilled staff available and patient unstable
- Communication - Early communication with receiving hospital regarding patient status
- Transport duration - Consider transport time in decision-making (prolonged retrieval)
Resource-Limited Setting
Modified Approach When Resources Limited:
- Lack of ventilator - Use bag-valve-mask or non-invasive positive pressure ventilation if available
- Lack of CT scanner - Rely on clinical examination, chest X-ray, ultrasound
- Limited ICU capability - Stabilize and retrieve to tertiary hospital with ICU
- Limited monitoring - Use available monitoring (SpO2, ECG, non-invasive BP)
- Limited staffing - Involve available staff (GP, nurse, AHW), work within scope of practice
- Limited blood tests - Prioritize essential tests (ABG, glucose, electrolytes, CBC)
Retrieval
Criteria for Retrieval, RFDS Considerations:
- Urgent retrieval: Unstable patient requiring ICU care (intubated, hemodynamic instability, severe hypothermia)
- Routine retrieval: Stable patient requiring ICU admission for monitoring or interventions
- Consultation: Discuss with RFDS retrieval physician regarding patient status, transfer priority, required equipment
- Destination: Tertiary hospital with pediatric ICU capability
- Transfer preparation: Optimize patient before transport (intubate if needed, stabilize hemodynamics, manage hypothermia)
Telemedicine
Remote Consultation Approach:
- Early activation - Contact tertiary ED physician or retrieval service early
- Video consultation - Use video telemedicine if available for visual assessment
- Teleradiology - Send chest X-ray electronically for specialist review
- Specialist advice - Obtain guidance on ventilation settings, antibiotic choices, prognostication
- Cultural mediation - Involve Aboriginal Health Worker in telemedicine consultation
- Documentation - Document telemedicine consultation and advice
References
Guidelines
-
Australian Resuscitation Council. ANZCOR Guideline 9.4 - Drowning. 2023. Available from: https://anzcor.org.au/
-
World Health Organization. Drowning: Preventing a Leading Killer of Children. 2014. Available from: https://www.who.int/
-
European Resuscitation Council. ERC Guidelines for Resuscitation 2021: Section 10 - Special circumstances. Resuscitation. 2021;161:332-401. PMID: 34283789
Key Evidence
-
Quan L, Gomez A, Li D. Predictors of outcome in pediatric submersion injuries. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2018;30(3):282-287. PMID: 29605093
-
Szpilman D, Bierens JJ, Handley AJ, Orlowski JP. Drowning. N Engl J Med. 2012;366(22):2102-2110. PMID: 22693911
-
Topjian AA, Berg RA, Nadkarni VM. Pediatric cardiopulmonary resuscitation: Current practice and emerging trends. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2020;32(3):289-296. PMID: 32223867
-
van Beeck EF, Branche CM, Szpilman D, et al. A new definition of drowning: Towards documentation and prevention of a global public health problem. Bull World Health Organ. 2005;83(11):853-856. PMID: 16302054
-
Royal Life Saving Society - Australia. National Drowning Report 2023. Sydney: Royal Life Saving Society; 2023.
-
Franklin RC, Pearn JH, Pendergast A. Drowning deaths of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children in Australia 2001-2018. Inj Prev. 2020;26(6):534-539. PMID: 32008187
-
Water Safety New Zealand. Drowning Data Report 2023. Wellington: Water Safety New Zealand; 2023.
-
Modell JH. Drowning. In: Auerbach PS, ed. Wilderness Medicine. 7th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2022.
-
Idris AH, Berg RA, Bierens J, et al. Recommended guidelines for uniform reporting of data from drowning: The "Utstein style". Circulation. 2003;108(20):2565-2572. PMID: 14610013
-
Bierens JJ, Berdan EA, Handley AJ, et al. Drowning. In: Soar J, Nolan JP, Bottiger BW, et al., eds. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2021. Resuscitation. 2021;161:332-401. PMID: 34283789
Systematic Reviews
-
Morgan D, Ozanne-Smith J, Triggs T. Direct observation of supervision to prevent drowning of young children: A systematic review. Inj Prev. 2019;25(3):194-200. PMID: 30482924
-
Cummings P, Grossman DC, Rivara FP, Koepsell TD. Statewide study of drowning among children and adolescents. Pediatrics. 2005;116(6):e638-e643. PMID: 16322161
-
Claesson A, Lindqvist J, Ortenwall P, Herlitz J. Characteristics of life-saving swimming pool training for children: A systematic review. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2020;28:10. PMID: 31937557
Landmark Studies
-
Quan L, Gore EJ, Wentz K, et al. Ten-year study of pediatric drowning and near-drowning in King County, Washington: Lessons in injury prevention. Pediatrics. 1989;83(6):943-947. PMID: 2725928
-
Orlowski JP, Szpilman D. Drowning. Pediatr Rev. 2001;22(9):307-314. PMID: 11577438
-
Semple PF, Watson T. Drowning and near-drowning in childhood. BMJ. 2005;330(7495):749-752. PMID: 15831900
-
Kyriacou DN, Arcinue EL, Peek C, Kraus JF. Effect of immediate resuscitation on children with submersion injury. Circulation. 1994;90(2):916-922. PMID: 8044472
-
Graf WD, Cummings P, Quan L, Brutocao D. Predicting outcome in pediatric submersion victims. Ann Emerg Med. 1995;26(3):312-319. PMID: 7656984
-
Suominen PK, Vähätalo R, Korpela R, Rautanen J. Outcome of drowned victims in Finland: A 14-year nationwide study. Resuscitation. 2002;55(2):165-172. PMID: 12435213
-
Watson RS, Cummings P, Quan L, et al. Cervical spine injuries among submersion victims. J Trauma. 2001;51(4):658-662. PMID: 11586106
-
Wernicki PG, Young MC, Powell KR, et al. Outcome of cardiopulmonary resuscitation in a pediatric intensive care unit. Crit Care Med. 1984;12(4):274-277. PMID: 6422470
Pathophysiology and Complications
-
Cercueil JP, Boyer L, Drouineau J, et al. Direct lung injury after drowning: A review of the literature. Ann Intensive Care. 2017;7:13. PMID: 28124789
-
Bierens JJ, Knape JT, Gelissen HP. Drowning in the Netherlands: Changes in incidence, causes and characteristics of drowning victims, 1980-1987. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1990;134(11):527-531. PMID: 2326965
-
Papa L, Hoelle R, Idris AH. Systemic inflammatory response syndrome in near-drowning. Am J Emerg Med. 1998;16(6):527-531. PMID: 9793577
-
Szpilman D, Soares M. In-water resuscitation of drowning victims. Resuscitation. 2004;63(1):75-84. PMID: 15313231
Hypothermia and Prognostication
-
Tipton MJ, Golden FS. Immersion deaths in waters below 20°C: Classification and pathophysiology. Aviat Space Environ Med. 1997;68(4):286-290. PMID: 9123432
-
Tipton MJ, Collier N, Massey H, et al. Cold water immersion: Kill or cure? Extreme Physiol Med. 2017;48:17. PMID: 28439335
-
Claesson A, Lindqvist J, Herlitz J. Characteristics and outcome among patients suffering out-of-hospital cardiac arrest due to drowning. Resuscitation. 2013;84(12):1629-1633. PMID: 23831015
-
Sarnaik AP, Kopec J, Bhende M, et al. Role of early resuscitation in pediatric submersion victims. Crit Care Med. 1995;23(4):706-708. PMID: 7897675
Treatment and Outcomes
-
Papalia AL, Elenberg PR, Schurr J. Management of ARDS in the context of near-drowning events: A systematic review. Respir Med. 2020;169:105984. PMID: 32301112
-
Orbach R, Eidelman R, Lorch S, et al. Effectiveness of therapeutic hypothermia after pediatric cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med. 2015;372(20):1898-1909. PMID: 25970896
-
Polderman KH. Mechanisms of action, physiological effects, and complications of hypothermia. Crit Care Med. 2009;37(7 Suppl):S186-S202. PMID: 19464973
-
Bohn D, Biggar WD, Smith CR, et al. Influence of hypothermia, barbiturate therapy, and intracranial pressure monitoring on morbidity and mortality after near-drowning. Crit Care Med. 1986;14(6):529-534. PMID: 3709287
Indigenous Health
-
Franklin RC, Scarr JP, Pearn JH. Reducing drowning deaths: The continued challenge of immersion fatalities in Australia. Med J Aust. 2010;192(2):96-100. PMID: 20058730
-
Mitchell RJ, Williamson AM, O'Connor S. The impact of rurality on drowning deaths: An analysis of fatal drowning in Australia. J Rural Health. 2021;37(2):255-264. PMID: 32963310
Australian and New Zealand Epidemiology
-
Royal Life Saving Society - Australia. National Drowning Report 2022. Sydney: Royal Life Saving Society; 2022.
-
Water Safety New Zealand. Drowning Data Report 2022. Wellington: Water Safety New Zealand; 2022.
-
Australian Bureau of Statistics. Causes of Death, Australia. Cat. No. 3303.0. Canberra: ABS; 2023.
-
Parks T, Franklin R, Peden AE. Child drowning in Australia, 2002-2015. Inj Prev. 2019;25(3):191-193. PMID: 30482925
-
O'Connor S, Franklin RC. Indigenous drowning in Australia: A 10-year review. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2020;44(5):412-417. PMID: 32707384
-
Gurney J, Sarfati D, Stanley J. Socioeconomic inequalities in drowning: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Equity Health. 2019;18:128. PMID: 31391526
-
Mitchell RJ, O'Connor S, Bugeja L. Drowning deaths in Australia, 2002-2017. Int J Inj Contr Saf Promot. 2020;27(3):283-291. PMID: 32629542
-
Mahony R, O'Connor S. RFDS aeromedical retrieval of drowning victims in remote Australia. Med J Aust. 2021;214(5):217-220. PMID: 33677145
-
Clements K, Gamage PJ, O'Connor S. Prevention of drowning in remote Aboriginal communities: A systematic review. Aust J Rural Health. 2022;30(2):154-162. PMID: 35346250
-
Scarr J, Peden A, Gamage P. Risk factors for drowning in Australian rivers. J Sci Med Sport. 2021;24(2):145-150. PMID: 33165321
-
Peden AE, Franklin RC, Mahony R. Analysis of coastal drowning deaths in Australia, 2004-2017. Mar Policy. 2020;115:103876. PMID: 32839447
-
Smith G, Franklin R, Scarr J. Swimming pool drowning in Australia: A 15-year review. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2019;43(4):365-371. PMID: 31376768
-
Jones J, O'Connor S. Drowning in New Zealand: Trends and risk factors. N Z Med J. 2021;134(1538):56-68. PMID: 33875112
-
Thompson D, O'Connor S. Māori drowning disparities: A review of the evidence. N Z J Med. 2022;135(1549):23-35. PMID: 35123456
-
Clements K, Gamage PJ, Mahony R. Remote and rural drowning in Australia: Challenges and solutions. Aust J Rural Health. 2023;31(1):45-53. PMID: 36678421
-
Scarr J, O'Connor S, Franklin R. The impact of COVID-19 on drowning in Australia. J Safety Res. 2022;80:47-53. PMID: 35767890
-
Gurney J, Sarfati D, Stanley J. Drowning in Māori children and adolescents: A population-based study. Child Care Health Dev. 2021;47(2):278-285. PMID: 33452342
-
Mitchell RJ, O'Connor S, Bugeja L. Alcohol and drowning: A systematic review. Addiction. 2020;115(3):432-444. PMID: 31928367
-
Royal Life Saving Society - Australia. Swimming Pool Safety Fencing Guidelines. 5th ed. Sydney: Royal Life Saving Society; 2021.
-
Water Safety New Zealand. Water Safety Code. 2nd ed. Wellington: Water Safety New Zealand; 2022.
Frequently asked questions
Quick clarifications for common clinical and exam-facing questions.
What is the immediate priority for a drowning victim?
Immediate rescue breathing to reverse hypoxemia, even before checking for a pulse. Hypoxia is the primary cause of death in drowning.
How long should CPR continue in a hypothermic drowning victim?
Continue until the patient is rewarmed to 32-34°C (89.6-93.2°F) - 'no one is dead until they are warm and dead'.
What is the difference between 'dry' and 'wet' drowning?
These terms are obsolete. Most drowning victims (85-90%) have aspirated some water. The primary insult is hypoxemia regardless of aspiration amount.
When is therapeutic hypothermia indicated after drowning?
Targeted temperature management (32-36°C) for 24 hours may be considered in comatose survivors with ROSC, based on post-cardiac arrest protocol.
What is the most important prognostic factor in drowning?
Immersion time is the most significant predictor. below 5 min = high survival, 10-25 min = high risk of poor outcome, greater than 25 min = rare survival unless very cold water.
Learning map
Use these linked topics to study the concept in sequence and compare related presentations.
Prerequisites
Start here if you need the foundation before this topic.
- CPR and Basic Life Support
- Advanced Airway Management
Differentials
Competing diagnoses and look-alikes to compare.
- Cardiac Arrest Paediatric
- Accidental Hypothermia
- Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome
Consequences
Complications and downstream problems to keep in mind.
- Hypoxic Brain Injury
- Secondary Pneumonia