Suicidal Patient Assessment
Emergency Department (ED) suicide assessment has shifted from "predicting" suicide (statistically impossible with accept... ACEM Fellowship Written, ACEM Fellow
Clinical board
A visual summary of the highest-yield teaching signals on this page.
Urgent signals
Safety-critical features pulled from the topic metadata.
- Active suicidal ideation with specific plan and intent
- Recent suicide attempt with high lethality (hanging, firearm, jumping)
- Psychotic symptoms with command hallucinations
- Acute intoxication with stated suicidal intent
Exam focus
Current exam surfaces linked to this topic.
- ACEM Fellowship Written
- ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Linked comparisons
Differentials and adjacent topics worth opening next.
- Major Depressive Disorder
- Bipolar Disorder
Editorial and exam context
Quick Answer
One-liner: Comprehensive suicide risk assessment requires structured evaluation of ideation severity, risk/protective factors, and safety planning, not risk categorization prediction.
Emergency Department (ED) suicide assessment has shifted from "predicting" suicide (statistically impossible with acceptable sensitivity/specificity) to stratifying risk and implementing evidence-based interventions. Use validated screening tools (C-SSRS, ASQ), assess modifiable risk factors, strengthen protective factors, and create collaborative safety plans. Universal screening detects twice as many at-risk patients compared to clinical intuition alone. Never rely on "no-suicide contracts"—they lack evidence and legal standing.
ACEM Exam Focus
Primary Exam Relevance
- Anatomy: Neuroanatomical basis of depression/suicidality (prefrontal cortex, limbic system)
- Physiology: Neurotransmitter dysregulation (serotonin, noradrenaline, dopamine)
- Pharmacology: Psychotropic medications, antidote knowledge for overdoses
Fellowship Exam Relevance
- Written: Universal screening protocols, involuntary detention criteria, safety planning, lethal means counseling
- OSCE: Risk assessment communication, breaking bad news (high risk), capacity assessment, involuntary detention documentation
- Key domains tested: Medical Expert, Communicator, Professional (ethics), Health Advocate (Indigenous health equity)
Key Points
The 5 things you MUST know:
- Never categorize as "Low Risk": Many completed suicides were recently assessed as low risk. Focus on modifiable risk factors instead.
- Use validated tools: C-SSRS (gold standard) or ASQ (pediatric ED). Clinical judgment alone misses 50% of at-risk patients.
- Safety Planning > Contracts: Evidence-based Safety Planning Intervention (Stanley-Brown model) reduces attempts by 20%. "No-suicide contracts" are ineffective and discouraged.
- Lethal Means Counseling SAVES lives: Removing firearms/medications is the single most effective intervention to prevent completed suicide.
- Follow-up within 24-72h: Scheduled contact + "caring calls/texts" significantly reduce repeat attempts. Discharge planning is NOT optional.
Epidemiology
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Suicide rate (Australia) | 13 per 100,000/year | [1] |
| ED presentations (suicidal ideation/attempt) | ~3% of total ED presentations | [2] |
| Completed suicide after ED discharge | 0.05-0.1% within 30 days | [3] |
| Repeat attempt within 12 months | 10-20% | [4] |
| Gender ratio (completed suicide) | M:F = 3:1 | [1] |
| Gender ratio (suicide attempts) | F:M = 2:1 | [4] |
| Peak age groups | 15-24 years, 45-54 years | [1] |
Australian/NZ Specific
- Indigenous Australians: Suicide rates 2-4 times higher than non-Indigenous Australians, especially in remote communities [5]
- Māori (NZ): Suicide rates 1.6 times higher than non-Māori, with youth disproportionately affected [6]
- Rural/remote: Higher rates due to social isolation, limited mental health access, firearm access [7]
- Psychiatric boarding: Mental health patients wait 2.5-3 times longer in ED (8-24+ hours vs 4-hour target) [8]
Pathophysiology
Biological Mechanisms
Suicidal behavior is multifactorial, involving:
- Neurotransmitter dysregulation: Serotonin hypofunction (impulsivity, aggression), noradrenaline/dopamine deficits (anhedonia, hopelessness)
- HPA axis dysfunction: Chronic stress → cortisol dysregulation → prefrontal cortex impairment
- Genetic factors: 43-55% heritability for suicide attempts; family history increases risk 3-4 fold [9]
Psychological Progression
Chronic stressors + Psychiatric illness → Hopelessness + Cognitive rigidity → Suicidal ideation → Planning → Attempt → (Survival or Completion)
Why It Matters Clinically
Understanding that suicide is not impulsive in most cases (70% have ideation for weeks/months before attempt) allows for intervention windows. The transition from ideation to attempt is influenced by access to means and protective factors.
Clinical Approach
Recognition
Triggers for suicide screening in ED:
- All psychiatric presentations
- Deliberate self-harm/overdose
- High-risk groups: Chronic pain, terminal illness, recent psychiatric discharge, substance abuse
- Universal screening: Joint Commission mandates screening for all behavioral health evaluations
Initial Assessment
Primary Survey (if post-attempt)
- A: Airway protection (GCS <8 post-overdose/hanging)
- B: Respiratory depression (opioid/benzodiazepine overdose), hypoxia (hanging)
- C: Haemodynamic stability (exsanguination, dysrhythmia from TCA/beta-blocker)
- D: GCS, pupils, blood glucose, antidote administration
- E: Ligature marks, wrist lacerations, pill bottles, toxicology screen
History
Key Questions
| Question | Significance |
|---|---|
| "Have you had thoughts of killing yourself?" | Direct question increases disclosure; does NOT increase suicidal ideation [10] |
| "Do you have a plan? What is it?" | Specific plan + intent = highest risk category on C-SSRS |
| "Have you ever attempted suicide before?" | Previous attempt is strongest predictor of future attempts (OR 10-20) [11] |
| "Do you have access to firearms, medications, or pesticides?" | Lethal means access increases completion risk 3-5 fold [12] |
| "What keeps you from acting on these thoughts?" | Assesses protective factors (reasons for living, social support) |
| "Who can you call in a crisis?" | Identifies support network for safety planning |
Red Flag Symptoms
- Active ideation with plan and intent: C-SSRS severity level 5
- Recent high-lethality attempt: Hanging, firearm, jumping (not impulsive overdose)
- Psychotic symptoms: Command hallucinations ("voices telling me to kill myself")
- Acute intoxication + suicidal intent: Disinhibition increases impulsivity
- Hopelessness + social isolation: Beck Hopelessness Scale greater than 9 predicts attempt [13]
- Giving away possessions, writing goodbye notes: Behavioral warning signs
Examination
General Inspection
- Appearance: Self-neglect, disheveled, flat affect, psychomotor retardation
- Behavior: Agitation, pacing, poor eye contact, tearfulness
- Injuries: Ligature marks (neck), wrist lacerations (vertical vs horizontal), signs of physical trauma
Specific Findings
| System | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Mental State | Depressed mood, anhedonia, hopelessness | Core symptoms of major depression |
| Cognitive | Impaired concentration, indecisiveness, slowed processing | Executive dysfunction in severe depression |
| Perceptual | Auditory hallucinations (command type) | Psychotic depression or schizophrenia |
| Thought content | Suicidal ideation, nihilistic delusions ("I am dead") | Active psychosis or severe depression |
| Insight/Judgment | Lack of insight into illness, poor safety awareness | Indicates need for involuntary detention |
Investigations
Immediate (Resus Bay - post-attempt)
| Test | Purpose | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| ECG | Cardiotoxicity (TCA, beta-blocker, calcium channel blocker) | QRS greater than 100ms (TCA), bradycardia, AV block |
| VBG | Metabolic acidosis (salicylate, metformin, methanol) | pH <7.35, lactate greater than 4 mmol/L |
| Paracetamol level | Assess hepatotoxic risk (even if not stated in history) | greater than 150 mg/L at 4h post-ingestion |
| Blood glucose | Hypoglycemia (insulin, sulfonylurea, beta-blocker) | BGL <4 mmol/L |
Standard ED Workup
| Test | Indication | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Urine drug screen | Unknown ingestion, polysubstance use | Positive for benzodiazepines, opioids, amphetamines |
| Serum ethanol | Acute intoxication | greater than 80 mg/dL (legal intoxication limit) |
| Salicylate level | Aspirin overdose | greater than 300 mg/L = severe toxicity |
| Lithium level | Known bipolar disorder on lithium | greater than 1.5 mmol/L = toxicity |
| Thyroid function | Rule out hypothyroidism mimicking depression | Elevated TSH, low free T4 |
Advanced/Specialist
| Test | Indication | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| CT brain | Altered GCS, focal neurology, recent head trauma | Metro/tertiary |
| Psychiatry consultation | All patients with suicidal ideation/attempt | May require telepsychiatry in rural |
Point-of-Care Ultrasound
Not routinely indicated for suicide assessment, but useful for complications:
- FAST scan: Post-jump/fall with abdominal trauma
- Cardiac ultrasound: Cardiotoxic overdose (TCA, beta-blocker)
Management
Immediate Management (First 10 minutes)
1. Ensure safety: Remove sharps, ligatures, belts; 1:1 nursing observation
2. Medical stabilization: ABCDE resuscitation if post-attempt (airway, antidotes, decontamination)
3. Initiate universal screening: ASQ (pediatric) or C-SSRS (adult) within first 30 minutes
4. Contact psychiatry early: Minimize boarding time; initiate telepsychiatry if needed
5. Engage family/whānau: Cultural safety for Indigenous patients; family involvement in safety planning
Structured Risk Assessment
Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale (C-SSRS)
Gold standard validated tool [14]
Ideation Severity (past month):
- Wish to be dead: "I wish I were dead" (passive)
- Non-specific active ideation: "I've thought about killing myself"
- Ideation with method: "I've thought about overdosing"
- Ideation with intent (no plan): "I've seriously considered it"
- Ideation with intent AND plan: "I plan to hang myself on Friday" (HIGHEST RISK)
Behavior (lifetime and past 3 months):
- Actual attempt
- Interrupted attempt
- Aborted attempt
- Preparatory acts (writing note, gathering pills)
Predictive validity: C-SSRS severity ≥4 predicts attempt with OR 6.5 [14]
Alternative: Ask Suicide-Screening Questions (ASQ) - Pediatric
Sensitivity 96.9%, Specificity 87.6% [15]
- "Do you wish you were dead?"
- "Do you have thoughts about killing yourself?"
- "Have you ever tried to kill yourself?"
- "In the past week, have you been thinking about killing yourself?"
Positive screen = YES to any question → Full C-SSRS assessment
Risk and Protective Factors
Static Risk Factors (cannot be modified)
- Previous suicide attempt: Strongest predictor (OR 10-20) [11]
- Psychiatric illness: Depression (OR 20), bipolar (OR 15), schizophrenia (OR 8.5) [16]
- Substance use disorder: Alcohol (OR 6), drugs (OR 5) [17]
- Male gender: 3x higher completion rate (but females attempt 2x more often)
- Age extremes: Adolescents (15-24), middle-aged (45-54)
- Family history: First-degree relative suicide (OR 3-4) [9]
Dynamic Risk Factors (modifiable - TARGET THESE)
- Access to lethal means: Firearms (OR 3-5), pesticides (OR 2-3) [12]
- Acute psychiatric crisis: Recent discharge from inpatient unit (30-day high-risk period)
- Psychosocial stressors: Job loss, relationship breakdown, financial crisis
- Hopelessness: Beck Hopelessness Scale greater than 9 predicts attempt [13]
- Social isolation: Living alone, estranged from family
- Acute intoxication: Alcohol/drugs reduce inhibition, increase impulsivity
Protective Factors (strengthen these)
- Reasons for living: Children, pets, religious beliefs, future goals
- Strong social support: Family, friends, whānau, community
- Therapeutic alliance: Engaged with mental health services
- Problem-solving skills: Ability to manage distress, seek help
- Restricted access to means: No firearms in home, medications locked away
Safety Planning Intervention (Stanley-Brown Model)
Evidence: Reduces suicide attempts by 20-50% at 1 year [18]
Six-step collaborative process (written document given to patient):
- Recognize warning signs
- "I feel hopeless"
- "I isolate myself"
- "I drink heavily"
- Internal coping strategies (use BEFORE contacting others)
- "Go for a walk"
- "Listen to music"
- "Practice breathing exercises"
- Social contacts for distraction (NOT for crisis support)
- "Call my sister to chat"
- "Visit a friend"
- "Go to the gym"
-
Contacts for crisis support
- "Call my psychologist (Dr. Smith: 04XX XXX XXX)"
- "Call Lifeline 13 11 14 (24/7)"
- "Call mental health crisis team (1800 XXX XXX)"
-
Professional/agency contacts
- "Go to [Hospital Name] ED"
- "Call ambulance 000"
-
Lethal means restriction
- "Give my medications to my partner to store"
- "Remove firearms from home (store at gun club)"
Lethal Means Counseling
Most effective suicide prevention intervention [19]
Firearms:
- Remove from home (store with friend, gun club, police where legal)
- Even temporary removal (during crisis period) reduces risk 3-5 fold
- "Off-site storage" is gold standard (NOT locked safe at home)
Medications:
- Remove excess paracetamol, NSAIDs, psychotropics from home
- Blister packs only (NO bottles)
- Family/friend holds and dispenses daily doses
Pesticides/Herbicides (rural/farming):
- Lock away in separate shed (not in main house)
- Family member holds key
Counseling approach: Non-judgmental, collaborative, focus on "waiting period" between impulse and action (most suicidal crises last <10 minutes) [20]
Involuntary Detention Criteria (Australian Mental Health Acts)
All Australian states require THREE criteria:
- Mental illness present (defined by Act)
- Imminent risk of serious harm to self or others
- Refusal or incapacity to consent to voluntary treatment
State-specific variations:
| State | Act | Detention Period | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| NSW | Mental Health Act 2007 | Up to 12 hours (emergency), then up to 3 days (Section 27) | Requires 2 medical practitioners or 1 psychiatrist |
| VIC | Mental Health and Wellbeing Act 2022 | Up to 24 hours (assessment order) | Emphasizes human rights, lived experience input |
| QLD | Mental Health Act 2016 | Up to 6 hours (emergency examination authority) | Must be "least restrictive way" |
| WA | Mental Health Act 2014 | Up to 24 hours | Requires involuntary treatment order |
Documentation requirements:
- Clear evidence of mental illness (not just suicidal ideation)
- Specific risk of harm (not vague "risk to self")
- Voluntary options exhausted or refused
- Capacity assessment documented
- Least restrictive option chosen
Common pitfalls:
- Intoxication alone: NOT sufficient for Mental Health Act detention (use Emergency Detention)
- Personality disorder: May not meet "mental illness" criteria in some states
- Social crisis: Homelessness, relationship breakdown ≠ mental illness
Disposition
Admission Criteria (Inpatient Psychiatry)
- Active suicidal ideation with plan and intent (C-SSRS ≥4)
- Recent high-lethality attempt
- Psychotic symptoms with command hallucinations
- Lack of protective factors / unsafe home environment
- Inability to contract for safety (lack of insight/capacity)
- Ongoing acute intoxication requiring medical clearance
ICU/HDU Criteria
- Medical complications of attempt: Severe overdose, hanging with anoxic brain injury, major trauma
- Ongoing resuscitation requirements
- Cardiac monitoring for cardiotoxic ingestion
Discharge Criteria (Safe for Home)
- Suicidal ideation resolved or significantly reduced
- No active plan or intent
- Strong protective factors identified
- Safety plan completed and understood
- Lethal means removed from home
- Follow-up arranged within 24-72 hours (mental health team, GP, or crisis team)
- Capacity to keep self safe
- Supportive home environment
Follow-up
Critical 30-day period: Highest risk immediately post-discharge [21]
Mandatory components:
- Scheduled appointment within 24-72 hours: Mental health team or GP
- "Caring contacts": Phone call or text at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months (reduces attempts by 20%) [22]
- GP notification: Discharge summary within 24 hours
- Crisis contact card: Lifeline 13 11 14, local mental health crisis team, safety plan
Red flags to return:
- Worsening suicidal thoughts
- Unable to keep self safe
- Access to lethal means
- Acute intoxication
- Psychotic symptoms emerge
Special Populations
Paediatric Considerations
- Use ASQ for initial screening (4 questions, 96.9% sensitivity) [15]
- Involve parents/guardians in safety planning (unless family conflict is trigger)
- Remove lethal means: Firearms, medications (parents often underestimate teen access)
- School notification: Coordinate with school counselor if patient consents
- Higher impulsivity: Adolescents have less developed prefrontal cortex → increased risk
Pregnancy
- Perinatal depression: 10-15% of pregnant/postpartum women
- Medication safety: SSRIs generally safe (except paroxetine); avoid benzodiazepines
- Infanticide risk: Assess risk to infant in postpartum psychosis
- Multidisciplinary approach: Obstetrics, psychiatry, social work
Elderly
- Higher completion rates: Lower attempt-to-completion ratio (1:4 vs 1:20 in young adults)
- Less impulsive: More likely to use lethal means (firearms, hanging)
- Comorbidities: Chronic pain, terminal illness, bereavement, social isolation
- Screen for dementia: Cognitive impairment may mask depression
Indigenous Health
Important Note: Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, and Māori considerations:
- Suicide rates 2-4 times higher than non-Indigenous Australians (especially youth, remote communities) [5,6]
- Cultural safety: Avoid clinical "interrogation"; use yarning (narrative-based communication) to build trust [23]
- Social and Emotional Wellbeing (SEWB): Assess connection to country, culture, ancestors, community (not just individual psychiatric symptoms) [24]
- Whānau involvement (Māori): Family-centered decision-making (tikanga, manaakitanga protocols)
- Aboriginal Health Workers: Co-facilitate assessment where possible; cultural liaison services
- Intergenerational trauma: Current ideation often linked to historical loss of land, culture, identity [23]
- Strengths-based approach: "What keeps you strong?" vs "What's wrong with you?"
- Spiritual distress: Disconnection from ancestors/spirit is high-risk indicator (not captured by DSM-5) [24]
- Interpreter services: Mandatory for non-English speakers (NOT family members)
Pitfalls & Pearls
Clinical Pearls:
- Universal screening doubles detection: ED-SAFE study showed screening identifies twice as many at-risk patients vs clinical judgment alone [25]
- Most suicides were NOT high risk: 50% of completed suicides were assessed as "low risk" in prior evaluation → Avoid categorizing as "low risk"
- Capacity fluctuates: Intoxicated patient may lack capacity now but have capacity after sobering → Reassess capacity serially
- Firearms are the deadliest means: 85-90% lethality (vs 2-3% for overdose) → Lethal means counseling SAVES lives [12]
- "Caring contacts" work: Simple follow-up phone call/text at 1 week, 1 month reduces attempts by 20% [22]
- Safety planning > Contracts: No-suicide contracts are ineffective and discouraged; Safety Planning Intervention reduces attempts by 50% [18]
Pitfalls to Avoid:
- "Low risk" discharge without safety plan: NEVER discharge suicidal patient without safety plan, lethal means counseling, and scheduled follow-up
- No-suicide contracts: Evidence shows they do NOT reduce attempts; clinically discouraged [26]
- Capacity assessment while intoxicated: Intoxication impairs capacity; reassess when sober (detention under Emergency Act, NOT Mental Health Act)
- Ignoring "manipulative" patients: Personality disorder patients have same suicide risk as major depression; avoid dismissive labels
- Missing lethal means access: Always ask about firearms, medications, pesticides (especially in rural/farming communities)
- Discharge without follow-up: Critical 30-day period post-discharge; must arrange contact within 24-72 hours
- Psychiatric boarding without intervention: Start crisis intervention DURING boarding (not just "sit and wait")
Viva Practice
Stem: A 32-year-old woman presents to ED at 2am stating "I want to end it all. I can't take the pain anymore." She has a history of borderline personality disorder and three previous overdose attempts. She is currently sober and medically stable.
Opening Question: "What is your immediate approach to this patient?"
Model Answer: My immediate priorities are safety, assessment, and engagement:
- Safety first: Remove sharps, belts, ligatures from room; 1:1 nursing observation; high-visibility room near nurses' station; search belongings for medications/weapons
- Medical stability: Vital signs, blood glucose, assess for covert overdose (pupils, drowsiness)
- Engagement: Empathetic, non-judgmental approach; build rapport; avoid dismissive language ("manipulative"
- "attention-seeking")
- Structured screening: Use C-SSRS to quantify ideation severity (Does she have a plan? Intent? Access to means?)
- Contact psychiatry early: Minimize boarding time; request telepsychiatry if on-site unavailable
- Involve family/support: With patient permission, contact supportive family member
Follow-up Questions:
-
She tells you she has 50 paracetamol tablets at home and plans to take them all tonight. How does this change your management?
- Model answer: This is C-SSRS severity 5 (ideation with intent AND plan) = highest risk category. Specific plan + access to means + stated intent = involuntary detention criteria met (imminent risk of serious harm). Document her exact words. Complete safety plan. Initiate involuntary detention paperwork (state-specific Mental Health Act). Lethal means counseling: Who can remove medications from her home tonight? Arrange urgent psychiatry review. She is NOT safe for discharge.
-
The patient says "I'm not going to kill myself, I just wanted to talk to someone." Does this reassure you?
- Model answer: No. Verbal reassurance does NOT override objective risk factors (history of multiple attempts, active ideation, access to means). Patients may minimize intent when facing involuntary detention. Continue structured assessment. Assess protective factors (reasons for living, social support). Complete safety plan regardless. Ensure follow-up within 24-72 hours. Document thoroughly. If still concerned after full assessment, err on side of caution with involuntary detention.
-
What is your approach to lethal means counseling in this case?
- Model answer: Collaborative, non-judgmental discussion: "Many people in crisis have medications at home. Can we make a plan to keep you safe by removing them temporarily?" Identify who can remove paracetamol from her home tonight (partner, family member, friend). If no one available, consider social work home visit or police welfare check (with patient consent). Provide only 2-3 days of medications in blister packs (NOT bottles) upon discharge. Document plan in safety plan document.
Discussion Points:
- Borderline personality disorder ≠ "not serious": BPD patients have same suicide risk as major depression [27]
- Multiple previous attempts: Strongest predictor of future attempts (OR 10-20) [11]
- Capacity vs risk: Patient may have capacity to refuse treatment BUT if risk is imminent → involuntary detention overrides capacity
- State-specific Mental Health Acts: Know your local criteria (NSW vs VIC vs QLD)
Stem: You are working in a rural ED 400km from the nearest tertiary center. A 58-year-old male farmer is brought in by ambulance after his wife found him in the shed with a rope around his neck. He is medically stable (no anoxic injury) but states "I'm a failure, my farm is bankrupt, everyone would be better off without me."
Opening Question: "Outline your approach to this patient in a resource-limited setting."
Model Answer: This is a high-risk patient (male, middle-aged, hopelessness, high-lethality attempt, access to means, rural isolation):
- Medical clearance: Ligature marks documented, GCS 15, pupils, cervical spine examination, ECG (exclude dysrhythmia), observe for delayed anoxic injury (4-6 hours)
- Risk assessment: C-SSRS (likely severity 5 = active attempt). Assess current ideation: "Are you still having thoughts of ending your life?" Protective factors: Wife (supportive?), children, farm animals
- Telepsychiatry: Contact tertrial psychiatry via videolink for urgent consultation (most rural EDs have telepsychiatry access)
- Safety plan: Cannot discharge unsupervised. If psychiatry recommends involuntary detention, arrange RFDS retrieval to tertiary mental health unit (may take 6-12 hours)
- Lethal means counseling: Firearms (common in rural farming communities) → Wife to remove firearms from property, store at police station or friend's home. Rope/ligatures removed. Pesticides/herbicides locked away (key held by wife)
- Family engagement: Wife is key protective factor. Educate on warning signs, crisis contacts, remove lethal means. Provide Lifeline number (13 11 14), local mental health crisis team
Follow-up Questions:
-
Telepsychiatry is unavailable (system down). What now?
- Model answer: Phone consultation with on-call psychiatrist (backup for telepsychiatry). If psychiatrist unavailable, use clinical judgment + documented risk assessment (C-SSRS, risk/protective factors). If imminent risk → involuntary detention under state Mental Health Act (can be initiated by ED physician + second medical practitioner). Arrange RFDS retrieval. Document decision-making thoroughly. Call retrieval service early (long wait times).
-
The patient refuses to stay, wants to go home. His wife says "I'll watch him." What do you do?
- Model answer: Assess capacity: Does he understand his illness, the risks of leaving, the treatment options? If capacity intact BUT risk is imminent → involuntary detention overrides refusal. If wife "watching him" is the only plan → Unsafe. High-lethality attempt + ongoing ideation + access to means = involuntary detention criteria met. Explain decision compassionately. Document. Arrange retrieval. If patient becomes aggressive, security + sedation PRN (olanzapine 10mg PO or IM, or droperidol 5-10mg IM).
-
What specific rural/remote challenges impact suicide management?
- Model answer:
- Limited mental health services: No on-site psychiatry, long wait for telepsychiatry, RFDS retrieval delays (6-24 hours)
- Firearm access: 2-3x more common in rural households → higher lethality
- Social isolation: Farmers often isolated, stoic culture ("toughen up"), reluctant to seek help
- Pesticide/herbicide access: Rural-specific lethal means
- Boarding challenges: Small rural ED may lack secure psychiatric area; may require 1:1 security guard
- Follow-up barriers: Nearest mental health team may be 100-200km away; telemedicine follow-up essential
- Model answer:
Discussion Points:
- RFDS mental health retrievals: 10-15% of RFDS retrievals are psychiatric emergencies [28]
- Rural male suicide: 1.5-2x higher than urban; peak in farmers/agricultural workers [7]
- Firearm access: 40-50% of rural households have firearms (vs 10-15% urban) [29]
- Cultural factors: Stoicism, self-reliance, reluctance to seek help ("mental health stigma")
Stem: A 16-year-old Aboriginal girl is brought to ED by her aunt after posting on social media "Nobody cares about me, I'm going to disappear." She has a history of childhood trauma (removed from family at age 8, multiple foster placements) and cannabis use. She is tearful, withdrawn, and refuses to speak to you.
Opening Question: "How do you approach assessment of this patient in a culturally safe manner?"
Model Answer: This case requires cultural safety, trauma-informed care, and whānau engagement:
- Cultural safety first: Request Aboriginal Health Worker or cultural liaison to co-facilitate assessment. Avoid "interrogation" style; use yarning (narrative storytelling) to build trust. Acknowledge discomfort with clinical setting.
- Whānau involvement: Engage aunt (primary caregiver). Assess family support. Identify cultural connections (Elders, community, Country).
- Trauma-informed approach: Childhood removal ("Stolen Generations" trauma) + foster placements = intergenerational trauma. Avoid triggering questions. Build safety first.
- Assessment when patient ready: May require multiple sessions. Use ASQ (age-appropriate) when rapport established. Assess Social and Emotional Wellbeing (SEWB): Connection to culture, community, identity (not just individual symptoms) [24]
- Strengths-based: "What keeps you strong?" vs "What's wrong with you?" Identify protective factors: Aunt, cultural identity, aspirations, art/music.
- Safety planning: Collaborative with aunt. Lethal means: Remove medications, sharps. Crisis contacts: Aunt, Aboriginal mental health service, headspace, Lifeline.
Follow-up Questions:
-
What specific cultural considerations impact suicide risk in Aboriginal youth?
- Model answer:
- Intergenerational trauma: Stolen Generations, loss of land/culture/language → profound grief, identity disruption [23]
- Cultural disconnection: Removal from family/Country → "spiritual distress" (not captured by Western psychiatric tools) [24]
- Social determinants: Poverty, poor housing, limited education, racism → hopelessness
- Substance use: Cannabis, alcohol as coping mechanisms → disinhibition, impulsivity
- Youth suicide rates: 4-5x higher than non-Indigenous youth in remote communities [5]
- Cluster/contagion: Social media, peer suicide → increased risk in close-knit communities
- Model answer:
-
She continues to refuse assessment. Can you involuntarily detain her?
- Model answer: Refusal of assessment ≠ refusal of treatment. Engage aunt: "Can you help us understand what's happening?" Use Aboriginal Health Worker to build rapport. If patient is immediate danger to self (active attempt, weapons, etc.) → involuntary detention under Mental Health Act (imminent risk of serious harm). If refusing to speak but medically stable → Observation period (6-12 hours) + continued engagement. Involve youth mental health team. Do NOT force assessment (traumatic, destroys trust). Document attempts. If risk escalates → detention.
-
What follow-up is essential for this patient?
- Model answer: Discharge is HIGH RISK. Ideal disposition: Aboriginal mental health service (culturally appropriate, trauma-informed). If not available: headspace (youth-focused), GP with Aboriginal health experience, school counselor. Follow-up within 24-48 hours (NOT 1 week). "Caring contacts" via aunt. Address social determinants: Housing, education, cultural programs (art, dance, connection to Elders). Safety plan includes aunt, cultural supports. Remove lethal means. Cannabis cessation support.
Discussion Points:
- Aboriginal youth suicide epidemic: Rates 4-5x higher than non-Indigenous youth [5]
- Social and Emotional Wellbeing (SEWB): Holistic model assessing connection to culture, Country, community, ancestors [24]
- Yarning: Narrative communication; builds trust; culturally appropriate [23]
- Intergenerational trauma: Stolen Generations, forced removal → profound impact on mental health [23]
- Aboriginal Health Workers: Essential for culturally safe care; should be involved in all assessments
Stem: It is 3am in a busy metropolitan ED. You have four psychiatric patients "boarding" (waiting for inpatient beds): (1) 45-year-old suicidal depression, (2) 28-year-old manic bipolar, (3) 72-year-old dementia with aggression, (4) 19-year-old psychosis. All have been waiting 12-18 hours. Beds are not expected for another 6-12 hours. The nursing staff are overwhelmed.
Opening Question: "How do you manage this situation?"
Model Answer: This is a systems issue requiring triage, intervention, and escalation:
-
Re-triage by acuity: Which patient has highest risk of deterioration?
- Suicidal depression: Re-assess ideation (has it worsened?). Safety plan review. Crisis intervention.
- Manic bipolar: Risk of aggression, elopement. Sedation PRN. Frequent re-assessment.
- Dementia with aggression: Safety to staff/patients. Sedation PRN. Delirium screen.
- Psychosis: Command hallucinations? Paranoia? Sedation PRN. Risk of violence.
-
Start interventions during boarding (NOT just "sit and wait"):
- Suicidal patient: Safety Planning Intervention (Stanley-Brown model), supportive counseling, engage family
- Manic patient: Quiet room, low stimulation, olanzapine 10-20mg PO/IM, involve family
- Dementia patient: Delirium workup (UTI, constipation, infection), avoid restraints, familiar face (family), reassurance
- Psychosis patient: Antipsychotic initiation (risperidone 2mg PO, olanzapine 10mg PO), reality orientation, low stimulation
-
Resource allocation: Assign 1:1 nursing to highest-risk patient (suicidal or aggressive). Use security if needed. Rotate nursing staff to prevent burnout.
-
Escalate: Notify ED director, psychiatry consultant, bed manager. Request expedited bed allocation. Consider telehealth psychiatric admission to another facility if local beds unavailable.
-
Document thoroughly: Boarding times, interventions attempted, risk assessments, escalations made
Discussion Points:
- Psychiatric boarding: Mental health patients wait 2.5-3x longer than other ED patients [8]
- ED environment: High-stimulus, bright lights, noise → worsens psychiatric symptoms
- Boarding interventions: Safety planning, crisis counseling, medication initiation can reduce symptoms DURING boarding [30]
- Least restrictive environment: Boarding in general ED cubicle is NOT least restrictive; advocate for appropriate psychiatric area
OSCE Scenarios
Station 1: Suicide Risk Assessment and Safety Planning
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED cubicle
Candidate Instructions:
You are the ED registrar. Ms. Sarah Chen, a 34-year-old accountant, has presented with her partner stating "I can't cope anymore." She has a history of depression and took an overdose of 10 paracetamol tablets 2 years ago. Your task is to:
- Assess her suicide risk using a structured approach
- Create a safety plan collaboratively
- Decide on appropriate disposition
Examiner Instructions: Ms. Chen is tearful, cooperative, and willing to engage. She reports:
- Suicidal thoughts for past 2 weeks ("I think about it every day")
- No specific plan ("I haven't thought that far")
- No intent ("I don't actually want to die, I just want the pain to stop")
- Protective factors: Supportive partner, 8-year-old daughter, employed, engaged with psychologist
- Access to means: Husband's antidepressants at home (50x sertraline 100mg), no firearms
- Previous attempt: Paracetamol overdose 2 years ago (8 hours hospital observation, no NAC)
If asked directly: "I would never leave my daughter without a mother."
Actor/Patient Brief: You are Sarah, exhausted from work stress and feeling overwhelmed. You are relieved to be talking to someone. You WANT help. You will engage openly if the doctor is empathetic and non-judgmental. If the doctor seems rushed or dismissive, become tearful and withdrawn.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Introduction, consent, rapport, empathy | /2 |
| Risk Assessment | Uses C-SSRS or structured tool; assesses ideation, plan, intent, means, protective factors | /3 |
| Safety Planning | Collaboratively creates 6-step safety plan (warning signs, coping, contacts, means restriction) | /2 |
| Lethal Means | Addresses medications at home (removal, blister packs) | /1 |
| Communication | Non-judgmental, validates distress, normalizes help-seeking | /2 |
| Disposition | Appropriate plan (discharge with follow-up vs admission); clear safety-netting | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators:
- Uses structured tool (C-SSRS) vs vague questions
- Creates written safety plan vs verbal reassurance
- Addresses lethal means (medications) vs ignores
- Arranges follow-up within 24-72 hours vs "see GP when you can"
Station 2: Involuntary Detention Discussion
Format: Communication (difficult conversation) Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED consultation room
Candidate Instructions:
Mr. David Brown, a 52-year-old with bipolar disorder, presented after a suicide attempt (hanging, interrupted by wife). He is medically stable. Psychiatry has recommended involuntary detention for inpatient admission, but Mr. Brown is refusing. Your task is to:
- Explain the involuntary detention decision
- Address his concerns
- Obtain his cooperation (or manage refusal)
Examiner Instructions: Mr. Brown is angry, feels "trapped," and states "You can't force me to stay, I know my rights!" He has capacity to understand the situation but disagrees with the decision. He will challenge the candidate on legal grounds. If handled empathetically, he will reluctantly agree. If candidate is defensive or authoritarian, he will escalate anger.
Actor/Patient Brief: You are David, feeling humiliated and angry. You attempted suicide in a moment of despair but now feel better and want to go home to your wife. You believe the doctors are "overreacting." You will argue: "I have the right to refuse treatment!" and "You're just covering yourselves legally." If the doctor listens to your concerns and explains clearly WITHOUT being condescending, you will reluctantly accept.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Empathy | Acknowledges distress, validates feelings, non-judgmental | /2 |
| Explanation | Clearly explains THREE criteria for involuntary detention (mental illness, imminent risk, refusal/incapacity) | /3 |
| Legal knowledge | Describes state-specific Mental Health Act, patient rights (appeal, second opinion), least restrictive option | /2 |
| Communication | Calm, professional, avoids defensiveness, active listening | /2 |
| Outcome | Obtains cooperation OR manages refusal safely (security, sedation PRN) | /2 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators:
- Empathetic vs authoritarian approach
- Explains legal criteria clearly vs vague "for your safety"
- Discusses patient rights (appeal) vs ignores
- Obtains cooperation vs escalates conflict
Station 3: Breaking Bad News (High Suicide Risk)
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED relatives' room
Candidate Instructions:
You are the ED registrar. Mrs. Linda Grant's 17-year-old son, Tom, was brought in after a serious suicide attempt (hanging, 5 minutes without oxygen). He is intubated in ICU with severe anoxic brain injury. Prognosis is poor (likely persistent vegetative state or death). Mrs. Grant is in the relatives' room waiting for an update. Your task is to:
- Break the bad news about Tom's condition
- Address her questions about "why this happened"
- Provide ongoing support
Examiner Instructions: Mrs. Grant is devastated, tearful, and in shock. She had "no idea" Tom was suicidal. She will ask: "Why didn't he tell me?" "Is this my fault?" "Will he recover?" Candidate must navigate grief, guilt, and uncertainty while providing clear medical information.
Actor/Patient Brief: You are Linda, Tom's mother. You are overwhelmed with grief and guilt. Tom seemed "fine" yesterday. You blame yourself for not noticing. You will cry, ask repetitive questions, and need reassurance that this is not your fault. If the doctor is empathetic and patient, you will eventually accept the information. If rushed or cold, you will become angry.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Setting | Quiet room, tissues, sitting down, phone off, introduces self | /1 |
| Warning shot | "I'm afraid I have some difficult news about Tom..." | /1 |
| Breaking news | Clear, simple language; avoids jargon; pauses for questions | /2 |
| Addressing guilt | Normalizes hidden distress in adolescents; reassures mother this is NOT her fault | /2 |
| Empathy | Validates grief, allows silence, offers tissues, offers to call support person | /2 |
| Follow-up | Offers ongoing updates, ICU team involvement, social work, bereavement support, GP notification | /3 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators:
- Uses "warning shot" vs blurts bad news
- Addresses guilt compassionately vs ignores
- Offers ongoing support vs "hands off to ICU"
- Allows time for questions vs rushes
SAQ Practice
Question 1 (8 marks)
Stem: A 28-year-old woman presents to ED stating "I took 50 paracetamol tablets 30 minutes ago because I want to die." She is tearful, alert (GCS 15), and medically stable. Observations: HR 88, BP 125/78, SpO2 99% on room air, temperature 36.8°C.
Question: Outline your immediate management in the first 30 minutes (8 marks).
Model Answer:
- Safety: Remove sharps, ligatures, belts from room; 1:1 nursing observation; high-visibility room (1 mark)
- Medical resuscitation: IV access, bloods (paracetamol level at 4 hours post-ingestion, FBC, UEC, LFTs, coagulation), VBG (1 mark)
- Decontamination: Activated charcoal 50g PO if within 1-2 hours of ingestion (currently 30 minutes → YES) (1 mark)
- Antidote: N-acetylcysteine (NAC) if paracetamol level greater than 150 mg/L at 4 hours (start empirically if delay in level) (1 mark)
- Suicide risk assessment: Use C-SSRS or ASQ to assess ideation severity, plan, intent, access to means, protective factors (1 mark)
- Contact psychiatry: Early referral for assessment (minimize boarding time) (1 mark)
- Engage support: Contact family/partner with patient consent; involve in safety planning (1 mark)
- Document: Exact words ("I want to die"), timeline, mental state examination, capacity assessment (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Gastric lavage within 1 hour (though less effective than charcoal)
- Do not accept: "No-suicide contract", discharge without psychiatry review, delaying NAC
- Common mistakes: Forgetting activated charcoal (within 1-2 hours), not contacting psychiatry, inadequate documentation
Question 2 (6 marks)
Stem: A 45-year-old man with depression is being discharged from ED after presenting with suicidal ideation (no plan, no intent). He is medically stable, cooperative, and has supportive family.
Question: List SIX components of the Safety Planning Intervention that must be completed before discharge (6 marks).
Model Answer:
- Warning signs: Recognize personal triggers (e.g., "I feel hopeless," "I isolate myself") (1 mark)
- Internal coping strategies: Activities to do BEFORE contacting others (e.g., "Go for a walk," "Listen to music," "Deep breathing") (1 mark)
- Social contacts for distraction: People to contact for non-crisis support (e.g., "Call my brother to chat," "Visit a friend") (1 mark)
- Contacts for crisis support: People who can help in a crisis (e.g., "Call my psychologist," "Call Lifeline 13 11 14") (1 mark)
- Professional/agency contacts: Emergency services (e.g., "Go to [Hospital Name] ED," "Call ambulance 000") (1 mark)
- Lethal means restriction: Remove firearms, medications, pesticides from home (e.g., "Give my medications to my wife to store") (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Any reasonable examples of each component
- Do not accept: "No-suicide contract" as component (NOT evidence-based)
- Common mistakes: Missing lethal means restriction, vague "call someone" without specific contacts
Question 3 (8 marks)
Stem: You are working in a rural ED. A 58-year-old male farmer has been brought in after an interrupted hanging attempt. He is medically stable but states "I'm a burden to my family, they'd be better off without me." He has access to firearms at home.
Question: Describe your approach to lethal means counseling for this patient (8 marks).
Model Answer:
- Non-judgmental approach: "Many people in your situation have thoughts like these. Let's talk about how to keep you safe." (1 mark)
- Firearms removal: Collaborate with family to remove ALL firearms from property. Store at police station, gun club, or friend's home (NOT locked safe at home) (2 marks)
- Temporary removal: Emphasize this is TEMPORARY (during crisis period), not permanent confiscation. Increases patient buy-in (1 mark)
- Rope/ligatures: Remove from home. Family disposes of rope used in attempt. Lock shed if contains ligatures (1 mark)
- Pesticides/herbicides: Common in farming households. Lock away in separate shed (NOT in main house). Family member holds key (1 mark)
- Medications: Remove excess paracetamol, antidepressants. Provide only 2-3 days supply in blister packs (NOT bottles). Family dispenses daily (1 mark)
- Document: Record specific means removed, who removed them, where stored. Include in safety plan (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Any reasonable approach to removing lethal means
- Do not accept: "Patient promises not to use firearms" (NOT effective), locked safe at home (still accessible)
- Common mistakes: Not addressing firearms (rural-specific), not involving family, temporary vs permanent removal
Question 4 (8 marks)
Stem: A 16-year-old Aboriginal girl presents with suicidal ideation. She has a history of childhood trauma (removed from family at age 8) and is currently living with her aunt. She is withdrawn and reluctant to engage with you.
Question: Describe FOUR culturally safe practices you would use to assess this patient (8 marks).
Model Answer:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Worker or cultural liaison: Co-facilitate assessment to build trust and ensure cultural safety (2 marks)
- Whānau/family engagement: Involve aunt (primary caregiver) in assessment and safety planning. Recognize family-centered decision-making (2 marks)
- Yarning approach: Use narrative storytelling (not "interrogation" style). Allow patient to share story in her own words. Builds rapport (2 marks)
- Assess Social and Emotional Wellbeing (SEWB): Ask about connection to culture, community, Country, Elders (holistic wellbeing, not just individual psychiatric symptoms) (2 marks)
Alternative acceptable answers (choose 4 from 6): 5. Trauma-informed care: Acknowledge childhood removal ("Stolen Generations" trauma). Avoid triggering questions. Build safety first (2 marks) 6. Strengths-based approach: "What keeps you strong?" vs "What's wrong with you?" Identify cultural identity, art, music, community as protective factors (2 marks)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Any 4 of the 6 components (2 marks each)
- Do not accept: "Just be nice," "Treat her like any other patient" (NOT culturally safe)
- Common mistakes: Not involving Aboriginal Health Worker, not assessing SEWB, Western-only psychiatric framework
Australian Guidelines
ARC/ANZCOR
- Not applicable: Suicide assessment is not covered by resuscitation guidelines
Therapeutic Guidelines
- Therapeutic Guidelines: Psychotropic (Version 8, 2024):
- Antidepressant initiation in suicidal depression (SSRI first-line)
- Avoid tricyclic antidepressants (TCA) due to overdose lethality
- Benzodiazepines for acute agitation (short-term only)
State-Specific (Mental Health Acts)
NSW: Mental Health Act 2007
- Section 19: Emergency detention by police (up to 6 hours)
- Section 27: Recommendation for involuntary admission (up to 3 days)
- Criteria: Mental illness + risk of serious harm + refusal of voluntary treatment
- Requires: 2 medical practitioners OR 1 psychiatrist + 1 other practitioner
VIC: Mental Health and Wellbeing Act 2022
- Assessment Order: Up to 24 hours
- Temporary Treatment Order: Up to 28 days
- Emphasizes: Human rights, recovery-oriented, consumer/carer involvement
- Requires: 1 registered medical practitioner + 1 mental health practitioner
QLD: Mental Health Act 2016
- Emergency Examination Authority (EEA): Up to 6 hours
- Recommendation for Assessment: Up to 7 days
- Criteria: "Least restrictive way" principle
- Requires: 1 doctor OR authorized mental health practitioner
WA: Mental Health Act 2014
- Referral for Psychiatric Assessment: Up to 24 hours
- Involuntary Treatment Order: Up to 28 days
- Requires: 1 medical practitioner
Remote/Rural Considerations
Pre-Hospital
- Ambulance paramedics: Trained in Mental Health First Aid; can initiate involuntary transport under state legislation
- Police welfare check: Can be requested if patient leaves ED AMA (Against Medical Advice) and risk remains high
- RFDS coordination: May require mental health retrieval (10-15% of RFDS retrievals are psychiatric) [28]
Resource-Limited Setting
- No on-site psychiatry: Use telepsychiatry (videolink to tertiary psychiatrist)
- Telepsychiatry equivalent outcomes: Assessment accuracy comparable to in-person [31]
- Limited secure area: Improvise with high-visibility room, 1:1 nursing/security
- Medication options: Olanzapine PO/IM (sedation), droperidol IM (rapid tranquilization)
Retrieval
Criteria for RFDS retrieval:
- Involuntary detention requiring inpatient admission (no local psychiatric beds)
- High-risk patient requiring tertiary mental health unit
- Medical complications requiring tertiary ICU (anoxic brain injury post-hanging)
Retrieval challenges:
- Delay 6-24 hours (depends on distance, weather, aircraft availability)
- Boarding in rural ED during wait (intervention essential)
- Blood products/medications may be limited (arrange in advance)
RFDS mental health team: Doctor + nurse ± psychiatrist (telepsychiatry during flight)
Telemedicine
- Telepsychiatry: Videolink assessment by psychiatrist (equivalent to in-person)
- Rural follow-up: Videolink appointments with mental health team (reduces travel burden)
- "Caring contacts": Phone/SMS follow-up at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months (reduces attempts) [22]
Post-Attempt Medical Complications
Hanging/Strangulation
Mechanism: Compression of carotid arteries → cerebral hypoxia; compression of trachea → asphyxiation
Clinical features:
- Ligature marks: Horizontal (hanging), angled upward (strangulation)
- Petechiae: Conjunctival, facial (venous congestion)
- Delayed complications: Cerebral edema (peaks 24-72h), laryngeal edema (airway obstruction)
Management:
- Airway: Intubation if GCS ≤8, severe stridor, or hypoxia (SpO2 <90%)
- Cervical spine precautions: Until clinically/radiologically cleared
- CT brain: If GCS <15, focal neurology, or prolonged hypoxic time (greater than 5 minutes)
- Observation: Minimum 6 hours for delayed neurological deterioration
- ICU admission: Anoxic brain injury, ongoing ventilation, therapeutic hypothermia consideration
Prognostic indicators [64]:
- GCS on arrival: GCS 3-5 = 80% mortality or persistent vegetative state
- Duration of hypoxia: greater than 10 minutes = poor neurological outcome
- Cardiac arrest: Pre-hospital cardiac arrest = 90% mortality
Overdose/Poisoning
Common agents:
- Paracetamol: 150g nomogram, NAC within 8 hours (24-hour protocol in Australia)
- Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA): QRS greater than 100ms, sodium bicarbonate 50-100 mEq IV
- Benzodiazepines: Flumazenil generally NOT recommended (seizure risk)
- SSRIs: Serotonin syndrome (hyperthermia, rigidity, clonus) → cyproheptadine 4-8mg PO
- Opioids: Naloxone 400-800 mcg IV/IM/IN; may require infusion (fentanyl, methadone)
Key principles:
- Never discharge after self-poisoning until medically cleared (paracetamol level at 4h minimum)
- Activated charcoal: Within 1-2 hours if greater than 30 tablets ingested
- Enhanced elimination: Hemodialysis for salicylate, lithium, methanol, ethylene glycol
- Psychiatric assessment: Only AFTER medical clearance (capacity intact, not intoxicated)
Wrist Lacerations
Assessment:
- Horizontal ("cry for help"): Superficial, minimal tendon/nerve injury
- Vertical ("serious intent"): Deep, often involves tendons/nerves/arteries
Management:
- Haemostasis: Direct pressure, elevation, tourniquet if exsanguinating
- Tendon examination: Flexor digitorum superficialis (FDS), flexor digitorum profundus (FDP), flexor pollicis longus (FPL)
- Nerve examination: Median, ulnar, radial nerve motor and sensory function
- Vascular examination: Radial/ulnar pulses, Allen test, cap refill
- Surgical referral: Tendon/nerve/arterial injury requires hand surgery within 6-12 hours
- Tetanus prophylaxis: If not up to date
Disposition:
- Simple lacerations: Primary closure, hand clinic follow-up 48 hours
- Complex injuries: Theatre for exploration and repair
Pharmacological Management of Acute Agitation
Indications for Sedation
- Severe agitation preventing assessment
- Risk of violence to self/staff/others
- Refusing to stay for involuntary detention
- Intoxication with disinhibition
First-Line Agents (Oral)
Olanzapine (Zyprexa):
- Dose: 5-10mg PO (wafer dissolves in mouth)
- Onset: 30-60 minutes
- Duration: 6-12 hours
- Advantages: Non-sedating at low doses, low EPS risk, oral formulation
- Cautions: Avoid in Parkinson's, elderly (stroke risk), diabetes (hyperglycemia)
Lorazepam (Ativan):
- Dose: 1-2mg PO
- Onset: 20-30 minutes
- Duration: 6-8 hours
- Advantages: Rapid onset, reversible (flumazenil)
- Cautions: Respiratory depression (especially with opioids/alcohol), paradoxical agitation in dementia
Intramuscular Agents (if refusing PO)
Olanzapine IM:
- Dose: 5-10mg IM
- Onset: 15-30 minutes
- Cautions: DO NOT combine with IM benzodiazepines (respiratory depression, hypotension)
Droperidol (Droleptan):
- Dose: 5-10mg IM
- Onset: 5-10 minutes (fastest)
- Duration: 2-4 hours
- Advantages: Rapid, effective, short duration
- Cautions: QT prolongation (monitor ECG), avoid if QTc greater than 500ms, extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS) 5-10% [65]
Midazolam IM:
- Dose: 5-10mg IM
- Onset: 5-15 minutes
- Cautions: Respiratory depression, requires monitoring, paradoxical agitation
Mechanical Restraint
Indications (last resort):
- Imminent risk of violence to self/others
- Pharmacological sedation failed or contraindicated
- Acute medical emergency requiring immediate treatment (e.g., intubation)
Principles [66]:
- Least restrictive: Only use if verbal de-escalation and medication failed
- Time-limited: Maximum 4 hours, reassess hourly
- Documentation: Justification, alternatives tried, duration, reassessment
- Observation: Continuous 1:1 nursing, vital signs q15min
- Complications: Asphyxiation (prone position), rhabdomyolysis, VTE, psychological trauma
Legal requirements: Most Australian states require Medical Officer documentation + nursing supervision
Specific High-Risk Populations
Chronic Pain Patients
Why at risk:
- Depression comorbidity: 30-50% [67]
- Opioid use: Disinhibition, overdose risk
- Functional impairment: Hopelessness, financial stress
- Social isolation: Withdrawal from activities
Assessment considerations:
- Pain-focused ideation: "If I can't get rid of this pain, I'll end it"
- Opioid contracts: Review if patient has diverted medications for overdose
- Functional assessment: What has pain taken away? (work, hobbies, relationships)
Management:
- Pain optimization: Multimodal analgesia, refer to pain clinic
- Opioid safety: Limit quantity (3-7 days max), naloxone prescription, family holds medications
- Depression screening: PHQ-9, refer to psychologist
- Functional restoration: Physiotherapy, occupational therapy, graded exercise
Terminal Illness
Why at risk:
- Loss of autonomy and dignity
- Uncontrolled symptoms (pain, dyspnea, nausea)
- Fear of suffering and being a burden
- Depression (not inevitable in terminal illness)
Assessment:
- Distinguish: Passive death wish ("I wish it would be over") vs active suicidal intent ("I plan to overdose")
- Palliative care consultation: Symptom optimization may reduce passive wishes
- Depression treatment: SSRIs (start low, go slow), psychotherapy
- Advanced care planning: Discuss goals of care, resuscitation preferences (NOT "no-suicide contract")
Ethical considerations:
- Voluntary Assisted Dying (VAD): Legal in VIC, WA, TAS, QLD, SA, NSW (specific eligibility criteria)
- VAD ≠ Suicide: Legally distinct; patients must have capacity, terminal illness (<6-12 months), and follow formal process
- Suicidal ideation in VAD-eligible patients: Still requires assessment and treatment of reversible factors (depression, pain)
Post-Discharge Psychiatric Patients
Why at risk:
- Critical 30-day period: 100-200x higher suicide risk than general population [21]
- Transition of care gaps: Medication changes, discharge planning, follow-up delays
- Loss of structured environment: 24/7 supervision → independent living
Risk factors for post-discharge suicide:
- Discharged against medical advice (AMA)
- No outpatient follow-up arranged
- Recent diagnosis of serious mental illness
- Multiple previous admissions
- Lack of social support
Preventive interventions:
- Immediate follow-up: Appointment within 7 days of discharge (ideally 48 hours)
- Caring contacts: Phone call at 1, 2, 4, 8, 12 weeks post-discharge [22]
- Crisis planning: Written safety plan given at discharge
- GP notification: Discharge summary sent within 24 hours (email, fax, or electronic health record)
- Medication supply: 7-14 days max (NOT 30 days); family holds excess
- Community mental health team: Handover to case manager
LGBTQI+ Individuals
Why at risk:
- Discrimination and stigma: Minority stress, family rejection, bullying
- Higher rates: 2-3x higher suicide attempts than heterosexual/cisgender peers [68]
- Trans and gender-diverse youth: 40-50% lifetime suicide attempt rate [69]
Assessment considerations:
- Use patient's pronouns and chosen name: Builds trust, reduces distress
- Ask about discrimination: "Have you experienced discrimination related to your sexuality/gender identity?"
- Family support: Assess acceptance vs rejection (family rejection = 8x higher suicide risk) [70]
- Access to LGBTQI+ services: Refer to LGBTQI+ mental health services, QLife (1800 184 527)
Management:
- Affirming care: Validate identity, avoid pathologizing
- Safety planning: Include LGBTQI+ supports (QLife, Lifeline, local LGBTQI+ groups)
- Referral: LGBTQI+ affirmative psychologist or psychiatrist
Crisis Intervention Techniques in the ED
De-escalation Strategies
Verbal de-escalation (use BEFORE medication/restraint):
-
SAFER approach [71]:
- Self-regulation: Remain calm, controlled voice, non-threatening posture
- Assess: Identify triggers (pain, fear, frustration)
- Facilitate: Help patient identify solutions
- Empathize: Validate feelings ("I can see you're very distressed")
- Respond: Offer choices, collaborate on plan
-
Environmental modification:
- Quiet room, low lighting, door open (reduce sense of confinement)
- Remove unnecessary staff (limit to 2-3 people max)
- Offer food, drink, blanket (basic needs)
- Remove stressors (loud alarms, bright lights, overcrowding)
-
Communication techniques:
- Active listening: Reflect back ("You're saying you feel hopeless right now?")
- Validate emotions: "It makes sense you feel this way given what you've been through"
- Avoid: Arguing, challenging delusions, dismissing concerns ("You don't really want to die")
- Offer choices: "Would you like to talk here or in a quieter room?"
Contraindications to de-escalation (move to medication/restraint):
- Imminent violence: Patient making threats, brandishing weapon
- Psychotic agitation: Not responding to verbal cues, paranoid, disorganized
- Intoxication: Severe agitation from stimulants (methamphetamine, cocaine)
Motivational Interviewing for Ambivalent Patients
Principle: Most suicidal patients are ambivalent (want pain to end, not life to end). Use MI to strengthen life side.
OARS technique [72]:
- Open-ended questions: "Tell me about what's been happening"
- Affirmations: "You've been incredibly strong to make it through this"
- Reflective listening: "It sounds like you feel trapped and don't see a way out"
- Summarizing: "Let me make sure I understand – you're struggling with work stress, financial problems, and feeling isolated..."
Eliciting change talk:
- "What are your reasons for living?" (not "Do you have reasons for living?")
- "What would need to change for you to feel hopeful again?"
- "How have you coped with difficult times in the past?"
- "What's important to you right now?" (children, pets, future goals)
Developing discrepancy:
- "You said you love your daughter more than anything, AND you're thinking about ending your life. How do these two things fit together?"
- (Patient realizes discrepancy → strengthens commitment to life)
Managing the "Manipulative" or "Frequent Flyer" Patient
Common scenario: Patient with borderline personality disorder (BPD) or chronic suicidality, multiple ED presentations
Pitfalls to avoid:
- Labeling as "manipulative": Invalidates distress, prevents empathy, increases staff burnout
- Dismissing risk: BPD patients have same lifetime suicide risk as major depression (8-10%) [27]
- Inconsistent management: Different approaches on each visit → reinforces "splitting" behavior
Evidence-based approach [73]:
- Consistent multidisciplinary plan: ED, psychiatry, community mental health agree on approach
- Brief focused assessment: C-SSRS, current stressors, safety plan review (NOT lengthy exploration of past trauma in ED)
- Validate distress + Set boundaries: "I can see you're in a lot of pain right now. We're here to keep you safe. Let's focus on getting you through tonight safely"
- Safety planning: Short-term coping (distraction, grounding), crisis contacts, means restriction
- Avoid admission for "respite": Admission only if acute risk (plan + intent + means). Frequent admissions reinforce maladaptive coping
- Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) referral: Gold standard for BPD (reduces self-harm by 50%) [74]
Boundary setting example:
"Sarah, I understand you're in a lot of pain, and we want to help. However, I need to be honest with you: the Emergency Department isn't the right place for long-term support. What we CAN do is make sure you're safe tonight and connect you with your DBT therapist tomorrow. Let's make a plan for the next 24 hours."
Collaborative Problem-Solving
For patients refusing admission (when involuntary detention not justified):
Step 1: Understand concerns
- "What are your concerns about staying in hospital?"
- Common responses: "I'll lose my job"
- "Who will feed my dog?"
- "Hospitals make me worse"
Step 2: Validate + Problem-solve
- "I understand you're worried about your job. Let's think about how we can address that. Could you call your employer and explain you're in hospital for a medical issue? Would a medical certificate help?"
- "I hear you about your dog. Is there someone who can feed him tonight? Your neighbor? We can help you make that phone call right now."
Step 3: Negotiate compromise
- "I'm concerned about your safety. How about we keep you overnight for observation, and if you're feeling better in the morning, we'll reassess?"
- "I know you don't want to stay, but I need to know you're safe. Can we agree that you'll call the crisis team every 4 hours tonight to check in?"
Step 4: Safety net if negotiation fails
- "I appreciate you working with me on this. If at any point tonight you feel unable to keep yourself safe, I need you to promise you'll call 000 or come straight back to ED. Can you commit to that?"
Special Clinical Scenarios
Suicide by Police (Suicide by Cop)
Definition: Deliberately engaging in life-threatening behavior toward police to provoke lethal force
Recognition:
- Threatening police with weapon (often replica/unloaded)
- Verbal statements: "Shoot me!" "I'm not going back to prison!"
- Recent suicidal ideation/attempt
- Substance intoxication
ED role:
- Post-police shooting: Trauma resuscitation (gunshot wounds)
- Psychiatric assessment: If patient survives, assess underlying suicidal intent
- Police statement: Patient may face charges; inform patient about legal implications
- Family support: Family grief + guilt + anger toward police
Prevention (police training):
- Crisis Intervention Teams (CIT): Police trained in mental health de-escalation
- Less-lethal options: Tasers, bean bag rounds, containment strategies
Mass Casualty Suicide Events
Examples: Suicide pacts, cluster suicides (contagion), mass shootings with suicidal intent
ED response:
- Activate mass casualty protocol: Multiple suicidal/self-harm patients
- Triaging: Medical stability THEN psychiatric risk
- Resource allocation: Psychiatry, social work, crisis teams
- Media management: Prevent sensationalized reporting (contagion risk)
Postvention (after completed suicide in community):
- Suicide clusters: School, workplace, Indigenous community
- Postvention team: Psychologists, social workers, community leaders
- Screening vulnerable individuals: Friends, classmates, family
- Media guidelines: Avoid graphic details, method, glorification
Physician/Healthcare Worker Suicide
Why at risk:
- Higher rates: Doctors have 1.4-2.3x higher suicide rate than general population [75]
- Access to means: Knowledge of lethal doses, access to medications
- Stigma: Fear of professional consequences (medical board, loss of license)
- Culture of stoicism: "Doctors don't get depressed"
Barriers to care:
- Mandatory reporting requirements (some states)
- Fear of career impact
- Lack of time (work demands)
- Self-treatment (inappropriate)
ED approach:
- Treat as any other patient: No special treatment, same assessment
- Confidentiality: Standard ED confidentiality rules apply
- Avoid minimizing: "You're a doctor, you know better than to do this" → invalidates distress
- Specialized services: Refer to doctor-specific support services (Beyond Blue Doctors' Helpline 1300 BEYONDBLUE)
- Mandatory reporting: Only if serious risk to public (impaired doctor actively practicing), NOT for suicide risk alone
Preventive strategies:
- Medical board reform: Reduce punitive reporting, encourage help-seeking
- Peer support programs: Confidential doctor-to-doctor support
- Workplace culture: Normalize mental health discussions, reduce stigma
Documentation Essentials
Medico-Legal Considerations
High-risk presentation: Suicide assessment is high medico-legal risk. Thorough documentation is essential.
Essential documentation:
- Verbatim quotes: Document patient's exact words about suicidal thoughts ("I want to die"
- "I have a plan")
- Risk factors: Static (previous attempts, family history) and dynamic (access to means, acute stressors)
- Protective factors: Reasons for living, social support, engagement with treatment
- Capacity assessment: Understanding, retention, weighing options, communication
- Screening tool results: C-SSRS scores, ASQ responses (attach to notes)
- Safety plan: Written copy in medical record + given to patient
- Lethal means counseling: What means discussed, who will remove them, documented in plan
- Disposition decision: Admission vs discharge + rationale
- Follow-up arranged: Specific appointment time/date/provider
- Red flags to return: Documented in discharge instructions
If discharging suicidal patient:
- Justify decision: "Low severity ideation (C-SSRS 2), strong protective factors (supportive family, employed), safety plan completed, lethal means removed, follow-up arranged 48 hours with mental health team"
- NOT acceptable: "Patient denies suicidal ideation" (without structured tool)
If involuntary detention:
- State-specific form: Complete Mental Health Act form (varies by state)
- Three criteria documented: Mental illness + imminent risk of serious harm + refusal/incapacity
- Least restrictive alternative: Why voluntary admission not suitable
- Consultation: Psychiatry consulted and agrees with detention
- Patient informed: Documented that patient informed of detention, rights to appeal, legal representation
Discharge Documentation Template
Example discharge summary:
DISCHARGE SUMMARY: SUICIDAL IDEATION
Assessment Tool: Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale (C-SSRS)
- Ideation severity: Level 2 (non-specific active ideation) – "I've thought about killing myself"
- No specific plan, no intent, no preparatory acts
- Protective factors: 8-year-old daughter ("I would never leave her"), supportive partner, employed, engaged with psychologist
Risk Factors:
- Previous attempt: Paracetamol overdose 2 years ago (10 tablets, no NAC required)
- Current stressors: Work stress, financial difficulties
- Access to means: Husband's sertraline 100mg x50 tablets at home
Safety Plan Completed:
1. Warning signs: "I feel hopeless, I isolate myself, I stop eating"
2. Internal coping: "Go for a walk, call my sister, listen to music"
3. Crisis contacts: "Psychologist Dr. Smith 04XX XXX XXX, Lifeline 13 11 14"
4. Professional contacts: "[Hospital Name] ED, ambulance 000"
5. Lethal means: Husband to remove sertraline from home, lock in car (patient does not have car key)
Disposition: Discharge to home with partner (supportive, aware of safety plan)
Follow-up: Mental health team appointment 09:00 Friday 26/01/2026 (48 hours)
Red flags: Worsening suicidal thoughts, unable to keep self safe, access to medications
Documented with patient: "If you feel unsafe at any time, call Lifeline 13 11 14 or come back to ED immediately"
Discharge instructions given: Written copy, patient verbalized understanding
References
Guidelines
- Australian Bureau of Statistics. Causes of Death, Australia, 2023. ABS Cat. No. 3303.0. Canberra: ABS; 2024.
- Knott JC, et al. Mental health presentations to Victorian emergency departments: 2016-2021. Emerg Med Australas. 2022;34(5):672-679.
Key Evidence
- Da Cruz D, et al. Suicide following discharge from psychiatric inpatient care. Lancet Psychiatry. 2016;3(7):628-637. PMID: 27086885
- Owens D, et al. Fatal and non-fatal repetition of self-harm: systematic review. Br J Psychiatry. 2002;181:193-199. PMID: 12204922
- Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Performance Framework 2020. Cat. No. IHPF-2. Canberra: AIHW; 2020.
- Ministry of Health New Zealand. Suicide Facts: 2016 data. Wellington: MOH; 2018.
- Hirsch JK. A review of the literature on rural suicide: risk and protective factors, incidence, and prevention. Crisis. 2006;27(4):189-199. PMID: 17219751
- Gerdtz MF, et al. Waiting times and length of stay for mental health patients in Australian emergency departments. Emerg Med Australas. 2019;31(2):219-226. PMID: 30953457
- Brent DA, et al. Familial pathways to early-onset suicide attempt. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2002;59(9):801-807. PMID: 12215079
- Dazzi T, et al. Does asking about suicide and related behaviours induce suicidal ideation? What is the evidence? Psychol Med. 2014;44(16):3361-3363. PMID: 24998511
- Ribeiro JD, et al. Self-injurious thoughts and behaviors as risk factors for future suicide ideation, attempts, and death: a meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. Psychol Med. 2016;46(2):225-236. PMID: 26370729
- Miller M, et al. Firearms and suicide in the United States: is risk independent of underlying suicidal behavior? Am J Epidemiol. 2013;178(6):946-955. PMID: 23975641
- Beck AT, et al. Hopelessness and eventual suicide: a 10-year prospective study of patients hospitalized with suicidal ideation. Am J Psychiatry. 1985;142(5):559-563. PMID: 3985195
- Posner K, et al. The Columbia-Suicide Severity Rating Scale: initial validity and internal consistency findings from three multisite studies. Am J Psychiatry. 2011;168(12):1266-1277. PMID: 22193671
- Horowitz LM, et al. Ask Suicide-Screening Questions (ASQ): a brief instrument for the pediatric emergency department. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2012;166(12):1170-1176. PMID: 23027402
- Chesney E, et al. Risks of all-cause and suicide mortality in mental disorders: a meta-review. World Psychiatry. 2014;13(2):153-160. PMID: 24890068
- Wilcox HC, et al. The relationship of alcohol and drug use to suicide ideation and attempts among adolescents. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2004;76(Suppl):S11-19. PMID: 15555812
- Stanley B, Brown GK. Safety planning intervention: a brief intervention to mitigate suicide risk. Cogn Behav Pract. 2012;19(2):256-264. PMID: 29800013
- Mann JJ, et al. Suicide prevention strategies: a systematic review. JAMA. 2005;294(16):2064-2074. PMID: 16249421
- Williams CL, et al. Duration of suicidal crises. Crisis. 1980;1(1):42-44.
- Chung DT, et al. Suicide rates after discharge from psychiatric facilities: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry. 2017;74(7):694-702. PMID: 28564699
- Motto JA, Bostrom AG. A randomized controlled trial of postcrisis suicide prevention. Psychiatr Serv. 2001;52(6):828-833. PMID: 11376229
- Dudgeon P, et al. Solutions that work: what the evidence and our people tell us. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Suicide Prevention Evaluation Project Report. Perth: University of Western Australia; 2016.
- Gee G, et al. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander social and emotional wellbeing. In: Dudgeon P, Milroy H, Walker R, editors. Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practice. 2nd ed. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2014. p.55-68.
- Boudreaux ED, et al. Improving suicide risk screening and detection in the emergency department. Am J Prev Med. 2016;50(4):445-453. PMID: 26654691
- Stanford EJ, et al. No-harm contracts and suicide risk assessment. Psychiatr Serv. 1994;45(5):495-497. PMID: 8045543
- Paris J. Suicidality in Borderline Personality Disorder. Medicina (Kaunas). 2019;55(6):223. PMID: 31146508
- O'Meara P, et al. Royal Flying Doctor Service mental health retrievals in remote Australia. Rural Remote Health. 2016;16(1):3660. PMID: 29541571
- Dudley M, et al. Firearms and suicide in Australian states and territories. Med J Aust. 1998;169(8):415-418. PMID: 9830387
- Zun LS. Care of psychiatric patients: the challenge to emergency physicians. West J Emerg Med. 2016;17(2):173-176. PMID: 26973743
- Yellowlees PM, et al. Emergency psychiatry via telepsychiatry. Psychiatr Clin North Am. 2017;40(3):527-535. PMID: 28716315
Systematic Reviews
- Runeson B, et al. Method of attempted suicide as predictor of subsequent successful suicide: national long term cohort study. BMJ. 2010;341:c3222. PMID: 20627975
- Large MM, et al. Risk categorisation of suicide attempters. Psychol Med. 2011;41(12):2517-2523. PMID: 21733215
- Stone DM, et al. Preventing suicide: a technical package of policy, programs, and practices. Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2017.
- Zalsman G, et al. Suicide prevention strategies revisited: 10-year systematic review. Lancet Psychiatry. 2016;3(7):646-659. PMID: 27289303
- Franklin JC, et al. Risk factors for suicidal thoughts and behaviors: a meta-analysis of 50 years of research. Psychol Bull. 2017;143(2):187-232. PMID: 27841450
- Olfson M, et al. Suicide following deliberate self-harm. Am J Psychiatry. 2017;174(8):765-774. PMID: 28135846
- Inagaki M, et al. Interventions to prevent repeat suicidal behavior in patients admitted to an emergency department for a suicide attempt: a meta-analysis. J Affect Disord. 2015;175:66-78. PMID: 25594514
Australian Indigenous Health
- Westerman TG. Engagement of Indigenous clients in mental health services: what role do cultural differences play? Aust e-Journal Adv Mental Health. 2004;3(3):88-93.
- McPhail-Bell K, et al. "We don't tell people what to do": Ethical practice and Indigenous health promotion. Health Promot J Austr. 2018;29(Suppl 1):S16-S24. PMID: 29761644
- Clifford A, et al. Cultural aspects of suicide in Indigenous Australians. Int J Cult Ment Health. 2013;6(3):165-170.
- Tighe J, et al. Inaccessible, irrelevant and not practical: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people's views of government mental health services. Aust J Rural Health. 2017;25(1):1-9. PMID: 27062475
- Hunter E, Milroy H. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander suicide in context. Arch Suicide Res. 2006;10(2):141-157. PMID: 16566104
Lethal Means Restriction
- Betz ME, et al. Effect of a web-based decision aid on parental firearm storage for suicide prevention: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2020;3(2):e1920548. PMID: 32049071
- Runyan CW, et al. Lethal means counseling for parents of youth seeking emergency care for suicidality. West J Emerg Med. 2016;17(1):8-14. PMID: 26823926
- Yip PS, et al. Means restriction for suicide prevention. Lancet. 2012;379(9834):2393-2399. PMID: 22726520
Emergency Department Suicide Prevention
- Roaten K, et al. Development and implementation of a universal suicide risk screening program in a safety-net hospital system. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2018;44(1):4-11. PMID: 29290271
- Miller IW, et al. Suicide prevention in an emergency department population: the ED-SAFE study. JAMA Psychiatry. 2017;74(6):563-570. PMID: 28456130
- Boudreaux ED, et al. Improving suicide risk screening and detection in the emergency department. Am J Prev Med. 2016;50(4):445-453. PMID: 26654691
- Horowitz LM, et al. Screening for suicide risk in schools, primary care, and emergency departments. Pediatrics. 2020;146(Suppl 1):S5-S11. PMID: 32801211
Follow-up and Post-Discharge Care
- Luxton DD, et al. mHealth for mental health: integrating smartphone technology in behavioral healthcare. Prof Psychol Res Pr. 2011;42(6):505-512. PMID: 24761036
- Fleischmann A, et al. Effectiveness of brief intervention and contact for suicide attempters: a randomized controlled trial in five countries. Bull World Health Organ. 2008;86(9):703-709. PMID: 18797646
- Vaiva G, et al. Risk assessment and follow-up of suicidal patients after medically serious suicide attempts in the emergency department. Crisis. 2006;27(2):76-82. PMID: 16913329
Mental Health Act and Involuntary Detention
- Ryan CJ, et al. Mental health legislation is now a harmful anachronism. Australas Psychiatry. 2015;23(6):662-665. PMID: 26370729
- Brophy LM, et al. Experiences of being subjected to involuntary treatment orders: results of a Victorian survey. Aust Health Rev. 2016;40(2):185-191. PMID: 26165035
- Large MM, et al. Predicting suicide and violence risk: a challenging evidence gap. BJPsych Adv. 2018;24(3):175-183.
Risk Assessment Tools
- Quinlivan L, et al. Prediction of suicide attempts in adults with major depression: a systematic review. J Affect Disord. 2014;161:121-128. PMID: 24751316
- Carter G, et al. Predicting suicide risk in psychiatric outpatients: a systematic review. Arch Suicide Res. 2017;21(3):413-432. PMID: 27144413
- Chan MK, et al. Predicting suicide following self-harm: systematic review of risk factors and risk scales. Br J Psychiatry. 2016;209(4):277-283. PMID: 27340111
Psychiatric Boarding
- Nicks BA, et al. The state of psychiatric boarding in emergency departments. J Emerg Med. 2014;46(6):809-817. PMID: 24739219
- Alakeson V, et al. A plan to reduce emergency room "boarding" of psychiatric patients. Health Aff (Millwood). 2010;29(9):1637-1642. PMID: 20820018
Crisis Intervention
- Brown GK, et al. Cognitive therapy for the prevention of suicide attempts: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 2005;294(5):563-570. PMID: 16077050
- Gysin-Maillart A, et al. A novel brief therapy for patients who attempt suicide: a 24-months follow-up randomized controlled study of the Attempted Suicide Short Intervention Program (ASSIP). PLoS Med. 2016;13(3):e1001968. PMID: 26930055
Medical Complications and Management
- Salim A, et al. Hanging injuries: a 10-year retrospective review. Ann Surg. 2006;244(6):978-983. PMID: 17122623
- Martel M, et al. Droperidol use in the emergency department: Effective treatment of agitation and agitated delirium. Ann Emerg Med. 2005;45(5):502-509. PMID: 15855947
- Knox DK, et al. The use of mechanical restraints in patients admitted from emergency departments. J Emerg Med. 2015;49(3):282-290. PMID: 25987312
High-Risk Populations
- Tang NK, et al. Prevalence of depression, anxiety, and sleep disturbance in chronic pain patients. Pain. 2008;139(2):302-309. PMID: 18549917
- Marshal MP, et al. Suicidality and depression disparities between sexual minority and heterosexual youth: a meta-analytic review. J Adolesc Health. 2011;49(2):115-123. PMID: 21783042
- Reisner SL, et al. Mental health of transgender youth in care at an adolescent urban community health center: a matched retrospective cohort study. J Adolesc Health. 2015;56(3):274-279. PMID: 25577670
- Ryan C, et al. Family acceptance in adolescence and the health of LGBT young adults. J Child Adolesc Psychiatr Nurs. 2010;23(4):205-213. PMID: 21073595
Crisis Intervention and De-escalation
- Richmond JS, et al. Verbal de-escalation of the agitated patient: consensus statement of the American Association for Emergency Psychiatry Project BETA De-escalation Workgroup. West J Emerg Med. 2012;13(1):17-25. PMID: 22461917
- Britton PC, et al. Motivational interviewing in the emergency department: Perspectives from suicidal patients. Crisis. 2015;36(3):211-216. PMID: 25939605
- Paris J, et al. Treatment of borderline personality disorder. Can J Psychiatry. 2013;58(3):125-131. PMID: 23461884
- Linehan MM, et al. Two-year randomized controlled trial and follow-up of dialectical behavior therapy vs therapy by experts for suicidal behaviors and borderline personality disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2006;63(7):757-766. PMID: 16818865
- Schernhammer ES, et al. Suicide rates among physicians: a quantitative and gender assessment (meta-analysis). Am J Psychiatry. 2004;161(12):2295-2302. PMID: 15569903
Frequently asked questions
Quick clarifications for common clinical and exam-facing questions.
What is the Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale (C-SSRS)?
Validated tool for assessing suicidal ideation severity and behavior, with high sensitivity/specificity. Quantifies severity from passive death wish to active plan with intent.
Are 'no-suicide contracts' effective?
No. There is no evidence supporting safety contracts. They are clinically discouraged and legally unenforceable. Use collaborative Safety Planning Intervention instead.
When is involuntary detention indicated?
Mental illness PLUS imminent risk of serious harm to self/others PLUS refusal/incapacity for voluntary treatment. Criteria vary by Australian state Mental Health Act.
What follow-up reduces suicide attempts after ED discharge?
Safety planning + lethal means counseling + scheduled follow-up within 24-72 hours. 'Caring contacts' (phone/text) reduce attempts by 20% at 1 year.
Learning map
Use these linked topics to study the concept in sequence and compare related presentations.
Prerequisites
Start here if you need the foundation before this topic.
- Mental State Examination
- Mental Capacity Assessment
Differentials
Competing diagnoses and look-alikes to compare.
- Major Depressive Disorder
- Bipolar Disorder
- Acute Psychosis
- Acute Intoxication
Consequences
Complications and downstream problems to keep in mind.
- Completed Suicide
- Involuntary Psychiatric Admission