Charcot Neuroarthropathy (Charcot Foot)
Summary
Charcot Neuroarthropathy (CN), commonly known as Charcot Foot, is a progressive, destructive condition of the bones and joints in a foot with peripheral neuropathy. It most commonly occurs in patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy. The combination of loss of protective sensation and ongoing weight-bearing leads to microfractures, joint dislocations, and bony collapse. The acute phase presents with a hot, red, swollen foot – often painless or only mildly painful due to neuropathy – which mimics infection (cellulitis, osteomyelitis). The key differentiator is that acute Charcot improves with elevation, while infection does not. If untreated, the midfoot collapses into a "Rocker Bottom" deformity, causing plantar ulceration and high amputation risk. Management involves immediate offloading (Total Contact Cast), immobilisation until the acute phase resolves (Eichenholtz stages), and protective footwear long-term.
Key Facts
- Cause: Peripheral Neuropathy (Diabetes – Most Common).
- Mechanism: Loss of protective sensation + Uncontrolled weight-bearing -> Microfractures -> Bony collapse.
- Acute Presentation: Hot, Red, Swollen, (Painless) Foot. MIMICS INFECTION.
- Key Differentiator: Elevation reduces redness/warmth in Charcot (Not in Infection).
- Chronic/End-Stage: Rocker Bottom Deformity (Midfoot Collapse).
- Treatment (Acute): Total Contact Cast (TCC). Non-Weight Bearing. ("Cool the Foot").
- Treatment (Chronic): CROW Walker/Boot. Custom Footwear. Surgery for Deformity.
Clinical Pearls
"Hot Foot in a Diabetic – Think Charcot, Not Just Infection": Acute Charcot and Cellulitis/Osteomyelitis present identically. Differentiate with the Elevation Test (Charcot redness improves, Infection does not).
"Painless Destruction": Due to neuropathy, patients may walk on a broken, dislocating foot without significant pain. Early recognition is crucial.
"Rocker Bottom = High Amputation Risk": Once the midfoot collapses, abnormal pressure points cause ulcers, which lead to infection and amputation.
"Off-Load, Off-Load, Off-Load": The cornerstone of Charcot management is complete offloading. Continued weight-bearing destroys the foot.
Why This Matters Clinically
Charcot Foot is frequently misdiagnosed as infection, leading to unnecessary antibiotics and delayed treatment. Early recognition and aggressive offloading can prevent catastrophic deformity and amputation.
Incidence
- Prevalence in Diabetics: ~0.1-0.5% of all diabetics. Higher (~2-3%) in those with severe neuropathy.
- Peak Incidence: Duration of diabetes >10 years. Age 50-60.
- Bilateral: ~20-30% of cases.
Risk Factors
| Factor | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Diabetes Mellitus | Most common cause. Peripheral neuropathy. |
| Peripheral Neuropathy (Any Cause) | Loss of protective sensation. |
| Alcohol Abuse | Alcoholic neuropathy. |
| Chronic Kidney Disease / Transplant | Immunosuppression, Neuropathy. |
| Trauma / Surgery | Initiating trigger. |
| Obesity | Increased mechanical stress. |
Causes of Neuropathic Arthropathy (Historical and Modern)
| Condition | Notes |
|---|---|
| Diabetes Mellitus | By far the most common today. |
| Syphilis (Tabes Dorsalis) | Historical. "Charcot Joint" was first described in syphilis. |
| Leprosy | Endemic areas. |
| Syringomyelia | Upper limb involvement. |
| Spinal Cord Injury | Below injury level. |
Mechanism of Joint Destruction
- Peripheral Neuropathy -> Loss of protective sensation.
- Repeated Micro-trauma -> Undetected fractures.
- Autonomic Neuropathy -> Increased blood flow (Hypervascularisation). Enhanced bone resorption.
- Osteoclast Activation -> RANKL upregulation. Bone weakening.
- Continued Weight-Bearing -> Fracture progression, Joint dislocation.
- Collapse and Deformity -> Rocker Bottom Foot.
Neurotraumatic vs Neurovascular Theory
| Theory | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Neurotraumatic | Insensitivity -> Repetitive trauma -> Destruction. |
| Neurovascular | Autonomic dysfunction -> Increased blood flow -> Bone resorption. |
| Current Understanding | Both contribute. |
Anatomical Patterns (Sanders/Frykberg Classification)
| Pattern | Location | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| I | Forefoot (Metatarsal-Phalangeal) | |
| II | Tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) | ~25%. |
| III (Most Common) | Midtarsal (Chopart) | ~40%. Leads to Rocker Bottom. |
| IV | Ankle | Less common. High morbidity. |
| V | Calcaneus | Calcaneal insufficiency fracture. |
Acute Charcot
| Feature | Notes |
|---|---|
| Hot, Red, Swollen Foot | Cardinal feature. Looks like infection. |
| Relatively Painless | Due to neuropathy. May have mild ache. |
| Unilateral (Usually) | 20-30% bilateral. |
| Bounding Pulses | Hypervascularisation. |
| Temperature Difference | >°C warmer than contralateral foot (Measured with thermometer). |
Elevation Test (Key Differentiator)
| Finding | Charcot | Infection |
|---|---|---|
| After 10-15 mins Elevation | Redness/Warmth Reduces | Redness/Warmth Persists |
Chronic Charcot
| Feature | Notes |
|---|---|
| Rocker Bottom Deformity | Midfoot collapse. Plantar bony prominence. |
| Bony Prominences | Abnormal pressure points. |
| Ulceration | Overlying bony prominence. High infection risk. |
| Joint Instability | Abnormal motion. |
| Shortened Foot | Due to collapse. |
Inspection
- Erythema, Swelling in acute phase.
- Deformity (Rocker Bottom, Midfoot sag) in chronic phase.
- Ulceration? Infection signs?
Palpation
- Temperature (Use thermometer. Compare sides. >2°C difference significant).
- Bony prominences.
- Peripheral pulses (Often bounding in acute Charcot).
Neurological Assessment
- Peripheral Neuropathy Assessment: 10g Monofilament, Vibration sense.
- Document sensory loss.
Vascular Assessment
- Pulses, ABPI if indicated.
X-Ray
| Stage | Findings |
|---|---|
| Acute (Early) | May appear normal initially. Subtle soft tissue swelling. |
| Developmental | Subluxation, Fragmentation, Joint destruction. |
| Coalescence | Bony healing. Sclerosis. Fusion. |
MRI
| Use | Notes |
|---|---|
| Differentiate from Osteomyelitis | Bone marrow oedema in both. Charcot more periarticular. MRI often non-specific. |
| Early Detection | Bone oedema before X-ray changes. |
Bone Scan / WBC Scan
- Can help differentiate infection from Charcot. Not always definitive.
Blood Tests
| Test | Purpose |
|---|---|
| WCC, CRP, ESR | Elevated in infection. Often normal in acute Charcot. |
| Blood Glucose, HbA1c | Assess diabetic control. |
| Probe-to-Bone | If ulcer present. Positive = High suspicion for Osteomyelitis. |
Principles
- Early Recognition.
- Immediate Offloading (Acute Phase).
- Protect the Foot Long-Term (Chronic Phase).
- MDT Approach: Orthopaedics, Podiatry, Diabetes, Vascular.
Acute Phase: Offloading
| Intervention | Detail |
|---|---|
| Total Contact Cast (TCC) | Gold Standard. Immobilise and offload. Non-removable. |
| Alternative: Removable Cast Walker | If TCC not available. Less effective if patient removes. |
| Non-Weight Bearing | Crutches, Wheelchair. |
| Duration | Until foot "cools" (Temperature difference <2°C). Often 3-6 months. |
Chronic Phase: Protection
| Intervention | Detail |
|---|---|
| CROW Walker (Charcot Restraint Orthotic Walker) | Custom moulded. Protects healed Charcot foot. |
| Bespoke Footwear | High-risk diabetic footwear. Moulded insoles. |
| Lifelong Protection | Risk of recurrence and ulceration. |
Surgical Management
| Indication | Procedure |
|---|---|
| Unstable Deformity | Corrective osteotomy. Fusion (Arthrodesis). |
| Ulceration Over Prominence | Exostectomy (Bony prominence removal). |
| Failed Conservative | Reconstruction. High complication rate (Non-union, Infection). |
Treating Associated Ulcers
- Offload.
- Debridement.
- Rule out/Treat Osteomyelitis.
- Vascular assessment.
| Stage | Name | Features | X-Ray |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Prodromal | Hot, swollen foot. Normal X-ray. Bone oedema on MRI. | Normal |
| I | Developmental (Fragmentation) | Acute inflammation. Joint effusion. Subluxation. Fragmentation. | Subluxation, Fragmentation |
| II | Coalescence | Inflammation subsides. Bony healing begins. Sclerosis. | Sclerosis, Fusion |
| III | Consolidation (Remodelling) | Healed. Deformity present. | Healed bony architecture. Deformity. |
- With Early Offloading: Deformity can be minimised. Ulcer/Amputation risk reduced.
- Without Offloading: Collapse, Rocker Bottom, Ulceration, Infection, Amputation.
- Amputation Rate: Significantly elevated in Charcot patients, especially with ulcers.
Key Guidelines
| Guideline | Organisation | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| NICE NG19: Diabetic Foot | NICE | Recommends urgent referral if acute Charcot suspected. Offloading. |
| International Working Group on the Diabetic Foot (IWGDF) | IWGDF | Global guidelines on Charcot management. |
Scenario 1:
- Stem: A 55-year-old diabetic with peripheral neuropathy presents with a hot, red, swollen left foot. He has no pain. Pulses are bounding. X-ray is normal. How do you differentiate from cellulitis?
- Answer: Elevation Test: Elevate the foot. If redness/warmth improves after 15 minutes, suspect Charcot. If it persists, suspect infection. Also check inflammatory markers (CRP, WCC) – often normal in Charcot.
Scenario 2:
- Stem: What is the acute management of Charcot Foot?
- Answer: Immediate Offloading with Total Contact Cast (TCC) or Removable Cast Walker. Non-weight bearing. Continue until the foot "cools" (Temperature difference <2°C compared to other foot).
Scenario 3:
- Stem: What is the "Rocker Bottom" deformity?
- Answer: Midfoot collapse (typically Chopart/midtarsal region) leading to a convex plantar surface with bony prominence. This creates abnormal pressure points, leading to ulceration.
| Scenario | Urgency | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Hot, Red, Swollen Foot in Diabetic | Urgent | Diabetic Foot Team / Orthopaedics. Same-week review. X-ray. Offload immediately. |
| Rocker Bottom Deformity | Urgent | Orthopaedics / Podiatry. Custom footwear. Risk of ulcer. |
| Ulcer Over Deformity | Urgent | Diabetic Foot MDT. Rule out Osteomyelitis. |
| Uncertain Diagnosis (Infection vs Charcot) | Urgent | Specialist review. MRI. Bloods. |
What is Charcot Foot?
Charcot Foot is a condition where the bones in your foot break down and collapse because you cannot feel pain properly (due to nerve damage from diabetes). Because you don't feel pain, you keep walking on a broken foot, making it worse.
What are the symptoms?
- Hot, red, swollen foot.
- The foot may not be painful (or only mildly aching).
- If left untreated, the foot can collapse and become deformed ("Rocker Bottom").
How is it treated?
- Offloading: Wearing a special cast or boot so you don't put weight on the foot.
- Protective footwear: Special shoes to prevent pressure ulcers.
- Surgery: Sometimes needed if the foot collapses badly.
Key Counselling Points
- Don't Walk On It: "Walking on your foot will make it collapse. You must use the cast or boot."
- Check Your Feet Daily: "Neuropathy means you can't feel injuries. Look at your feet every day."
- Long-Term Footwear: "You will need special shoes for life to protect your feet."
- Diabetic Control: "Good blood sugar control helps prevent further problems."
| Standard | Target |
|---|---|
| Acute Charcot referred to Diabetic Foot Team within 1 working day | 100% |
| TCC or equivalent offloading initiated at first specialist visit | >0% |
| Temperature monitoring documented at each visit | 100% |
| Custom footwear prescribed for healed Charcot | 100% |
- Jean-Martin Charcot (1868): French neurologist who described neuropathic arthropathy in patients with Tabes Dorsalis (Syphilis).
- Diabetes Now Predominates: With the decline of syphilis and increase in diabetes, diabetic neuropathy is now the leading cause globally.
- NICE NG19. Diabetic foot problems: prevention and management. 2015 (Updated 2019). nice.org.uk
- Rogers LC, et al. The Charcot foot in diabetes. Diabetes Care. 2011. PMID: 21788609
- IWGDF Guidelines on the Diabetic Foot: iwgdfguidelines.org
Medical Disclaimer: MedVellum content is for educational purposes and clinical reference. If you have Charcot Foot, please consult a specialist immediately.