Safeguarding (Children & Adults)

1. Clinical Overview

Summary

Safeguarding is the statutory duty to protect the health, well-being, and human rights of individuals (children and vulnerable adults) to live free from abuse, harm, and neglect. It represents a core competency for all healthcare professionals across all specialties. [1,2]

In the UK, the legal framework is established through:

• Children Act 1989 and 2004: Legal basis for child protection
• Care Act 2014: Framework for adult safeguarding
• Working Together to Safeguard Children (2023): Statutory inter-agency guidance
• Mental Capacity Act 2005: Protection for those lacking capacity

Critical Principle: "Doing nothing" is never an option. When safeguarding concerns arise, clinicians have both a professional and legal duty to act. [3]

Epidemiology

Safeguarding concerns are more common than many clinicians recognize:

• Child maltreatment: Affects approximately 1 in 10 children in the UK at some point during childhood [4]
• Prevalence in clinical settings: 1-5% of children presenting to emergency departments have safeguarding concerns [5]
• Elder abuse: Affects 2.6% of older adults (≥60 years) living in the community, rising to 15% in institutional settings [6]
• Domestic abuse: Estimated lifetime prevalence of 25-30% among women and 15-20% among men [7]
• Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs): 47% of adults report at least one ACE; 9% report four or more [8]

The true incidence is likely higher due to underreporting and detection failures.

Clinical Pearls

The Pre-Mobile Baby: "Those who don't cruise, don't bruise." Any bruise in a baby who is not yet crawling or walking is Non-Accidental Injury (Physical Abuse) until proven otherwise by full skeletal survey and multi-agency review. [9]

Triangle of Safeguarding: In child protection, always consider:

1. The Child's Developmental needs
2. Parenting Capacity
3. Family & Environmental factors

Capacity & Adults: Competent adults have the right to make "unwise decisions" (e.g., staying with an abusive partner). However, if there is coercion or lack of capacity, safeguarding duties override autonomy.

Information Sharing: GDPR does NOT prevent sharing information for safeguarding purposes. Safety trumps privacy. Share what is necessary, proportionate, and relevant. [10]

---

2. Categories of Abuse

Child Abuse (Classification)

1. Physical Abuse

• Hitting, shaking, throwing, poisoning, burning, scalding, drowning, suffocating
• Fabricated or Induced Illness (FII) - formerly Munchausen's by Proxy
• Giving alcohol or inappropriate drugs

2. Sexual Abuse

• Forcing or enticing a child to take part in sexual activities
• Includes contact (rape, penetrative acts) and non-contact (grooming, exploitation, viewing sexual images)
• Child Sexual Exploitation (CSE) is a specific form involving coercion, manipulation, or deception

3. Emotional/Psychological Abuse

• Persistent emotional maltreatment causing severe and persistent adverse effects on emotional development
• Includes conveying to children they are worthless, unloved, inadequate
• Age or developmentally inappropriate expectations
• Seeing or hearing ill-treatment of another (e.g., domestic violence)

4. Neglect

• Persistent failure to meet a child's basic physical and/or psychological needs
• Can occur during pregnancy through maternal substance abuse
• Includes failure to:
  • Provide adequate food, clothing, shelter
  • Protect from physical and emotional harm or danger
  • Ensure adequate supervision
  • Ensure access to appropriate medical care or treatment

Adult Abuse (Classification)

1. Physical Abuse

• Assault, hitting, slapping, pushing, misuse of medication, restraint, inappropriate physical sanctions

2. Sexual Abuse

• Rape, sexual assault, sexual acts without consent or where consent cannot be given

3. Psychological/Emotional Abuse

• Threats of harm or abandonment, deprivation of contact, humiliation, blaming, controlling, intimidation, coercion, harassment, verbal abuse, isolation

4. Neglect and Acts of Omission

• Ignoring medical or physical care needs, failure to provide access to health, social care, or educational services
• Withholding necessities of life (medication, nutrition, heating)

5. Financial/Material Abuse

• Theft, fraud, exploitation, pressure regarding wills, property, inheritance, financial transactions
• Misuse or misappropriation of property, possessions, or benefits

6. Discriminatory Abuse

• Harassment, slurs, or similar treatment based on race, gender, disability, sexual orientation, religion

7. Institutional/Organizational Abuse

• Neglect and poor care in institutional settings (hospitals, care homes)
• Includes poor professional practice, rigid routines, inadequate staffing

8. Modern Slavery

• Human trafficking, forced labor, domestic servitude, sexual exploitation

9. Self-Neglect

• Hoarding, neglecting to care for personal hygiene, health, or surroundings
• May indicate underlying mental health issues, substance misuse, or cognitive decline

---

3. Recognition and Red Flags

Physical Indicators of Non-Accidental Injury (NAI)

High-Specificity Injury Patterns [9,11]

1. Bruising Patterns

• Location: Bruises on ears, cheeks, neck, genitals, buttocks, hands, feet (TED - Torso, Ears, Defensive areas)
• Age: ANY bruise in a pre-mobile infant (less than 6 months, not rolling/crawling)
• Pattern: Finger marks, grip marks, slap marks, linear bruises (object marks)
• Shape: Identifiable objects (belt buckle, hand, cord)
• Distribution: Multiple bruises at different stages of healing

Accidental bruising typically affects bony prominences: shins, knees, elbows, forehead

2. Burns and Scalds

• Cigarette burns: Circular, punched-out lesions (8-10mm diameter)
• Contact burns: Clear outline of object (iron, radiator)
• Immersion scalds: Symmetrical, demarcated stocking/glove distribution with no splash marks
• Forced immersion signs: Flexural sparing (knees pulled up), buttock sparing (pressed against tub bottom)

3. Fractures

• Rib fractures: Especially posterior/lateral ribs (high specificity for abuse in less than 2 years) [12]
• Metaphyseal corner fractures (bucket-handle fractures): Classic for shaking/twisting injuries
• Spiral fractures of long bones in non-ambulatory children
• Multiple fractures at different stages of healing
• Skull fractures: Complex, bilateral, crossing suture lines, or depressed

4. Head Injuries

• Subdural hemorrhage (especially bilateral)
• Retinal hemorrhages (multiple, bilateral, extending to periphery)
• "Shaken Baby Syndrome": Triad of subdural hemorrhage, retinal hemorrhages, and encephalopathy (though absence of all three does not exclude abuse) [13]

5. Abdominal Injuries

• Second leading cause of death from physical abuse
• Duodenal hematoma, pancreatic injury, liver laceration
• Often delayed presentation

6. Other Injuries

• Bite marks: Oval/crescent bruising; intercanine distance > 3cm suggests adult
• Ligature marks: On wrists, ankles, neck
• Oral injuries: Torn frenulum (forced feeding/silencing)
• Genital injuries: Unexplained trauma, foreign bodies, STIs in prepubertal children

Behavioral and Contextual Red Flags

In the Child/Adult:

• Fearful, withdrawn, or frozen watchfulness
• Aggressive, oppositional behavior
• Delayed presentation for medical care
• Regression in developmental milestones
• Sexualized behavior (age-inappropriate)
• Self-harm, substance abuse (adolescents)
• Running away, school absenteeism

In the Parent/Caregiver:

• Inconsistent, changing, or implausible explanation for injuries
• Delay in seeking medical attention
• Inappropriate affect (unconcerned or overly concerned)
• Blaming the child or sibling for injuries
• Refusing investigations or leaving before assessment complete
• History of violence, substance abuse, mental illness
• Isolated from family/social support

In the Consultation:

• The Silent Child: Looking to parent for permission to speak
• The Controlling Partner: Answering all questions for the patient
• Doctor shopping: Multiple presentations to different facilities
• Non-adherence: Repeated missed appointments for chronic conditions

---

4. Differential Diagnosis (Conditions Mimicking Abuse)

It is crucial to exclude medical conditions that can mimic abuse. However, the presence of a medical condition does not exclude concurrent abuse. [14]

Bruising/Bleeding Disorders

Skin Conditions

Bone Disorders

Birth Trauma vs. NAI

• Cephalohematoma: Does not cross suture lines, resolves within weeks
• Subgaleal hemorrhage: Can be significant, but history of traumatic delivery
• Brachial plexus injury: Associated with shoulder dystocia
• Clavicle fracture: Common birth injury, usually uncomplicated

Key principle: Always consider NAI, but investigate appropriately to exclude medical mimics.

---

5. Assessment and Investigation

Initial Assessment

1. Comprehensive History

• Mechanism of injury (who, what, when, where, how)
• Developmental capabilities of child (could they have performed described action?)
• Timeline of events
• Who was present
• Delay in presentation and reasons given
• Previous injuries or hospital attendances
• Family and social circumstances
• Parental mental health, substance use, domestic violence

2. Complete Physical Examination

• Full body examination (with chaperone, appropriate consent)
• Growth parameters: Plot on growth chart (failure to thrive?)
• Developmental assessment: Red Book review
• Skin examination: Document all injuries with body map diagram
• Photographic documentation (with consent, following local protocols)
• Examination of genitalia and anus (if sexual abuse suspected - by trained practitioner only)

3. Documentation Principles [15]

• Verbatim quotes: "Mother said, 'He fell off the sofa'"
• Fact, not opinion: Describe what you see, not what you think
• Detailed body maps: Exact location, size, color, shape of injuries
• Developmental context: "Child is 4 months old and not yet rolling"
• Date, time, who was present during examination
• Legible, permanent records: These may be used in legal proceedings

Paediatric Investigations (Suspected NAI)

Mandatory Investigations [9,16]

1. Skeletal Survey (less than 2 years old, or older if indicated)

• Full series of X-rays to identify occult fractures
• Includes: skull (AP/lateral), chest (AP/lateral), abdomen, pelvis, spine, all limbs
• Repeat skeletal survey at 14 days: Increased sensitivity for healing fractures (periosteal reaction)
• Sensitivity: 80-90% for detecting fractures
• Indications: All children less than 2 years with suspected physical abuse; siblings of abused children

2. CT Head (if any concern for intracranial injury)

• Indications: Altered consciousness, seizures, focal neurology, vomiting, head trauma
• Detects subdural hemorrhage, cerebral edema, skull fractures
• May require MRI brain for better soft tissue detail and dating of injuries

3. Ophthalmology Examination

• Dilated fundoscopy by ophthalmologist
• Retinal hemorrhages: High specificity for abusive head trauma [13]
• Pattern: Multiple, bilateral, extending to periphery (vs. few, posterior in accidental trauma or birth)

4. Coagulation Screen

• FBC, PT, aPTT, fibrinogen
• Von Willebrand studies if indicated
• Purpose: Exclude bleeding disorder as cause of bruising

5. Other Investigations (as indicated)

• Abdominal imaging: CT/ultrasound if abdominal trauma suspected (elevated liver enzymes)
• Urinalysis: Hematuria suggests renal trauma
• Liver function tests, amylase/lipase: Visceral injury
• Metabolic screen: If bone fragility disorder suspected
• Toxicology: If poisoning or sedation suspected

Adult Safeguarding Investigations

1. Photographic Documentation

• With patient consent (or police involvement if criminal investigation)
• Use ruler for scale, multiple angles
• Store securely in medical records

2. Body Map Diagram

• Anatomical chart documenting all injuries
• Include size, color, pattern description

3. Cognitive Assessment

• Mental Capacity Assessment: Does the adult have capacity to make decisions about their safety?
• Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA), Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE)
• Assessment for delirium, dementia, depression

4. Safeguarding Blood Tests (if neglect suspected)

• FBC (anemia, nutritional deficiency)
• Renal function, liver function
• Bone profile (vitamin D, calcium)
• HbA1c (diabetes mismanagement)
• Medication levels (if poisoning/overdose suspected)

5. Imaging (as indicated by injuries)

• X-rays for suspected fractures
• CT/MRI for head injuries

---

6. Management and Safeguarding Procedures

The 4 Rs of Safeguarding

           SUSPICION OF ABUSE
                    ↓
               RECOGNISE
     - Spot the red flags
     - Listen to the disclosure
     - Consider safeguarding
                    ↓
                RESPOND
     - Is there IMMEDIATE danger?
       YES → Call Police (999)
       NO  → Keep safe, separate from alleged perpetrator
     - Treat medical injuries
     - DO NOT confront alleged perpetrator
                    ↓
                 RECORD
     - Verbatim quotes ("He said...")
     - Fact not opinion
     - Body map of injuries
     - Date/Time/Who was present
     - Developmental context
                    ↓
                 REFER
     - Discuss with Named Safeguarding Lead
     - Contact Local Authority (Children's/Adult Social Care)
     - Submit Safeguarding Referral (within 24 hours)
     - Police involvement if criminal offense suspected

Immediate Actions

1. Ensure Safety

• If immediate risk to life: Call Police (999)
• If child in hospital: Consider admission for "social admission" while investigation proceeds
• If child at home with risk: Do not allow child to leave until discussed with safeguarding team
• Separate alleged victim from alleged perpetrator (if safe to do so)

2. Do NOT:

• Confront the alleged perpetrator (may endanger child/adult or lead to absconding)
• Conduct a detailed interrogative interview (this is role of police/social workers)
• Promise confidentiality to the victim
• Allow child to go home if at risk

3. Medical Stabilization

• Treat life-threatening injuries as priority
• Analgesia, wound care, fracture stabilization
• Document injuries before treatment (photographs, body maps)

Handling a Disclosure

When a child or adult discloses abuse to you:

DO:

• Listen actively: Stay calm, do not show shock or disbelief
• Use open questions: "Tell me what happened"
  • "Explain what you mean"
  • "Describe..."
• Reassure: "You are brave to tell me"
  • "This is not your fault"
• Explain limits of confidentiality: "I need to share this with people who can help keep you safe"
• Record verbatim: Write down exact words as soon as possible

DO NOT:

• Promise confidentiality: You have a duty to share
• Ask leading questions: "Did daddy hit you?" (contaminates evidence)
• Ask child to repeat story multiple times: Causes re-traumatization
• Express judgment about alleged perpetrator
• Investigate: That is the role of police/social workers

Information Sharing

Legal Basis: [10]

• GDPR and Data Protection Act 2018: Do NOT prevent sharing information for safeguarding
• Common Law Duty of Confidentiality: Can be breached in the public interest (protecting others from serious harm)
• Human Rights Act 1998: Right to life (Article 2) and protection from torture/inhuman treatment (Article 3) override right to privacy (Article 8)

Principles:

• Necessary: Share only what is needed for safeguarding purposes
• Proportionate: Balance against right to privacy
• Relevant: Share information that pertains to the safeguarding concern
• Adequate: Provide sufficient detail for receiving agency to act
• Timely: Do not delay if urgent

With patient consent: Always preferable, explain why information needs to be shared

Without patient consent: Justifiable if:

• Person lacks capacity to consent
• Seeking consent would place person or others at increased risk
• There is an overriding public interest (serious harm to others)

Document: Record decision-making, who information was shared with, and rationale

Multi-Agency Safeguarding Procedures

Children's Safeguarding

1. Initial Referral

• To: Local Authority Children's Social Care (or MASH - Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub)
• Timeframe: Within 24 hours of concern arising
• Method: Phone call followed by written referral
• Information to include:
  • Child's name, age, address, school
  • Nature of concerns
  • Details of injuries/disclosure
  • Parents' details
  • Consent status (if sought)
  • Any immediate safety concerns

2. Local Authority Response Timeframe

• Initial decision: Within 1 working day - whether to proceed to assessment
• Assessment outcome: Within 45 working days (for Section 17 Child in Need assessment or Section 47 Child Protection investigation)

3. Section 17 (Child in Need)

• Threshold: Child unlikely to achieve/maintain reasonable standard of health or development without provision of services
• Intervention: Support services provided to family (parenting classes, family support worker, financial assistance)
• Child usually remains at home

4. Section 47 (Child Protection Investigation)

• Threshold: Reasonable cause to suspect child is suffering, or likely to suffer, significant harm
• Led by: Social worker with police involvement
• Includes: Strategy meeting (health, police, social care, education), medical examination, interviews
• Outcomes:
  • No further action
  • Child in Need plan (Section 17)
  • Child Protection Plan
  • Care proceedings (removal from home)

5. Strategy Meeting/Discussion

• Convened within 24 hours if Section 47 threshold met
• Attendees: Police, social care, health (pediatrician, GP, health visitor), education
• Decisions:
  • Whether Section 47 investigation should proceed
  • What immediate protection is needed
  • Whether child should be medically examined
  • Whether police investigation warranted

6. Child Protection Conference

• Held within 15 working days of strategy meeting if concerns substantiated
• Purpose: Determine if child is at continuing risk of significant harm
• Outcome: Decision on whether child should be subject to Child Protection Plan (CPP)
• Categories of CPP: Physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, neglect (can be multiple)

7. Child Protection Plan

• Core Group: Meets within 10 working days of conference
• Reviews: At least every 6 months
• Includes specific actions to reduce risk, allocated key worker, multi-agency involvement

8. Emergency Protection

• Police Protection Order (PPO): Police can remove child to safe place for up to 72 hours (no court order required)
• Emergency Protection Order (EPO): Court order allowing removal for up to 8 days (extendable to 15 days)

Adult Safeguarding

1. Initial Referral (The Care Act 2014 - Section 42 Duty)

• To: Local Authority Adult Social Care Safeguarding Team
• Threshold ("Three-Point Test"):
  1. Adult has care and support needs (regardless of whether LA meeting them)
  2. Adult is experiencing, or at risk of, abuse or neglect
  3. As a result of care needs, adult is unable to protect themselves

2. Local Authority Response

• Safeguarding Enquiry (Section 42): Must make enquiries to decide what action needed
• Principles (The Six Safeguarding Principles):
  1. Empowerment: Person-led decisions and informed consent
  2. Prevention: Proactive interventions before harm occurs
  3. Proportionality: Least intrusive response appropriate to risk
  4. Protection: Support and representation for those in greatest need
  5. Partnership: Local solutions through working with communities
  6. Accountability: Transparency in delivering safeguarding

3. Safeguarding Enquiry Process

• Led by social worker or other delegated professional
• May include interviews, home visits, medical assessments, financial reviews
• Outcomes:
  • No further action
  • Support services (care package, home adaptations)
  • Care home placement
  • Police involvement (criminal investigation)
  • Court of Protection application (if capacity issues)

4. Mental Capacity Assessment

• Critical component of adult safeguarding
• Presumption of capacity: Assume adult has capacity unless proven otherwise
• Decision-specific: Capacity assessed for the specific decision at hand
• Two-stage test (Mental Capacity Act 2005):
  1. Does person have impairment/disturbance of mind or brain? (temporary or permanent)
  2. Does impairment mean person unable to:
     • Understand relevant information
     • Retain information long enough to make decision
     • Weigh/use information as part of decision-making process
     • Communicate decision

5. Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS)

• Applies when person lacking capacity is in hospital/care home and arrangements amount to deprivation of liberty
• Standard Authorization: Must be applied for via Local Authority
• Urgent Authorization: Can be used for up to 7 days while standard authorization processed

6. Safeguarding Adults Review (SAR)

• Conducted when adult dies (or experiences serious harm) due to abuse/neglect, and there is concern agencies could have worked together more effectively
• Analogous to Serious Case Review in children's safeguarding

Special Circumstances

Fabricated or Induced Illness (FII)

Formerly "Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy" [17]

Definition: Parent/carer fabricates or induces illness in a child to gain medical attention

Forms:

1. Fabrication: False reporting of symptoms (e.g., seizures, apneas)
2. Induction: Deliberately causing symptoms (e.g., poisoning, suffocation, contaminating samples)
3. Exaggeration: Overstating real symptoms

Red Flags:

• Symptoms only occur in presence of one carer
• Unexplained, persistent, or recurrent illness
• Discrepancy between reported symptoms and clinical findings
• Parent welcomes invasive investigations/treatments
• Parent has medical knowledge or works in healthcare
• Sibling with similar unexplained illness or unexplained death
• Witnessed events (covert video surveillance - only in hospital setting with ethical approval)

Management:

• High index of suspicion: Often delayed diagnosis due to clinician reluctance to believe
• Multi-agency: Early involvement of safeguarding team
• Separation test: Improvement when child separated from carer
• Review medical records: Pattern of presentations across multiple hospitals

Child Sexual Exploitation (CSE)

Definition: Form of sexual abuse where children are sexually exploited for money, power, or status [18]

Models:

• Grooming: Building trust, controlling, isolating
• Inappropriate relationships: Boyfriend model (older "boyfriend")
• Peer-on-peer exploitation: Within peer groups

Red Flags:

• Going missing from home/school
• Unexplained gifts, money, new possessions
• Older "boyfriend" or associating with older individuals
• Sexually transmitted infections, pregnancy (under 16)
• Substance misuse
• Self-harm, eating disorders
• Change in behavior, emotional well-being

Management:

• Recognize CSE as child abuse, not lifestyle choice
• Safeguarding referral via standard pathways
• May require multi-agency disruption tactics (police operations)

Prevent Duty (Radicalisation)

Context: Counter-Terrorism and Security Act 2015

Definition: Safeguarding duty to prevent people being drawn into terrorism

Red Flags (Be cautious - avoid stereotyping):

• Expressing extremist views
• Accessing extremist material online
• Justifying violence to solve societal issues
• Sudden change in behavior, appearance, friendship groups
• Isolating from family and previous peer group

Management:

• Channel Programme: Multi-agency support for individuals at risk of radicalization
• Referral via local Prevent lead or police

Domestic Abuse

Definition: Controlling, coercive, threatening behavior, violence, or abuse between partners/ex-partners or family members [7,19]

Prevalence: 1 in 4 women, 1 in 6-7 men experience domestic abuse in their lifetime

Impact on children: Children living with domestic violence are at risk of emotional abuse and often witness violence (Adverse Childhood Experience)

Screening:

• HARK questions (Humiliation, Afraid, Rape, Kick)
• HITS tool (Hurt, Insult, Threaten, Scream)
• Routine inquiry in antenatal clinics, safeguarding assessments

Management:

• See patient alone (crucial - offender often accompanies to control)
• Safety planning (escape plan, safe place, emergency contacts)
• Referral to Independent Domestic Violence Advisor (IDVA)
• Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conference (MARAC) for high-risk cases
• Police involvement if immediate risk or criminal offense

Legal protections:

• Non-molestation order
• Occupation order (excluding perpetrator from home)

Elder Abuse

Risk Factors: [6,20]

• Cognitive impairment (dementia)
• Dependency on caregiver
• Social isolation
• Caregiver stress, mental illness, substance abuse
• Shared living situation
• History of family violence

Red Flags:

• Unexplained injuries, pressure sores, malnutrition, dehydration
• Poor hygiene, inappropriate clothing
• Over-sedation, misuse of medication
• Unexplained financial transactions, sudden changes to wills
• Fearful, withdrawn, or anxious in presence of carer
• Caregiver preventing access to patient, answering for them

Management:

• Adult safeguarding referral (Section 42 enquiry)
• Assessment of mental capacity
• Consider alternative care arrangements
• Financial safeguarding (lasting power of attorney review, Court of Protection)

---

7. Complications and Long-Term Outcomes

Immediate Complications

Mortality

• Child abuse is a leading cause of death in children under 5 years
• Abusive head trauma: 25-30% mortality rate [13]
• Abdominal trauma: Second most common cause of fatal child abuse

Acute Medical

• Traumatic brain injury, permanent neurological disability
• Fractures, deformities, chronic pain
• Visceral injuries requiring surgery
• Sexually transmitted infections, pregnancy (sexual abuse)

Long-Term Health Consequences

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) [8,21]

ACEs are traumatic events occurring before age 18, including:

• Physical, sexual, emotional abuse
• Physical and emotional neglect
• Household dysfunction (domestic violence, substance abuse, mental illness, parental separation, incarceration)

Dose-Response Relationship: Greater number of ACEs → Greater health risks

Health Impacts (compared to 0 ACEs):

• Mental Health: 4+ ACEs → 4-fold increased risk of depression, 12-fold increased risk of suicide attempt
• Substance Use: 4+ ACEs → 7-fold increased risk of alcoholism, 10-fold increased risk of injecting drug use
• Physical Health: Increased risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes, obesity, cancer, chronic lung disease
• Social: Increased risk of unemployment, homelessness, criminality, early pregnancy
• Life Expectancy: 4+ ACEs associated with 20-year reduction in life expectancy

Mechanisms:

• Toxic stress and dysregulation of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis
• Chronic inflammation
• Health-risk behaviors (smoking, substance use, overeating)
• Difficulties in relationships and parenting (intergenerational transmission)

Clinical Implication: Trauma-informed care - understanding patient behaviors and health conditions in context of potential trauma history

Developmental and Psychological Outcomes

• Attachment disorders: Reactive attachment disorder, disinhibited social engagement disorder
• Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
• Developmental delay: Language, motor, cognitive delays
• Educational underachievement
• Behavioral problems: Aggression, oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder
• Adolescent risks: Self-harm, eating disorders, risky sexual behavior, substance misuse

Intergenerational Transmission

• Adults who experienced abuse as children are at higher risk of abusing their own children (though most do NOT go on to abuse)
• Cycle can be broken with appropriate support, therapy, and interventions

---

8. Prognosis and Intervention Outcomes

Early Intervention Saves Lives

• Timely identification and intervention can prevent escalation to serious injury or death
• Multi-agency working improves outcomes

Outcomes for Children:

• Remain at Home with Support (Child in Need plan): Majority of children; family provided with support services (parenting programs, financial aid, mental health services)
• Child Protection Plan: Regular monitoring, specific interventions to reduce risk
• Foster Care/Adoption: For children who cannot be kept safe at home; evidence suggests better outcomes than remaining in abusive environment
• Reunification: Some children are returned to parents after sustained improvements in safety

Outcomes for Adults:

• Safeguarding interventions range from minimal (raising awareness) to major (care home placement, criminal prosecution)
• Emphasis on empowerment and individual's wishes (where they have capacity)

System Improvements:

• Landmark cases (Victoria Climbié, Baby P, Daniel Pelka) have driven reforms in multi-agency working and information sharing
• Continuous learning through Serious Case Reviews and Safeguarding Adults Reviews

---

9. Legal Framework and Professional Duties

Statutory Duties

General Medical Council (GMC) - Good Medical Practice [22]

• Doctors must protect and promote the health and well-being of children and young people
• If you believe a child or young person is at risk of, or is suffering, abuse or neglect, you must follow local safeguarding procedures without delay
• Applies to vulnerable adults similarly

Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) - The Code

• Make the care of people your first concern
• Act without delay if you believe there is a risk to patient safety

All Healthcare Professionals:

• Statutory duty to cooperate with safeguarding enquiries (Children Act 2004, Care Act 2014)
• Required to have appropriate level of safeguarding training:
  • "Level 1: All staff (awareness)"
  • "Level 2: Staff with regular patient contact"
  • "Level 3: Specialist safeguarding staff, designated doctors/nurses"

Mandatory Reporting

UK: No statutory mandatory reporting for healthcare professionals (differs from some countries like USA, Australia)

However: Professional duty (GMC, NMC) means that failure to report safeguarding concerns can result in fitness-to-practice proceedings

Information Sharing: As discussed, legal protections exist for sharing information for safeguarding purposes without consent

Legal Proceedings

Criminal Proceedings

• Assault, rape, neglect, manslaughter, murder
• Healthcare professionals may be required as witnesses
• Medical evidence critical (documentation, photographs, expert testimony)

Family Court Proceedings

• Care orders, supervision orders, emergency protection orders
• Lower burden of proof than criminal (balance of probabilities vs. beyond reasonable doubt)
• Named Person Report may be requested from treating clinicians

Fitness to Practice (Professional Regulation)

• Healthcare professionals who abuse patients or fail in safeguarding duties may face GMC/NMC hearings

---

10. Practical Guidance for Clinicians

Consultation Skills

Seeing the Patient Alone

• Golden Rule: Always find a reason to see patient alone, even briefly
• Examples: "I just need to check your blood pressure in the treatment room"
  • "We need a urine sample - can you come with the nurse?"
• Essential for disclosure and assessing coercion

Communicating with Children

• Use age-appropriate language
• Get down to child's level physically
• Use play, drawing, dolls to facilitate communication (younger children)
• Explain what you are doing and why
• Reassure: "You are not in trouble"
  • "This is not your fault"

Assessing Capacity in Adults

• Always start with presumption of capacity
• Assess for coercion: Is patient able to speak freely? Are they looking to partner for approval?
• Two-stage test (Mental Capacity Act 2005)

Documentation Best Practice

Golden Rules: [15]

• Timely: Document as soon as possible after encounter
• Accurate: Stick to facts, avoid speculation
• Legible: Clear, permanent records (may be used in court years later)
• Verbatim quotes: Use quotation marks for patient's exact words
• Body maps: Anatomical diagrams for all injuries
• Photographs: Taken with consent, using ruler for scale, include face (for identification) and close-ups of injuries

Example of Good Documentation:

"4-month-old infant brought by mother at 16:30 on 06/01/2026. Mother states, 'He fell off the changing table this morning at 9am.' On examination, 3cm bruise noted over left parietal region of scalp. Additionally, 1cm circular bruise on left cheek, and linear 2cm bruise on upper right arm. Child is pre-mobile (not rolling). No fractures palpable. Discussed with Dr. Smith (Paediatric Consultant) - skeletal survey and safeguarding referral to be completed. Mother informed of concerns and reason for skeletal survey."

Example of Poor Documentation:

"Mum says he fell. Got some bruises. Think NAI. Will refer."

Managing Uncertainty

"When in Doubt, Reach Out"

• Safeguarding is complex; no one expects you to be an expert
• Discuss with:
  • Named/Designated Safeguarding Lead in your organization
  • Senior colleague (Consultant, Safeguarding Nurse)
  • Local Authority Social Care (for advice - does not constitute formal referral)
• It is better to discuss a case and be reassured than to miss safeguarding concern

Threshold for Referral

• Does NOT require certainty of abuse
• Threshold: "Reasonable cause to suspect" (children) or "Care needs + experiencing/at risk of abuse + unable to protect self" (adults)
• The safeguarding team/social services will investigate and make determination

Self-Care and Support

Emotional Impact

• Safeguarding work is emotionally challenging
• Normal to feel distressed, uncertain, or conflicted
• Access to debriefing, supervision, and support services
• Recognize vicarious trauma and burnout

Clinical Supervision

• Regular safeguarding supervision for staff dealing with complex cases

---

11. Evidence and Guidelines

Key Guidelines

Landmark Legal Cases

1. Victoria Climbié (2000)

• 8-year-old died from abuse despite 128 injuries noted by healthcare professionals
• Multiple agencies involved but poor communication and information sharing
• Laming Report (2003): Led to the Every Child Matters agenda and Children Act 2004

2. Baby P (Peter Connelly) (2007)

• 17-month-old died despite being on Child Protection Plan
• Over 60 contacts with health, police, and social services
• Highlighted failures in multi-agency working and professional accountability
• Led to reforms in Working Together guidance

3. Daniel Pelka (2012)

• 4-year-old died from starvation and abuse
• Schools and healthcare professionals missed signs of neglect
• Serious Case Review highlighted need for professional curiosity and challenging parental explanations

Lessons Learned:

• Importance of information sharing between agencies
• Need for professional curiosity: Not accepting implausible explanations
• See and speak to the child individually
• Recognize disguised compliance: Parents appearing to cooperate but not changing
• Escalation procedures: If concerns not addressed, escalate to senior management

---

12. Examination Focus

High-Yield Exam Topics

Paediatric Postgraduate Exams (MRCPCH)

1. Bruise in Pre-Mobile Baby

• Question: "2-month-old with bruise on cheek. What is your management?"
• Answer: Non-accidental injury until proven otherwise. Immediate safeguarding referral, skeletal survey, coagulation screen, CT head, ophthalmology review, discuss with safeguarding lead, do not allow child to leave hospital.

2. Specific NAI Fractures

• Question: "Most specific fracture for non-accidental injury?"
• Answer: Metaphyseal corner (bucket-handle) fracture or posterior rib fractures (especially in child less than 2 years)

3. Shaken Baby Syndrome

• Question: "Triad of abusive head trauma?"
• Answer: Subdural hemorrhage, retinal hemorrhages, encephalopathy (though not all need to be present)

4. Fabricated or Induced Illness

• Question: "Mother reports child has recurrent apneas, but never witnessed by staff. What is your concern?"
• Answer: Fabricated or Induced Illness (formerly Munchausen's by Proxy). Management includes covert surveillance (ethically approved), review of all medical records, separation test, multi-agency safeguarding.

5. Disclosure Management

• Question: "6-year-old says 'Daddy hurts me.' What do you do?"
• Answer: Listen calmly, use open questions (TED - Tell, Explain, Describe), do NOT promise confidentiality, do NOT ask leading questions, record verbatim, refer to safeguarding team immediately.

General Practice / Emergency Medicine Exams

6. Legal Framework (Adults)

• Question: "What is the key legislation for adult safeguarding?"
• Answer: Care Act 2014 (Section 42 duty to make safeguarding enquiries). Also relevant: Mental Capacity Act 2005, Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS).

7. Information Sharing

• Question: "Can you share information about safeguarding concerns without patient consent?"
• Answer: Yes. GDPR and duty of confidentiality do NOT prevent information sharing for safeguarding purposes. Legal basis: overriding public interest, right to life and protection from harm (Human Rights Act Articles 2, 3) override right to privacy (Article 8). Must be necessary, proportionate, and documented.

8. Domestic Violence Screening

• Question: "How do you ask about domestic violence?"
• Answer: See patient alone, normalize questioning ("We ask all patients..."), use validated tools (HARK, HITS), ensure safety planning if disclosed, refer to IDVA (Independent Domestic Violence Advisor), consider MARAC if high-risk.

9. Safeguarding Referral Process

• Question: "To whom do you refer safeguarding concerns?"
• Answer:
  • "Children: Local Authority Children's Social Care or MASH (Multi-Agency Safeguarding Hub)"
  • "Adults: Local Authority Adult Social Care Safeguarding Team"
  • "Immediate danger: Police (999)"

10. Mental Capacity Assessment

• Question: "How do you assess mental capacity?"
• Answer: Mental Capacity Act 2005. Two-stage test:
  1. Is there impairment/disturbance of mind/brain?
  2. Does this mean person unable to: (a) Understand, (b) Retain, (c) Weigh/use, (d) Communicate decision?
  • Capacity is decision-specific, time-specific, and presumed unless proven otherwise.

Viva Voce Preparation

Scenario 1: Pre-Mobile Baby with Bruising

• Viva Question: "You are the paediatric SHO in ED. A mother brings her 3-month-old baby with a bruise on the forehead. She says the baby rolled off the sofa. What are your concerns and management?"
• Model Answer:
  • "Concern: Pre-mobile baby (3 months old, unlikely to be rolling) with bruise - high suspicion for NAI"
  • "History: Detailed mechanism, developmental stage, who was present, time of injury, delay in presentation, previous injuries"
  • "Examination: Full top-to-toe examination (with chaperone), growth parameters, developmental assessment, body map all injuries"
  • "Investigations: Skeletal survey, CT head, ophthalmology, coagulation screen"
  • "Safeguarding: Discuss with safeguarding lead, refer to social services, do not allow child to leave hospital until discussed, document verbatim"
  • "Differentials: Consider bleeding disorder (ITP, hemophilia), but NAI until proven otherwise"

Scenario 2: Adult with Possible Financial Abuse

• Viva Question: "You are a GP. An 82-year-old woman with mild dementia attends with her son. You notice unexplained bank withdrawals on a recent financial document in her notes. How do you proceed?"
• Model Answer:
  • "Concern: Possible financial abuse (son may be exploiting mother)"
  • "See patient alone: Essential to assess if coercion present"
  • "Capacity assessment: Does patient have capacity to make financial decisions? Two-stage test."
  • Gentle exploration: "How are things at home?" "Who helps with your finances?" "Have there been any changes to your banking?"
  • "Safeguarding referral: If concerns substantiated, refer to Local Authority Adult Safeguarding (Care Act Section 42)"
  • "Other support: Consider referral to Independent Mental Capacity Advocate (IMCA), Lasting Power of Attorney review, possible Court of Protection involvement"
  • "Document: Factual record of concerns and actions taken"

Scenario 3: Disclosure in OSCE Station

• OSCE Task: "This 14-year-old girl has attended with abdominal pain. Take a history."
• Scenario: During history, patient discloses sexual abuse by stepfather
• Expected Actions:
  • "Stay calm: Do not show shock, thank patient for trusting you"
  • "Listen: Allow patient to speak without interruption"
  • Open questions: "Can you tell me more about what happened?" (Do NOT ask leading questions)
  • Reassure: "This is not your fault"
  • "You are brave to tell me"
  • Limits of confidentiality: "I need to share this with people who can keep you safe. I cannot keep this confidential because you are at risk."
  • Do NOT promise confidentiality
  • Do NOT confront stepfather or inform him (may endanger patient)
  • "Immediate actions: Inform senior (consultant, safeguarding lead), refer to social services immediately, consider admission if unsafe to go home"
  • "Document verbatim: Exact words patient used"

Scenario 4: FII (Fabricated or Induced Illness)

• Viva Question: "Describe your approach to suspected Fabricated or Induced Illness."
• Model Answer:
  • "High index of suspicion: Symptoms only occur with one parent present, discrepancy between reported and observed, parent welcomes invasive tests"
  • "Review all medical records: Pattern across multiple hospitals"
  • "Multi-agency approach: Early involvement of safeguarding team, police, social services"
  • "Evidence gathering: Covert video surveillance (only in hospital, ethically approved), separation test (child improves when away from parent)"
  • "Avoid confrontation: Do not accuse parent (may abscond with child, destroy evidence)"
  • "Child protection: High threshold for child protection plan or care proceedings"
  • "Forms: Fabrication (false reporting), Induction (deliberately causing), Exaggeration"

---

13. Patient and Layperson Explanation

What is Safeguarding?

Safeguarding means making sure that children and vulnerable adults are safe, healthy, and protected from harm. It is about:

• Keeping people safe from abuse and neglect
• Making sure people are treated well and with respect
• Helping people to live safely and independently

Doctors, nurses, social workers, teachers, and police all work together to protect people who may be at risk.

Why Are Healthcare Professionals Asking About My Home Life?

Healthcare professionals ask about home life because:

• Home environment affects health: Stress, financial problems, and relationship difficulties can make physical and mental health worse
• We want to help: If you are struggling, we can connect you with support services (counseling, financial advice, housing support)
• We have a duty to protect: If someone is being hurt or neglected, we have a legal responsibility to help keep them safe

We ask everyone these questions - it is routine, and you are not being singled out.

What Happens If I Tell You Something?

If you are an adult with capacity:

• We will discuss the best way to keep you safe
• We will usually ask your permission before sharing information with other services
• However, if you or someone else is in serious danger, we may need to share information without your permission to protect you

If you are a child, or an adult who cannot make decisions for yourself:

• We will share information with the safeguarding team (social workers, police) to make sure you are safe
• We will usually tell you that we are doing this
• We will not tell the person who is harming you (if that would put you in more danger)

Will My Children Be Taken Away?

Most children stay at home with their families. The goal of safeguarding is to:

• Help families stay together safely
• Provide support (parenting classes, financial help, counseling)
• Only remove children if they cannot be kept safe at home

Removal of children (foster care or adoption) is a last resort and only happens when all other options have been tried, or when there is serious immediate risk.

I'm Worried About Someone Else. What Should I Do?

If you are worried that a child or vulnerable adult is being abused or neglected:

• Tell someone: Contact your GP, health visitor, social services, or police
• NSPCC Helpline (for child concerns): 0808 800 5000
• Action on Elder Abuse Helpline: 0808 808 8141
• National Domestic Abuse Helpline: 0808 2000 247

You do not need proof - just a concern. The safeguarding team will investigate.

---

14. References

Primary Sources

1. HM Government. Working Together to Safeguard Children: A Guide to Inter-Agency Working to Safeguard and Promote the Welfare of Children. 2023. [Statutory Guidance, UK Government]

2. Department of Health and Social Care. Care and Support Statutory Guidance: Issued under the Care Act 2014. 2014 (updated 2020). [Statutory Guidance]

3. General Medical Council. Protecting Children and Young People: The Responsibilities of All Doctors. 2012 (updated 2018). GMC Guidance.

4. Radford L, Corral S, Bradley C, et al. Child Abuse and Neglect in the UK Today. NSPCC, 2011. [Prevalence study]

5. Woodman J, Lecky F, Hodes D, et al. Screening injured children for physical abuse or neglect in emergency departments: a systematic review. Child Care Health Dev. 2010;36(2):153-164. PMID: 19961492

6. Pillemer K, Burnes D, Riffin C, Lachs MS. Elder abuse: global situation, risk factors, and prevention strategies. Gerontologist. 2016;56(Suppl 2):S194-S205. PMID: 26994260. DOI: 10.1093/geront/gnw004

7. Office for National Statistics. Domestic Abuse in England and Wales: Year Ending March 2020. ONS Statistical Bulletin, 2020.

8. Bellis MA, Hughes K, Leckenby N, et al. Adverse childhood experiences and associations with health-harming behaviours in young adults: surveys in eight eastern European countries. Bull World Health Organ. 2014;92(9):641-655. PMID: 25378755. DOI: 10.2471/BLT.13.129247

9. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Child Maltreatment: When to Suspect Maltreatment in Under 18s (CG89). NICE Clinical Guideline, 2009 (updated 2017).

10. HM Government. Information Sharing: Advice for Practitioners Providing Safeguarding Services to Children, Young People, Parents and Carers. 2018.

11. Maguire S, Mann M, Sibert J, Kemp A. Are there patterns of bruising in childhood which are diagnostic or suggestive of abuse? A systematic review. Arch Dis Child. 2005;90(2):182-186. PMID: 15665176. DOI: 10.1136/adc.2003.044065

12. Barsness KA, Cha ES, Bensard DD, et al. The positive predictive value of rib fractures as an indicator of nonaccidental trauma in children. J Trauma. 2003;54(6):1107-1110. PMID: 12813329. DOI: 10.1097/01.TA.0000068992.01030.A8

13. Narang SK, Fingarson A, Lukefahr J; Council on Child Abuse and Neglect. Abusive head trauma in infants and children. Pediatrics. 2020;145(4):e20200203. PMID: 32358224. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2020-0203

14. Anderst JD, Carpenter SL, Abshire TC; Section on Hematology/Oncology and Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect. Evaluation for bleeding disorders in suspected child abuse. Pediatrics. 2013;131(4):e1314-e1322. PMID: 23530173. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2013-0195

15. Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. The Physical Signs of Child Sexual Abuse: An Evidence-Based Review and Guideline. RCPCH, 2015.

16. Section on Radiology, American Academy of Pediatrics. Diagnostic imaging of child abuse. Pediatrics. 2009;123(5):1430-1435. PMID: 19403511. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2009-0558

17. Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. Fabricated or Induced Illness (FII) by Carers: A Practical Guide for Paediatricians. RCPCH, 2021.

18. Department for Education. Child Sexual Exploitation: Definition and Guide for Practitioners. 2017.

19. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Domestic Violence and Abuse: Multi-Agency Working (PH50). NICE Public Health Guideline, 2014 (updated 2016).

20. Lachs MS, Pillemer KA. Elder abuse. N Engl J Med. 2015;373(20):1947-1956. PMID: 26559573. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMra1404688

21. Felitti VJ, Anda RF, Nordenberg D, et al. Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. Am J Prev Med. 1998;14(4):245-258. PMID: 9635069. DOI: 10.1016/s0749-3797(98)00017-8

22. General Medical Council. Good Medical Practice. GMC, 2013 (updated 2024).

23. Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. Safeguarding Children and Young People: Roles and Competences for Healthcare Staff (Intercollegiate Document). 4th edition, RCPCH, 2019.

24. Royal College of Nursing and Royal College of Physicians. Adult Safeguarding: Roles and Competences for Health Care Staff (Intercollegiate Document). 2nd edition, RCN/RCP, 2018.

---

Medical Disclaimer: MedVellum content is for educational purposes and clinical reference. Clinical decisions should account for individual patient circumstances. Safeguarding is a complex area with legal implications - always consult local safeguarding leads and follow institutional protocols. When in doubt, seek senior advice.