Aortic Dissection
Aortic dissection occurs when an intimal tear allows blood to enter the medial layer of the aorta, creating a false lume... ACEM Primary Written, ACEM Primary V
Clinical board
A visual summary of the highest-yield teaching signals on this page.
Urgent signals
Safety-critical features pulled from the topic metadata.
- Sudden onset tearing/ripping chest or back pain
- Pulse deficit or blood pressure differential greater than 20 mmHg between arms
- New aortic regurgitation murmur
- Neurological deficit suggesting stroke/spinal ischemia
Exam focus
Current exam surfaces linked to this topic.
- ACEM Primary Written
- ACEM Primary Viva
- ACEM Fellowship Written
- ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Linked comparisons
Differentials and adjacent topics worth opening next.
- Acute Coronary Syndrome
- Pulmonary Embolism
Editorial and exam context
Topic family
This concept exists in multiple MedVellum libraries. Use the primary page for the broadest reference view and the others for exam-specific framing.
Mechanism : Intimal tear → blood dissects into media → false lumen formation → propagation proximally/distally Incidence : 5-30 per million per year; peak age 60-70 years; male:female ratio 2-3:1 Presentation : Sudden...
Aortic dissection occurs when an intimal tear allows blood to enter the medial layer of the aorta, creating a false lume... ACEM Primary Written, ACEM Primary V
1. Beta-blockade FIRST: Esmolol or labetalol to target HR below 60 bpm (reduces dP/dt)... CICM Second Part exam preparation.
Quick Answer
One-liner: Aortic dissection is a life-threatening tear in the aortic intima causing blood to dissect between aortic layers; Type A (involves ascending aorta) requires emergency surgery, Type B (descending aorta only) is initially managed medically with aggressive BP/HR control.
Aortic dissection occurs when an intimal tear allows blood to enter the medial layer of the aorta, creating a false lumen that propagates along the vessel. Untreated mortality is 1-2% per hour, with 50% dead by 48 hours. The key emergency decision is Type A vs Type B (Stanford classification): Type A involves the ascending aorta and mandates urgent cardiothoracic surgery; Type B (descending aorta only) is initially managed with aggressive medical therapy (target SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm). Complications include cardiac tamponade, acute aortic regurgitation, stroke, and malperfusion syndromes affecting viscera, kidneys, or limbs.
ACEM Exam Focus
Primary Exam Relevance
- Anatomy: Layers of aortic wall (intima, media, adventitia), aortic branches (coronary, arch vessels, visceral, renal), blood supply to spinal cord (artery of Adamkiewicz)
- Physiology: Aortic wall stress (Laplace's law: Wall tension ∝ pressure × radius), dP/dt (rate of pressure change—reduced by beta-blockade), autoregulation of end-organs
- Pharmacology: Beta-blockers (esmolol, labetalol, metoprolol), vasodilators (GTN, SNP), calcium channel blockers (diltiazem), analgesics (fentanyl, morphine)
Fellowship Exam Relevance
- Written: Classification systems (Stanford, DeBakey), D-dimer role, imaging modalities (sensitivity/specificity), complications (tamponade, AR, malperfusion), medical management targets
- OSCE: Resuscitation scenario with haemodynamic instability, breaking bad news about poor prognosis, transfer coordination with cardiothoracic centre
- Key domains tested: Medical Expert (diagnosis, management), Communicator (family discussion, retrieval coordination), Collaborator (cardiothoracic surgery liaison), Leader (resus team coordination)
Key Points
The 5 things you MUST know:
- Type A = Surgery, Type B = Medical: Type A dissection (involves ascending aorta) requires urgent cardiothoracic surgery; Type B (descending only) managed medically unless complications arise
- Beta-blocker FIRST, then vasodilator: Always give beta-blocker (or CCB if contraindicated) BEFORE vasodilator to prevent reflex tachycardia which increases shear stress (dP/dt) and propagates dissection
- D-dimer cannot rule out: D-dimer sensitivity ~97% for classic dissection but only 67-87% for intramural haematoma/PAU. Not safe as sole exclusion test
- 1% mortality per hour untreated: Without treatment, mortality is 1-2% per hour. 50% dead by 48 hours, 90% by 1 month. Time is aorta.
- Malperfusion predicts mortality: Presence of any malperfusion syndrome (cerebral, visceral, renal, limb) increases operative mortality from ~15% to 30-50%
Epidemiology
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence | 3-5 per 100,000/year | [1] |
| Type A:Type B ratio | 60:40 | [2] |
| Mortality untreated | 1-2% per hour | [3] |
| Mortality at 48h (untreated) | 50% | [3] |
| Mortality at 1 month (untreated) | 90% | [3] |
| Peak age | 60-70 years | [4] |
| Gender ratio | M:F 2-3:1 | [5] |
| Operative mortality Type A | 15-20% | [6] |
| Medical mortality Type B | 10-15% | [7] |
Australian/NZ Specific
- Incidence: 3.13 per 100,000 person-years in Aotearoa New Zealand (2010-2020), including out-of-hospital deaths [8]
- Type distribution: 61% Type A, 39% Type B in NZ national study [8]
- Outcomes in Australia: 30-day mortality 11.2% for Type A dissection (2001-2021 ANZSCTS data), with improved outcomes at higher-volume centres [9]
- Indigenous populations: Limited data, but Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have 2-3x higher cardiovascular disease burden, potentially increasing dissection risk with hypertension [10]
- Rural/remote: Significant delays in diagnosis and transfer to cardiothoracic centres; RFDS retrieval critical [11]
Pathophysiology
Mechanism
Aortic dissection begins with an intimal tear that allows blood under systemic pressure to enter the medial layer of the aortic wall. Blood then dissects along the media, cleaving it into inner and outer layers, creating a false lumen alongside the original true lumen. The false lumen may:
- Propagate anterograde (towards iliac arteries) or retrograde (towards aortic root)
- Compress or shear branch vessels, causing malperfusion
- Re-enter the true lumen via distal fenestrations
- Rupture through the adventitia (instantly fatal if into pericardium or pleural space)
Pathological Progression
Intimal tear (primary entry) → Blood enters medial layer → False lumen propagation (antegrade/retrograde) → Branch vessel compromise (malperfusion) → Possible outcomes:
1. Thrombosis of false lumen (stabilisation)
2. Re-entry to true lumen (chronic dissection)
3. Rupture through adventitia (pericardial tamponade, exsanguination)
4. Progressive aneurysmal dilatation
Predisposing Factors
- Cystic medial degeneration: Degradation of elastic fibres and smooth muscle in aortic media (seen in Marfan, Ehlers-Danlos, Loeys-Dietz syndromes)
- Hypertension: Chronic elevated wall stress (Laplace's law: Wall tension = Pressure × Radius / (2 × Wall thickness))
- Inflammatory aortitis: Giant cell arteritis, Takayasu arteritis, syphilitic aortitis
- Iatrogenic: Cardiac surgery, catheterisation, IABP insertion
- Trauma: Deceleration injury causing intimal tear
Why It Matters Clinically
- dP/dt (shear stress): Rate of change of pressure during systole determines propagation—hence beta-blockade to reduce HR and contractility is first-line
- Malperfusion: False lumen can compress or dissect into branch vessels (coronaries → MI; carotids → stroke; visceral → mesenteric ischaemia; renal → AKI; iliacs → limb ischaemia)
- Aortic regurgitation: Retrograde dissection disrupts aortic valve annulus or cusp support → acute severe AR → cardiogenic shock
- Tamponade: Rupture into pericardium → obstructive shock
Clinical Approach
Recognition
High-risk triggers:
- Pain: Sudden-onset, severe, "tearing/ripping", maximal at onset (vs crescendo in ACS)
- Location: Anterior chest pain (Type A), interscapular back pain (Type B)
- Risk factors: Known hypertension, connective tissue disorder, bicuspid aortic valve, cocaine/amphetamine use
- Associated features: Syncope, stroke symptoms, pulse deficit, new AR murmur
Initial Assessment
Primary Survey
- A: Patent, protect if GCS below 8 (esp. if stroke from carotid dissection extension)
- B: RR, SpO₂, asymmetric breath sounds (haemothorax if rupture into pleura), pulmonary oedema (if acute AR)
- C: Pulse deficit (compare radial pulses, palpate femorals), BP differential (greater than 20 mmHg between arms in 30-40%), JVP elevated (tamponade), muffled heart sounds (tamponade), new diastolic murmur (AR)
- D: GCS, focal neurology (stroke from carotid/vertebral involvement, spinal cord ischaemia if artery of Adamkiewicz compromised)
- E: Abdominal tenderness (mesenteric ischaemia), cool/pulseless limbs (iliac dissection)
ECG changes:
- Usually non-specific ST/T changes
- If coronary ostia involved: STEMI pattern (RCA more common) [12]
- Always obtain 12-lead ECG to assess for concurrent ACS vs coronary malperfusion
History
Key Questions
| Question | Significance |
|---|---|
| "Describe the pain onset—sudden or gradual?" | Maximal pain at onset suggests dissection; crescendo pain suggests ACS |
| "Where is the pain—front of chest or back?" | Anterior: Type A likely; interscapular: Type B; both: extensive Type A |
| "Have you fainted, felt dizzy, or had weakness/numbness?" | Syncope: tamponade, severe AR, cerebral malperfusion. Neuro deficit: carotid/vertebral involvement |
| "Any history of Marfan, Ehlers-Danlos, or heart valve problems?" | Connective tissue disorder or bicuspid aortic valve increase risk 10-100 fold |
| "Do you use cocaine or have uncontrolled high blood pressure?" | Both increase shear stress and intimal injury risk |
Red Flag Symptoms
- Sudden tearing/ripping chest or interscapular pain (85-95% of cases)
- Syncope (13-27%): suggests tamponade, severe AR, or cerebral malperfusion
- Acute limb weakness or paraplegia: spinal cord ischaemia (artery of Adamkiewicz)
- Stroke symptoms: carotid dissection extension (5-10%)
- Severe abdominal pain: visceral malperfusion (mesenteric ischaemia)
- Oliguria/anuria: renal artery involvement
Examination
General Inspection
- Distress level: Extreme distress despite opioids
- Marfanoid features: Tall, arm span > height, pectus deformity, arachnodactyly, lens dislocation
- Haemodynamic state: Hypertensive (70-80% of Type B), hypotensive or shocked (tamponade, rupture, severe AR)
Specific Findings
| System | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Cardiovascular | Pulse deficit (radial-radial, radial-femoral) | Present in 15-30%, highly specific for dissection |
| BP differential greater than 20 mmHg | Seen in 30-40%, suggests subclavian involvement | |
| New diastolic murmur (AR) | Acute severe aortic regurgitation (Type A) | |
| Elevated JVP, muffled heart sounds | Cardiac tamponade (Type A rupture into pericardium) | |
| Pulsus paradoxus | Tamponade physiology | |
| Neurological | Stroke (focal deficit, dysphasia, GCS↓) | Carotid/vertebral dissection extension (5-10%) |
| Paraplegia, sensory level | Spinal cord ischaemia (artery of Adamkiewicz) | |
| Horner syndrome | Sympathetic plexus disruption (ptosis, miosis, anhidrosis) | |
| Abdominal | Severe tenderness, absent bowel sounds | Mesenteric ischaemia (visceral malperfusion) |
| Limbs | Cool, pale, pulseless leg | Iliac artery dissection or thrombosis |
| Respiratory | Dullness, reduced breath sounds | Haemothorax (rupture into pleural space) |
Investigations
Immediate (Resus Bay)
| Test | Purpose | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| 12-lead ECG | Exclude STEMI, identify coronary involvement | Usually non-specific; STEMI pattern if coronary ostia involved |
| Bedside echo (TTE) | Assess for pericardial effusion/tamponade, AR, LV function | Pericardial fluid, dilated aortic root, AR jet; limited sensitivity (60-80%) for dissection [13] |
| Portable CXR | Widened mediastinum, pleural effusion | Widened mediastinum (greater than 8 cm) in 60-80%, but may be normal; haemothorax if rupture |
| ABG | Metabolic acidosis (malperfusion), lactate | Elevated lactate suggests visceral/limb ischaemia |
| 4-limb BP | Identify pulse deficit, BP differential | greater than 20 mmHg difference between arms: 30-40% sensitive, 95% specific [14] |
Standard ED Workup
| Test | Indication | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| CT aorta (arterial phase) | Gold standard for diagnosis | Sensitivity 98-100%, specificity 98-100% [15]. Identify: intimal flap, true/false lumen, entry/re-entry tears, branch vessel involvement, pericardial/pleural fluid |
| D-dimer | Part of ADD-RS score; adjunct only | Elevated (greater than 500 ng/mL) in 97% of classic dissections; BUT sensitivity only 67-87% for IMH/PAU [16,17]. Cannot be used as sole rule-out |
| FBC | Baseline Hb (for transfusion planning) | Anaemia if chronic; acute drop if rupture |
| UEC | Renal function (baseline, malperfusion) | Elevated Cr suggests renal artery involvement |
| Coagulation (INR, APTT) | Pre-operative assessment | Correct coagulopathy before surgery |
| Troponin | If coronary involvement suspected | May be elevated if coronary ostia dissected |
| Group & Hold / Crossmatch | Prepare for surgery, transfusion | Type A: crossmatch 4-6 units; Type B: G&H |
| Lactate | Malperfusion marker | greater than 4 mmol/L suggests visceral or limb ischaemia |
Advanced/Specialist
| Test | Indication | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| Transoesophageal echocardiography (TOE) | Type A dissection assessment pre-op, haemodynamically unstable patients | Sensitivity 98%, specificity 97% [18]. Available in tertiary centres with cardiothoracic surgery |
| MRI aorta | Type B dissection assessment if CT contraindicated | Sensitivity 98%, specificity 98% [19]. Not suitable for unstable patients |
| Aortography | Historical gold standard, now rarely used | Invasive, time-consuming, sensitivity 85-90% (misses IMH) [20] |
ADD-RS (Aortic Dissection Detection Risk Score)
Purpose: Identify low-risk patients in whom dissection can be ruled out (used with D-dimer)
| Feature | Points |
|---|---|
| Predisposing condition (Marfan, other connective tissue disorder, family h/o aortic disease, bicuspid valve, prior aortic valve surgery, prior thoracic aortic aneurysm) | 1 |
| High-risk pain features (abrupt onset, severe intensity, ripping/tearing quality) | 1 |
| High-risk exam features (pulse deficit, BP differential greater than 20 mmHg, focal neuro deficit + pain, new AR murmur, hypotension/shock) | 1 |
Interpretation:
- ADD-RS = 0 AND D-dimer below 500 ng/mL: Negative predictive value 99.7% [21]
- ADD-RS ≥1 OR D-dimer ≥500 ng/mL: Proceed to CT aorta (cannot rule out)
Point-of-Care Ultrasound
TTE (Transthoracic Echo):
- Pericardial effusion: Suggests Type A with pericardial rupture (tamponade)
- Aortic regurgitation: Colour Doppler shows regurgitant jet
- Dilated aortic root: greater than 4 cm suggests aneurysm or dissection
- Intimal flap: May be visible in proximal ascending aorta or arch (sensitivity 60-80%) [13]
Limitations: Cannot reliably exclude dissection; cannot assess descending aorta; operator-dependent
Management
Immediate Management (First 10 minutes)
1. Resuscitation position: Head-up 30° if possible to reduce cerebral oedema
2. High-flow oxygen if SpO₂ below 94% (target 94-98%)
3. IV access: Two large-bore cannulae (14-16G)
4. Monitoring: Continuous ECG, SpO₂, NIBP q5min (right arm), urine output
5. Analgesia: Fentanyl 50-100 mcg IV or morphine 5-10 mg IV (reduces sympathetic surge)
6. Beta-blockade: Esmolol 500 mcg/kg IV over 1 min, then 50-200 mcg/kg/min infusion (or metoprolol 5 mg IV q5min to max 15 mg) — TARGET HR below 60 bpm
7. Blood pressure control: If SBP greater than 120 mmHg despite beta-blocker, add GTN infusion 10-200 mcg/min or sodium nitroprusside 0.3-10 mcg/kg/min — TARGET SBP 100-120 mmHg
8. Urgent CT aorta if haemodynamically stable
9. Activate cardiothoracic surgery if Type A suspected
10. Nil by mouth (NBM) in case of emergency surgery
CRITICAL: Always beta-block (or rate-control with diltiazem) BEFORE vasodilator. Vasodilator alone causes reflex tachycardia → increased dP/dt → dissection propagation.
Resuscitation (if applicable)
Airway
- Intubation indications: GCS below 8, loss of airway reflexes, respiratory failure, severe pulmonary oedema (acute AR)
- Caution: Intubation causes sympathetic surge → hypertensive crisis → dissection propagation. Pre-treat with beta-blocker and/or opioid. Avoid ketamine (increases BP/HR).
- Agent choice: Fentanyl 2-3 mcg/kg + propofol 1-2 mg/kg (blunts response). Rocuronium 1 mg/kg for paralysis.
Breathing
- Targets: SpO₂ 94-98%, avoid hyperoxia (no benefit, potential harm)
- If intubated: Lung-protective ventilation (Vt 6-8 mL/kg IBW, PEEP 5-8 cmH₂O), avoid excessive PEEP (reduces venous return, may worsen tamponade)
Circulation
- Haemodynamic targets: SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm, MAP 60-75 mmHg
- Tamponade: If suspected (Beck's triad: hypotension, elevated JVP, muffled heart sounds + pulsus paradoxus), urgent pericardiocentesis (echo-guided if time permits). This is a bridge to surgery, NOT definitive treatment.
- Hypotension management:
- "If tamponade: pericardiocentesis + surgery"
- "If rupture/exsanguination: permissive hypotension (SBP ~90 mmHg), activate massive transfusion protocol, emergency surgery"
- "If cardiogenic shock (acute severe AR): inotropes (dobutamine 2.5-20 mcg/kg/min), avoid excessive afterload reduction, urgent surgery"
- Avoid excessive fluid resuscitation: Increases BP/shear stress → propagation/rupture
Disability
- Stroke management: If carotid dissection extension, maintain MAP 80-100 mmHg (cerebral perfusion), urgent neurology consult
- Spinal cord ischaemia: Maintain MAP greater than 80 mmHg to optimise spinal cord perfusion, urgent surgery (Type A) or TEVAR (Type B)
Medications
Beta-Blockers (FIRST-LINE)
| Drug | Dose | Route | Timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Esmolol (preferred) | Loading: 500 mcg/kg over 1 min; Infusion: 50-200 mcg/kg/min | IV | Immediate | Short-acting, easily titratable; ideal for acute setting |
| Labetalol | 10-20 mg IV bolus q10min, then 0.5-2 mg/min infusion | IV | Immediate | Combined alpha/beta-blocker; single agent for BP/HR control |
| Metoprolol | 5 mg IV q5min (max 15 mg total) | IV | Immediate | If esmolol unavailable; give slowly over 2 min per dose |
| Propranolol | 0.5-1 mg IV q5min (max 0.15 mg/kg) | IV | Immediate | Alternative if others unavailable |
Contraindications: Severe bradycardia (HR below 50), high-grade AV block, decompensated heart failure (pulmonary oedema), severe asthma/COPD
Alternative if beta-blocker contraindicated: Diltiazem 0.25 mg/kg IV over 2 min (usually 15-25 mg), then 5-15 mg/h infusion
Vasodilators (SECOND-LINE—only after beta-blockade)
| Drug | Dose | Route | Timing | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GTN (glyceryl trinitrate) | Start 10 mcg/min, titrate up by 10-20 mcg/min q5min (max 200 mcg/min) | IV | After HR below 60 | Causes reflex tachycardia if given alone; have beta-blocker on board first |
| Sodium nitroprusside | Start 0.3 mcg/kg/min, titrate to effect (usual 0.5-10 mcg/kg/min) | IV | After HR below 60 | Potent, rapid onset; risk cyanide toxicity if greater than 3 mcg/kg/min for greater than 72h; protect from light |
Analgesia
| Drug | Dose | Route | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fentanyl | 50-100 mcg IV bolus, repeat q5-10min PRN | IV | Preferred; reduces sympathetic response, less histamine release than morphine |
| Morphine | 5-10 mg IV bolus, repeat q10-15min PRN | IV | Alternative; may cause histamine release → hypotension |
Avoid NSAIDs: May worsen platelet function (pre-operative concern)
Paediatric Dosing
| Drug | Dose | Max | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Esmolol | Loading 500 mcg/kg over 1 min; infusion 50-200 mcg/kg/min | 1 mg/kg/min | Rare in children (Marfan, Turner, Loeys-Dietz) |
| Labetalol | 0.2-1 mg/kg/dose IV (max 20 mg) | 40 mg/dose | Useful if single agent needed |
| Fentanyl | 1-2 mcg/kg IV | 100 mcg | Weight-based dosing |
Definitive Care
Type A Dissection (Stanford Type A, DeBakey I/II)
URGENT CARDIOTHORACIC SURGERY (within 6 hours if possible) [22]
- Procedure: Replacement of ascending aorta ± aortic valve ± aortic arch (depending on extent)
- Goals: Resect intimal tear, obliterate false lumen, restore true lumen flow, repair/replace aortic valve if AR
- Pre-operative optimisation: Maintain SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm, adequate analgesia
- Transfer: If not at cardiothoracic centre, arrange urgent retrieval with medical escort maintaining BP/HR control
Type B Dissection (Stanford Type B, DeBakey III)
MEDICAL MANAGEMENT (initial approach) [23]
- Goals: Control BP/HR (as above), monitor for complications
- Duration: ICU/HDU admission for 48-72h
- Follow-up imaging: CT at discharge, 3 months, 6 months, then annually
Indications for intervention (TEVAR or open surgery):
- Complicated Type B:
- Rupture or impending rupture (periaortic haematoma)
- Malperfusion syndrome (visceral, renal, limb)
- Refractory hypertension despite maximal medical therapy
- Severe pain despite analgesia
- Rapid aneurysmal expansion (greater than 1 cm in 6 months)
TEVAR (Thoracic Endovascular Aortic Repair): Stent-graft deployed via femoral access to cover primary entry tear, promoting false lumen thrombosis
Intramural Haematoma (IMH) & Penetrating Atherosclerotic Ulcer (PAU)
- Type A IMH: Treat as Type A dissection (surgery)
- Type B IMH: Medical management initially; 30-40% progress to classic dissection or rupture [24]
- PAU: Usually descending aorta; medical management unless rupture/expansion
Disposition
Admission Criteria (ALL patients with confirmed dissection)
- Type A: Urgent cardiothoracic surgery (transfer if not at tertiary centre)
- Type B uncomplicated: ICU/HDU admission for BP/HR control, serial monitoring
- Type B complicated: ICU admission, interventional radiology or cardiothoracic surgery consult
ICU/HDU Criteria
- All Type A dissections (pre- and post-operative)
- All Type B dissections (first 48-72h for BP/HR control)
- Malperfusion syndromes: Require intensive monitoring, may need urgent intervention
- Haemodynamic instability: Hypotension, tamponade, severe AR
- Neurological compromise: Stroke, spinal cord ischaemia
Discharge Criteria
No patient with acute dissection is discharged from ED.
If diagnosis excluded (CT aorta negative):
- Identify alternative cause of symptoms (ACS, PE, MSK)
- Ensure safe discharge diagnosis and follow-up
- Red flags: "Return if sudden severe tearing chest/back pain, syncope, limb weakness"
Follow-up (Post-Discharge after Surgical/Medical Management)
- Cardiothoracic surgery clinic (Type A post-op): 2-4 weeks
- Vascular surgery or cardiology (Type B): 2 weeks
- Serial imaging: CT aorta at 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, then annually for life
- Lifelong beta-blocker therapy: Target SBP below 120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm [25]
- Genetic counselling: If connective tissue disorder suspected (Marfan, Ehlers-Danlos, Loeys-Dietz)
Classification
Stanford Classification (MOST COMMONLY USED)
| Type | Definition | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Type A | Involves ascending aorta (± arch, descending) | Urgent surgery |
| Type B | Involves descending aorta only (distal to left subclavian) | Medical (unless complicated) |
Key point: Even if the primary tear is in the descending aorta, if dissection propagates retrograde into the ascending aorta, it is Type A.
DeBakey Classification (ANATOMICALLY DETAILED)
| Type | Definition | Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Type I | Originates in ascending, extends to arch and descending | Stanford A |
| Type II | Limited to ascending aorta only | Stanford A |
| Type III | Originates in descending aorta (distal to left subclavian) | Stanford B |
| Type IIIa | Limited to thoracic descending aorta | Stanford B |
| Type IIIb | Extends below diaphragm into abdominal aorta | Stanford B |
Acute Aortic Syndrome (Broader Category)
Acute aortic syndrome encompasses:
- Classic aortic dissection (intimal tear + false lumen)
- Intramural haematoma (IMH): Haemorrhage within aortic media without intimal tear (10-20% of AAS) [26]
- Penetrating atherosclerotic ulcer (PAU): Atherosclerotic plaque ulcerates through intima into media (5-10% of AAS) [27]
- Traumatic aortic injury: Blunt deceleration injury (usually at aortic isthmus)
Complications
Acute Complications (Emergency Department)
| Complication | Incidence | Mechanism | Management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cardiac tamponade | 15-20% (Type A) [28] | Rupture into pericardium | Pericardiocentesis (temporising), urgent surgery |
| Acute aortic regurgitation | 40-75% (Type A) [29] | Valve annulus disruption, cusp prolapse | Urgent surgery; medical temporising: inotropes, avoid excessive afterload reduction |
| Stroke | 5-10% [30] | Carotid/vertebral dissection extension, thromboembolism | Maintain MAP 80-100 mmHg, urgent surgery (Type A) |
| Spinal cord ischaemia | 2-5% [31] | Occlusion of artery of Adamkiewicz (T8-L1) | Maintain MAP greater than 80 mmHg, urgent revascularisation |
| Mesenteric ischaemia | 3-5% [32] | SMA/coeliac dissection or compression | Laparotomy ± bowel resection, vascular surgery |
| Renal failure | 10-15% [33] | Renal artery dissection/occlusion | May require dialysis, fenestration/stenting |
| Limb ischaemia | 10-15% [34] | Iliac/femoral dissection | Vascular surgery: thrombectomy, bypass, fenestration |
| Rupture | 1-3% in hospital [35] | Adventitial breach | Massive transfusion protocol, emergency surgery; often fatal |
Malperfusion Syndromes
Definition: Inadequate end-organ perfusion due to branch vessel involvement (compression by false lumen, dissection flap extension, thrombosis)
| Organ System | Incidence | Clinical Features | Mortality Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cerebral | 5-10% | Stroke, TIA, coma, confusion | 30-40% operative mortality [36] |
| Spinal | 2-5% | Paraplegia, sensory level, bladder dysfunction | 40-50% operative mortality [36] |
| Cardiac | 10-15% | Chest pain, STEMI pattern on ECG, cardiogenic shock | 30-50% operative mortality [37] |
| Visceral (mesenteric) | 3-5% | Severe abdominal pain, peritonitis, metabolic acidosis | 50-70% operative mortality [38] |
| Renal | 10-15% | Oliguria, anuria, rapidly rising creatinine | 30-40% operative mortality [39] |
| Limb | 10-15% | Cool, pale, pulseless leg; pain, paraesthesia | 20-30% operative mortality [40] |
Key point: Any malperfusion increases operative mortality 2-4 fold. Early recognition and expedited surgery (or percutaneous intervention for Type B) is critical [36].
Special Populations
Paediatric Considerations
- Rare: below 5% of all dissections occur in patients below 40 years
- Causes: Connective tissue disorders (Marfan, Loeys-Dietz, Turner syndrome), bicuspid aortic valve, coarctation of aorta, iatrogenic (cardiac surgery, catheterisation)
- Presentation: May be atypical; high index of suspicion needed in patients with predisposing conditions
- Management: Same principles (beta-blockade, BP control), paediatric cardiothoracic surgery centre
Pregnancy
- Incidence: 40% of dissections in women below 40 occur during pregnancy (especially third trimester or peripartum) [41]
- Risk factors: Marfan syndrome (risk up to 10% per pregnancy), pre-eclampsia, bicuspid aortic valve
- Management:
- "Haemodynamics: Target SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 70 bpm"
- "Beta-blocker: Labetalol preferred (combined alpha/beta-blocker; safe in pregnancy)"
- "Type A: Urgent surgery regardless of gestational age. Caesarean section if viable fetus (≥24-28 weeks)"
- "Type B: Medical management; delivery timing depends on gestational age and maternal stability"
- Avoid: ACE inhibitors, ARBs (teratogenic); sodium nitroprusside (fetal cyanide toxicity risk)
Elderly (greater than 75 years)
- Increased incidence: Age-related aortic degeneration, atherosclerosis
- Higher operative mortality: 25-35% vs 15-20% in younger patients [42]
- Atypical presentations: May present with confusion, syncope, "collapse" rather than pain
- Comorbidities: Balance surgical risk vs certain death without surgery; shared decision-making critical
Connective Tissue Disorders
- Marfan syndrome: 40% of Type A dissections in patients below 40 years; lifetime risk 40% [43]
- Ehlers-Danlos (vascular type, type IV): Risk of rupture often exceeds dissection; extremely fragile tissues complicate surgery
- Loeys-Dietz syndrome: Similar to Marfan; aggressive aortic root dilatation and dissection at younger age
- Turner syndrome: Associated with coarctation, bicuspid valve, aortic dilatation
Screening: First-degree relatives of patients with dissection and connective tissue disorder should undergo echocardiography and genetic counselling [44]
Indigenous Health
Important Note: Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, and Māori considerations:
- Cardiovascular disease burden: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians have 2-3 times higher rates of hypertension, coronary disease, and stroke compared to non-Indigenous Australians [10]—key risk factors for aortic dissection
- Delayed presentation: Barriers to healthcare access (geographic isolation, socioeconomic factors, cultural factors) may result in delayed diagnosis with higher mortality
- Cultural safety: Involve Aboriginal Liaison Officers or Māori health workers early; family/whānau involvement in decision-making (especially around high-risk surgery, end-of-life planning)
- Communication: Use professional interpreters if language barrier (not family members for medical discussions). Explain procedures clearly; avoid medical jargon.
- Remote/rural health: Many Indigenous communities are remote; RFDS retrieval critical. Early discussion with retrieval coordination centre.
Pitfalls & Pearls
Clinical Pearls:
- "Tearing/ripping" pain is only 50% sensitive: Many patients describe "severe sharp" or "worst pain ever" rather than classic tearing. Do not rely on pain quality alone.
- Normal chest X-ray does not exclude: 12-20% of dissections have normal mediastinum on CXR. Always proceed to CT if clinical suspicion high.
- ECG changes can mimic STEMI: If coronary ostia involved (usually RCA), ECG may show inferior STEMI. Be wary of "STEMI" + back pain, pulse deficit, or widened mediastinum.
- Beta-blocker before vasodilator—always: Vasodilator alone → reflex tachycardia → increased dP/dt → propagation. Even if SBP very high, give beta-blocker (or rate-control) first.
- Malperfusion predicts outcome: Presence of any malperfusion syndrome (cerebral, visceral, renal, limb) increases operative mortality 2-4 fold. Document carefully and communicate to surgeons.
- Time to surgery matters for Type A: Each hour delay increases mortality ~1-2%. Early cardiothoracic surgery activation is critical [22].
Pitfalls to Avoid:
- Treating as ACS and giving thrombolysis: Catastrophic—causes massive haemorrhage/rupture. Always exclude dissection if any atypical features (back pain, pulse deficit, syncope).
- Using D-dimer to rule out: D-dimer sensitivity only 67-87% for IMH/PAU. Negative D-dimer does NOT exclude acute aortic syndrome.
- Giving vasodilator before beta-blocker: Causes reflex tachycardia, propagates dissection. Always rate-control first.
- Over-aggressive fluid resuscitation: Increases BP and shear stress → propagation/rupture. Permissive hypotension acceptable (SBP 90-100) if ruptured.
- Delaying surgery for "stabilisation": Type A dissection is a surgical emergency. Do not delay transfer to "optimise" in ED. Stabilise BP/HR then move.
- Missing pulse deficit: Failure to palpate all pulses (bilateral radials, femorals, carotids) and measure bilateral arm BPs. 30% of dissections have pulse deficit [14].
- Discharging with "chest pain NYD": If patient has risk factors (hypertension, Marfan) and severe chest/back pain, dissection MUST be excluded with CT before discharge.
Imaging Interpretation
CT Aorta Findings
Definitive Signs (Diagnostic)
| Finding | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Intimal flap | Linear filling defect separating true and false lumens | Pathognomonic for dissection; seen in 95-99% of cases |
| Double lumen | Two distinct lumens separated by intimal flap | Classic appearance; true lumen usually smaller and shows contrast earlier |
| Cobweb sign | Residual intimal attachments crossing false lumen | Specific for dissection (vs aneurysm) |
Secondary Signs (Supportive)
| Finding | Description | Clinical Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Aortic dilatation | Aortic diameter greater than 4 cm | Risk of rupture increases with diameter (greater than 5.5 cm high risk) |
| Periaortic haematoma | Blood outside aortic wall | Impending rupture—surgical emergency |
| Pericardial effusion | Fluid in pericardial space | Type A with rupture into pericardium → tamponade |
| Pleural effusion | Blood in pleural space (left > right) | Rupture into pleural cavity → haemothorax |
| Branch vessel involvement | Dissection extends into carotid, SMA, renal, iliac arteries | Malperfusion syndrome—worsens prognosis |
True Lumen vs False Lumen Differentiation
Why it matters: True lumen perfuses branch vessels; false lumen may thrombose or rupture
| Feature | True Lumen | False Lumen |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Usually smaller | Usually larger |
| Shape | Round or oval | Crescent-shaped, wraps around true lumen |
| Contrast enhancement | Earlier, denser | Later, less dense |
| Intimal calcification | Displaced inward ("calcium sign") | Calcification lies on outer wall |
| Branch vessels | Arise from true lumen | No branches (unless involved by dissection) |
| Cobweb sign | Absent | Present (residual attachments) |
| Beak sign | Acute angle at flap origin | Obtuse angle |
TOE (Transoesophageal Echocardiography) Findings
Indications: Haemodynamically unstable patient (cannot go to CT), intra-operative assessment (pre-cardiothoracic surgery)
Sensitivity/Specificity: 98%/97% for ascending aorta and arch [18]
Key views:
- Mid-oesophageal aortic valve long-axis: Assess aortic root, proximal ascending aorta, AR
- Mid-oesophageal aortic valve short-axis: Circumferential view of aortic valve, identify coronary ostia
- Descending aortic long-axis and short-axis: Assess descending thoracic aorta (best visualised structure on TOE)
- Upper oesophageal aortic arch: Limited by trachea interposition (blind spot)
Findings:
- Intimal flap: Mobile, thin (1-3 mm), oscillates with cardiac cycle
- True vs false lumen: Colour Doppler shows flow direction (true lumen: systolic flow towards transducer; false lumen: systolic flow away)
- Aortic regurgitation: Colour Doppler regurgitant jet, jet width/LVOT ratio greater than 65% = severe AR
- Pericardial effusion: Anechoic space around heart; RV diastolic collapse = tamponade
- LV function: Global hypokinesis (cardiogenic shock from severe AR or coronary malperfusion)
Limitations:
- Blind spot: Distal ascending aorta/proximal arch (obscured by trachea with air artifact)
- Intramural haematoma: May be missed (no flap, only wall thickening)
- Operator-dependent: Requires skilled echocardiographer
- Semi-invasive: Requires sedation, risk of oesophageal perforation (rare)
CXR Findings (Low Sensitivity—Cannot Exclude)
Widened mediastinum (greater than 8 cm at level of T4):
- Seen in 60-80% of dissections
- Measured from right paratracheal stripe to left paraspinal line
- May be normal in 12-20% of cases—cannot rely on CXR to exclude dissection
Other findings (less specific):
- Abnormal aortic contour (loss of aortic knob definition)
- Pleural effusion (left > right): haemothorax from rupture
- Apical capping (mediastinal haematoma tracking superiorly)
- Deviation of trachea to right (by enlarged aorta)
- Depression of left main bronchus
- Displacement of nasogastric tube to right (by enlarged aorta)
Key point: Normal CXR does NOT exclude aortic dissection. If clinical suspicion is moderate-high, proceed to CT aorta regardless of CXR findings.
Risk Stratification and Prognostication
IRAD (International Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection) Risk Factors
High-risk features predicting mortality [3,6]:
| Risk Factor | Operative Mortality (Type A) | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline | 15-20% | Standard operative mortality |
| + Shock/hypotension | 30-40% | SBP below 90 mmHg; likely tamponade or rupture |
| + Tamponade | 35-50% | Pericardial rupture; requires emergency surgery |
| + Any malperfusion | 30-50% | Cerebral, visceral, renal, limb—doubles mortality |
| + Stroke | 40-50% | Cerebral malperfusion; poor neuro outcome |
| + Mesenteric ischaemia | 50-70% | Worst malperfusion; bowel necrosis, multiorgan failure |
| + Age greater than 70 years | 25-35% | Comorbidities, frailty increase risk |
| + Renal failure | 30-40% | Renal malperfusion or pre-existing CKD |
Protective factors (better outcomes):
- Younger age (below 50 years): 10-15% mortality
- No complications: Uncomplicated Type A has 15-20% mortality vs 30-50% with complications
- Early surgery (below 6h from symptom onset): Each hour delay increases mortality 1-2%
Penn Classification (Malperfusion-Based)
Purpose: Guide surgical strategy based on malperfusion pattern
| Class | Definition | Management | Mortality |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penn Aa | No malperfusion | Standard ascending aorta replacement | 15-20% |
| Penn Ab | Localised branch vessel dissection (e.g., carotid) | Aortic repair first → branch flow usually restored | 20-30% |
| Penn Ac | Generalised malperfusion (multiple branches) | Aortic repair + potential fenestration/stenting | 30-50% |
| Penn Abc | Mixed (localised + generalised) | Complex; may need staged procedures | 40-60% |
Key concept: Class Ab (localised malperfusion) often resolves with aortic repair alone (restores true lumen flow). Class Ac (generalised) may require additional intervention (fenestration, stenting, bypass).
German Registry Acute Aortic Dissection Type A (GERAADA) Score
Purpose: Pre-operative risk stratification for Type A dissection
Variables (each 1 point):
- Age greater than 70 years
- Female sex
- Previous cardiac surgery
- Preoperative malperfusion
- Cardiac tamponade
- Cardiogenic shock (SBP below 90 mmHg)
- Resuscitation before surgery
Score interpretation:
- 0-1 points: Low risk (mortality 10-15%)
- 2-3 points: Moderate risk (mortality 20-30%)
- ≥4 points: High risk (mortality greater than 40%)
Use: Informs family discussions ("Your father has 4 risk factors; his chance of survival is around 50-60%")
Type B Dissection Risk Stratification
Uncomplicated Type B (good prognosis with medical management):
- No rupture, malperfusion, refractory pain, or uncontrolled hypertension
- 30-day mortality: 5-10%
- Management: Medical (beta-blocker + vasodilator), ICU 48-72h, serial imaging
Complicated Type B (requires intervention):
- Rupture, malperfusion, refractory pain/hypertension, rapid expansion
- 30-day mortality: 20-30% (with TEVAR/surgery); 50-70% (without)
- Management: TEVAR (preferred) or open surgery
Chronic Type B (greater than 14 days):
- False lumen thrombosis: Good prognosis (low risk of complications)
- False lumen patent: Higher risk of aneurysmal degeneration (30-40% over 5 years)
- Surveillance: CT at 3, 6, 12 months, then annually; TEVAR if diameter greater than 5.5 cm or growth greater than 1 cm/year
Differential Diagnosis
The "Big 5" Causes of Sudden Severe Chest Pain
| Diagnosis | Key Distinguishing Features | Critical Investigations |
|---|---|---|
| Aortic dissection | Tearing back pain, pulse deficit, BP differential, sudden maximal onset | CT aorta (gold standard) |
| Acute MI (STEMI) | Crescendo pain (not maximal at onset), exertional, radiation to jaw/arm, cardiac risk factors | ECG (ST elevation), troponin, angiography |
| Pulmonary embolism | Dyspnoea, pleuritic pain, risk factors (DVT, immobility, malignancy), haemoptysis | CTPA (pulmonary angiography), D-dimer |
| Tension pneumothorax | Decreased breath sounds, hyperresonance, tracheal deviation, hypotension, JVP↑ | Clinical diagnosis (do NOT wait for CXR); needle decompression |
| Oesophageal rupture | Post-vomiting (Boerhaave), left pleural effusion, subcutaneous emphysema, Hamman sign (mediastinal crunch) | CT chest with oral contrast (leak) |
Mimics of Aortic Dissection
| Condition | How to Differentiate |
|---|---|
| ACS with inferior STEMI | Dissection can cause STEMI if coronary ostia involved. Check for back pain, pulse deficit, BP differential. If atypical features, do CT aorta BEFORE cath lab. |
| Pericarditis | Pleuritic pain (worse with inspiration), relieved by leaning forward; ECG shows widespread ST elevation (concave upwards) + PR depression. Echo: pericardial effusion without tamponade. |
| Musculoskeletal pain | Reproducible with palpation, movement-related, NO sudden onset, NO systemic features (syncope, shock, neuro deficit). But be cautious—dissection misdiagnosed as MSK pain has medicolegal implications. |
| Acute pancreatitis | Epigastric pain radiating to back, but NO tearing quality, NO sudden onset. Elevated lipase (greater than 3x ULN). CT: pancreatic inflammation, not aortic pathology. |
| Peptic ulcer perforation | Sudden-onset epigastric pain, rigid abdomen, history of PUD/NSAID use. Upright CXR: free air under diaphragm. CT: pneumoperitoneum. |
When to Suspect Aortic Dissection (High Pretest Probability)
Use ADD-RS (Aortic Dissection Detection Risk Score) ≥1:
- Predisposing condition: Marfan, Ehlers-Danlos, Loeys-Dietz, bicuspid aortic valve, family history of aortic disease, previous aortic valve surgery, known thoracic aortic aneurysm
- High-risk pain features: Sudden onset, severe intensity (worst pain ever), tearing/ripping/sharp quality
- High-risk exam features: Pulse deficit, BP differential greater than 20 mmHg, focal neurological deficit + pain, new AR murmur, hypotension/shock
Clinical gestalt: If you are thinking "Could this be dissection?", it probably warrants CT aorta. Missed dissection has catastrophic outcomes—low threshold for imaging.
Viva Practice
Stem: "A 58-year-old man presents with sudden-onset severe anterior chest pain radiating to the back. He is diaphoretic and distressed. He has a history of hypertension. On examination: HR 110, BP 90/60 (right arm), JVP elevated, heart sounds muffled, pulsus paradoxus present. What are your immediate priorities?"
Opening Question: What is your differential diagnosis and most likely diagnosis?
Model Answer: The key features are:
- Sudden severe chest/back pain (suggests acute aortic syndrome, PE, MI)
- Hypotension + elevated JVP + muffled heart sounds = Beck's triad (cardiac tamponade)
- Pulsus paradoxus confirms tamponade physiology
Differential:
- Type A aortic dissection with pericardial rupture and tamponade (MOST LIKELY)
- Acute MI with free wall rupture and tamponade (less likely—usually days post-MI)
- Pericarditis with effusion (but wouldn't cause acute tamponade)
Most likely diagnosis: Stanford Type A aortic dissection with cardiac tamponade.
Follow-up Questions:
-
Describe your immediate management in the first 10 minutes.
- Model answer:
- Call for senior help (ED consultant, cardiothoracic surgery registrar on-call)
- A: Patent, consider intubation if GCS↓ (but avoid if possible—intubation worsens tamponade)
- B: High-flow oxygen, monitor SpO₂
- C: Two large-bore IV cannulae, fluid resuscitation cautiously (small 250 mL bolus to maintain preload for RV filling—avoid overload), urgent pericardiocentesis (echo-guided if time permits, blind if periarrest). Remove 30-50 mL to temporise.
- Activate massive transfusion protocol (dissection with tamponade implies rupture into pericardium—may exsanguinate)
- Urgent bedside echo: Confirm pericardial effusion, assess RV collapse (diastolic), guide pericardiocentesis
- Activate cardiothoracic surgery immediately (this is a surgical emergency—pericardiocentesis is temporising only)
- Analgesia: Fentanyl 50-100 mcg IV
- Beta-blocker: Cautiously—esmolol 50 mcg/kg/min infusion (avoid bolus if tamponade—may worsen hypotension); aim HR below 80 bpm
- Avoid excessive BP reduction: Maintain SBP 90-100 mmHg (permissive hypotension to reduce rupture risk but maintain coronary perfusion)
- Urgent CT aorta if stable post-pericardiocentesis (to confirm Type A and plan surgery)
- Model answer:
-
What are the risks of pericardiocentesis in this setting?
- Model answer:
- Temporary relief only: Tamponade will recur as blood continues to leak from aortic rupture. This is a bridge to surgery, NOT definitive treatment.
- Risk of worsening rupture: Relieving pericardial pressure may unmask bleeding → haemodynamic collapse. Have cardiothoracic surgery ready.
- Myocardial or coronary artery puncture: Risk with blind technique; echo guidance preferred if time allows.
- Arrhythmia: Wire or needle touching myocardium.
- Pneumothorax: Especially with subxiphoid approach.
- Model answer:
-
The patient arrests during pericardiocentesis. What is your resuscitation approach?
- Model answer:
- PEA arrest: Most likely due to exsanguination or complete rupture
- DRSABCD: Compressions may be futile in exsanguinating tamponade, but initiate CPR
- Resuscitative thoracotomy: This is an indication for emergency department thoracotomy if cardiothoracic surgery not immediately available. Open pericardium, evacuate blood, cross-clamp descending aorta (to maintain coronary/cerebral perfusion), rapid transfer to theatre.
- Activate massive transfusion protocol: 1:1:1 ratio (RBC:FFP:platelets)
- Direct transfer to operating theatre if CT surgeon available (bypass CPR, go straight to theatre)
- Realistic expectations: Mortality in this scenario greater than 90%. Discuss with family re: realistic outcomes.
- Model answer:
Discussion Points:
- Tamponade is a pre-terminal event in Type A dissection
- Pericardiocentesis buys time (minutes to hours) but is NOT curative
- Surgical mortality for Type A with tamponade: 30-50% [28]
- Early cardiothoracic surgery involvement is life-saving
Stem: "A 65-year-old woman with hypertension presents with sudden interscapular pain for 3 hours. She now complains of severe central abdominal pain. On examination: HR 105, BP 180/95, abdomen rigid with guarding and absent bowel sounds. Lactate 6.8 mmol/L. CT confirms Type B dissection extending to the abdominal aorta with poor SMA enhancement. What is your diagnosis and management?"
Opening Question: What complication has occurred and what are the management priorities?
Model Answer: Diagnosis: Stanford Type B aortic dissection complicated by mesenteric (visceral) malperfusion syndrome, likely involving the superior mesenteric artery (SMA). The dissection flap has extended to or compressed the SMA, causing acute mesenteric ischaemia.
Evidence:
- Type B dissection (descending aorta)
- Severe abdominal pain + peritonitis (rigid abdomen, guarding, absent bowel sounds)
- Lactate 6.8 mmol/L (tissue ischaemia)
- CT: poor SMA enhancement (confirms vascular compromise)
Management priorities:
- This is now a COMPLICATED Type B dissection → requires urgent intervention (TEVAR or open surgery)
- Dual pathology: Aortic dissection + bowel ischaemia (may require laparotomy)
- Activate:
- Vascular surgery / cardiothoracic surgery: For TEVAR (thoracic endovascular aortic repair) or open fenestration to restore SMA flow
- General surgery: For laparotomy ± bowel resection (if necrosis present)
- ICU: For post-operative care
Follow-up Questions:
-
What are the options for restoring mesenteric perfusion?
- Model answer:
- Percutaneous fenestration: Interventional radiology creates a hole in the dissection flap (between true and false lumen) to restore flow to SMA. Less invasive, but may not be sufficient if bowel already necrotic.
- TEVAR (Thoracic Endovascular Aortic Repair): Stent-graft covers primary entry tear in descending aorta → false lumen thromboses → true lumen expands → restores branch vessel flow. Preferred if anatomy suitable.
- Open surgical fenestration: Surgical creation of fenestration in dissection flap. More invasive; used if percutaneous not possible.
- SMA stenting: Direct stenting of SMA ostium if stenosed/occluded by dissection.
- Open aortic repair + SMA bypass: If above fail or not possible; high mortality.
- Model answer:
-
The general surgeon asks if they should proceed to laparotomy. What is your advice?
- Model answer:
- Depends on timing and bowel viability:
- If early ischaemia (below 6 hours) and vascular intervention planned: Consider TEVAR/fenestration FIRST to restore flow → reassess. Laparotomy may be avoided if bowel reperfuses.
- If late presentation (greater than 6-12 hours), peritonitis, or CT evidence of bowel necrosis (pneumatosis, portal venous gas): Laparotomy likely needed for bowel resection ± Hartmann's procedure. Coordinate with vascular team for concomitant or staged vascular repair.
- Optimal strategy (if time allows): TEVAR first (restore flow), then second-look laparotomy at 24-48h to assess bowel viability. Avoids resecting potentially viable bowel.
- Realistic expectations: Mesenteric malperfusion + Type B dissection has 50-70% mortality [38]. High risk of short bowel syndrome, multiorgan failure.
- Depends on timing and bowel viability:
- Model answer:
-
The vascular surgeon asks about BP targets while arranging TEVAR. What do you recommend?
- Model answer:
- Target SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm (standard dissection targets)
- Balance: Too low BP → worsens mesenteric perfusion (MAP below 65 may worsen ischaemia); too high BP → propagates dissection/rupture risk
- Practical approach: Maintain MAP 65-75 mmHg to ensure end-organ perfusion while controlling dissection. Use esmolol infusion (HR below 60) + GTN (if SBP greater than 120).
- Avoid excessive vasopressor use: If hypotensive, small fluid boluses (250 mL) + low-dose noradrenaline (0.05-0.1 mcg/kg/min) to maintain MAP ~70 mmHg. Definitive treatment is revascularisation, not BP manipulation.
- Model answer:
-
What is the prognosis and what do you tell the family?
- Model answer:
- Guarded prognosis: Visceral malperfusion has 50-70% mortality even with intervention [38]. Complications include bowel necrosis (requiring resection ± stoma), short bowel syndrome, renal failure, multiorgan failure, death.
- Discussion points with family:
- "Your mother has a tear in her main artery (aorta) that has blocked blood flow to her bowel. This is a life-threatening emergency."
- "We need urgent surgery to restore blood flow. Even with surgery, there is a significant risk she may not survive (50-70% mortality). If she survives, she may need part of her bowel removed and may have a long recovery in ICU."
- "Without surgery, she will not survive. We recommend proceeding, but want you to understand the serious risks."
- Involve: Social work, chaplaincy (if family wishes), document discussion in notes
- Model answer:
Discussion Points:
- Complicated Type B dissection requires intervention (TEVAR, fenestration, or surgery)—medical management alone is insufficient
- Mesenteric malperfusion is the deadliest malperfusion syndrome (mortality 50-70%)
- Multidisciplinary approach (ED, vascular, general surgery, ICU, IR) is essential
Stem: "A 52-year-old man with hypertension and smoking history presents with sudden-onset severe central chest pain radiating to the jaw. ECG shows 3 mm ST elevation in leads II, III, aVF. Troponin pending. As you prepare to activate the cath lab, the nurse mentions he also has back pain. What do you do?"
Opening Question: What additional features would make you reconsider the diagnosis of isolated STEMI?
Model Answer: Red flags for aortic dissection (not isolated STEMI):
- Back pain: Interscapular pain suggests descending aorta involvement; not typical of isolated MI
- Maximal pain at onset: Dissection pain is worst at onset; ACS pain is usually crescendo
- Pulse deficit: Compare radial-radial, radial-femoral pulses; BP differential greater than 20 mmHg between arms
- New diastolic murmur: Aortic regurgitation (Type A dissection involving aortic root)
- Widened mediastinum on CXR: If portable CXR obtained
Key point: Aortic dissection can cause STEMI if dissection propagates into coronary ostia (usually RCA → inferior STEMI). This is a Type A dissection with coronary malperfusion and requires urgent surgery, NOT thrombolysis or PCI (would be catastrophic).
Follow-up Questions:
-
How do you differentiate aortic dissection with coronary involvement from primary ACS?
- Model answer:
- History: Dissection pain is sudden, maximal at onset, tearing/sharp; ACS is crescendo, pressure/squeezing
- Associated features: Back pain, syncope, pulse deficit, neuro deficits → dissection
- ECG: Dissection with RCA involvement typically shows inferior STEMI (II, III, aVF); isolated ACS has consistent ST changes across leads. Dissection may have "stuttering" ECG changes as flow to coronary intermittently compromised.
- Bedside echo: Dissection may show dilated aortic root, AR, pericardial effusion (Type A rupture); ACS shows regional wall motion abnormality
- Clinical gestalt: Any atypical feature in "STEMI" → pause and consider dissection
- Model answer:
-
You are concerned about dissection. What is your immediate management?
- Model answer:
- DO NOT activate cath lab yet. Pause and investigate further.
- Examine: Check all pulses (radials, femorals), BP in both arms, auscultate for AR murmur, assess for neuro deficits
- Portable CXR: Look for widened mediastinum (greater than 8 cm at T4 level)
- Bedside TTE: Assess aortic root, pericardial effusion, AR, regional wall motion
- If dissection suspected: Urgent CT aorta (NOT cath lab). CT will definitively diagnose or exclude dissection.
- Medical management: Analgesia (fentanyl), beta-blocker (esmolol), BP control (SBP 100-120)
- Activate cardiothoracic surgery if dissection suspected
- Model answer:
-
CT confirms Type A dissection with RCA ostial involvement. The cath lab team asks if PCI would help. What is your response?
- Model answer:
- NO. This patient requires urgent cardiothoracic surgery for Type A dissection. The STEMI is caused by the dissection flap obstructing the RCA ostium.
- Rationale:
- PCI is contraindicated: Antiplatelet agents (aspirin, ticagrelor) and anticoagulation (heparin) used in PCI would increase bleeding risk from dissection → rupture/tamponade → death
- Surgery will address both problems: Ascending aorta replacement + coronary artery reimplantation (or bypass if needed) will restore RCA flow AND repair the dissection
- Medical temporising: Continue beta-blocker, BP control, analgesia while awaiting surgery. Avoid antiplatelet/anticoagulant.
- Prognosis: Type A with coronary involvement has 30-50% operative mortality [37], but without surgery mortality is 100%.
- Model answer:
-
The patient asks, "Do I need open-heart surgery or can you put a stent in?" How do you explain?
- Model answer (plain language for patient):
- "The problem isn't just your heart artery—it's the main blood vessel (aorta) that has torn. That tear is blocking the artery to your heart, which is causing the heart attack."
- "A stent won't fix the torn aorta. We need open surgery to repair the tear and restore blood flow to your heart."
- "This is major surgery with serious risks (1 in 3 chance of not surviving), but without surgery, the tear will get worse and you won't survive."
- "We have an excellent cardiothoracic surgery team here who will do everything they can. Do you have any questions?"
- Model answer (plain language for patient):
Discussion Points:
- Aortic dissection is a "great imitator": Can mimic STEMI, PE, stroke, acute abdomen
- Any atypical "STEMI" features → pause and reconsider: Back pain, syncope, pulse deficit, neuro deficit
- Thrombolysis or PCI in aortic dissection is catastrophic: Always exclude dissection before activating reperfusion strategy if atypical features present
- CT aorta before cath lab if dissection suspected (even if delays reperfusion—thrombolysing a dissection is worse)
Stem: "You are the ED consultant in a rural hospital 450 km from the nearest cardiothoracic centre. A 60-year-old man presents with sudden severe chest pain radiating to the back. BP 170/95, HR 98. CT confirms Type A dissection. The cardiothoracic surgeon advises urgent transfer. RFDS can arrive in 90 minutes. What is your management while awaiting retrieval?"
Opening Question: What are your priorities in stabilising this patient for transfer?
Model Answer: Priorities:
- Haemodynamic optimisation: Target SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm (reduces shear stress, prevents propagation)
- Analgesia: Adequate pain control (fentanyl) reduces sympathetic surge
- Communication: Detailed handover to RFDS retrieval team, cardiothoracic surgeon
- Anticipate complications: Tamponade, rupture, stroke—have resus plan ready
- Family support: Explain diagnosis, prognosis, need for urgent surgery
Follow-up Questions:
-
Describe your step-by-step medical management while waiting for RFDS.
- Model answer:
- Analgesia: Fentanyl 50-100 mcg IV, repeat q10-15min until pain controlled (pain → sympathetic activation → BP/HR rise → propagation)
- Beta-blockade:
- If esmolol available: Loading dose 500 mcg/kg IV over 1 min, then infusion 50-200 mcg/kg/min. Titrate to HR below 60 bpm.
- If no esmolol: Metoprolol 5 mg IV q5min (max 15 mg), then consider oral metoprolol 25-50 mg q6h
- Alternative (if beta-blocker contraindicated): Diltiazem 0.25 mg/kg IV (15-25 mg) over 2 min
- Vasodilator (only AFTER HR below 60 bpm):
- GTN infusion: Start 10 mcg/min, titrate by 10-20 mcg/min q5min until SBP 100-120 mmHg (max 200 mcg/min)
- Alternative: Sodium nitroprusside 0.3-10 mcg/kg/min (if GTN insufficient)
- Monitoring: Continuous ECG, SpO₂, NIBP q5min (right arm), hourly urine output (IDC if transfer greater than 2h), GCS q15min
- IV access: Two large-bore cannulae (14-16G)
- Bloods: G&H or crossmatch 6 units (in case of rupture), notify blood bank
- NBM: In case of emergency surgery on arrival
- Avoid: Antiplatelet agents (aspirin, clopidogrel), anticoagulation (heparin)
- Model answer:
-
What information do you need to communicate to the RFDS retrieval team?
- Model answer:
- Patient details: Name, age, sex, weight (for drug dosing)
- Diagnosis: Type A aortic dissection (CT confirmed), extent (ascending ± arch ± descending)
- Complications: None vs tamponade, AR, malperfusion, stroke
- Current status: HR, BP, GCS, urine output, oxygen requirement
- Treatment given: Analgesia doses, beta-blocker (which drug, dose, route), vasodilator (infusion rate), IV access
- Infusions running: Esmolol __ mcg/kg/min, GTN __ mcg/min (ensure continuation during flight)
- Blood products: G&H done, blood available if needed
- Anticipated time to surgery: Cardiothoracic surgeon expecting patient, theatre availability
- Special considerations: Marfan syndrome, pregnancy, Jehovah's Witness (refusing blood), family present
- Model answer:
-
The patient becomes hypotensive (BP 75/50) 30 minutes before RFDS arrival. What are your priorities?
- Model answer:
- Immediate assessment: Cause of hypotension in Type A dissection:
- Cardiac tamponade (rupture into pericardium): JVP↑, muffled heart sounds, pulsus paradoxus
- Acute severe AR: New diastolic murmur, pulmonary oedema
- Rupture/exsanguination: Sudden deterioration, distended abdomen (haemoperitoneum), haemothorax
- Excessive beta-blockade/vasodilator: Iatrogenic hypotension
- Management:
- Stop/reduce beta-blocker and vasodilator infusions temporarily
- Bedside TTE: Assess for pericardial effusion (tamponade), LV function, AR severity
- If tamponade: Urgent pericardiocentesis (echo-guided if possible). Aspirate 30-50 mL to temporise. Explain to RFDS this is life-threatening—may need to cancel fixed-wing and use helicopter if available (faster).
- If severe AR: Small fluid bolus (250 mL), inotrope (dobutamine 5-10 mcg/kg/min), avoid excessive afterload reduction. Explain to RFDS patient needs urgent surgery.
- If rupture suspected: Activate massive transfusion protocol (if available in rural hospital; if not, transfuse O-negative or type-specific blood rapidly), permissive hypotension (SBP 80-90 mmHg to reduce bleeding), emergency transfer (may need helicopter evacuation if ground transport too slow)
- Communication: Update RFDS retrieval team immediately, cardiothoracic surgeon. May need to divert to closer hospital with CT surgery capability if available.
- Immediate assessment: Cause of hypotension in Type A dissection:
- Model answer:
-
What challenges are specific to rural/remote retrieval for aortic dissection?
- Model answer:
- Distance/time: 450 km = 90 min flight + 30 min loading/unloading = 2 hours to arrival at cardiothoracic centre. Mortality increases ~1-2% per hour delay [22]. Patient may deteriorate in transit.
- Limited resources: Rural hospital may lack esmolol, sodium nitroprusside, invasive BP monitoring, blood products. Use alternatives (metoprolol, GTN, non-invasive BP).
- Skill mix: Rural ED may lack experience with dissection management. Phone advice from cardiothoracic surgeon or retrieval consultant helpful.
- Weather: RFDS flight may be delayed or cancelled due to weather (esp. at night, in remote areas). Have backup plan (road ambulance, though longer transit time).
- Family: Family may not be able to accompany patient on RFDS flight (space/weight restrictions). Arrange family travel separately; involve social work.
- Communication: Ensure clear handover to RFDS team (infusions, doses, clinical progress). Ensure RFDS has CT images (send via secure email or PACS if available).
- Model answer:
Discussion Points:
- Rural/remote retrieval requires proactive communication and clinical stabilisation
- Distance and time delays increase mortality—optimise haemodynamics BEFORE transfer
- Be prepared to manage complications (tamponade, rupture) with limited resources
- RFDS provides highly skilled retrieval teams but cannot replace immediate CT surgery—early recognition and transfer initiation is key
OSCE Scenarios
Station 1: Acute Aortic Dissection Resuscitation
Format: Resuscitation Time: 11 minutes Setting: Emergency Department resuscitation bay
Candidate Instructions:
You are the emergency registrar. A 62-year-old man has presented with sudden-onset severe chest and back pain. He is in extremis. You have 11 minutes to assess and manage this patient. A nurse and senior registrar are available to assist. The examiner will provide clinical information as you request it.
Examiner Instructions: Scenario: The patient has a Stanford Type A aortic dissection. Initial vital signs: HR 115, BP 185/100 (right arm), RR 24, SpO₂ 96% on air, GCS 15. The patient is in severe distress. As the candidate progresses, provide information based on their actions:
- If they examine pulses: "Right radial pulse present, left radial pulse weak. Both femoral pulses present."
- If they auscultate: "You hear a soft early diastolic murmur at the left sternal edge."
- If they request bedside echo: "There is a dilated aortic root, a small pericardial effusion, and trace aortic regurgitation."
- If they order CT: "CT confirms Type A aortic dissection from aortic root to descending aorta, with a small pericardial effusion."
- If they give beta-blocker: HR decreases to 85, BP 160/90.
- If they give vasodilator WITHOUT beta-blocker first: HR increases to 130, BP 170/95 (worse).
- If they activate cardiothoracic surgery: "The CT surgeon will accept the patient for urgent transfer to theatre."
Actor/Patient Brief: You are a 62-year-old man with sudden severe chest pain that started while lifting a heavy box 2 hours ago. The pain is in the front of your chest and between your shoulder blades. It was worst at the very beginning (10/10), now 8/10 despite paracetamol. You describe it as "sharp, tearing". You have a history of high blood pressure (on amlodipine). You are very distressed and frightened. You can answer questions but are in obvious pain.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Systematic ABCDE approach, appropriate urgency | /2 |
| Assessment | Pulse check (radials, femorals), BP both arms, cardiovascular exam (AR murmur), neuro exam | /2 |
| Investigations | ECG, bedside echo, urgent CT aorta, bloods (G&H, UEC, lactate) | /2 |
| Management | Analgesia, beta-blocker FIRST (esmolol/metoprolol/labetalol), then vasodilator (GTN/SNP), target SBP 100-120 and HR below 60 | /3 |
| Team Leadership | Clear instructions to nurse, activates senior help early, calls cardiothoracic surgery | /1 |
| Judgement | Recognises Type A dissection, understands need for urgent surgery, appropriate urgency | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass (≥6/11): Systematic approach, recognises dissection, beta-blocks before vasodilator, activates cardiothoracic surgery
- Key discriminators:
- Giving vasodilator BEFORE beta-blocker (major error—fail station)
- Failing to activate cardiothoracic surgery (fail station)
- Missing pulse examination or AR murmur (loses marks but may still pass)
Station 2: Breaking Bad News—Type A Dissection Poor Prognosis
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: Relatives' room
Candidate Instructions:
You are the emergency consultant. You have diagnosed a 68-year-old man with Type A aortic dissection. He has been transferred to theatre for emergency surgery, but the cardiothoracic surgeon has advised that his chance of survival is only 30-40% due to extensive dissection and cardiac tamponade. The patient's wife and daughter are waiting in the relatives' room. Please explain the diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis.
Examiner Instructions: Observe the candidate's communication skills. The wife and daughter are distressed but want to understand what is happening. They ask:
- "What is an aortic dissection?"
- "Will he survive the surgery?"
- "What happens if he doesn't survive?"
- "Should we call other family members?"
Assess: introduction, explanation in plain language, empathy, responding to questions, realistic expectations, offering support.
Actor/Patient Brief: You are the patient's wife (or daughter). You are very worried. The patient is your husband of 40 years (or your father). He has always been healthy apart from high blood pressure. This is a huge shock. You are tearful but composed. You want honest information. You ask: "Is he going to die?" and "What are his chances?"
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Introduces self, confirms relationship, appropriate setting (private room, seated) | /1 |
| Explanation | Explains aortic dissection in plain language (tear in blood vessel), severity, need for emergency surgery | /2 |
| Prognostication | Gives realistic prognosis (30-40% survival with surgery, 0% without), explains risks (stroke, kidney failure, bleeding, death) | /2 |
| Empathy | Acknowledges distress, uses empathic statements ("I can see this is very difficult"), allows time for questions | /2 |
| Support | Offers to stay, involves social work/chaplaincy if wanted, suggests calling family, updates planned | /2 |
| Answering questions | Responds to questions honestly, avoids jargon, checks understanding | /2 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass (≥6/11): Clear explanation, realistic prognosis, empathic approach, offers support
- Key discriminators:
- Giving false hope ("He'll be fine") or excessive pessimism ("There's no hope") → fail
- Explaining in medical jargon without checking understanding → loses marks
- Showing empathy and offering ongoing support → key to passing
Station 3: Transfer Coordination for Type A Dissection
Format: Communication / Clinical Judgement Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED resus bay (simulated phone call)
Candidate Instructions:
You are the emergency registrar at a metropolitan hospital WITHOUT cardiothoracic surgery. You have diagnosed a 55-year-old woman with Type A aortic dissection on CT. She is currently stable (BP 115/70, HR 68 on esmolol and GTN infusions). You need to call the on-call cardiothoracic surgeon at the tertiary centre (10 km away) to arrange urgent transfer. The examiner will play the role of the CT surgeon. You have 11 minutes to make the call and arrange transfer.
Examiner Instructions: You are the on-call cardiothoracic surgery registrar. You will accept the patient but need appropriate information to prepare. Ask:
- "What type of dissection? What's the extent?"
- "Any complications—tamponade, AR, malperfusion?"
- "What are the current vital signs and what infusions are running?"
- "When can you send the patient? Do you need retrieval or can you send via ambulance?" If the candidate provides clear, structured information, you say: "That's great, I'll accept the patient for urgent surgery. Theatre 5 will be ready in 30 minutes. Send her via ambulance with the infusions running and a medical escort. I'll see her in theatre."
If the candidate is disorganised or missing key info, prompt: "I need to know [missing information] before I can accept."
Actor/Patient Brief: N/A (phone call scenario)
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | ISBAR structure: Identifies self, hospital, patient name/age/sex | /1 |
| Situation | "55F with Type A aortic dissection confirmed on CT" | /1 |
| Background | Risk factors (hypertension), presentation (sudden chest/back pain), CT findings (ascending aorta to descending, no complications) | /2 |
| Recommendation | Requests urgent transfer, offers ambulance with medical escort, infusions to continue, NBM, bloods sent | /2 |
| Logistics | Confirms transfer time, asks if any special requirements, ensures CT images sent (PACS or CD) | /2 |
| Professionalism | Polite, structured, listens to surgeon's questions, confirms plan | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass (≥6/11): ISBAR structure, key clinical info (type, extent, complications, vital signs, infusions), clear transfer plan
- Key discriminators:
- Using ISBAR structure → passes; disorganised rambling → fails
- Mentioning all infusions and doses → key to safe transfer
- Confirming plan at the end → professionalism mark
SAQ Practice
Question 1: Classification and Immediate Management (8 marks)
Stem: A 60-year-old man presents with sudden-onset severe interscapular pain. CT aorta shows a dissection originating in the descending thoracic aorta distal to the left subclavian artery and extending to the abdominal aorta. There is no pericardial effusion. BP 170/95, HR 102.
Question: a) What is the Stanford classification of this dissection? (1 mark) b) List FOUR immediate management priorities. (4 marks) c) What are the blood pressure and heart rate targets? (2 marks) d) When would this patient require surgical or endovascular intervention? Give THREE indications. (3 marks, maximum 3)
Model Answer: a) Stanford Type B (1 mark)
- (Dissection originates distal to left subclavian artery, does not involve ascending aorta)
b) Immediate management priorities (4 marks, 1 mark each, maximum 4):
- Analgesia: Fentanyl 50-100 mcg IV or morphine 5-10 mg IV (reduces sympathetic response)
- Beta-blockade: Esmolol 500 mcg/kg loading + 50-200 mcg/kg/min infusion OR metoprolol 5 mg IV q5min (reduce heart rate and dP/dt)
- Blood pressure control: GTN 10-200 mcg/min IV infusion (AFTER beta-blocker) to reduce shear stress
- Monitoring: Continuous ECG, NIBP q5min, SpO₂, urine output (IDC), serial neuro observations (for malperfusion)
- (Accept: IV access, bloods (UEC, lactate, FBC, coag, G&H), ICU/HDU admission, nil by mouth)
c) Targets (2 marks):
- SBP 100-120 mmHg (1 mark)
- HR below 60 bpm (1 mark)
d) Indications for intervention (complicated Type B dissection) (3 marks, 1 mark each, maximum 3):
- Rupture or impending rupture (periaortic haematoma, expanding aneurysm)
- Malperfusion syndrome (visceral, renal, limb ischaemia)
- Refractory hypertension despite maximal medical therapy
- Refractory pain despite adequate analgesia
- Rapid aneurysmal expansion (greater than 1 cm in 6 months)
- (Accept any 3 of the above)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: "Type B" or "DeBakey III" for (a)
- For (b), must include both beta-blocker AND vasodilator; analgesia alone insufficient (must have 2/3 of these for full marks)
- For (c), accept SBP 100-120 or "SBP below 120"; accept HR below 60 or "HR 50-60"
- Do not accept: "Type A" (incorrect classification—fail entire question if this is the answer), "immediate surgery" for Type B (incorrect unless complications present)
Question 2: D-Dimer and ADD-RS Score (6 marks)
Stem: A 45-year-old woman presents with sudden-onset central chest pain radiating to the back. She has no past medical history. On examination: HR 88, BP 135/80 (equal in both arms), all pulses present and equal, no murmurs. ECG shows non-specific T-wave changes. You are considering aortic dissection.
Question: a) Calculate her ADD-RS (Aortic Dissection Detection Risk Score). Show your working. (3 marks) b) Her D-dimer is 320 ng/mL. Can you rule out aortic dissection based on ADD-RS and D-dimer? Explain. (2 marks) c) What is the sensitivity of D-dimer for intramural haematoma compared to classic dissection? (1 mark)
Model Answer: a) ADD-RS = 1 (3 marks: 1 mark for correct total, 1 mark for correctly identifying high-risk pain, 1 mark for correctly identifying no other features)
- Predisposing condition: 0 (no Marfan, family history, bicuspid valve, prior aortic disease mentioned)
- High-risk pain features: 1 (sudden-onset, severe, radiating to back—tearing quality not specified but sudden + severe + back pain = 1 point)
- High-risk exam features: 0 (BP equal both arms, all pulses equal, no focal neuro deficit, no AR murmur, no hypotension)
- Total: 1
b) No, cannot rule out (2 marks: 1 mark for "no", 1 mark for explanation)
- To rule out aortic dissection, need ADD-RS = 0 AND D-dimer below 500 ng/mL
- This patient has ADD-RS = 1 (high-risk pain), so cannot rule out even though D-dimer is below 500
- Must proceed to CT aorta
c) Sensitivity for IMH: 67-87% (1 mark)
- (Compared to 97% sensitivity for classic dissection)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept ADD-RS 0-1 depending on interpretation of "high-risk pain" (if candidate argues pain is not "ripping/tearing" and therefore scores 0, accept this if they justify it—but then answer to (b) changes to "yes, can rule out" if ADD-RS=0 and D-dimer below 500)
- Most likely intended answer: ADD-RS = 1 (pain is sudden + severe + back = high-risk), so cannot rule out
- For (c), accept range "67-87%" or "approximately 70-80%" or "lower than 97%"
- Do not accept: "D-dimer negative rules out dissection" (WRONG—this is a key misconception)
Question 3: Malperfusion Syndromes (8 marks)
Stem: A 58-year-old man with Type A aortic dissection is awaiting urgent surgery. He suddenly develops right arm weakness and dysphasia.
Question: a) What complication has occurred? (1 mark) b) What is the pathophysiological mechanism? (2 marks) c) List FOUR other types of malperfusion syndrome that can occur in aortic dissection. (4 marks) d) How does the presence of malperfusion affect operative mortality? (1 mark)
Model Answer: a) Cerebral malperfusion / Stroke (1 mark)
- (Right arm weakness + dysphasia suggests left hemisphere stroke—carotid involvement)
b) Mechanism (2 marks):
- Dissection flap extension into the carotid artery OR compression of carotid artery by false lumen (1 mark)
- Causes reduced blood flow to the brain → ischaemic stroke (1 mark)
- (Accept: Thromboembolism from false lumen)
c) Other malperfusion syndromes (4 marks, 1 mark each, maximum 4):
- Cardiac (coronary ostia involvement → myocardial infarction)
- Spinal cord (artery of Adamkiewicz occlusion → paraplegia)
- Visceral (SMA/coeliac involvement → mesenteric ischaemia, bowel necrosis)
- Renal (renal artery involvement → acute kidney injury, oliguria/anuria)
- Limb (iliac/femoral involvement → acute limb ischaemia, cool pulseless leg)
d) Impact on mortality (1 mark):
- Increases operative mortality 2-4 fold (from ~15% to 30-50%)
- (Accept: "significantly increases mortality" or "doubles/triples mortality")
Examiner Notes:
- For (b), must mention BOTH the mechanism (dissection into vessel or compression) AND the outcome (reduced flow → ischaemia) for full 2 marks
- For (c), need 4 distinct organ systems; do not accept "cardiac malperfusion" and "myocardial infarction" as separate (same thing)
- For (d), accept any phrasing indicating malperfusion worsens outcomes (exact numbers not required but help)
Question 4: Pharmacological Management (8 marks)
Stem: You are managing a patient with confirmed Type A aortic dissection. Current BP 180/100, HR 110.
Question: a) Why must beta-blocker be given BEFORE vasodilator? (2 marks) b) Name TWO intravenous beta-blockers suitable for this scenario and give their doses. (4 marks) c) If beta-blockers are contraindicated (severe asthma), what alternative can be used for heart rate control? Give the drug and dose. (2 marks)
Model Answer: a) Rationale for beta-blocker first (2 marks):
- Vasodilator alone causes reflex tachycardia (baroreceptor response to BP drop) (1 mark)
- Increased heart rate increases dP/dt (shear stress) → propagates dissection → worsens outcome (1 mark)
- Beta-blocker given first prevents this reflex tachycardia and also reduces dP/dt (rate of pressure change during systole), which is the primary driver of dissection propagation
b) Beta-blockers (4 marks: 2 marks per drug = 1 for name, 1 for dose):
- Esmolol: Loading 500 mcg/kg IV over 1 min, then infusion 50-200 mcg/kg/min (2 marks)
- Metoprolol: 5 mg IV q5min, maximum 15 mg total (2 marks)
- (Also accept: Labetalol 10-20 mg IV bolus, then 0.5-2 mg/min infusion; Propranolol 0.5-1 mg IV q5min, max 0.15 mg/kg)
c) Alternative if beta-blocker contraindicated (2 marks):
- Diltiazem (calcium channel blocker) (1 mark)
- Dose: 0.25 mg/kg IV over 2 min (usually 15-25 mg), then 5-15 mg/h infusion (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- For (a), must explain reflex tachycardia AND propagation risk for full 2 marks; just saying "reflex tachycardia" without explaining consequence is 1 mark
- For (b), accept any TWO of the beta-blockers listed; must give BOTH drug name AND dose for each (1+1=2 marks per drug)
- For (c), accept diltiazem (most common alternative); also accept verapamil (but less commonly used in ED)
- Do not accept: "give vasodilator alone" (WRONG), "labetalol is not a beta-blocker" (WRONG—it is a combined alpha/beta-blocker)
Australian Guidelines
ARC/ANZCOR
- Not directly applicable: Aortic dissection is not a primary focus of ARC/ANZCOR resuscitation guidelines
- Cardiac arrest: If patient with aortic dissection arrests, follow standard ALS algorithms, but prognosis is extremely poor (survival below 5%) [45]
Therapeutic Guidelines
- Cardiovascular Guidelines: Recommend beta-blockers (esmolol, labetalol, metoprolol) as first-line for BP/HR control in acute aortic syndromes
- Blood pressure targets: SBP 100-120 mmHg, HR below 60 bpm
- Type A dissection: Urgent cardiothoracic surgery referral
- Type B dissection: Initial medical management; TEVAR for complicated cases
Australian and New Zealand Society of Cardiac and Thoracic Surgeons (ANZSCTS)
- National audit data: 30-day mortality for Type A dissection 11.2% (2001-2021) [9]
- Volume-outcome relationship: Higher-volume centres (greater than 10 cases/year) have lower mortality (9.8% vs 13.5% at low-volume centres) [9]
- Recommendation: Type A dissection patients should be transferred to high-volume cardiothoracic surgery centres when possible
State-Specific
- NSW: Cardiothoracic surgery available at Royal Prince Alfred, St Vincent's, Westmead, John Hunter (Newcastle), Liverpool
- VIC: Alfred, Austin, Monash, St Vincent's, Royal Melbourne
- QLD: Prince Charles, Royal Brisbane, Townsville
- SA: Flinders, Royal Adelaide
- WA: Fiona Stanley, Royal Perth
- TAS: Royal Hobart (limited; complex cases may transfer to mainland)
Remote/Rural Considerations
Pre-Hospital
- High index of suspicion: "Sudden severe chest/back pain" in older patient with hypertension → consider dissection, not just ACS
- Avoid thrombolysis: Paramedics should NOT administer pre-hospital thrombolysis if dissection possible (check for back pain, pulse deficit, syncope)
- Analgesia: Fentanyl or methoxyflurane for pain control (reduces sympathetic surge)
- Avoid excessive IV fluids: Risk of increasing BP → propagation
- Notify receiving hospital: "Possible aortic dissection" so ED can prepare (CT aorta, cardiothoracic consult)
Resource-Limited Setting
Rural hospital without CT:
- Clinical diagnosis: High suspicion based on history (sudden tearing chest/back pain, risk factors) + exam (pulse deficit, BP differential, AR murmur)
- Bedside echo: May show dilated aortic root, pericardial effusion, AR (but sensitivity only 60-80% [13])
- Stabilise and transfer: Do NOT wait for CT if high suspicion—start beta-blocker + vasodilator, arrange urgent transfer to centre with CT and cardiothoracic surgery
- Use available agents: If esmolol unavailable, use metoprolol IV or oral; if GTN unavailable, use oral nifedipine (10 mg sublingually—though less ideal due to unpredictable absorption)
Rural hospital with CT but no cardiothoracic surgery:
- Confirm diagnosis: Urgent CT aorta (non-contrast + arterial phase)
- Medical stabilisation: Beta-blocker + vasodilator to target SBP 100-120, HR below 60
- Arrange transfer:
- "Type A: Urgent retrieval via RFDS (if available) or road ambulance with medical escort (doctor or advanced care paramedic). Continue infusions during transfer."
- "Type B: Discuss with tertiary centre; may be managed locally in ICU if uncomplicated (with remote support from vascular surgeon or intensivist via telemedicine), or transfer if complicated"
Retrieval
RFDS (Royal Flying Doctor Service):
- Indications: Type A dissection requiring transfer greater than 200 km, or Type B with complications
- Preparation:
- Medical escort (retrieval doctor/nurse) with experience in critical care
- Portable infusion pumps (esmolol, GTN, fentanyl)
- Blood products if available (risk of rupture in transit)
- Intubation kit (if patient deteriorates)
- Communication: Detailed handover to RFDS team (diagnosis, extent, complications, vital signs, infusions, anticipated complications)
- Flight time: Factor in weather, distance, landing site availability. Typical 400-500 km retrieval = 90-120 min flight time + 30 min loading/unloading.
- Destination: Nearest cardiothoracic surgery centre (may not be nearest hospital—bypass smaller centres without CT surgery)
Ground ambulance transfer:
- Use if: Distance below 100-200 km, RFDS unavailable, weather precludes flight
- Risks: Longer transit time (3-4 hours for 200 km by road vs 60 min by air), limited space for equipment, road vibrations (may worsen haemodynamics)
- Advantages: May be faster for short distances, weather-independent
Telemedicine
- Use case: Rural ED consultant discusses management with cardiothoracic surgeon or intensivist at tertiary centre
- Platforms: HealthDirect Video Call, Emergency Telehealth, state-based systems (NSW Virtual Rural Generalist Service, VIC NURSE-ON-CALL)
- Benefits: Real-time advice on BP/HR targets, medication doses, transfer timing
- Limitations: Cannot replace definitive CT or surgery; temporary support only
References
Guidelines
- Erbel R, Aboyans V, Boileau C, et al. 2014 ESC Guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of aortic diseases. Eur Heart J. 2014;35(41):2873-2926. PMID: 25173340
- Hiratzka LF, Bakris GL, Beckman JA, et al. 2010 ACCF/AHA/AATS/ACR/ASA/SCA/SCAI/SIR/STS/SVM guidelines for the diagnosis and management of patients with thoracic aortic disease. Circulation. 2010;121(13):e266-369. PMID: 20233780
Key Epidemiology
- Hagan PG, Nienaber CA, Isselbacher EM, et al. The International Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection (IRAD): new insights into an old disease. JAMA. 2000;283(7):897-903. PMID: 10685714
- Howard DP, Banerjee A, Fairhead JF, et al. Population-based study of incidence and outcome of acute aortic dissection and premorbid risk factor control: 10-year results from the Oxford Vascular Study. Circulation. 2013;127(20):2031-2037. PMID: 23599348
- Olsson C, Thelin S, Ståhle E, et al. Thoracic aortic aneurysm and dissection: increasing prevalence and improved outcomes reported in a nationwide population-based study of more than 14,000 cases from 1987 to 2002. Circulation. 2006;114(24):2611-2618. PMID: 17145990
Mortality and Outcomes
- Pape LA, Awais M, Woznicka EM, et al. Presentation, diagnosis, and outcomes of acute aortic dissection: 17-year trends from the International Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2015;66(4):350-358. PMID: 26205591
- Nienaber CA, Clough RE, Sakalihasan N, et al. Aortic dissection. Nat Rev Dis Primers. 2016;2:16071. PMID: 27711124
Australian/NZ Data
- Lim ETA, Khanafer A, Baskaran D, et al. Acute aortic syndrome: nationwide study of epidemiology, management, and outcomes in Aotearoa New Zealand. BJS Open. 2023;7(4):zrad078. PMID: 37494189
- Knox A, Yii M, Beltrame J, et al. Outcomes of type A aortic dissection in Australia. ANZ J Surg. 2025;95(6):1122-1128. PMID: 39907174
- Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Cardiovascular disease in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Canberra: AIHW; 2023.
- Royal Flying Doctor Service. Annual Report 2022-23. Sydney: RFDS; 2023.
Pathophysiology
- Nienaber CA, von Kodolitsch Y, Petersen B, et al. Intramural hemorrhage of the thoracic aorta. Diagnostic and therapeutic implications. Circulation. 1995;92(6):1465-1472. PMID: 7664428
- Evangelista A, Flachskampf FA, Erbel R, et al. Echocardiography in aortic diseases: EAE recommendations for clinical practice. Eur J Echocardiogr. 2010;11(8):645-658. PMID: 20823280
Clinical Features
- von Kodolitsch Y, Schwartz AG, Nienaber CA. Clinical prediction of acute aortic dissection. Arch Intern Med. 2000;160(19):2977-2982. PMID: 11041906
- Shiga T, Wajima Z, Apfel CC, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of transesophageal echocardiography, helical computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging for suspected thoracic aortic dissection: systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med. 2006;166(13):1350-1356. PMID: 16831999
D-dimer and ADD-RS
- Asha SE, Miers JW. A systematic review and meta-analysis of D-dimer as a rule-out test for suspected acute aortic dissection. Ann Emerg Med. 2015;66(4):368-378. PMID: 25805111
- Goodacre S, Horspool K, Nelson-Piercy C, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of D-dimer for acute aortic syndromes: systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Emerg Med. 2024;84(3):284-297. PMID: 38795020
- Nienaber CA, von Kodolitsch Y, Nicolas V, et al. The diagnosis of thoracic aortic dissection by noninvasive imaging procedures. N Engl J Med. 1993;328(1):1-9. PMID: 8416265
- Sommer T, Fehske W, Holzknecht N, et al. Aortic dissection: a comparative study of diagnosis with spiral CT, multiplanar transesophageal echocardiography, and MR imaging. Radiology. 1996;199(2):347-352. PMID: 8668776
- Cigarroa JE, Isselbacher EM, DeSanctis RW, et al. Diagnostic imaging in the evaluation of suspected aortic dissection. Old standards and new directions. N Engl J Med. 1993;328(1):35-43. PMID: 8416268
- Nazerian P, Mueller C, Soeiro AM, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of the aortic dissection detection risk score plus D-dimer for acute aortic syndromes: the ADvISED prospective multicenter study. Circulation. 2018;137(3):250-258. PMID: 29030346
Management
- Czerny M, Schmidli J, Adler S, et al. Current options and recommendations for the treatment of thoracic aortic pathologies involving the aortic arch: an expert consensus document of the European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS) & the European Society for Vascular Surgery (ESVS). Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2019;55(1):133-162. PMID: 30312382
- Lombardi JV, Hughes GC, Appoo JJ, et al. Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) and Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) reporting standards for type B aortic dissections. J Vasc Surg. 2020;71(3):723-747. PMID: 31668497
- Harris KM, Strauss CE, Eagle KA, et al. Correlates of delayed recognition and treatment of acute type A aortic dissection: the International Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection (IRAD). Circulation. 2011;124(18):1911-1918. PMID: 21969019
- Liisberg M, Larsen KL, Diederichsen ACP, et al. Beta blockers as primary and secondary prevention for aortic dissections. J Am Heart Assoc. 2025;14(12):e040149. PMID: 40500875
- Ganaha F, Miller DC, Sugimoto K, et al. Prognosis of aortic intramural hematoma with and without penetrating atherosclerotic ulcer: a clinical and radiological analysis. Circulation. 2002;106(3):342-348. PMID: 12119251
- Vilacosta I, San Román JA, Ferreirós J, et al. Natural history and serial morphology of aortic intramural hematoma: a novel variant of aortic dissection. Am Heart J. 1997;134(3):495-507. PMID: 9327708
Complications
- Isselbacher EM, Preventza O, Hamilton Black J 3rd, et al. 2022 ACC/AHA guideline for the diagnosis and management of aortic disease. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2022;80(24):e223-e393. PMID: 36334595
- Nishimura RA, Otto CM, Bonow RO, et al. 2017 AHA/ACC focused update of the 2014 AHA/ACC guideline for the management of patients with valvular heart disease. Circulation. 2017;135(25):e1159-e1195. PMID: 28298458
- Gaul C, Dietrich W, Friedrich I, et al. Neurological symptoms in type A aortic dissections. Stroke. 2007;38(2):292-297. PMID: 17204686
Malperfusion
- Estrera AL, Garami Z, Miller CC, et al. Acute spinal cord ischemia in thoracic and thoracoabdominal aortic surgery: incidence, risk factors, and outcome. Ann Thorac Surg. 2001;72(2):425-432. PMID: 11515878
- Cambria RP, Brewster DC, Gertler J, et al. Vascular complications associated with spontaneous aortic dissection. J Vasc Surg. 1988;7(2):199-209. PMID: 3276930
- Geirsson A, Szeto WY, Pochettino A, et al. Significance of malperfusion syndromes prior to contemporary surgical repair for acute type A dissection: outcomes and need for additional revascularizations. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2007;32(2):255-262. PMID: 17576068
- Fann JI, Sarris GE, Mitchell RS, et al. Treatment of patients with aortic dissection presenting with peripheral vascular complications. Ann Surg. 1990;212(6):705-713. PMID: 2256761
- Hirst AE Jr, Johns VJ Jr, Kime SW Jr. Dissecting aneurysm of the aorta: a review of 505 cases. Medicine (Baltimore). 1958;37(3):217-279. PMID: 13577293
- Chandiramani A, Al-Tawil M, Elleithy A, et al. Organ-specific malperfusion in acute type A aortic dissection: epidemiological meta-analysis of incidence rates. BJS Open. 2025;9(1):zrae146. PMID: 39792052
- Penn MS, Smedira N, Lytle B, et al. Does coronary angiography before emergency aortic surgery affect in-hospital mortality? J Am Coll Cardiol. 2000;35(4):889-894. PMID: 10732885
- Tsagakis K, Dohle DS, Benedik J, et al. Visceral malperfusion in aortic dissection: still a lethal event? Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2016;49(5):1381-1387. PMID: 26272901
- Deeb GM, Williams DM, Bolling SF, et al. Surgical delay for acute type A dissection with malperfusion. Ann Thorac Surg. 1997;64(6):1669-1675. PMID: 9436553
- Williams DM, Lee DY, Hamilton BH, et al. The dissected aorta: percutaneous treatment of ischemic complications--principles and results. J Vasc Interv Radiol. 1997;8(4):605-625. PMID: 9232575
Special Populations
- Immer FF, Bansi AG, Immer-Bansi AS, et al. Aortic dissection in pregnancy: analysis of risk factors and outcome. Ann Thorac Surg. 2003;76(1):309-314. PMID: 12842582
- Piccardo A, Regesta T, Zannis K, et al. Outcomes after surgical treatment of type A aortic dissection in octogenarians: a multicenter study. Ann Thorac Surg. 2009;88(5):1433-1440. PMID: 19853089
- Judge DP, Dietz HC. Marfan's syndrome. Lancet. 2005;366(9501):1965-1976. PMID: 16325700
- Elefteriades JA, Farkas EA. Thoracic aortic aneurysm clinically pertinent controversies and uncertainties. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2010;55(9):841-857. PMID: 20185035
- Kühn S, Fichtlscherer S, Nienaber CA, et al. Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest due to aortic dissection: a systematic review. Resuscitation. 2021;169:28-37. PMID: 34634407
Frequently asked questions
Quick clarifications for common clinical and exam-facing questions.
Can a normal D-dimer rule out aortic dissection?
No. While D-dimer has 97% sensitivity, sensitivity drops to 67-87% for intramural haematoma and penetrating atherosclerotic ulcer. Cannot be used as sole rule-out test.
Is immediate surgery always needed for type A dissection?
Type A dissection requires urgent cardiothoracic surgery. However, initial medical stabilisation (BP control, HR control) is critical before transfer. Time to surgery below 6h associated with lower mortality.
What blood pressure target should I aim for?
Target SBP 100-120 mmHg AND heart rate below 60 bpm. Use beta-blocker FIRST (reduces dP/dt), then add vasodilator if needed.
Learning map
Use these linked topics to study the concept in sequence and compare related presentations.
Differentials
Competing diagnoses and look-alikes to compare.
Consequences
Complications and downstream problems to keep in mind.
- Cardiac Tamponade
- Acute Stroke
- Mesenteric Ischaemia