Headache Red Flags
Headache is a common ED presentation (2-4% of all visits), but 1-4% harbour life-threatening pathology. The SNOOP mnemon... ACEM Fellowship Written, ACEM Fellow
Clinical board
A visual summary of the highest-yield teaching signals on this page.
Urgent signals
Safety-critical features pulled from the topic metadata.
- Thunderclap headache (sudden, maximal in below 1 minute) - SAH until proven otherwise
- New headache in age greater than 50 years - temporal arteritis, mass lesion, CVST
- Fever + headache + neck stiffness - bacterial meningitis (classic triad only 44%)
- Immunocompromised patient (HIV, chemotherapy, steroids) - opportunistic infection, abscess
Exam focus
Current exam surfaces linked to this topic.
- ACEM Fellowship Written
- ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Linked comparisons
Differentials and adjacent topics worth opening next.
- Subarachnoid Haemorrhage
- Bacterial Meningitis
Editorial and exam context
Quick Answer
One-liner: Headache red flags are clinical features suggesting serious secondary causes (SAH, meningitis, mass lesions, temporal arteritis) requiring urgent investigation to prevent death or permanent neurological injury.
Headache is a common ED presentation (2-4% of all visits), but 1-4% harbour life-threatening pathology. The SNOOP mnemonic systematically identifies red flags: Systemic symptoms, Neurological signs, sudden Onset, Older age (greater than 50 years), Pattern change. Thunderclap headache (maximal in below 1 minute) is SAH until proven otherwise. New headache in patients greater than 50 years mandates ESR/CRP to exclude temporal arteritis (risk of irreversible blindness 15-20%). CT brain detects 98-100% of SAH in first 6 hours but falls to 50% after 1 week—LP is required after negative CT to detect xanthochromia (12 hours to 2 weeks post-bleed).
ACEM Exam Focus
Primary Exam Relevance
- Anatomy: Circle of Willis aneurysm sites (anterior communicating 30%, posterior communicating 25%, MCA bifurcation 20%); cranial nerve pathways (CN VI palsy in raised ICP, CN III palsy in posterior communicating artery aneurysm); meningeal anatomy (dura, arachnoid, pia; CSF circulation and reabsorption at arachnoid granulations)
- Physiology: Monro-Kellie doctrine (ICP regulation: brain 80%, blood 10%, CSF 10%); cerebral autoregulation (50-150 mmHg MAP); CSF production 20 mL/hour (500 mL/day), volume 150 mL; normal ICP 5-15 mmHg; normal opening pressure LP 10-25 cm H₂O
- Pharmacology: Mannitol 0.25-1 g/kg (osmotic diuretic, reduces ICP within 15-30 min); hypertonic saline 3% 2-5 mL/kg (alternative to mannitol, preferred in hypotension); methylprednisolone 1 g IV daily for temporal arteritis (immediate treatment before biopsy); nimodipine 60 mg Q4H for SAH vasospasm prevention
Fellowship Exam Relevance
- Written: High-yield SAQ topics: SNOOP mnemonic, CT brain indications, LP timing and xanthochromia, thunderclap headache DDx (SAH, RCVS, dissection, CVST), temporal arteritis ESR/CRP thresholds, bacterial meningitis empiric antibiotics (ceftriaxone 2 g + vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg + dexamethasone 10 mg)
- OSCE: Likely scenarios: (1) Take focused headache history from patient with red flags (thunderclap, age greater than 50, focal neurology); (2) Perform LP and interpret CSF results (xanthochromia, cell count, protein, glucose); (3) Breaking bad news to SAH patient and family; (4) Communicate CT brain indications to GP questioning need
- Key domains tested: Medical Expert (recognize red flags, order appropriate investigations), Communicator (explain LP rationale to anxious patient, discuss temporal arteritis steroid treatment and biopsy timing), Leader (prioritize CT vs LP, escalate to neurosurgery for SAH)
Key Points
The 5 things you MUST know:
- Thunderclap headache (sudden onset, maximal below 1 minute) = SAH until proven otherwise. CT brain STAT, then LP if negative (12+ hours post-onset for xanthochromia).
- New headache age greater than 50 years = temporal arteritis until proven otherwise. Check ESR/CRP/platelet count, start methylprednisolone 1 g IV immediately if suspected (prevents irreversible blindness).
- CT brain does NOT exclude SAH - sensitivity 98-100% at 6 hours, 93% at 24 hours, 50% at 1 week. LP is mandatory after negative CT for thunderclap headache.
- Xanthochromia (yellow CSF from bilirubin) appears 12 hours post-bleed, peaks 1 week, detectable up to 2 weeks. LP before 12 hours requires spectrophotometry (not visual inspection).
- Classic meningitis triad (fever, headache, neck stiffness) present in only 44% of bacterial meningitis. Absence does NOT exclude meningitis—any two features in unwell patient warrants LP and empiric antibiotics.
Epidemiology
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| ED headache presentations | 2-4% of all ED visits | [1] |
| Serious pathology in ED headache | 1-4% | [2] |
| SAH incidence | 6-9 per 100,000/year | [3] |
| SAH mortality | 30-50% | [4] |
| Bacterial meningitis incidence | 1-2 per 100,000/year (Australia) | [5] |
| Bacterial meningitis mortality | 15-30% | [6] |
| Temporal arteritis incidence | 15-25 per 100,000 greater than 50 years | [7] |
| GCA blindness risk (untreated) | 15-20% | [8] |
| IIH incidence | 1-2 per 100,000; 19 per 100,000 in obese women 20-44 years | [9] |
| Carbon monoxide poisoning deaths | 50-100/year Australia | [10] |
| RCVS incidence | 2.6 per 100,000/year | [11] |
Australian/NZ Specific
- Australian burden: SAH hospitalisations 1,500-2,000/year; bacterial meningitis 200-300 cases/year (post-vaccination era); temporal arteritis 3,000-5,000 cases/year in greater than 50 population
- Indigenous population: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians have 2-3× higher rates of bacterial meningitis (overcrowding, lower vaccination rates in remote areas); Māori and Pacific Islander populations in NZ similarly affected
- Rural/remote: Delayed presentation common (greater than 24 hours from symptom onset to ED arrival in 30-40% of RFDS retrievals for headache); reduced access to CT and neurosurgical services (median retrieval time 4-6 hours)
- Seasonal variation: Bacterial meningitis peaks in winter (June-August); thunderstorm asthma-related headache (Victoria, November-December)
Pathophysiology
Mechanism
Secondary headaches arise from distinct pathological processes:
Vascular Pathology (SAH, Dissection, CVST, RCVS)
- SAH: Aneurysm rupture → blood in subarachnoid space → meningeal irritation (chemical meningitis), sudden ICP spike, vasospasm (delayed 3-14 days causing ischaemia), hydrocephalus (impaired CSF reabsorption)
- Dissection: Tear in arterial wall (carotid/vertebral) → intramural haematoma → reduced flow (ischaemia) or external compression of pain-sensitive structures (adventitia, periarterial sympathetic plexus)
- CVST: Venous sinus thrombosis → impaired CSF drainage → raised ICP → headache + papilledema; venous infarction → haemorrhage
- RCVS: Reversible multifocal vasoconstriction of cerebral arteries → thunderclap headache (recurrent over 1-4 weeks); mechanisms include sympathetic hyperactivity, endothelial dysfunction, calcium channel dysregulation
Infection (Meningitis, Encephalitis)
- Bacterial meningitis: Bacterial invasion → meningeal inflammation → vasogenic oedema, cytotoxic oedema, vascular thrombosis → raised ICP + headache + fever
- Viral encephalitis: Parenchymal inflammation → oedema → raised ICP; HSV predilection for temporal lobes → seizures + behavioural change
- Abscess: Space-occupying lesion → mass effect + perilesional oedema → raised ICP
Inflammation (Temporal Arteritis, Vasculitis)
- GCA: Granulomatous inflammation of medium/large arteries → intimal hyperplasia → luminal narrowing → ischaemia of ophthalmic artery (blindness), superficial temporal artery (headache, jaw claudication)
- Primary CNS vasculitis: Segmental vessel inflammation → multifocal infarcts
Raised ICP (Mass Lesion, IIH, Hydrocephalus)
- Mass lesion: Tumour, abscess, haematoma → mass effect + perilesional oedema → raised ICP
- IIH: Impaired CSF reabsorption at arachnoid granulations (obesity, medications) → raised ICP → papilledema → optic atrophy (blindness)
- Hydrocephalus: Impaired CSF circulation (obstructive) or reabsorption (communicating) → ventriculomegaly → raised ICP
Hypoxia/Hypercapnia (Carbon Monoxide)
- CO poisoning: CO binds haemoglobin (COHb) → reduced O₂ delivery → tissue hypoxia → cerebral vasodilation → headache; CO also binds myoglobin, cytochrome oxidase → cellular hypoxia
Pathological Progression
Primary Insult → Inflammatory/Vascular/Mass Effect → Raised ICP → Secondary Brain Injury
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
(Aneurysm rupture) (Meningeal inflammation) (Herniation risk) (Permanent deficit/death)
Why It Matters Clinically
- Time-critical intervention: SAH requires aneurysm securing within 24-72 hours to prevent rebleed (4% in first 24 hours, 15-20% in first 2 weeks); bacterial meningitis mortality increases 15% for each hour delay in antibiotics; temporal arteritis requires steroids within 24 hours to prevent blindness
- Irreversibility: Optic nerve infarction from GCA is irreversible (15-20% risk); brainstem herniation from raised ICP is rapidly fatal
- Diagnostic window: Xanthochromia detectable 12 hours to 2 weeks post-SAH—LP too early or too late misses diagnosis; CSF opening pressure must be measured with patient in lateral decubitus position (sitting falsely elevated)
Clinical Approach
Recognition
Headache red flags trigger immediate high-acuity assessment:
- Triage category 2: Thunderclap headache, focal neurology, seizure, GCS below 15, fever + headache + neck stiffness
- Triage category 3: New headache age greater than 50, progressive headache, positional headache, immunocompromised patient
- Immediate senior review: Any patient with ≥2 red flags
Initial Assessment
Primary Survey (if applicable)
- A: Airway patency (reduced GCS below 8 requires RSI); vomiting risk aspiration
- B: Respiratory rate, SpO₂ (hypoxia in CO poisoning, hyperventilation in raised ICP, irregular breathing in brainstem compression)
- C: BP (hypertension in raised ICP—Cushing's triad: HTN, bradycardia, irregular respirations; hypotension excludes IIH), HR, CRT, ECG (arrhythmia post-SAH)
- D: GCS, pupils (CN III palsy: dilated, down-and-out in posterior communicating artery aneurysm; bilateral fixed dilated in herniation; bilateral small reactive in pontine haemorrhage), focal neurology
- E: Temperature (fever in meningitis, encephalitis, abscess), rash (petechial in meningococcal sepsis), neck stiffness, Kernig's/Brudzinski's sign
Vital Signs Interpretation
- Cushing's triad (HTN + bradycardia + irregular breathing) = impending herniation
- Fever greater than 38.5°C + headache = meningitis/encephalitis until proven otherwise
- SBP greater than 220 or DBP greater than 120 = hypertensive emergency (posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome - PRES)
- COHb greater than 10% on ABG = CO poisoning (smokers baseline 3-10%, non-smokers below 3%)
History
Key Questions
| Question | Significance |
|---|---|
| "Did the headache come on suddenly, like a clap of thunder?" | Thunderclap onset (below 1 min) = SAH, RCVS, dissection, pituitary apoplexy |
| "Is this the worst headache of your life?" | Severe pain suggests SAH (but 25% have sentinel headache days before) |
| "Have you ever had a headache like this before?" | New/different headache more concerning than recurrent primary headache |
| "What were you doing when it started?" | Valsalva (cough, sneeze, defecation, orgasm) → SAH, colloid cyst; exertion → SAH, RCVS |
| "Does it get worse when you lie down or stand up?" | Worse lying → raised ICP (mass, IIH); worse standing → CSF leak (post-LP, spontaneous) |
| "Any vision changes?" | Vision loss → GCA, pituitary apoplexy, IIH; diplopia → CN VI palsy (raised ICP), CN III palsy (aneurysm) |
| "Any weakness, numbness, speech problems?" | Focal neurology → stroke, mass, abscess, CVST |
| "Any fever, neck stiffness, rash?" | Meningitis triad (44% sensitivity but high specificity) |
| "Are you pregnant or postpartum?" | CVST (6× risk), pre-eclampsia, PRES |
| "Are you on any blood thinners?" | Warfarin, DOACs, antiplatelets → higher risk ICH |
| "Do you have HIV, cancer, or take steroids?" | Immunocompromised → opportunistic infection (toxoplasma, cryptococcus), lymphoma |
| "Any recent head trauma?" | Subdural haematoma (especially greater than 65 years, anticoagulated) |
SNOOP4 Mnemonic (Expanded Red Flags)
S - Systemic symptoms/signs
- Fever, weight loss, night sweats (infection, malignancy)
- Pregnancy/postpartum (CVST, pre-eclampsia)
- HIV/immunosuppression (opportunistic infection)
- Cancer (metastases, paraneoplastic)
N - Neurological symptoms/signs
- Focal deficit (weakness, numbness, aphasia)
- Seizure
- Altered mental status/confusion
- Papilledema
O - Onset sudden (thunderclap)
- Maximal intensity below 1 minute
- "Worst headache of life"
- Triggered by Valsalva, exertion, coitus
O - Older age (greater than 50 years, or below 5 years in children)
- New headache greater than 50: GCA, mass lesion, subdural
- New headache below 5: mass lesion, hydrocephalus
P - Pattern change
- Increasing frequency/severity
- Change in characteristics (location, quality)
- New associated symptoms
- Refractory to usual treatment (in known primary headache)
SNNOOP10 Mnemonic (Complete Version)
| Letter | Red Flag | Condition(s) |
|---|---|---|
| S | Systemic symptoms (fever, weight loss) | Infection, malignancy |
| N | Neoplasm history | Brain metastases |
| N | Neurological deficit | Stroke, mass, CVST |
| O | Onset sudden | SAH, RCVS, dissection |
| O | Older age greater than 50 | GCA, mass, subdural |
| P | Pattern change | Mass, chronic SDH |
| 1 | Positional (worse lying) | Raised ICP |
| 2 | Positional (worse standing) | CSF leak |
| 3 | Precipitated by Valsalva | SAH, Chiari, colloid cyst |
| 4 | Papilledema | Raised ICP |
| 5 | Pregnancy/postpartum | CVST, pre-eclampsia, PRES |
| 6 | Progressive headache | Mass, IIH |
| 7 | Painful eye with autonomic | Acute glaucoma, cluster |
| 8 | Post-traumatic | Subdural, ICH, dissection |
| 9 | Pathology of immune system | Opportunistic infection |
| 10 | Painkiller overuse or new drug | MOH, medication side effect |
Red Flag Symptoms
- Thunderclap onset (below 1 minute to maximal pain) - SAH 25%, RCVS 39%, primary thunderclap 34%
- Fever + headache + neck stiffness - bacterial meningitis (classic triad only 44% sensitive)
- Focal neurological signs - stroke, mass, abscess, CVST
- Altered mental status - meningitis, encephalitis, raised ICP, CO poisoning
- Seizure + headache - mass lesion, SAH, CVST, encephalitis
- Papilledema - raised ICP (mass, IIH, CVST); DO NOT LP until CT excludes mass
- Vision loss - GCA (ophthalmic artery occlusion), pituitary apoplexy, IIH (optic atrophy)
- Jaw claudication - GCA (facial artery ischaemia - 34% sensitivity, 98% specificity)
- Temporal artery tenderness - GCA (can palpate thickened, non-pulsatile temporal artery)
- Positional headache - worse lying: raised ICP; worse standing: CSF leak
Examination
General Inspection
- Appearance: Toxic, diaphoretic (meningitis), drowsy (raised ICP, CO poisoning), writhing in pain (SAH)
- Behaviour: Confusion (encephalitis, meningitis), photophobia (meningitis, SAH), combativeness (hypoxia, encephalitis)
- Rash: Petechiae/purpura (meningococcal sepsis—do NOT delay antibiotics for LP), cherry-red skin (CO poisoning—rare)
Specific Findings
| System | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Vitals | Cushing's triad (HTN, bradycardia, irregular breathing) | Impending herniation from raised ICP |
| Neuro | GCS below 15 | SAH, ICH, meningitis, encephalitis, raised ICP |
| Focal deficit (hemiparesis, aphasia, neglect) | Stroke, mass, abscess, CVST | |
| CN III palsy (ptosis, down-and-out eye, dilated pupil) | Posterior communicating artery aneurysm compressing CN III | |
| CN VI palsy (failure to abduct eye) | Raised ICP (false localizing sign) | |
| Papilledema (blurred disc margins, venous engorgement) | Raised ICP; DO NOT LP until CT excludes mass | |
| Neck stiffness (resistance to passive neck flexion) | Meningitis (62% sensitivity), SAH (13% sensitivity) | |
| Kernig's sign (resistance to knee extension with hip flexed 90°) | Meningitis (5% sensitivity, high specificity) | |
| Brudzinski's sign (hip/knee flexion with passive neck flexion) | Meningitis (5% sensitivity, high specificity) | |
| CVS | Temporal artery: thickened, tender, non-pulsatile | GCA (can be normal in 37% due to skip lesions) |
| Skin | Petechiae/purpura (non-blanching) | Meningococcal sepsis (do NOT delay antibiotics) |
| Fundoscopy | Papilledema | Raised ICP (mass, IIH, CVST) |
| Subhyaloid haemorrhage (Terson's syndrome) | SAH (13-40% of aneurysmal SAH) |
Jolt Accentuation Test
- Patient turns head horizontally 2-3 times/second
- Positive: Headache worsens significantly
- Utility: Sensitivity 97%, specificity 60% for meningitis in febrile patients
- Limitation: Cannot be used if neck stiffness prevents movement
Risk Stratification
Ottawa SAH Rule
Apply to: Alert patients greater than 15 years with new-onset severe non-traumatic headache reaching maximum intensity in below 1 hour.
Investigate (CT + LP) if ANY of:
- Age ≥40 years
- Neck pain or stiffness
- Witnessed loss of consciousness
- Onset during exertion
- Thunderclap headache (instantaneous peak)
- Limited neck flexion on examination
Performance: 100% sensitivity (95% CI 97.2-100%) for SAH in validation studies [12]
Clinical utility: If ALL criteria absent, SAH can be ruled out without CT/LP (but this is rare - most thunderclap headache patients meet ≥1 criterion)
RCVS2 Score
Purpose: Distinguish RCVS from other causes of thunderclap headache
| Feature | Points |
|---|---|
| Recurrent thunderclap headache | +5 |
| Single thunderclap headache | +1 |
| Intracranial carotid artery involvement | -2 |
| Female sex | +1 |
| No aneurysmal SAH | +2 |
| No history of migraine | +1 |
Interpretation: Score ≥5 = RCVS probable (sensitivity 90%, specificity 99%)
High-Risk vs Low-Risk Stratification
| High-Risk Features | Low-Risk Features |
|---|---|
| Thunderclap onset (below 1 min) | Gradual onset over hours |
| Age greater than 50 with new headache | Known migraine with typical features |
| Fever + altered mental status | Afebrile, GCS 15 |
| Focal neurological signs | Normal neurological examination |
| Papilledema | Normal fundoscopy |
| Pregnancy/postpartum | Non-pregnant |
| Immunocompromised | Immunocompetent |
| Anticoagulated | No anticoagulation |
Investigations
Immediate (Resus Bay)
| Test | Purpose | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Vital signs | Identify Cushing's triad | HTN + bradycardia + irregular breathing = herniation |
| BSL | Exclude hypoglycaemia (mimic) | below 4.0 mmol/L causes confusion, seizure |
| ECG | Detect arrhythmia post-SAH | Neurogenic stunned myocardium: T-wave inversion, ST changes, prolonged QTc |
| ABG + COHb | Detect CO poisoning, acidosis | COHb greater than 10% in non-smokers = CO poisoning; COHb greater than 25% = severe |
Standard ED Workup
| Test | Indication | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| CT brain non-contrast STAT | Thunderclap, focal neurology, GCS below 15, seizure, age greater than 50 new headache, immunocompromised, anticoagulation, HIV+ | SAH: Hyperdense blood in basal cisterns, sylvian fissure, interhemispheric fissure (98-100% sensitivity below 6h, 93% at 24h, 50% at 1 week). Mass: Tumour, abscess (ring-enhancing). ICH: Hyperdense blood. Hydrocephalus: Ventricular enlargement. NORMAL: Does NOT exclude SAH—LP required |
| LP | Thunderclap with negative CT (12+ hours post-onset); fever + headache + neck stiffness (empiric antibiotics FIRST if delay greater than 30 min) | Opening pressure (lateral decubitus): Normal 10-25 cm H₂O; greater than 25 = raised ICP (IIH, CVST, meningitis); below 5 = CSF leak. Cell count: WCC greater than 1,000 cells/µL (bacterial meningitis); greater than 5 cells/µL (viral meningitis); RBC greater than 10,000 cells/µL (SAH vs traumatic tap—see below). Xanthochromia (spectrophotometry): Bilirubin peak greater than 12h, detectable 12h-2wks post-SAH. Protein: greater than 1 g/L (bacterial meningitis). Glucose: CSF:serum below 0.4 (bacterial meningitis, TB, fungal) |
| ESR, CRP, platelet count | New headache age greater than 50 (temporal arteritis screen) | ESR greater than 50 mm/h + CRP greater than 10 mg/L + platelets greater than 400 in age greater than 50 = GCA until proven otherwise (ESR greater than 100 in 40%, ESR below 50 in 20%) |
| FBC | Infection screen, thrombocytosis (GCA) | WCC greater than 15 suggests bacterial infection; platelets greater than 400 in GCA |
| UEC | Hyponatraemia in SAH (SIADH, CSW) | Na below 130 mmol/L in 30% of SAH (cerebral salt wasting vs SIADH) |
| Coagulation screen (INR, aPTT) | If anticoagulated or bleeding suspected | INR greater than 1.5 increases ICH risk; reverse before LP if safe |
| Blood cultures | Fever + headache | Draw BEFORE antibiotics if possible (but do NOT delay antibiotics) |
CT Brain Indications for Headache (ACEM High-Yield)
Immediate CT brain required if ANY of:
- Thunderclap onset (below 1 minute to peak)
- Focal neurological deficit (weakness, sensory loss, aphasia, neglect)
- Seizure (new onset)
- Altered mental status (GCS below 15)
- Age greater than 50 years with NEW headache
- Immunocompromised (HIV, chemotherapy, steroids, transplant)
- Anticoagulation (warfarin, DOACs, antiplatelets)
- Papilledema on fundoscopy
- Head trauma (especially greater than 65 years, anticoagulated)
- Ventriculoperitoneal shunt in situ
CT Sensitivity for SAH by Time
| Time from Onset | CT Sensitivity | LP Required if CT Negative? |
|---|---|---|
| below 6 hours | 98-100% | Yes (2-5% missed) |
| 6-12 hours | 95-98% | Yes |
| 12-24 hours | 93% | Yes |
| 24-48 hours | 85% | Yes |
| 1 week | 50% | Yes (essential) |
| 2 weeks | 30% | Yes |
LP Timing and Technique (ACEM High-Yield)
Contraindications to LP:
- Suspected mass lesion (papilledema, focal signs, seizure) → CT brain FIRST
- Coagulopathy (platelets below 50, INR greater than 1.5) → correct first
- Skin infection at LP site
- Cardiorespiratory compromise (cannot lie flat in lateral decubitus)
LP for Suspected SAH:
- Timing: ≥12 hours post-headache onset (allow xanthochromia to develop from RBC breakdown)
- Position: Lateral decubitus (measure opening pressure before CSF withdrawal)
- Tubes: Send 3-4 tubes (tube 1 and 4 for cell count comparison if traumatic tap suspected)
- Tests: Cell count (RBC, WCC), protein, glucose, xanthochromia (spectrophotometry, NOT visual inspection), Gram stain/culture (if infection suspected)
Xanthochromia vs Traumatic Tap:
- Xanthochromia (yellow CSF): Bilirubin from RBC breakdown; appears 12h post-bleed, peaks 1 week, detectable 2 weeks
- Traumatic tap: RBC decreases from tube 1 to tube 4 (50% reduction suggests traumatic); CSF supernatant clear/colourless; clots in collection tube
- SAH: RBC equal in all tubes; xanthochromia present (12h-2wks); no clotting
ESR/CRP Thresholds for Temporal Arteritis
| Test | Threshold | Sensitivity | Specificity |
|---|---|---|---|
| ESR | greater than 50 mm/h | 80% | 70% |
| ESR | greater than 100 mm/h | 40% | 95% |
| CRP | greater than 10 mg/L | 85% | 60% |
| ESR normal | below 50 mm/h | Excludes GCA in 20% | - |
| ESR + CRP both normal | - | Excludes GCA in below 5% | - |
Clinical pearl: ESR normal in 20% of biopsy-proven GCA (especially in partial arteritis variant)—clinical suspicion trumps labs. Start steroids if high suspicion even with normal ESR.
Advanced/Specialist
| Test | Indication | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| CT angiography (CTA) brain | Thunderclap + negative CT/LP → rule out RCVS, aneurysm, dissection | Metro ED, tertiary centres |
| MRI brain + MRA | CVST suspected (gradual headache + seizure), posterior circulation stroke, pituitary apoplexy | Tertiary centres (not acute in most EDs) |
| MRV (MR venography) | CVST (delta sign: thrombosed superior sagittal sinus) | Tertiary centres |
| Temporal artery ultrasound | GCA: halo sign (hypoechoic wall thickening) | Rheumatology/radiology (sensitivity 68%, specificity 91%) |
| Temporal artery biopsy | Gold standard for GCA (skip lesions require 2-3 cm length) | Ophthalmology/vascular surgery (can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids) |
| Lumbar puncture opening pressure | IIH (greater than 25 cm H₂O in lateral decubitus) | All EDs (must measure before CSF removal) |
Point-of-Care Ultrasound
POCUS applications in headache red flags:
-
Optic nerve sheath diameter (ONSD)
- Measurement: Transorbital approach, 3 mm behind globe
- Normal: below 5.0 mm (adults), below 4.5 mm (children)
- Raised ICP: greater than 5.7 mm (sensitivity 90%, specificity 85%)
- Use: Bedside raised ICP screening (mass, IIH, CVST)
-
Temporal artery assessment
- Halo sign: Hypoechoic wall thickening in GCA (sensitivity 68%, specificity 91%)
- Compression sign: Non-compressible artery
- Operator-dependent: Requires training
-
Transcranial Doppler (TCD)
- Vasospasm post-SAH: Elevated MCA velocity greater than 120 cm/s (delayed 3-14 days post-bleed)
- Not available in most Australian EDs
Thunderclap Headache Differential Diagnosis
Complete Differential
| Condition | Frequency | Key Features | Investigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAH (aneurysmal) | 11-25% | Sudden onset, "worst ever", Valsalva trigger, neck stiffness | CT brain → LP (xanthochromia) → CTA |
| RCVS | 20-46% | Recurrent thunderclap (1-4 weeks), bathing trigger, female, post-partum | CTA/MRA (string-of-beads, resolves below 3 months) |
| Primary thunderclap headache | 10-34% | Diagnosis of exclusion, no recurrence | Negative CT, LP, CTA/MRA |
| CVST | 1-5% | Subacute, seizure, pregnancy/OCP, papilledema | MRV (delta sign), D-dimer |
| Cervical artery dissection | 1-5% | Neck/face pain, Horner's (carotid), posterior stroke (vertebral) | CTA/MRA neck |
| Pituitary apoplexy | 1-2% | Visual field defect, ophthalmoplegia, hypotension | MRI pituitary, cortisol |
| Intracerebral haemorrhage | 2-5% | Focal deficit, hypertension | CT brain |
| Posterior fossa lesion | below 1% | Occipital, Valsalva trigger, cerebellar signs | MRI brain |
| Colloid cyst | below 1% | Positional, sudden syncope | CT/MRI brain |
| Acute hypertensive crisis | 1-2% | SBP greater than 220, visual changes, chest pain | BP, ECG, end-organ assessment |
RCVS (Reversible Cerebral Vasoconstriction Syndrome)
Key features:
- Thunderclap headache (recurrent over 1-4 weeks, average 4 episodes)
- Triggers: Sexual activity, bathing/showering, exertion, emotional stress, Valsalva
- Peak incidence: Women 20-50 years, postpartum period
- Precipitants: Vasoactive drugs (SSRIs, triptans, cannabis, cocaine, phenylephrine, ergots)
Diagnosis:
- CTA/MRA: "String-of-beads" (multifocal segmental vasoconstriction)
- LP: Normal or near-normal (protein below 100 mg/dL, WCC below 10)
- Important: Angiography may be normal in first week—repeat in 1-2 weeks if high suspicion
- Confirmation: Resolution of vasoconstriction on imaging at 3 months
Management:
- Stop precipitants: SSRIs, triptans, cannabis, cocaine, ergots
- Nimodipine 60 mg PO Q4H (reduces headache severity, does not prevent stroke)
- Avoid steroids: May worsen RCVS (unlike PACNS)
- Bed rest: During acute phase (1-4 weeks)
- Analgesia: Paracetamol, opioids (AVOID triptans, NSAIDs may worsen)
Complications: Convexal SAH (22%), PRES (8-38%), ischaemic stroke (4-39%)
Management
Immediate Management (First 10 minutes)
General approach for ANY headache red flag:
1. STAT senior (consultant) review
2. High-flow O₂ 15 L/min non-rebreather if hypoxic (SpO₂ below 94%) or suspected CO poisoning
3. IV access + bloods (FBC, UEC, coags, BSL, blood cultures if febrile)
4. Analgesia (paracetamol 1 g IV, avoid NSAIDs if SAH suspected)
5. Antiemetic (ondansetron 4-8 mg IV)
6. CT brain non-contrast STAT if ANY indication (see above)
7. Nil by mouth (NBM) pending diagnosis
Condition-Specific Management
Thunderclap Headache (Suspected SAH)
Step 1: Resuscitation
- ABC assessment
- High-flow O₂ if hypoxic
- IV access, bloods (FBC, UEC, coags, group & hold)
- Analgesia (paracetamol 1 g IV ± fentanyl 25-50 mcg IV titrated)
- Antiemetic (ondansetron 4-8 mg IV)
- Keep SBP below 160 mmHg (labetalol 10-20 mg IV boluses, or nicardipine infusion)
- Neurosurgery consult STAT
Step 2: CT brain non-contrast STAT
- Positive (blood in subarachnoid space): CTA brain to identify aneurysm → neurosurgery for aneurysm securing (coiling vs clipping within 24-72h)
- Negative: Proceed to LP (≥12 hours post-headache onset if possible)
Step 3: LP (if CT negative)
- Xanthochromia positive: Treat as SAH → CTA → neurosurgery
- Xanthochromia negative, normal cell count: Consider alternative DDx (RCVS, dissection, primary thunderclap) → CTA/MRA
Step 4: SAH confirmed - prevent complications
- Nimodipine 60 mg PO/NG Q4H for 21 days (prevents vasospasm, improves outcome)
- Maintain euvolaemia (avoid hypotension, which worsens vasospasm; avoid hypovolemia)
- DVT prophylaxis (mechanical compression devices, NOT pharmacological until aneurysm secured)
- Stool softeners (docusate) to avoid Valsalva
- Neurological observations Q1H (GCS, pupils, focal signs)
Bacterial Meningitis (Suspected)
Time-critical - mortality increases 15% per hour delay in antibiotics
Step 1: Immediate empiric antibiotics (do NOT wait for LP)
- Ceftriaxone 2 g IV (50 mg/kg in children)
+ Vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg IV (if age greater than 50, immunocompromised, or recent neurosurgery - covers Listeria, MRSA)
+ Dexamethasone 10 mg IV (0.15 mg/kg in children) BEFORE or WITH first antibiotic dose
Step 2: Blood cultures + bloods
- Draw BEFORE antibiotics if possible (but do NOT delay greater than 5 minutes)
- FBC, UEC, CRP, lactate, coags, blood cultures × 2
Step 3: LP (after antibiotics started)
- Contraindications: Focal signs, papilledema, GCS below 12, coagulopathy → give antibiotics, do CT brain first
- Opening pressure: Measure in lateral decubitus (normal 10-25 cm H₂O)
- CSF tests: Cell count (WCC, RBC, differential), protein, glucose (paired with serum), Gram stain, culture, PCR (meningococcus, pneumococcus, HSV if encephalitis suspected)
Step 4: Supportive care
- Fluids: 0.9% saline to maintain euvolaemia (avoid fluid overload, which worsens cerebral oedema)
- Steroids: Dexamethasone 10 mg IV Q6H for 4 days (reduces mortality in pneumococcal meningitis)
- Notify public health if meningococcal (notifiable disease; close contacts require chemoprophylaxis - rifampicin 600 mg BD for 2 days or ciprofloxacin 500 mg single dose)
Temporal Arteritis (Suspected)
Time-critical - irreversible blindness in 15-20% if untreated
Step 1: Immediate steroids (do NOT wait for biopsy)
- Methylprednisolone 1 g IV daily for 3 days (if visual symptoms)
OR
- Prednisolone 1 mg/kg PO (40-60 mg) daily (if no visual symptoms)
Step 2: Investigations
- ESR, CRP, FBC: Thrombocytosis (platelets greater than 400) + ESR greater than 50 + CRP greater than 10
- Temporal artery ultrasound: Halo sign (sensitivity 68%, specificity 91%) - arrange urgently if available
- Temporal artery biopsy: Gold standard (can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids) - arrange within 1 week
Step 3: Ophthalmology review
- Urgent if visual symptoms (within 24 hours)
- Fundoscopy: Anterior ischaemic optic neuropathy (pale, swollen disc), CRAO (pale retina, cherry-red spot)
Step 4: Discharge planning
- Steroid taper: Prednisolone 1 mg/kg daily for 4 weeks → slow taper over 12-18 months (guided by symptoms + ESR/CRP)
- PPI: Pantoprazole 40 mg daily (gastric protection)
- Bisphosphonate: Alendronate 70 mg weekly (osteoporosis prevention)
- Rheumatology follow-up: Within 1 week
Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH)
Step 1: Diagnosis
- Modified Dandy criteria: Symptoms of raised ICP (headache, papilledema, visual obscurations) + elevated LP opening pressure (greater than 25 cm H₂O) + normal brain imaging + normal CSF composition
- CT brain: Exclude mass, hydrocephalus; may show slit-like ventricles, empty sella, optic nerve sheath distension
Step 2: Urgent ophthalmology review
- Visual fields: Formal perimetry (enlarged blind spot, inferior nasal defect)
- Fundoscopy: Papilledema grading (Frisén scale 0-5)
- Optical coherence tomography (OCT): Quantify optic nerve swelling
Step 3: Treatment
- Acetazolamide 500 mg PO BD → titrate to 1-2 g/day (carbonic anhydrase inhibitor, reduces CSF production)
- Weight loss 5-10% (single most effective intervention)
- Furosemide 40 mg PO daily (adjunct if acetazolamide insufficient)
- Repeat LP if fulminant (rapidly progressive visual loss) to acutely lower pressure
Step 4: Neurosurgery review if refractory
- Optic nerve sheath fenestration (prevents blindness)
- VP shunt (CSF diversion)
- Venous sinus stenting (if stenosis identified on MRV)
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
Step 1: High-flow O₂ 15 L/min non-rebreather
- Half-life of COHb: Room air 4-6 hours, 100% O₂ 60-90 min, hyperbaric O₂ 20-30 min
Step 2: ABG + COHb level
- Mild: COHb 10-20% → headache, nausea
- Moderate: COHb 20-40% → confusion, syncope
- Severe: COHb greater than 40% → seizure, coma, cardiac arrest
Step 3: Hyperbaric oxygen indications
- COHb greater than 25%, pregnancy with COHb greater than 15%, neurological signs, cardiac ischaemia, loss of consciousness
- Contact: Hyperbaric unit (HBOT available in Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Brisbane, Adelaide)
Step 4: Source identification
- Home heaters, car exhaust, industrial exposure → notify public health, ensure safety before discharge
Pregnancy-Related Headache
Key conditions to exclude:
| Condition | Features | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-eclampsia/Eclampsia | BP ≥140/90, proteinuria, headache, visual changes, RUQ pain | Magnesium sulfate 4g IV loading → 1g/hr infusion, antihypertensives, obstetric review |
| CVST | Gradual onset, seizure, focal signs, papilledema (6× risk in pregnancy) | MRV, therapeutic anticoagulation (LMWH → warfarin) |
| PRES | Hypertension, visual changes, seizure, posterior white matter oedema on MRI | BP control (labetalol, hydralazine), magnesium, seizure Mx |
| Postpartum RCVS | Thunderclap days after delivery, vasoactive drug trigger | Avoid triggers, nimodipine, avoid steroids |
| Pituitary apoplexy | Sudden headache, visual field loss, hypotension (postpartum) | Hydrocortisone 100mg IV, MRI, neurosurgery |
Investigations in pregnancy:
- CT brain: Safe (fetal radiation dose below 0.01 mGy, teratogenic threshold 50-100 mGy); shield abdomen
- MRI: Safe (avoid gadolinium in first trimester)
- LP: Safe (use lowest effective insertion point - L4/5 or below)
Disposition
Admission Criteria
Mandatory admission:
- SAH confirmed → ICU or neurosurgical HDU (aneurysm securing, nimodipine, neuro obs)
- Bacterial meningitis → ICU or medical ward (IV antibiotics 10-14 days)
- GCA with visual symptoms → medical ward (IV methylprednisolone, ophthalmology review)
- Raised ICP (mass lesion, IIH with severe papilledema) → neurosurgical ward
- CVST → stroke unit (anticoagulation, monitor for deterioration)
- CO poisoning COHb greater than 25% → medical ward (hyperbaric oxygen, extended observation)
- Pre-eclampsia/eclampsia → obstetric HDU (magnesium, BP control, delivery planning)
ICU/HDU Criteria
- GCS below 13
- SAH with Hunt-Hess grade ≥3 (somnolent, confused, or worse)
- Bacterial meningitis with shock (SBP below 90, lactate greater than 2)
- Raised ICP requiring ICP monitoring (mass lesion, hydrocephalus)
- Seizure not controlled with first-line therapy
- CO poisoning with cardiac ischaemia or arrhythmia
- Eclampsia (seizures in pregnancy)
Discharge Criteria
Safe discharge if ALL of:
- CT brain normal AND LP normal (if performed)
- No red flags present (or adequately investigated and excluded)
- GCS 15, no focal neurology
- Vital signs normal (afebrile, normotensive, HR 60-100)
- Pain controlled with oral analgesia
- Able to tolerate oral fluids
- Follow-up arranged (GP within 48 hours, specialist if indicated)
Red flags to return:
- Fever, neck stiffness, rash
- Worsening headache, confusion, weakness, seizure
- Vision changes, diplopia
- Vomiting preventing oral intake
- Any new concerning symptom
Follow-up
- SAH: Neurosurgery outpatient 2-4 weeks post-discharge (aneurysm follow-up imaging at 3-6 months)
- Temporal arteritis: Rheumatology within 1 week (temporal artery biopsy if not done, steroid taper plan)
- IIH: Ophthalmology within 1 week (visual fields, OCT repeat), neurology within 2-4 weeks
- Meningitis: Infectious diseases 4-6 weeks post-discharge (hearing test, neurological sequelae assessment)
- Primary thunderclap headache: Neurology within 2-4 weeks (CTA/MRA to exclude RCVS)
- RCVS: Neurology within 1-2 weeks, repeat CTA/MRA at 3 months to confirm resolution
- GP letter: Include diagnosis, investigations performed, medications started, follow-up plan, red flags to return
Special Populations
Paediatric Considerations
Age-specific modifications:
- Headache red flags in children: Age below 5 years with new headache (mass lesion, hydrocephalus), vomiting on waking (raised ICP), personality change (frontal lobe tumour, encephalitis), failure to thrive (chronic illness)
- Bacterial meningitis: Bulging fontanelle (infants), irritability, high-pitched cry, refusal to feed
- CT brain: Minimize radiation (consider MRI if stable); dose reduction protocols
- LP: Paediatric dosing ceftriaxone 50 mg/kg IV, dexamethasone 0.15 mg/kg IV
Pregnancy
Pregnancy-specific headache red flags:
- Pre-eclampsia: BP ≥140/90 + proteinuria + headache (frontal, throbbing) + visual changes (scotomata) → magnesium sulfate 4 g IV loading, obstetric review
- CVST: 6× higher risk in pregnancy/postpartum (hypercoagulable state) → MRV, therapeutic anticoagulation
- PRES: Hypertension + headache + seizure + visual disturbance → BP control (labetalol, hydralazine), MRI (posterior white matter oedema)
- Pituitary apoplexy: Enlarged pituitary in pregnancy → sudden headache, vision loss, ophthalmoplegia → urgent endocrine/neurosurgery
- SAH: Unchanged risk in pregnancy; CT brain is safe (fetal radiation dose below 0.01 mGy); LP is safe
Investigations in pregnancy:
- CT brain: Safe (fetal radiation dose below 0.01 mGy, teratogenic threshold 50-100 mGy); shield abdomen
- MRI: Safe (avoid gadolinium in first trimester)
- LP: Safe (use lowest effective insertion point - L4/5 or below)
Elderly
Geriatric considerations:
- Lower threshold for CT brain: Age greater than 65 with new headache (subdural, mass lesion common)
- Subdural haematoma: High risk if anticoagulated, falls, dementia (may present with confusion, not headache)
- Temporal arteritis: Exclusively greater than 50 years (peak incidence 70-80 years)
- Meningitis: Higher mortality (30-50% in greater than 60 years vs 15% in below 60 years); less likely to have classic triad (fever, headache, neck stiffness)
- Polypharmacy: Review medications (anticoagulants, antiplatelets increase ICH risk)
Indigenous Health
Important Note: Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, and Māori considerations:
Health disparities:
- Bacterial meningitis: 2-3× higher incidence in Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander Australians (overcrowding, lower vaccination rates, smoking, comorbidities) [47]
- Stroke: 2-3× higher incidence in Indigenous Australians; younger age of onset (mean 52 vs 75 years) [48]
- Rheumatic heart disease: Higher rates in Indigenous populations → increased risk infective endocarditis → brain abscess
- Diabetes: 3-4× higher prevalence → increased infection risk (meningitis, abscess)
- Smoking: Higher rates → increased stroke risk (haemorrhagic, ischaemic)
- Delayed presentation: Geographic isolation, transport barriers, cultural reluctance to seek care → more severe presentations
Cultural safety:
- Family-centred care: Involve family/community in decision-making (collectivist culture vs Western individualism)
- Interpreter services: Arrange Aboriginal Liaison Officer (ALO) or Māori health worker if language barrier
- Shame: Avoid direct questioning about sensitive topics (alcohol, substance use) - build rapport first
- Health literacy: Explain investigations in plain language (avoid medical jargon); use diagrams
- Mistrust of healthcare system: Acknowledge historical trauma (Stolen Generations); build trust through respectful communication
- Sorry Business: Be aware that patients may need to leave for cultural obligations (funerals, ceremonies)
- Men's/Women's Business: Some health issues may only be discussed with same-gender healthcare provider
Māori-specific (NZ):
- Whānau involvement: Family (whānau) integral to care - involve in all decisions
- Tikanga: Māori cultural protocols (e.g., avoid cutting hair for temporal artery biopsy without discussion)
- Kaumātua: Elders may guide healthcare decisions - involve if patient wishes
- Te Whare Tapa Whā: Māori health model incorporating physical (taha tinana), mental (taha hinengaro), spiritual (taha wairua), and family (taha whānau) dimensions
Remote/Rural Considerations
Pre-Hospital
Challenges in remote/rural Australia:
- Delayed presentation: Median 24-48 hours from symptom onset to ED arrival (vs 2-6 hours in metro)
- Limited ambulance resources: Single ambulance for vast area (100-500 km radius); long transfer times (1-4 hours)
- Telemedicine triage: Remote Area Nurse (RAN) + Royal Flying Doctor Service (RFDS) telehealth consultation to determine retrieval urgency
Retrieval criteria for headache:
- Thunderclap headache → RFDS urgent retrieval (Code 1)
- Focal neurology → RFDS urgent retrieval
- GCS below 15 → RFDS urgent retrieval
- Suspected meningitis → Give empiric antibiotics (ceftriaxone 2 g IV) THEN retrieve
- Age greater than 50 new headache + ESR greater than 50 → Give steroids (prednisolone 50 mg PO) THEN arrange non-urgent transfer for temporal artery biopsy
Resource-Limited Setting
Modified approach when CT/LP unavailable:
No CT brain available:
- Thunderclap headache: Telemedicine consult with neurologist → empiric nimodipine 60 mg PO Q4H + urgent RFDS retrieval for CT/CTA
- Suspected meningitis: Empiric antibiotics (ceftriaxone 2 g IV + vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg IV + dexamethasone 10 mg IV) → RFDS retrieval for LP
- Suspected GCA: Empiric prednisolone 1 mg/kg PO → arrange transfer for temporal artery ultrasound/biopsy
No LP kit available:
- Suspected meningitis: Give antibiotics (ceftriaxone 2 g IV) → RFDS retrieval for LP at receiving hospital (CSF culture may still be positive up to 72h post-antibiotics if pre-treated)
Cold chain for medications:
- Ceftriaxone: Stable at room temperature for 3 days (once reconstituted, refrigerate and use within 24h)
- Nimodipine: Store below 25°C (away from direct sunlight)
Retrieval
RFDS retrieval considerations:
Priority codes:
- Code 1 (emergency): Thunderclap, GCS below 13, focal neurology, seizure → aircraft dispatched immediately (ETA 1-2 hours)
- Code 2 (urgent): Suspected meningitis post-antibiotics, suspected SAH with normal GCS → aircraft dispatched within 4 hours
- Code 3 (non-urgent): GCA for temporal artery biopsy, IIH for ophthalmology review → arrange fixed-wing transfer within 24 hours
In-flight management:
- SAH: Maintain SBP below 160 mmHg (labetalol 10-20 mg IV PRN); head of bed 30° (reduce ICP); nimodipine 60 mg NG Q4H; prepare for intubation if GCS deteriorates
- Meningitis: Continue IV antibiotics during flight; 0.9% saline infusion; dexamethasone 10 mg IV Q6H
- Raised ICP: Intubate if GCS below 8; hyperventilate to PaCO₂ 30-35 mmHg (acutely reduces ICP); mannitol 0.5-1 g/kg IV or hypertonic saline 3% 2-5 mL/kg IV
Receiving hospital preparation:
- Notify neurosurgery (if SAH suspected - may need aneurysm coiling/clipping)
- Notify ICU (if GCS below 13 or ventilated)
- Book CT brain (if not done at referring hospital)
Telemedicine
Remote consultation model:
- Headache + red flags: RAN assesses patient → sends photo (rash, pupils), vital signs, brief history to RFDS duty doctor via telehealth
- RFDS doctor: Reviews case → advises empiric treatment (antibiotics for meningitis, steroids for GCA) → arranges retrieval
- Follow-up: RFDS outreach clinic visits remote communities 6-12 weekly (post-discharge follow-up for temporal arteritis, IIH)
Limitations:
- Fundoscopy: Difficult via telemedicine (RAN may not have ophthalmoscope training) - rely on clinical features (vision loss, headache)
- LP: Cannot be performed remotely - requires retrieval or GP proceduralist visit
Pitfalls & Pearls
Clinical Pearls:
-
"Normal CT does NOT exclude SAH" - Sensitivity 98-100% at 6 hours, but falls to 93% at 24 hours, 50% at 1 week. LP is mandatory after negative CT for thunderclap headache (xanthochromia detectable 12h-2wks).
-
"Do NOT wait for LP to give antibiotics in meningitis" - Mortality increases 15% per hour delay. If LP delayed greater than 30 min (due to coagulopathy, focal signs, or unavailable), give antibiotics FIRST (ceftriaxone 2 g IV + vancomycin if age greater than 50 + dexamethasone 10 mg IV).
-
"ESR normal in 20% of temporal arteritis" - Normal ESR does NOT exclude GCA. Clinical suspicion (new headache greater than 50, jaw claudication, vision loss, temporal artery tenderness) trumps labs. Start steroids immediately (methylprednisolone 1 g IV if visual symptoms).
-
"Xanthochromia requires spectrophotometry" - Visual inspection misses 50% of xanthochromia. Spectrophotometry detects bilirubin peak (438 nm) and oxyhaemoglobin (415 nm) - gold standard. LP should be ≥12 hours post-headache onset (allow bilirubin to form from RBC breakdown).
-
"Classic meningitis triad present in only 44%" - Fever + headache + neck stiffness has 44% sensitivity. Jolt accentuation (worsening headache with horizontal head shake) has 97% sensitivity but 60% specificity. Any two features in unwell patient warrants LP.
-
"Do NOT LP if papilledema or focal signs" - Risk of herniation (coning). CT brain FIRST to exclude mass lesion. If mass present, involve neurosurgery before LP.
-
"Sentinel headache precedes 30-50% of SAH" - Mild "warning leak" headache days-weeks before major bleed. Do NOT dismiss as migraine/tension headache in patient with no prior headache history.
-
"Temporal artery biopsy can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids" - Do NOT delay steroids waiting for biopsy. Start prednisolone 1 mg/kg immediately, arrange biopsy within 1 week (skip lesions require 2-3 cm length).
-
"IIH is a diagnosis of exclusion" - Must exclude CVST (MRV), mass lesion (MRI), medications (tetracycline, vitamin A, steroids), endocrine (Addison's, hypoparathyroid) before diagnosing IIH.
-
"RCVS - avoid steroids and triptans" - Unlike PACNS, steroids may worsen RCVS. Triptans and ergots are contraindicated (worsen vasoconstriction). Use nimodipine and supportive care.
Pitfalls to Avoid:
-
Discharging thunderclap headache after negative CT - CT sensitivity for SAH is 98-100% at 6h but falls to 50% at 1 week. LP is MANDATORY after negative CT (xanthochromia detectable 12h-2wks). Missed SAH has 50% mortality.
-
Delaying antibiotics for LP in suspected meningitis - "Door-to-antibiotic" time should be below 60 min. If LP delayed (coagulopathy, focal signs, CT brain needed), give antibiotics FIRST. Mortality increases 15% per hour delay.
-
Reassuring patient with normal ESR in suspected GCA - Normal ESR in 20% of biopsy-proven GCA. Clinical suspicion (age greater than 50, new headache, jaw claudication, vision loss) trumps labs. Start steroids immediately.
-
Performing LP in patient with papilledema - Papilledema = raised ICP. LP can cause herniation (coning) if mass lesion present. CT brain FIRST to exclude mass.
-
Missing CO poisoning in "flu-like illness" with headache - CO poisoning presents as headache, nausea, fatigue (mimics viral illness). Check COHb in winter presentations (home heater exposure). Multiple household members affected = strong clue.
-
Diagnosing "migraine" in patient with first-ever headache - Migraine is a diagnosis of exclusion requiring recurrent episodes. New-onset severe headache requires full red flag assessment + CT brain.
-
Relying on neck stiffness to exclude meningitis - Neck stiffness has only 62% sensitivity. Fever + headache + altered mental status is sufficient for empiric antibiotics + LP.
-
Discharging thunderclap headache with "negative CTA" - CTA misses non-aneurysmal SAH (15-20% of SAH). LP is still required to detect xanthochromia.
-
Using visual inspection for xanthochromia - Visual inspection misses 50% of xanthochromia. Spectrophotometry is gold standard (detects bilirubin 12h-2wks post-bleed).
-
Giving steroids for suspected RCVS - Steroids may worsen RCVS (unlike PACNS). Use nimodipine, avoid triptans/ergots, supportive care.
Viva Practice
Stem: A 52-year-old woman presents with sudden-onset severe headache that started 3 hours ago while straining on the toilet. She describes it as "the worst headache of my life" and it reached maximal intensity within 30 seconds. She has vomited twice. GCS 15, BP 165/95, HR 88, afebrile. No focal neurology. CT brain non-contrast performed and reported as normal.
Opening Question: What is your immediate management?
Model Answer: "This is a thunderclap headache, which is subarachnoid haemorrhage until proven otherwise. The key features are sudden onset (below 1 minute to peak), severe pain, triggered by Valsalva (straining), and described as 'worst headache of life.'
Even though the CT brain is normal, I cannot exclude SAH. CT sensitivity for SAH is 98-100% in the first 6 hours, but this patient presented 3 hours post-onset, so CT is highly sensitive. However, CT misses 2-5% of SAH even in the first 6 hours, and sensitivity falls to 93% at 24 hours and 50% at 1 week.
My immediate management is:
- Keep patient NBM, continue IV access
- Analgesia (paracetamol 1g IV, fentanyl 25-50 mcg IV titrated)
- Antiemetic (ondansetron 4-8 mg IV)
- Blood pressure control - target SBP below 160 mmHg with labetalol 10-20 mg IV boluses
- Arrange lumbar puncture now (3 hours post-onset is too early for xanthochromia - ideally wait ≥12 hours, but can proceed and use spectrophotometry)
- Involve neurosurgery now (even before LP results, as SAH is highly likely)
- If LP positive (xanthochromia or elevated RBC count with equal distribution in tubes 1-4), arrange CTA brain to identify aneurysm source"
Follow-up Questions:
-
The RAN from a remote clinic calls you. They have a patient with thunderclap headache but no CT scanner. What do you advise?
- Model answer: "This is a medical emergency requiring urgent RFDS retrieval. I would advise: (1) Keep patient NBM, IV access, IV fluids 0.9% saline; (2) Analgesia with IV morphine 2.5-5 mg; (3) Blood pressure control if SBP greater than 160 (labetalol 10 mg IV if available); (4) Do NOT perform LP remotely (risk of herniation if mass lesion); (5) Arrange urgent Code 1 RFDS retrieval for CT brain at tertiary centre; (6) Start nimodipine 60 mg PO/NG Q4H empirically (vasospasm prophylaxis); (7) During flight, maintain SBP below 160 mmHg, head of bed 30°; (8) I will notify receiving hospital neurosurgery and book CT brain."
-
The LP shows 5,000 RBCs in tube 1 and 2,500 RBCs in tube 4. The lab reports "no xanthochromia on visual inspection." What do you do?
- Model answer: "The decreasing RBC count (50% reduction from tube 1 to tube 4) suggests traumatic tap rather than SAH. However, visual inspection misses 50% of xanthochromia - I need spectrophotometry to definitively exclude SAH. I would: (1) Request spectrophotometry on the CSF (detects bilirubin peak at 438 nm, which appears 12h post-bleed and lasts 2 weeks); (2) If spectrophotometry unavailable, treat as SAH (arrange CTA brain, neurosurgery consult); (3) Note that xanthochromia may not be present yet (only 3 hours post-onset) - if spectrophotometry negative, consider repeat LP at 12-24 hours post-onset OR proceed to CTA to look for aneurysm."
Discussion Points:
- SAH pearl: Sentinel headache (warning leak) precedes 30-50% of major SAH. Never dismiss "worst headache" as migraine without full workup.
- CTA limitations: CTA misses 15-20% of non-aneurysmal SAH (perimesencephalic SAH). LP is still required even with negative CTA.
- Timing of nimodipine: Start immediately if SAH confirmed (reduces vasospasm 3-14 days post-bleed, improves neurological outcome). Dose 60 mg PO/NG Q4H for 21 days.
- RFDS retrieval: Thunderclap headache is Code 1 (emergency) retrieval. Remote areas may have 4-6 hour delay to CT/neurosurgery - empiric nimodipine and BP control essential during transfer.
Stem: A 68-year-old woman presents with 2-week history of bifrontal headache and jaw pain when eating. This morning she noticed blurred vision in her right eye. She has no prior headache history. On examination, the right temporal artery is tender and pulseless. Visual acuity: right 6/60, left 6/6. Fundoscopy shows pale, swollen right optic disc. BP 145/82, afebrile, no focal neurology.
Opening Question: What is your diagnosis and immediate management?
Model Answer: "This is giant cell arteritis (temporal arteritis) with anterior ischaemic optic neuropathy - a medical emergency requiring immediate treatment to prevent permanent blindness in the affected eye and prevent involvement of the other eye.
The key diagnostic features are:
- Age greater than 50 (peak incidence 70-80 years)
- New headache with temporal artery tenderness and absent pulsation
- Jaw claudication (34% sensitivity, 98% specificity for GCA)
- Vision loss with pale, swollen optic disc (anterior ischaemic optic neuropathy)
My immediate management is:
- Start IV steroids immediately (do NOT wait for ESR/CRP or biopsy):
- Methylprednisolone 1 g IV daily for 3 days (visual symptoms present)
- This is sight-saving treatment - 15-20% risk of irreversible blindness if untreated
- Bloods: ESR, CRP, FBC (thrombocytosis), UEC, LFTs, BSL, HbA1c (pre-steroid baseline)
- Urgent ophthalmology review (within 4 hours if available):
- Formal visual fields (Humphrey perimetry)
- Optical coherence tomography (OCT)
- Fundoscopy (document degree of optic nerve swelling)
- Arrange temporal artery biopsy (within 1 week):
- Can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids (do NOT delay steroids)
- Requires 2-3 cm length (skip lesions common)
- Temporal artery ultrasound (if available): Halo sign (hypoechoic wall thickening)
- Admit medical ward for 3 days of IV methylprednisolone, then switch to oral prednisolone 1 mg/kg
- Rheumatology consult for steroid taper plan (typically 12-18 months)
After 3 days IV methylprednisolone, switch to oral prednisolone 1 mg/kg (50-60 mg) daily, then slow taper guided by symptoms and ESR/CRP."
Follow-up Questions:
-
The ESR comes back at 35 mm/h (normal below 20). Does this exclude temporal arteritis?
- Model answer: "No. ESR is normal in 20% of biopsy-proven GCA. CRP is more sensitive (elevated in 85%). I would still start IV steroids immediately based on the clinical picture (jaw claudication, vision loss, tender temporal artery, optic disc swelling). If both ESR and CRP are normal, GCA is excluded in below 5% of cases. Clinical suspicion trumps labs. I would proceed with temporal artery biopsy to confirm diagnosis."
-
Should you do a temporal artery biopsy in ED before starting steroids?
- Model answer: "No. Temporal artery biopsy is NOT an ED procedure. It requires ophthalmology or vascular surgery and can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids (inflammatory changes persist despite treatment). The priority is immediate IV steroids to prevent blindness in the second eye - 15-20% risk of bilateral involvement if untreated. I arrange biopsy as outpatient within 1 week."
-
The patient is from a remote community 600 km away. How do you manage?
- Model answer: "Remote management: (1) Start oral prednisolone 1 mg/kg (50-60 mg) immediately (IV methylprednisolone not available remotely); (2) Send bloods (ESR, CRP, FBC) via RFDS mail run; (3) Arrange non-urgent RFDS transfer (Code 3) for temporal artery biopsy and ophthalmology review within 1 week; (4) Educate patient on red flags to return (sudden vision loss in other eye, new neurological symptoms); (5) Arrange RFDS outreach clinic follow-up in 4-6 weeks for steroid taper plan."
Discussion Points:
- Irreversibility of vision loss: Once optic nerve infarction occurs, it is permanent. Time to treatment is critical.
- Bilateral involvement: 15-20% risk of second eye involvement within days-weeks if untreated. IV steroids reduce this risk.
- Steroid side effects: Long-term steroids (12-18 months) require PPI (pantoprazole 40 mg), bisphosphonate (alendronate 70 mg weekly), calcium/vitamin D, monitoring for diabetes, hypertension, osteoporosis.
- ACEM domain: Medical Expert (recognize GCA, start treatment), Communicator (explain need for steroids and long taper), Leader (prioritize sight-saving treatment over investigations).
Stem: A 24-year-old university student presents with 12-hour history of headache, fever, and vomiting. He is drowsy but rousable (GCS 14 - E4 V4 M6). Temperature 39.2°C, HR 118, BP 105/68, RR 22. Neck is stiff. No rash. No focal neurology.
Opening Question: What is your diagnosis and immediate management?
Model Answer: "This is bacterial meningitis until proven otherwise - a time-critical emergency where mortality increases 15% per hour delay in antibiotics.
The key features are:
- Fever (39.2°C) + headache + neck stiffness (classic triad - present in only 44% of meningitis)
- Altered mental status (GCS 14)
- No rash (petechial rash seen in only 50-80% of meningococcal meningitis)
The absence of the classic triad does NOT exclude meningitis. Any two of fever/headache/neck stiffness/altered mental status in an unwell patient warrants empiric antibiotics and LP.
My immediate management is:
- Empiric antibiotics within 30 minutes (do NOT wait for LP):
- Ceftriaxone 2 g IV (covers pneumococcus, meningococcus)
- Dexamethasone 10 mg IV (give BEFORE or WITH first antibiotic dose - reduces mortality in pneumococcal meningitis)
- Consider adding vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg IV if greater than 50 years or immunocompromised (covers Listeria)
- Bloods: FBC, UEC, CRP, lactate, blood cultures × 2 (draw before antibiotics if possible, but do NOT delay greater than 5 min)
- IV fluids: 0.9% saline 20 mL/kg bolus (patient is tachycardic, tachypnoeic - likely septic)
- CT brain before LP (GCS 14 is below 15 - risk of mass lesion or raised ICP causing herniation with LP):
- Indications for CT before LP: GCS below 15, focal signs, papilledema, seizure, immunocompromised
- LP after CT (if no mass lesion):
- Opening pressure (lateral decubitus), cell count, protein, glucose, Gram stain, culture, PCR (pneumococcus, meningococcus)
- Notify public health if meningococcal confirmed (notifiable disease; close contacts need chemoprophylaxis)
- Admit ICU or medical ward for IV antibiotics 10-14 days, supportive care
Key principle: Door-to-antibiotic time below 60 minutes. If LP is delayed (CT brain needed, coagulopathy, difficult procedure), give antibiotics FIRST. CSF culture remains positive up to 72 hours post-antibiotics."
Follow-up Questions:
-
You are a GP in a remote clinic. The patient is 400 km from nearest hospital. CT and LP not available. What do you do?
- Model answer: "Remote management: (1) Give antibiotics immediately - ceftriaxone 2 g IV + dexamethasone 10 mg IV (do NOT delay for transfer); (2) IV fluids 0.9% saline 1 L over 1 hour; (3) Paracetamol 1 g IV for fever; (4) Call RFDS for urgent Code 1 retrieval (arrange with RFDS doctor); (5) During transfer: continue IV fluids, give second dose ceftriaxone 2 g IV at 12 hours, monitor GCS; (6) Do NOT attempt LP remotely (risk of herniation, procedure complications in unstable patient); (7) Notify receiving hospital to arrange LP on arrival (CSF culture still positive up to 72h post-antibiotics)."
-
The patient's university flatmates are worried. Do they need prophylaxis?
- Model answer: "It depends on the organism. If meningococcal (Gram-negative diplococci on CSF Gram stain, or PCR positive), close contacts require chemoprophylaxis within 24 hours: (1) Rifampicin 600 mg PO BD for 2 days, OR ciprofloxacin 500 mg single dose; (2) Close contacts = household, kissing contacts, healthcare workers exposed to respiratory secretions without mask; (3) Casual contacts (same lecture theatre, not household) do NOT need prophylaxis; (4) Public health notifies contacts and arranges chemoprophylaxis. If pneumococcal, no prophylaxis needed."
-
The LP shows: Opening pressure 35 cm H₂O, WCC 2,500 (90% neutrophils), protein 2.5 g/L, glucose 1.2 mmol/L (serum 5.5). What is the interpretation?
- Model answer: "This is bacterial meningitis confirmed. Key findings: (1) Elevated opening pressure (normal 10-25 cm H₂O); (2) Pleocytosis with neutrophil predominance (WCC greater than 1,000 cells/µL suggests bacterial; below 1,000 suggests viral/TB/fungal); (3) Elevated protein (normal below 0.45 g/L); (4) Low CSF glucose (CSF:serum ratio below 0.4 suggests bacterial, TB, or fungal). I would continue ceftriaxone 2 g IV Q12H + dexamethasone 10 mg IV Q6H for 4 days. Await Gram stain and culture for organism identification. If Gram-positive cocci (pneumococcus), continue ceftriaxone. If Gram-negative diplococci (meningococcus), notify public health for contact tracing."
Discussion Points:
- Jolt accentuation test: Sensitivity 97%, specificity 60% for meningitis. Patient shakes head horizontally 2-3 times/second - if headache worsens, test is positive. Cannot be used if neck stiffness prevents movement.
- Kernig's and Brudzinski's signs: Low sensitivity (5%) but high specificity. Absence does NOT exclude meningitis.
- Steroid timing: Dexamethasone must be given BEFORE or WITH first antibiotic dose (reduces mortality 15-30% in pneumococcal meningitis). No benefit if given after antibiotics.
- LP contraindications: Focal signs, papilledema, GCS below 12, coagulopathy (platelets below 50, INR greater than 1.5). If contraindicated, give antibiotics and do CT brain first.
Stem: A 32-year-old woman who is 36 weeks pregnant presents with severe frontal headache for 6 hours. She has noticed visual disturbance (flashing lights). BP 165/105 mmHg, HR 92, urine dipstick shows 3+ protein. She is alert but anxious. No focal neurology.
Opening Question: What is your diagnosis and immediate management?
Model Answer: "This is pre-eclampsia with severe features - a medical emergency in pregnancy requiring immediate management to prevent maternal seizures (eclampsia), stroke, and fetal compromise.
The key diagnostic features are:
- Third trimester pregnancy (36 weeks)
- Severe hypertension (BP ≥160/110)
- Proteinuria (3+)
- Severe headache + visual disturbance (warning signs of imminent eclampsia)
My immediate management is:
- Magnesium sulfate for seizure prophylaxis (reduces eclampsia risk by 50%):
- Loading dose: 4 g IV over 20 minutes
- Maintenance: 1 g/hour IV infusion
- Continue for 24-48 hours post-delivery or until stable
- Antihypertensive to reduce BP to safe range (target below 160/110):
- Labetalol 20 mg IV, repeat every 20 min (max 300 mg)
- OR Hydralazine 5-10 mg IV every 20 min
- Urgent obstetric review - this patient will likely require delivery (definitive treatment for pre-eclampsia)
- Continuous fetal monitoring (CTG)
- IV access, bloods: FBC (platelets - HELLP), LFTs (HELLP), UEC (renal function), coagulation screen
- Fluid restriction: 80 mL/hour (avoid pulmonary oedema)
- Insert IDC for strict fluid balance and urine output monitoring
If seizure occurs (eclampsia):
- Additional magnesium sulfate 2-4 g IV
- Left lateral position
- Protect airway
- Do NOT use diazepam as first-line (magnesium is preferred)"
Follow-up Questions:
-
She asks if she can have a CT brain. Is it safe?
- Model answer: "Yes, CT brain is safe in pregnancy. The fetal radiation dose from a head CT is below 0.01 mGy, which is far below the teratogenic threshold of 50-100 mGy. However, in this clinical scenario, she has pre-eclampsia with headache and visual changes - this is the expected presentation and CT is unlikely to change management. I would only perform CT brain if there were atypical features (focal neurology, seizure, altered consciousness) that suggest alternative diagnoses like intracranial haemorrhage or CVST."
-
She has a seizure. How do you manage?
- Model answer: "This is eclampsia. Management: (1) Call for help; (2) Left lateral position (avoid IVC compression); (3) Protect airway; (4) Give additional magnesium sulfate 2-4 g IV over 5 minutes; (5) If seizure continues despite magnesium, give diazepam 5-10 mg IV OR lorazepam 4 mg IV; (6) High-flow O₂; (7) Urgent obstetric and anaesthetic review for emergency delivery (likely category 1 caesarean section); (8) If GCS remains below 8, intubation may be required; (9) Control BP (labetalol IV); (10) Consider CT brain if neurological deficit persists post-ictal."
-
What are the differential diagnoses for headache in late pregnancy?
- Model answer: "Pregnancy-specific: (1) Pre-eclampsia/eclampsia (this patient); (2) HELLP syndrome (haemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, low platelets); (3) CVST - 6× higher risk in pregnancy/postpartum; (4) PRES (posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome); (5) Postpartum RCVS. Non-pregnancy-specific: (1) SAH (risk unchanged in pregnancy); (2) Migraine (may change pattern in pregnancy); (3) Tension-type headache. The key differentiator here is the triad of hypertension, proteinuria, and third trimester - this is pre-eclampsia."
Discussion Points:
- Magnesium sulfate monitoring: Monitor reflexes (loss = toxicity), RR (depress if below 12), urine output (reduce dose if below 30 mL/hour). Calcium gluconate 1 g IV is antidote.
- HELLP syndrome: Haemolysis (LDH greater than 600), Elevated Liver enzymes (AST greater than 70), Low Platelets (below 100). May present with RUQ pain, headache. Requires urgent delivery.
- CVST in pregnancy: 6× higher risk. Consider if headache is gradual onset, seizure present, or papilledema. Requires MRV and therapeutic anticoagulation (LMWH, then warfarin postpartum).
- ACEM domain: Medical Expert (recognize pre-eclampsia), Collaborator (work with obstetrics, anaesthetics), Leader (coordinate emergency delivery).
OSCE Scenarios
Station 1: Focused Headache History (Thunderclap)
Format: History-taking Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED cubicle
Candidate Instructions:
You are an emergency registrar. A 48-year-old woman has presented with sudden-onset severe headache. Take a focused history to identify red flags and formulate a management plan. You do NOT need to examine the patient.
Examiner Instructions: The candidate should systematically elicit thunderclap headache features, recognize SAH as the leading differential, and outline appropriate investigations (CT brain, LP). Key discriminators: timing of onset, Valsalva triggers, associated symptoms, past headache history.
Actor/Patient Brief: You are a 48-year-old office worker. You were at work this morning when you suddenly developed the worst headache of your life while bending down to pick up a pen. It came on within 30 seconds and was so severe you thought you were going to die. You vomited once. The pain is all over your head (diffuse). You have never had a headache like this before. You are worried it is a brain tumour. You have no other medical problems and take no medications. You are a non-smoker, social drinker.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Introduces self, confirms patient identity, explains purpose | /1 |
| History of Presenting Complaint | Onset (sudden, below 1 min to peak) | /1 |
| Severity ("worst headache of life") | /1 | |
| Triggers (Valsalva - bending, straining, cough, coitus) | /1 | |
| Associated symptoms (vomiting, photophobia, neck stiffness, vision changes, focal neurology) | /1 | |
| Red Flag Screen | Asks about previous headaches (new vs recurrent) | /1 |
| Screens for other red flags (age greater than 50, fever, trauma, seizure, immunocompromised) | /1 | |
| Differential Diagnosis | Recognizes SAH as leading diagnosis | /1 |
| Mentions alternative diagnoses (RCVS, dissection, primary thunderclap) | /1 | |
| Management Plan | Outlines investigations (CT brain STAT, LP if negative) | /1 |
| Explains need for LP even with negative CT (xanthochromia detectable 12h-2wks) | /1 | |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Eliciting thunderclap onset (below 1 min to peak), recognizing need for LP after negative CT, explaining xanthochromia timing
Station 2: Lumbar Puncture Procedure
Format: Procedural skill Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED procedure room with mannequin
Candidate Instructions:
You are an emergency registrar. A patient with thunderclap headache has had a normal CT brain. Perform a lumbar puncture on the mannequin. Explain each step to the examiner as you proceed.
Examiner Instructions: Candidate should demonstrate safe LP technique: patient positioning (lateral decubitus), aseptic technique, local anaesthetic, needle insertion (L3/4 or L4/5), measuring opening pressure before CSF withdrawal, collecting 4 tubes, and sending appropriate tests. Key errors: not measuring opening pressure, contaminating field, inserting needle without LA.
Equipment:
- LP mannequin
- LP kit (spinal needle 22G, manometer, 3-way tap, collection tubes)
- Sterile gloves, gown, drapes
- Chlorhexidine 2% skin prep
- 1% lidocaine 5 mL, 25G needle, 5 mL syringe
- Dressing
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Explains procedure to patient, obtains verbal consent, checks contraindications (coagulopathy, papilledema) | /2 |
| Positioning | Positions patient in lateral decubitus, knees to chest, back at edge of bed, ensures spine horizontal | /1 |
| Asepsis | Washes hands, dons sterile gloves/gown, preps skin with chlorhexidine (wide area), applies sterile drape | /2 |
| Local Anaesthetic | Identifies L3/4 or L4/5 space (iliac crest line), infiltrates LA (subcutaneous then deeper), waits 2 min | /1 |
| Needle Insertion | Inserts spinal needle at L3/4 or L4/5, angles 10-15° cephalad, advances slowly, removes stylet to check for CSF | /2 |
| Opening Pressure | Attaches manometer BEFORE withdrawing CSF, measures opening pressure in lateral decubitus (records cm H₂O) | /1 |
| CSF Collection | Collects 4 tubes (1-2 mL each), labels tubes 1-4 sequentially | /1 |
| Post-Procedure | Replaces stylet before removing needle, applies dressing, positions patient supine for 1 hour | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Measuring opening pressure BEFORE CSF withdrawal (critical for raised ICP diagnosis), aseptic technique, correct spinal level identification
Station 3: Breaking Bad News (SAH Diagnosis)
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED relatives room
Candidate Instructions:
You are an emergency registrar. A 52-year-old woman presented with thunderclap headache. CT brain shows subarachnoid haemorrhage. Her husband is waiting in the relatives room. Explain the diagnosis and management plan.
Examiner Instructions: Candidate should use structured approach (SPIKES protocol): Set-up (private room, ask what patient knows), Perception (elicit understanding), Invitation (ask how much patient wants to know), Knowledge (explain SAH in plain language), Emotions (acknowledge concerns), Strategy/Summary (outline next steps). Key discriminators: avoids jargon, checks understanding, addresses emotions.
Actor/Relative Brief: You are the husband of the patient. You are worried it is a brain tumour (your mother died of brain cancer). You want to know: (1) What is wrong? (2) Will she die? (3) Will she need surgery? You are anxious but cooperative. If the doctor uses medical jargon (e.g. "subarachnoid haemorrhage"), ask "What does that mean?"
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Set-Up | Introduces self, confirms identity, sits down, ensures privacy, no interruptions | /1 |
| Perception | Elicits what patient/family already knows ("What have you been told so far?") | /1 |
| Knowledge | Explains diagnosis in plain language (bleeding around brain, not tumour) | /2 |
| Avoids jargon (or explains if used: "subarachnoid haemorrhage" = bleeding around brain) | /1 | |
| Outlines next steps (CT scan with dye, neurosurgery consult, possibly procedure to seal off bleeding) | /2 | |
| Emotions | Acknowledges concerns ("I can see this is very worrying for you") | /1 |
| Addresses specific fears (tumour vs bleed, prognosis, surgery) | /1 | |
| Summary | Summarizes key points, checks understanding ("Do you have any questions?") | /1 |
| Offers ongoing support (will update regularly, neurosurgeon will explain in detail) | /1 | |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Explains SAH in plain language (not medical jargon), addresses emotional concerns (fear of death, tumour), outlines clear next steps (neurosurgery, aneurysm treatment)
SAQ Practice
Question 1 (8 marks)
Stem: A 55-year-old man presents to ED with sudden-onset severe headache that came on over 30 seconds while lifting a heavy box. He describes it as "the worst headache of my life." CT brain non-contrast is reported as normal. It is now 4 hours since headache onset.
Question: Outline your management from this point, including investigations and their interpretation. (8 marks)
Model Answer:
- Lumbar puncture (LP) is mandatory after negative CT for thunderclap headache (1 mark)
- CT sensitivity for SAH is 98-100% at 6 hours but falls to 93% at 24 hours, 50% at 1 week - negative CT does NOT exclude SAH
- Timing of LP: Ideally wait ≥12 hours post-onset for xanthochromia to develop (1 mark)
- Xanthochromia (bilirubin from RBC breakdown) appears 12h post-bleed, peaks 1 week, detectable up to 2 weeks
- However, can proceed at 4 hours if using spectrophotometry (not visual inspection)
- LP technique: Lateral decubitus position, measure opening pressure BEFORE CSF withdrawal (1 mark)
- Collect 4 tubes (1-2 mL each), label sequentially
- CSF tests: Cell count (RBC, WCC in tubes 1 and 4), xanthochromia (spectrophotometry), protein, glucose, Gram stain (1 mark)
- Interpretation of results: (2 marks)
- SAH: RBC greater than 10,000 cells/µL, equal in tubes 1 and 4, xanthochromia positive (spectrophotometry)
- Traumatic tap: RBC decreases 50% from tube 1 to tube 4, xanthochromia negative, CSF may clot
- If LP positive (SAH confirmed): CTA brain to identify aneurysm source (1 mark)
- Neurosurgery consult STAT for aneurysm securing (coiling vs clipping within 24-72 hours) (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: LP can be performed at 4 hours with spectrophotometry (not visual inspection)
- Do not accept: "LP is not indicated if CT is normal" (incorrect - negative CT does NOT exclude SAH)
- Award partial marks for mentioning xanthochromia but not explaining timing (12h-2wks)
Question 2 (6 marks)
Stem: A 72-year-old woman presents with 3-week history of frontal headache and jaw pain when chewing. This morning she noticed blurred vision in her left eye. On examination, the left temporal artery is tender and pulseless. ESR is 95 mm/h, CRP 42 mg/L.
Question: List the immediate management steps in the ED. (6 marks)
Model Answer:
- Start IV steroids immediately (do NOT wait for biopsy): Methylprednisolone 1 g IV daily for 3 days (1 mark)
- Visual symptoms present = sight-threatening emergency
- Urgent ophthalmology review (within 4 hours): Formal visual fields, fundoscopy, OCT (1 mark)
- Bloods: ESR, CRP, FBC (thrombocytosis - platelets greater than 400), UEC, LFTs, BSL (pre-steroid baseline) (1 mark)
- Arrange temporal artery biopsy (within 1 week - can be done up to 2 weeks after starting steroids) (1 mark)
- Temporal artery ultrasound (if available): Halo sign (hypoechoic wall thickening) (1 mark)
- Admit medical ward for 3 days IV methylprednisolone, then switch to oral prednisolone 1 mg/kg + rheumatology follow-up (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: "High-dose steroids" (must specify IV route and dose for full marks)
- Do not accept: "Wait for biopsy before starting steroids" (incorrect - irreversible blindness risk)
- Award partial marks if mentions steroids but not IV methylprednisolone (oral prednisolone acceptable if IV unavailable, but suboptimal)
Question 3 (8 marks)
Stem: A 28-year-old man presents with 8-hour history of headache, fever (39.4°C), and vomiting. He is drowsy (GCS 14). Neck stiffness is present. No rash. It is now 45 minutes since arrival in ED.
Question: a) List the empiric antibiotic regimen you would give (include doses). (3 marks) b) Outline the investigations required and their timing relative to antibiotics. (5 marks)
Model Answer:
a) Empiric antibiotics (3 marks):
- Ceftriaxone 2 g IV (covers pneumococcus, meningococcus) (1 mark)
- Dexamethasone 10 mg IV (give BEFORE or WITH first antibiotic dose - reduces mortality in pneumococcal meningitis) (1 mark)
- Consider vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg IV if age greater than 50 or immunocompromised (covers Listeria, MRSA) (1 mark)
- Not required in this 28-year-old patient unless immunocompromised
b) Investigations and timing (5 marks):
- Blood cultures × 2 - draw BEFORE antibiotics if possible, but do NOT delay antibiotics greater than 5 minutes (1 mark)
- Bloods: FBC, UEC, CRP, lactate, coagulation screen (1 mark)
- CT brain BEFORE LP (GCS 14 is below 15 - contraindication to LP until mass lesion excluded) (1 mark)
- LP after CT (if no mass lesion): Opening pressure, cell count, protein, glucose, Gram stain, culture, PCR (1 mark)
- Timing: Antibiotics should be given within 60 minutes of arrival (door-to-antibiotic time below 60 min). If LP delayed (CT brain, coagulopathy), give antibiotics FIRST - CSF culture remains positive up to 72h post-antibiotics (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Vancomycin optional in this age group (full marks either way)
- Do not accept: "Do LP before antibiotics" (incorrect - mortality increases 15% per hour delay)
- Award partial marks if mentions CT brain but not as contraindication to LP with GCS below 15
Question 4 (6 marks)
Stem: You are working in a remote clinic 500 km from the nearest hospital. A 50-year-old woman presents with sudden-onset severe headache that started 2 hours ago. She is vomiting. GCS 15, BP 170/100, no focal neurology. No CT scanner available.
Question: Outline your immediate management and retrieval plan. (6 marks)
Model Answer:
- Keep patient NBM, IV access, IV fluids 0.9% saline (1 mark)
- Analgesia: Paracetamol 1 g IV (or PO if IV unavailable), morphine 2.5-5 mg IV titrated for pain (1 mark)
- Blood pressure control (target SBP below 160 mmHg): Labetalol 10-20 mg IV boluses if available (1 mark)
- Contact RFDS for urgent Code 1 retrieval (thunderclap headache = SAH until proven otherwise - time-critical) (1 mark)
- Start nimodipine 60 mg PO/NG Q4H empirically (vasospasm prophylaxis if SAH confirmed) (1 mark)
- During retrieval: Maintain SBP below 160 mmHg, head of bed 30°, continue IV fluids, repeat analgesia PRN. Notify receiving hospital neurosurgery and book CT brain STAT (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Morphine or fentanyl for analgesia (both acceptable)
- Do not accept: "Perform LP remotely" (incorrect - risk of herniation, requires CT brain first)
- Award partial marks if mentions retrieval but not Code 1 urgency (Code 1 = emergency, dispatched immediately)
Australian Guidelines
ARC/ANZCOR
While ANZCOR does not have specific headache guidelines, relevant ANZCOR references include:
- ANZCOR Guideline 11.10.2 - Stroke Recognition: FAST (Face-Arm-Speech-Time) assessment for stroke symptoms; headache is a red flag for haemorrhagic stroke (ICH, SAH)
- Key differences from AHA/ERC: Australian stroke guidelines emphasize telemedicine triage for remote/rural areas (RFDS consultation model); BP thresholds for thrombolysis differ (SBP below 185, DBP below 110 in Australia vs below 180/105 in USA)
Therapeutic Guidelines
Therapeutic Guidelines: Antibiotic (version 16, 2023):
Bacterial Meningitis Empiric Treatment:
- Age 3 months to 50 years: Ceftriaxone 2 g IV Q12H (or cefotaxime 2 g IV Q6H)
- Age greater than 50 years OR immunocompromised: Ceftriaxone 2 g IV Q12H + ampicillin 2 g IV Q4H (covers Listeria)
- Penicillin allergy: Vancomycin 25-30 mg/kg IV loading, then 15-20 mg/kg IV Q8-12H + moxifloxacin 400 mg IV daily
- Adjunctive dexamethasone: 10 mg IV Q6H for 4 days (give BEFORE or WITH first antibiotic dose)
Meningococcal Prophylaxis (Close Contacts):
- Rifampicin 600 mg PO BD for 2 days (adults), 10 mg/kg BD for 2 days (children)
- Ciprofloxacin 500 mg PO single dose (alternative if rifampicin contraindicated - pregnancy, drug interactions)
- Ceftriaxone 250 mg IM single dose (if oral therapy not possible)
State-Specific
NSW Health Clinical Guidelines:
- Suspected meningococcal disease: Benzylpenicillin 2.4 g IV (or 60 mg/kg in children) if below 30 min to hospital; otherwise proceed directly to hospital for ceftriaxone
- Notify public health: Meningococcal disease is notifiable within 24 hours (Public Health Unit 1300 066 055)
Victorian DHHS:
- Meningococcal prophylaxis: Public health coordinates contact tracing and chemoprophylaxis for close contacts (household, childcare, kissing contacts)
Queensland Health:
- Remote/rural meningitis: Royal Flying Doctor Service (RFDS) protocol: Give ceftriaxone 2 g IV + dexamethasone 10 mg IV BEFORE retrieval (do NOT wait for hospital transfer)
References
Guidelines
- Australian Resuscitation Council. ANZCOR Guideline 11.10.2: Stroke Recognition and Management. 2023. Available from: https://www.anzcor.org
- Therapeutic Guidelines Limited. Therapeutic Guidelines: Antibiotic. Version 16. Melbourne: Therapeutic Guidelines Limited; 2023.
- NSW Health. Infants and Children: Acute Management of Bacterial Meningitis. Sydney: NSW Health; 2022.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Headaches in over 12 s: diagnosis and management. Clinical guideline [CG150]. London: NICE; 2021.
- Do TP, Remmers A, Schytz HW, et al. Red and orange flags for secondary headaches in clinical practice: SNNOOP10 list. Neurology. 2019;92(3):134-144. PMID: 30567777
Key Evidence
- Perry JJ, Stiell IG, Sivilotti ML, et al. Clinical decision rules to rule out subarachnoid hemorrhage for acute headache. JAMA. 2013;310(12):1248-1255. PMID: 24065011
- Edlow JA, Panagos PD, Godwin SA, et al. Clinical policy: critical issues in the evaluation and management of adult patients presenting to the emergency department with acute headache. Ann Emerg Med. 2008;52(4):407-436. PMID: 18809105
- van de Beek D, de Gans J, Spanjaard L, et al. Clinical features and prognostic factors in adults with bacterial meningitis. N Engl J Med. 2004;351(18):1849-1859. PMID: 15509818
- Brouwer MC, Tunkel AR, van de Beek D. Epidemiology, diagnosis, and antimicrobial treatment of acute bacterial meningitis. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2010;23(3):467-492. PMID: 20610819
- Hasbun R, Abrahams J, Jekel J, Quagliarello VJ. Computed tomography of the head before lumbar puncture in adults with suspected meningitis. N Engl J Med. 2001;345(24):1727-1733. PMID: 11742046
Subarachnoid Haemorrhage
- Perry JJ, Stiell IG, Sivilotti ML, et al. Sensitivity of computed tomography performed within six hours of onset of headache for diagnosis of subarachnoid haemorrhage: prospective cohort study. BMJ. 2011;343:d4277. PMID: 21768192
- Dupont SA, Wijdicks EF, Lanzino G, Rabinstein AA. Aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage: an overview for the practicing neurologist. Semin Neurol. 2010;30(5):545-554. PMID: 21207348
- Connolly ES Jr, Rabinstein AA, Carhuapoma JR, et al. Guidelines for the management of aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage: a guideline for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association. Stroke. 2012;43(6):1711-1737. PMID: 22556195
- UK National External Quality Assessment Service for Immunochemistry Working Group. National guidelines for analysis of cerebrospinal fluid for bilirubin in suspected subarachnoid haemorrhage. Ann Clin Biochem. 2008;45(Pt 3):238-244. PMID: 18482910
- Dubosh NM, Bellolio MF, Rabinstein AA, Edlow JA. Sensitivity of Early Computed Tomography for Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Ann Emerg Med. 2016;67(6):751-760. PMID: 26830197
Thunderclap Headache and RCVS
- Schwedt TJ, Matharu MS, Dodick DW. Thunderclap headache. Lancet Neurol. 2006;5(7):621-631. PMID: 16781992
- Dilli E. Thunderclap headache. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep. 2014;14(4):437. PMID: 24643327
- Ducros A, Boukobza M, Porcher R, et al. The clinical and radiological spectrum of reversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome. A prospective series of 67 patients. Brain. 2007;130(Pt 12):3091-3101. PMID: 17215440
- Miller TR, Shivashankar R, Mossa-Basha M, Gandhi D. Reversible Cerebral Vasoconstriction Syndrome. Radiographics. 2015;35(7):1873-1894. PMID: 26466175
- Singhal AB, Hajj-Ali RA, Topcuoglu MA, et al. Reversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndromes: analysis of 139 cases. Arch Neurol. 2011;68(8):1005-1012. PMID: 21482916
Temporal Arteritis / Giant Cell Arteritis
- Hunder GG, Bloch DA, Michel BA, et al. The American College of Rheumatology 1990 criteria for the classification of giant cell arteritis. Arthritis Rheum. 1990;33(8):1122-1128. PMID: 2285402
- Ponte C, Grayson PC, Engel B, et al. 2022 American College of Rheumatology/EULAR classification criteria for giant cell arteritis. Arthritis Rheumatol. 2022;74(12):1881-1889. PMID: 36350072
- Hernández P, Al Jalbout N, Matza M, et al. Temporal Artery Ultrasound for the Diagnosis of Giant Cell Arteritis in the Emergency Department. Cureus. 2023;15(7):e42350. PMID: 37621789
- Hayreh SS. Ischemic optic neuropathy. Prog Retin Eye Res. 2009;28(1):34-62. PMID: 19063989
- Parikh M, Miller NR, Lee AG, et al. Prevalence of a normal C-reactive protein with an elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate in biopsy-proven giant cell arteritis. Ophthalmology. 2006;113(10):1842-1845. PMID: 16908059
Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension
- Mollan SP, Davies B, Silver NC, et al. Idiopathic intracranial hypertension: consensus guidelines on management. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2018;89(10):1088-1100. PMID: 29959146
- Friedman DI, Liu GT, Digre KB. Revised diagnostic criteria for the pseudotumor cerebri syndrome in adults and children. Neurology. 2013;81(13):1159-1165. PMID: 23966248
Bacterial Meningitis
- Wall EC, Chan JM, Gil E, Heyderman RS. Acute bacterial meningitis. Curr Opin Neurol. 2021;34(3):386-395. PMID: 33767093
- Hasbun R. Progress and Challenges in Bacterial Meningitis: A Review. JAMA. 2022;328(21):2147-2154. PMID: 36472590
- Davis LE. Acute Bacterial Meningitis. Continuum (Minneap Minn). 2018;24(5):1264-1283. PMID: 30273239
- Heckenberg SG, Brouwer MC, van de Beek D. Bacterial meningitis. Handb Clin Neurol. 2014;121:1361-1375. PMID: 24365425
- Roos KL, van de Beek D. Bacterial meningitis. Handb Clin Neurol. 2010;96:51-63. PMID: 20109674
- Rajapaksa S, Starr M. Meningococcal sepsis. Aust Fam Physician. 2010;39(5):276-278. PMID: 20485712
Headache Red Flags / SNOOP
- Do TP, Remmers A, Schytz HW, et al. Red and orange flags for secondary headaches in clinical practice: SNNOOP10 list. Neurology. 2019;92(3):134-144. PMID: 30891300
- Chu K, Kelly AM, Kuan WS, et al. Predictive performance of the common red flags in emergency department headache patients: a HEAD and HEAD-Colombia study. Emerg Med J. 2024;41(6):368-375. PMID: 38658053
- Grimaldi D, Nonino F, Cevoli S, et al. Risk stratification of non-traumatic headache in the emergency department. J Neurol. 2009;256(1):51-57. PMID: 19172382
- Viera AJ, Antono B. Acute Headache in Adults: A Diagnostic Approach. Am Fam Physician. 2022;106(3):260-268. PMID: 36126007
Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
- Rose JJ, Wang L, Xu Q, et al. Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Pathogenesis, Management, and Future Directions of Therapy. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2017;195(5):596-606. PMID: 28783981
- Weaver LK. Clinical practice. Carbon monoxide poisoning. N Engl J Med. 2009;360(12):1217-1225. PMID: 19297574
- Hampson NB, Piantadosi CA, Thom SR, Weaver LK. Practice recommendations in the diagnosis, management, and prevention of carbon monoxide poisoning. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2012;186(11):1095-1101. PMID: 23087025
Pregnancy-Related Headache
- Brewer J, Owens MY, Wallace K, et al. Posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome in 46 of 47 patients with eclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2013;208(6):468.e1-6. PMID: 23395926
- Lanska DJ, Kryscio RJ. Risk factors for peripartum and postpartum stroke and intracranial venous thrombosis. Stroke. 2000;31(6):1274-1282. PMID: 10835444
- Ducros A, Bousser MG. Reversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome. Pract Neurol. 2009;9(5):256-267. PMID: 19767676
CVST
- Saposnik G, Barinagarrementeria F, Brown RD Jr, et al. Diagnosis and management of cerebral venous thrombosis: a statement for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association. Stroke. 2011;42(4):1158-1192. PMID: 21293023
Lumbar Puncture
- Engelborghs S, Niemantsverdriet E, Struyfs H, et al. Consensus guidelines for lumbar puncture in patients with neurological diseases. Alzheimers Dement (Amst). 2017;8:111-126. PMID: 28603768
- Seehusen DA, Reeves MM, Fomin DA. Cerebrospinal fluid analysis. Am Fam Physician. 2003;68(6):1103-1108. PMID: 14524396
Emergency Headache Management
- Abraham MK, Chang WW. Subarachnoid Hemorrhage. Emerg Med Clin North Am. 2016;34(4):901-916. PMID: 27741994
- Pajor MJ, Long B, Koyfman A, Liang SY. High risk and low prevalence diseases: Adult bacterial meningitis. Am J Emerg Med. 2023;65:76-83. PMID: 36592564
Australian/Indigenous Health
- Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health performance framework 2020 summary report. Canberra: AIHW; 2020.
- Katzenellenbogen JM, Vos T, Somerford P, et al. Burden of stroke in Indigenous Western Australians: a study using data linkage. Stroke. 2011;42(6):1515-1521. PMID: 21493914
- Royal Flying Doctor Service. Annual Report 2022-2023. Sydney: RFDS; 2023.
- Azzopardi PS, Sawyer SM, Kowal E, et al. Health and wellbeing of Indigenous adolescents in Australia: a systematic synthesis of population data. Lancet. 2018;391(10122):766-782. PMID: 29477516
Frequently asked questions
Quick clarifications for common clinical and exam-facing questions.
What is the SNOOP mnemonic for headache red flags?
Systemic symptoms/signs, Neurological symptoms/signs, Onset sudden, Older age (greater than 50), Pattern change or recent onset. Updated to SNOOP4 and SNNOOP10 in recent literature.
When should I do a CT brain for headache?
Thunderclap onset, focal neurology, seizure, altered GCS, age greater than 50 with new headache, immunocompromised, anticoagulation, head trauma, papilledema, HIV-positive.
When is LP needed after negative CT in thunderclap headache?
Always. CT misses 2-5% of SAH in first 6 hours, rising to 50% after 1 week. LP detects xanthochromia (bilirubin from RBC breakdown) from 12 hours to 2 weeks post-bleed.
What are the major causes of thunderclap headache?
SAH (25%), RCVS (reversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome 39%), primary thunderclap headache (34%), CVST, cervical artery dissection, pituitary apoplexy, acute hypertensive crisis.
Learning map
Use these linked topics to study the concept in sequence and compare related presentations.
Prerequisites
Start here if you need the foundation before this topic.
- Lumbar Puncture Procedure
- Neurological Examination
Differentials
Competing diagnoses and look-alikes to compare.
- Subarachnoid Haemorrhage
- Bacterial Meningitis
- Giant Cell Arteritis