Subarachnoid Haemorrhage (SAH)
Subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) accounts for 5% of strokes but carries disproportionate mortality (40-50% at 30 days) and... ACEM Fellowship Written, ACEM Fellow
Clinical board
A visual summary of the highest-yield teaching signals on this page.
Urgent signals
Safety-critical features pulled from the topic metadata.
- Thunderclap headache - worst headache of life, peak intensity below 1 minute
- Painful 3rd nerve palsy (eye down-and-out, dilated fixed pupil)
- Sudden loss of consciousness at headache onset
- Seizure at presentation (10-25%)
Exam focus
Current exam surfaces linked to this topic.
- ACEM Fellowship Written
- ACEM Fellowship OSCE
Linked comparisons
Differentials and adjacent topics worth opening next.
- Bacterial Meningitis
- Cervical Artery Dissection
Editorial and exam context
Topic family
This concept exists in multiple MedVellum libraries. Use the primary page for the broadest reference view and the others for exam-specific framing.
Subarachnoid Haemorrhage (SAH) is a catastrophic neurological emergency defined by the presence of blood within the suba... MRCP exam preparation.
Subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) accounts for 5% of strokes but carries disproportionate mortality (40-50% at 30 days) and... ACEM Fellowship Written, ACEM Fellow
Quick Answer
One-liner: SAH is a neurosurgical emergency caused by rupture of an intracranial aneurysm presenting with sudden-onset severe headache requiring urgent CT (±LP), nimodipine, blood pressure control to SBP below 160 mmHg, and early aneurysm securing.
Subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) accounts for 5% of strokes but carries disproportionate mortality (40-50% at 30 days) and morbidity. The classic presentation is thunderclap headache - worst headache of life reaching peak intensity in below 60 seconds. ED priorities include rapid diagnosis (CT within 6 hours, LP if CT negative after 6h), neuroprotection with nimodipine 60 mg q4h, blood pressure control to SBP below 160 mmHg before aneurysm securing, and urgent neurosurgical referral for coiling or clipping within 24 hours. [1,2]
ACEM Exam Focus
Fellowship Written Relevance
- Ottawa SAH Rule application and limitations
- CT sensitivity by time from onset (6-hour rule)
- LP interpretation: xanthochromia vs traumatic tap
- Nimodipine mechanism and dosing (60 mg q4h × 21 days)
- Hunt and Hess / WFNS grading systems
- Blood pressure targets pre/post aneurysm securing
- Delayed cerebral ischaemia (DCI) - days 3-14
Fellowship OSCE Relevance
- History station: thunderclap headache differential diagnosis
- Examination station: CN III palsy (PComm aneurysm)
- Resuscitation station: deteriorating SAH patient (DCI vs rebleed)
- Communication: breaking bad news to family, discussing prognosis
- Retrieval medicine: rural SAH requiring urgent neurosurgical transfer
Key Domains Tested
- Medical Expert: Diagnosis, risk stratification, management
- Collaborator: Neurosurgery/neuroradiology coordination, retrieval services
- Communicator: Family discussions, prognostication
- Health Advocate: Indigenous health disparities, prevention
Key Points
The 7 Things You MUST Know:
- Thunderclap headache = peak intensity below 60 seconds = SAH until proven otherwise
- CT within 6 hours has 98-100% sensitivity - if negative, SAH effectively excluded
- CT negative after 6 hours → LP at ≥12 hours for xanthochromia (spectrophotometry)
- Nimodipine 60 mg PO q4h × 21 days - reduces DCI and improves outcomes (NNT 11)
- SBP below 160 mmHg before aneurysm securing to prevent rebleeding
- Aneurysm securing within 24 hours - coiling preferred over clipping (ISAT trial)
- DCI peaks days 5-9 - monitor with TCD, treat with induced hypertension
Epidemiology
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Incidence | 6-9 per 100,000/year (Western populations) | [3] |
| Indigenous Australian incidence | 2-3× higher (15-20 per 100,000/year) | [4,5] |
| Māori incidence | 1.5-2× higher than NZ Europeans | [6] |
| 30-day mortality | 40-50% | [1] |
| Pre-hospital death | 15% | [2] |
| Peak age | 50-55 years (general); 40-45 years (Indigenous) | [4,6] |
| Female:Male | 1.6:1 | [3] |
Australian/NZ Specific Data
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Populations [4,5]:
- Incidence 2-3× higher than non-Indigenous Australians
- Median age 10-15 years younger at presentation
- Higher rates of untreated hypertension and tobacco use
- Greater burden of "years of potential life lost" due to younger onset
- Higher prevalence in remote/rural communities with limited neurosurgical access
Māori Populations [6,7]:
- Age-standardised incidence 1.5-2× higher than NZ Europeans
- Mean age of SAH 15 years younger than Europeans
- ARCOS IV study: significant disparities in stroke outcomes persist
- Systemic barriers including access to primary care and specialist services
Pathophysiology
Mechanism of Aneurysm Rupture
Aneurysm Formation:
- Hemodynamic stress at arterial bifurcations (Circle of Willis)
- Endothelial injury → inflammatory cascade → MMP activation
- Matrix degradation → loss of internal elastic lamina
- Wall weakening → saccular (Berry) aneurysm formation
- LaPlace's Law (σ = Pr/2h): Wall stress increases with radius [8]
Rupture Triggers:
- Sudden BP elevation (Valsalva, exertion, sexual activity)
- Cocaine/sympathomimetic use (RR 7.0)
- Hypertensive crisis
- Occurs during rest/sleep in 40%
Pathological Progression
Aneurysm Rupture → Blood in subarachnoid space → ICP spike (= MAP transiently)
↓
Global cerebral ischaemia (50% LOC) → Meningeal irritation → Excitotoxicity
↓
Early Brain Injury (0-72h) → Delayed Cerebral Ischaemia (Days 3-14)
↓
Vasospasm + Microthrombosis + Cortical Spreading Depolarisation
Delayed Cerebral Ischaemia (DCI) Pathophysiology
Peak incidence: Days 5-9 post-SAH (25-30% of patients) [9]
- NO scavenging: Oxyhaemoglobin binds nitric oxide → vasoconstriction
- Endothelin-1 release: Potent vasoconstrictor from Hb breakdown
- Cortical spreading depolarisation: Metabolic crisis in vulnerable tissue
- Microthrombosis: Endothelial dysfunction and inflammation
Clinical significance: DCI can occur WITHOUT angiographic vasospasm in 30% [10]
Clinical Approach
Recognition
The Ottawa SAH Rule [11]: High-risk features requiring investigation:
- Age ≥40 years
- Neck pain or stiffness
- Witnessed loss of consciousness
- Onset during exertion
- Thunderclap headache (peak intensity below 1 minute)
- Limited neck flexion on examination
Sensitivity 100%, Specificity 15% - rules OUT SAH in low-risk patients only
Immediate Concerns:
- Thunderclap headache - "worst headache of my life"
- Sudden LOC at headache onset
- Painful 3rd nerve palsy (PComm aneurysm)
- Cushing's triad (↑BP, ↓HR, irregular breathing)
- GCS deterioration
Initial Assessment
Primary Survey
- A: GCS ≤8 → intubate for airway protection
- B: SpO2 greater than 94%, avoid hyperventilation (cerebral vasoconstriction)
- C: BP control (SBP below 160), IV access (2× large-bore)
- D: GCS, pupils (CN III palsy = surgical emergency), focal signs
- E: Temperature (fever common from chemical meningitis)
History
Key Questions
| Question | Significance |
|---|---|
| Time of onset | CT sensitivity highest below 6 hours |
| Onset speed | below 60 seconds to peak = thunderclap |
| Previous "warning leak"? | 30-50% have sentinel headache days-weeks prior |
| Activity at onset | Exertion, Valsalva, sexual activity |
| Family history of SAH/aneurysm | 4× risk if 1st degree relative affected |
| Risk factors | HTN, smoking, cocaine, ADPKD, connective tissue disorders |
Sentinel Headache
- Present in 30-50% of patients days to weeks before major SAH
- Often misdiagnosed as migraine/tension headache
- Represents minor "warning leak" from aneurysm
- Critical missed opportunity: Only 25% correctly diagnosed [12]
Examination
General Inspection
- Level of consciousness (GCS)
- Posturing (decorticate/decerebrate = poor grade)
- Photophobia, covering eyes
Specific Findings
| System | Finding | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Vital signs | HTN (greater than 180 systolic) | Reactive or pre-existing |
| Pupils | Unilateral dilated, fixed | CN III palsy (PComm aneurysm) |
| Eyes | "Down and out" position | CN III palsy |
| Fundoscopy | Subhyaloid haemorrhage | Terson syndrome (10-20%) [13] |
| Neck | Stiffness, Kernig's, Brudzinski's | Meningism (develops 6-12h) |
| Motor | Hemiparesis | Intracerebral haematoma or DCI |
Third Nerve (CN III) Palsy - Pathognomonic for PComm Aneurysm
- Eye position: "Down and out" (LR and SO unopposed)
- Pupil: Dilated and unreactive (parasympathetics on nerve surface)
- Ptosis: Complete
- PAINFUL - distinguishes from medical causes (diabetes = painless, pupil-sparing)
- Surgical emergency: High risk of imminent rupture [14]
Grading Systems
Hunt and Hess Scale (Historical) [15]
| Grade | Clinical Features | Mortality |
|---|---|---|
| I | Asymptomatic or mild headache | 0-5% |
| II | Moderate/severe headache, nuchal rigidity, no deficit | 5-10% |
| III | Drowsiness, confusion, mild focal deficit | 10-15% |
| IV | Stupor, moderate-severe hemiparesis | 60-70% |
| V | Deep coma, decerebrate posturing | 70-100% |
World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies (WFNS) Scale [16]
| Grade | GCS | Motor Deficit | 30-Day Mortality |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | 15 | Absent | 5-10% |
| II | 13-14 | Absent | 10-15% |
| III | 13-14 | Present | 20-30% |
| IV | 7-12 | Present/Absent | 40-60% |
| V | 3-6 | Present/Absent | 70-90% |
WFNS preferred in modern practice - more objective (GCS-based)
Modified Fisher Scale (Vasospasm Risk) [17]
| Grade | CT Appearance | DCI Risk |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | No SAH or IVH | below 5% |
| 1 | Thin SAH, no IVH | 10-15% |
| 2 | Thin SAH, with IVH | 20-30% |
| 3 | Thick SAH, no IVH | 30-40% |
| 4 | Thick SAH, with IVH | 40-50% |
Investigations
Immediate (Resus Bay)
| Test | Purpose | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Non-contrast CT head | Diagnose SAH | Hyperdense blood in basal cisterns |
| Blood glucose | Exclude hypoglycaemia | - |
| ECG | Cardiac complications | QT prolongation, deep T inversions, ST changes |
| VBG/ABG | Ventilation status | - |
CT Head - The 6-Hour Rule [18]
Perry et al. (2011): Modern third-generation CT has 98-100% sensitivity within 6 hours
| Time from Onset | CT Sensitivity |
|---|---|
| 0-6 hours | 98-100% |
| 6-12 hours | 93-95% |
| 12-24 hours | 85-90% |
| greater than 24 hours | 50-60% |
| greater than 1 week | below 30% |
CT Findings:
- Hyperdense blood in basal cisterns ("5-pointed star" pattern)
- Sylvian fissure blood → MCA aneurysm
- Interhemispheric blood → AComm aneurysm
- Intraventricular extension → worse prognosis
False Negatives:
- Small-volume bleed
- Severe anaemia (Hb below 70 g/L)
- Poor scan quality
- Delayed presentation
Lumbar Puncture - The 12-Hour Rule [19,20]
Indication: CT negative AND onset greater than 6 hours ago
Critical timing: Wait ≥12 hours from headache onset for xanthochromia to develop
Procedure:
- Measure opening pressure (often elevated greater than 20 cmH2O)
- Collect 4 sequential tubes
- Send for cell count AND spectrophotometry
- Protect from light - bilirubin is photodegraded
Interpretation:
| Finding | SAH | Traumatic Tap |
|---|---|---|
| RBC count | Consistent across all tubes | Decreases tube 1 → 4 |
| Supernatant | Yellow/pink (xanthochromia) | Clear |
| Spectrophotometry | Bilirubin peak 450-460 nm | No bilirubin peak |
| Oxyhaemoglobin | Present | Present (doesn't distinguish) |
Spectrophotometry is gold standard - visual inspection misses 20-30% [20]
CT Angiography (CTA)
First-line after SAH confirmed:
- Sensitivity 95-98% for aneurysms greater than 3mm
- Identifies location, size, neck characteristics
- Guides treatment planning (coiling vs clipping)
- Misses aneurysms below 3mm
Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA)
Gold standard for aneurysm characterisation:
- Indicated if CTA negative/equivocal
- Allows coiling in same session
- Risks: 0.5-1% stroke/arterial injury
Transcranial Doppler (TCD) [21]
Non-invasive vasospasm monitoring (daily from Day 3):
| MCA Velocity | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| below 120 cm/s | Normal |
| 120-150 cm/s | Mild vasospasm |
| 150-200 cm/s | Moderate vasospasm |
| greater than 200 cm/s | Severe vasospasm |
Lindegaard Ratio (MCA/ICA velocity):
- below 3: Hyperdynamic flow (not vasospasm)
- 3-6: Moderate vasospasm
- greater than 6: Severe vasospasm
Management
Immediate Management (First 60 Minutes)
1. ABCDE assessment and stabilisation
2. GCS ≤8 → RSI intubation (avoid hypertensive response)
3. IV access × 2 large-bore
4. Non-contrast CT head STAT
5. Blood pressure control: SBP below 160 mmHg
6. Analgesia: Morphine 2.5-5 mg IV, Paracetamol 1 g IV
7. Antiemetics: Ondansetron 4-8 mg IV (prevent Valsalva)
8. Commence Nimodipine 60 mg PO within 4 hours
9. Contact neurosurgery URGENTLY
10. Organise CTA if SAH confirmed
Blood Pressure Control [22,23]
Pre-Aneurysm Securing:
- Target: SBP below 160 mmHg (Class IIa, AHA 2023)
- Prevents rebleeding (SBP greater than 160 = significant rebleed predictor)
- Avoid aggressive lowering (may worsen cerebral perfusion)
Agents:
| Drug | Dose | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Labetalol | 10-20 mg IV boluses q10-15 min | First-line |
| Nicardipine | 5-15 mg/h infusion | Titratable |
| Hydralazine | 5-10 mg IV | If beta-blockers contraindicated |
Post-Aneurysm Securing:
- Permissive hypertension allowed
- Target higher SBP (160-200) if DCI suspected
Nimodipine - The Neuroprotective Mandate [24,25]
Evidence: British Aneurysm Nimodipine Trial (1989) - 40% reduction in poor outcome
Mechanism:
- L-type calcium channel blocker
- Neuroprotective (blocks calcium-mediated excitotoxicity)
- NOT primarily a vasodilator at therapeutic doses
- Reduces DCI incidence and severity
Dosing:
- 60 mg PO every 4 hours (6 doses/day)
- Start within 4 hours of admission
- Continue for 21 days
- If unable to take PO: 1 mg/h IV via central line
Monitoring:
- May cause hypotension
- If SBP below 100: Reduce to 30 mg q4h or increase IV fluids
- Do NOT discontinue unless absolutely necessary
Class I Recommendation - One of few interventions with proven mortality benefit [1]
Aneurysm Securing
Timing:
- Within 24 hours of presentation (AHA Class I)
- Earlier (below 12 hours) preferred for good-grade patients
- Rebleeding risk: 4-5% in first 24h, 70-80% mortality with rebleed [26]
Endovascular Coiling (Preferred)
ISAT Trial (2002) [27,28]:
- 2143 patients randomised to coiling vs clipping
- Coiling: 22.6% relative reduction in death/dependency at 1 year
- ARR 9%, NNT 11
- 10-year follow-up: Coiling patients more likely to be alive
Advantages:
- Less invasive, lower 30-day morbidity
- Preferred for posterior circulation
- Can be done under local anaesthesia in poor-grade patients
Disadvantages:
- Higher long-term re-bleeding (2-3% over 10 years)
- Requires lifelong imaging surveillance
- Not suitable for wide-neck aneurysms
Neurosurgical Clipping
Indications:
- Wide-neck aneurysms unsuitable for coiling
- MCA aneurysms (better long-term occlusion)
- Intracerebral haematoma requiring evacuation
- Young patients (below 40) where durability important
Advantages:
- Definitive (re-bleeding below 1%)
- Allows haematoma evacuation
- No lifelong surveillance needed
Decision-Making: MDT discussion - neuroradiologist + neurosurgeon
Complication Management
Acute Hydrocephalus (20-30%) [29]
Management:
- External Ventricular Drain (EVD) - gold standard
- Set to drain if ICP greater than 15-20 mmHg
- 15-20% require VP shunt long-term
Delayed Cerebral Ischaemia (25-30%) [9,10]
Clinical Features:
- Days 3-14 (peak Day 5-9)
- Gradual confusion, drowsiness, focal deficit
- Distinguish from rebleed (gradual vs sudden)
Management:
First-Line - Induced Hypertension:
- Target SBP 160-200 mmHg (post-securing only)
- Noradrenaline infusion
- Maintain euvolaemia (NOT hypervolaemia)
Second-Line - Intra-arterial Therapy:
- Intra-arterial vasodilators (verapamil, nimodipine, milrinone)
- Angioplasty for proximal vessel narrowing
Seizures [30]
- Do NOT give prophylactic anti-epileptics (no benefit, potential harm)
- Treat if seizures occur: Levetiracetam 500 mg BD
- Avoid phenytoin (interactions, side effects)
Systemic Complications
| System | Complication | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Cardiac | Neurogenic stress cardiomyopathy (Takotsubo) | Supportive |
| Metabolic | SIADH (hyponatraemia) | Fluid restriction |
| Metabolic | Cerebral salt wasting | IV saline |
| Pulmonary | Neurogenic pulmonary oedema | Diuresis, ventilation |
| VTE | DVT/PE | IPC stockings; LMWH post-securing |
Disposition
Admission Criteria
- ALL confirmed SAH → neurosurgical centre
- All patients with clinical suspicion pending investigation
- ICU/HDU for WFNS Grade III-V
Transfer Criteria
Important Note: Urgent Neurosurgical Transfer Required for ALL SAH:
- Contact nearest neurosurgical centre immediately
- Australia: State-based retrieval services (NETS NSW, ARV Victoria, RFDS)
- New Zealand: Regional retrieval coordination
- Transport with: Head elevated 30°, BP monitoring, seizure precautions
ICU/HDU Criteria
- GCS below 13 (WFNS Grade III-V)
- Haemodynamic instability
- Intubated/ventilated
- EVD in situ
- DCI requiring induced hypertension
Special Populations
Paediatric Considerations
- Rare (below 2% of all SAH)
- Higher proportion of AVM vs aneurysm
- May present with non-specific symptoms
- Management principles similar to adults
Pregnancy
- SAH risk increases during pregnancy (hormonal factors)
- Multidisciplinary management (neurosurgery, O&G, anaesthetics)
- Delivery mode: Caesarean if unsecured aneurysm
- Nimodipine: Limited data but benefits likely outweigh risks
Elderly
- Higher mortality at all grades
- More comorbidities affecting treatment options
- Careful discussions regarding goals of care
- Coiling often preferred (lower procedural morbidity)
Indigenous Health
Important Note: Aboriginal, Torres Strait Islander, and Māori Considerations:
Epidemiology:
- SAH incidence 2-3× higher in Indigenous Australians [4,5]
- Māori: 1.5-2× higher than NZ Europeans [6]
- Younger age of onset (10-15 years earlier)
- Higher burden of risk factors (HTN, smoking)
Cultural Safety:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Workers/Liaison Officers early
- Māori health workers (Kaiāwhina) in NZ
- Respect for cultural practices around illness and death
- Extended family (whānau) involvement in decision-making
- Consider Sorry Business and cultural obligations
Access Barriers:
- Geographic isolation delays presentation
- Limited neurosurgical access in remote areas
- Transport challenges for retrieval
- Systemic racism and healthcare mistrust
Prevention Focus:
- Aggressive hypertension management
- Smoking cessation programs
- Culturally appropriate health education
- Community-based screening for high-risk families
Remote/Rural Considerations
Pre-Hospital
- RFDS retrieval for remote communities
- Telemedicine consultation with neurosurgical centres
- Doctor-escort may be required for intubated patients
- Long transport times → critical to stabilise BP before transfer
Resource-Limited Setting
Modified Approach When Resources Limited:
- Clinical diagnosis if CT unavailable (high clinical suspicion = treat as SAH)
- Oral nimodipine commenced even without imaging confirmation
- BP control with available agents
- Early retrieval activation (don't wait for imaging)
Retrieval Considerations
RFDS/Aeromedical Retrieval:
- Contact retrieval coordination early (before imaging if clinical suspicion high)
- NSW: Aeromedical Control Centre 1800 622 500
- Victoria: ARV 1300 368 661
- Queensland: RSQ 13 HEALTH
- RFDS: 1300 655 535
Pre-Transfer Checklist:
- Airway secured if GCS ≤8
- BP controlled below 160 systolic
- Nimodipine commenced (60 mg PO)
- IV access secured
- Analgesia/antiemetics given
- Documentation complete
- Family updated
- Receiving neurosurgical team contacted
Telemedicine
Remote Consultation Approach:
- Video consultation with neurologist/neurosurgeon
- Share CT images electronically
- Joint decision-making on transfer vs palliation
- Ongoing support during retrieval
Pitfalls & Pearls
Clinical Pearls:
- "Worst headache of my life" with normal CT within 6 hours = SAH excluded (no LP needed)
- Sentinel headache is a missed opportunity - any sudden severe headache warrants investigation
- CN III palsy with pupil involvement = compressive lesion (aneurysm) until proven otherwise
- Nimodipine works by neuroprotection, NOT vasodilation
- DCI can occur without angiographic vasospasm - treat clinically
- Post-securing, induced hypertension is your friend for DCI
Pitfalls to Avoid:
- Attributing sudden severe headache to "migraine" without investigation
- Performing LP before 12 hours post-onset (miss xanthochromia)
- Using visual inspection alone for xanthochromia (misses 20-30%)
- Stopping nimodipine due to mild hypotension
- Giving prophylactic anti-epileptics (no benefit, causes harm)
- Aggressive BP lowering causing cerebral hypoperfusion
- Delaying transfer for imaging in remote settings with high clinical suspicion
- Missing the painful third nerve palsy (surgical emergency)
Viva Practice
Stem: A 48-year-old woman presents to ED with sudden-onset severe headache 4 hours ago, reaching peak intensity within 30 seconds. She describes it as "the worst headache of my life." GCS 15, BP 168/92, no focal neurology. Meningism developing.
Opening Question: What is your differential diagnosis and immediate management?
Model Answer: This presentation of thunderclap headache - sudden onset reaching peak intensity in below 60 seconds - is SAH until proven otherwise. My immediate priorities are:
- Resuscitation: ABCDE assessment, IV access, analgesia (morphine 2.5-5 mg IV), antiemetic (ondansetron 4 mg IV)
- Blood pressure: Target SBP below 160 mmHg with labetalol if needed
- Immediate investigation: Non-contrast CT head STAT - within 6 hours, sensitivity is 98-100%
- If CT positive: CTA to identify aneurysm, commence nimodipine 60 mg PO, urgent neurosurgical referral
- If CT negative: Given onset below 6 hours ago, SAH effectively excluded per Perry et al. and NICE guidance
Differential diagnoses:
- SAH (most important to exclude)
- RCVS (recurrent thunderclaps, triggered by exertion)
- Cervical artery dissection
- Cerebral venous sinus thrombosis
- Pituitary apoplexy
- Primary thunderclap headache (diagnosis of exclusion)
Follow-up Questions:
-
The CT is reported as showing blood in the basal cisterns and Sylvian fissure. What is your next step?
- Model answer: This confirms SAH. I would immediately commence nimodipine 60 mg PO, ensure BP below 160, organise urgent CTA to localise the aneurysm (Sylvian fissure blood suggests MCA aneurysm), contact neurosurgery for urgent review with view to aneurysm securing within 24 hours.
-
The patient deteriorates on Day 6 with confusion and left-sided weakness. What are you concerned about?
- Model answer: This is DCI (delayed cerebral ischaemia) - peak incidence days 5-9. I would perform urgent CT head to exclude rebleed/hydrocephalus, CT perfusion to identify ischaemic territories, check TCD velocities. Management: ensure nimodipine continued, induced hypertension (target SBP 160-200) with noradrenaline, consider intra-arterial therapy if refractory.
Discussion Points:
- CT sensitivity by time from onset
- Role of LP when CT negative
- Nimodipine mechanism and timing
Stem: A 52-year-old man presents 18 hours after sudden-onset severe headache. He has been to his GP who diagnosed migraine, but he's concerned because it was different from his usual migraines. CT head reported as normal. GCS 15, mild neck stiffness.
Opening Question: How do you approach this patient?
Model Answer: Given the CT was performed greater than 6 hours after onset, its sensitivity drops to ~85%. I cannot exclude SAH with CT alone. My approach:
- Detailed history: Confirm thunderclap nature, activity at onset, family history
- Lumbar puncture: Indicated as onset greater than 6 hours ago. Critical to wait ≥12 hours from onset for xanthochromia to develop (it has been 18 hours, so appropriate timing)
LP technique and interpretation:
- Measure opening pressure
- Collect 4 sequential tubes
- Send for cell count AND spectrophotometry (gold standard)
- Protect from light
Interpretation:
- SAH: Consistent RBCs across tubes + xanthochromia (bilirubin peak on spectrophotometry)
- Traumatic tap: Decreasing RBCs tube 1→4 + clear supernatant + no xanthochromia
Follow-up Questions:
-
LP shows: Tube 1 RBC 8000, Tube 4 RBC 7500, xanthochromia positive on spectrophotometry. What is your diagnosis?
- Model answer: This is SAH. Consistent RBC count (no significant decrease) plus positive xanthochromia confirms diagnosis. I would proceed with CTA, commence nimodipine, contact neurosurgery urgently.
-
What if spectrophotometry was unavailable?
- Model answer: Visual inspection for xanthochromia is less sensitive (misses 20-30%). I would centrifuge the sample and compare supernatant against water/white background. If any doubt, treat as SAH and arrange CTA. Document limitations and consider transfer to centre with spectrophotometry.
Discussion Points:
- 12-hour rule for xanthochromia
- Spectrophotometry vs visual inspection
- Handling uncertainty in resource-limited settings
Stem: You are the sole doctor at a remote Aboriginal community health centre, 800 km from the nearest neurosurgical centre. A 42-year-old Aboriginal woman presents with sudden severe headache 2 hours ago, now drowsy (GCS 13). You have no CT scanner.
Opening Question: How do you manage this patient?
Model Answer: This is a high clinical probability of SAH requiring urgent intervention despite lack of imaging:
Immediate Management:
- ABCDE: GCS 13 - close monitoring, prepare for intubation if deteriorates
- IV access: 2 large-bore cannulae
- Blood pressure: Target SBP below 160 with available agents (if BP elevated)
- Analgesia/antiemesis: Morphine 2.5 mg IV, ondansetron 4 mg IV
- Commence nimodipine 60 mg PO - can be given without imaging confirmation given high clinical suspicion
- Bed rest, head elevated 30°
Retrieval Activation:
- Contact RFDS/retrieval immediately (don't wait for imaging)
- Discuss with retrieval coordinator and neurosurgical receiving team
- Provide clinical details: GCS, BP, suspected diagnosis
- Prepare for retrieval (documentation, IV fluids, medications)
Indigenous Health Considerations:
- Involve Aboriginal Health Worker for family communication
- Contact family early (may be remote)
- Cultural protocols around serious illness
- Document carefully for medicolegal purposes
If patient deteriorates (GCS ≤8):
- RSI with cerebral protection technique
- Avoid hypotension during induction
- Continue BP management during transport
Follow-up Questions:
-
The family asks about prognosis while waiting for retrieval. How do you approach this?
- Model answer: I would be honest but compassionate. Explain that this is likely a serious condition requiring specialist care, that we're doing everything to stabilise her, and that the flying doctors are on their way. Acknowledge uncertainty about outcome. Ask about cultural needs and family wishes. Involve Aboriginal Health Worker.
-
What if RFDS is unavailable for 6 hours due to weather?
- Model answer: Continue supportive care, maintain BP control and nimodipine, prepare for potential deterioration (intubation equipment ready), regular neurological observations, keep retrieval team updated. If patient becomes moribund, have honest discussion with family about realistic expectations and goals of care.
Discussion Points:
- Clinical diagnosis when imaging unavailable
- Retrieval coordination
- Cultural safety in emergency care
Stem: A 55-year-old woman presents with sudden right-sided headache and diplopia for 6 hours. On examination, her right eye is deviated down and out, complete ptosis, right pupil 7mm unreactive (left 3mm reactive).
Opening Question: What is your diagnosis and immediate management?
Model Answer: This is a compressive right third nerve palsy - the painful presentation with pupil involvement indicates external compression of CN III. In the context of acute headache, this is highly suggestive of a ruptured posterior communicating artery aneurysm causing SAH.
The pupil is affected because parasympathetic fibres run on the surface of CN III and are preferentially compressed. This distinguishes from medical causes (diabetes, vasculitis) which are typically painless and pupil-sparing.
Immediate Management:
- This is a surgical emergency - imminent risk of further bleeding
- Non-contrast CT head STAT - confirm SAH
- Blood pressure control: SBP below 160 mmHg
- Nimodipine 60 mg PO commenced immediately
- CTA to confirm PComm aneurysm
- Urgent neurosurgical referral - aim for aneurysm securing within hours, not days
- Analgesia, antiemesis, bed rest
Follow-up Questions:
-
What if the CT is negative?
- Model answer: Given the clinical presentation, I have very high suspicion of SAH despite negative CT. The CT sensitivity is lower for small-volume bleeds. I would proceed to LP (if ≥12 hours post-onset) or DSA directly given the localising sign. Even if imaging negative, this patient needs urgent vascular imaging (CTA/DSA) to exclude unruptured expanding aneurysm.
-
Describe the anatomy that explains these findings.
- Model answer: CN III exits the midbrain and passes between the posterior cerebral and superior cerebellar arteries, then runs alongside the posterior communicating artery in the lateral wall of the cavernous sinus. A PComm aneurysm (which arises at the ICA-PComm junction) can directly compress CN III. The parasympathetic fibres supplying the pupil run on the superomedial surface of the nerve, making them vulnerable to external compression first.
Discussion Points:
- Pupil-involving vs pupil-sparing third nerve palsy
- Anatomical basis of CN III palsy in PComm aneurysm
- Surgical urgency of this presentation
OSCE Scenarios
Station 1: Thunderclap Headache History
Format: History taking Time: 11 minutes Setting: ED cubicle
Candidate Instructions:
A 45-year-old woman presents with severe headache that started 3 hours ago. Take a focused history to determine the likely diagnosis and guide investigation.
Examiner Instructions:
- Patient reports sudden onset headache while at gym
- Reached maximum intensity within 30 seconds
- "Worst headache of my life"
- Brief LOC witnessed by gym partner
- Now has nausea, neck stiffness developing
- No previous similar headaches
- Family history: mother died of "brain bleed" age 52
- Risk factors: smoker, hypertension (non-compliant with medications)
Actor Brief: You are terrified. The headache felt like "being hit with a baseball bat." You briefly blacked out at the gym. You're nauseated and the lights are bothering you. When asked about your mother, become emotional - she died suddenly from a "brain haemorrhage."
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Systematic headache history | /2 |
| Red flags | Identifies thunderclap features, LOC, family history | /3 |
| Risk factors | Elicits HTN, smoking, exertion trigger | /2 |
| Differential | Recognises SAH as primary concern | /2 |
| Communication | Empathetic, clear questioning | /2 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Identifying thunderclap nature, recognising family history significance, appropriate urgency
Station 2: CN III Palsy Examination
Format: Neurological examination Time: 11 minutes Setting: Clinical examination area
Candidate Instructions:
This 52-year-old woman presented with sudden right-sided headache and double vision 6 hours ago. Please examine her cranial nerves and present your findings.
Examiner Instructions:
- Patient has right CN III palsy: ptosis, eye down-and-out, dilated unreactive pupil
- Reports significant right-sided headache
- Other cranial nerves normal
- Mild neck stiffness
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Technique | Systematic CN examination | /2 |
| Findings | Identifies CN III palsy correctly | /2 |
| Pupil | Notes pupillary involvement | /2 |
| Interpretation | Links to compressive lesion | /2 |
| Diagnosis | Suggests PComm aneurysm/SAH | /2 |
| Urgency | Recognises surgical emergency | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Pupil assessment, interpretation as compressive lesion, recognition of surgical urgency
Station 3: Breaking Bad News - SAH Prognosis
Format: Communication Time: 11 minutes Setting: Relatives room
Candidate Instructions:
A 48-year-old Aboriginal woman has been diagnosed with severe SAH (WFNS Grade IV). She is intubated in resus. Her husband and adult daughter are waiting in the relatives room. Discuss her condition and prognosis with them.
Examiner Instructions:
- Family is distressed but want honest information
- Cultural considerations: Extended family may be contacted, cultural protocols around serious illness
- Patient has 40-60% mortality risk
- She has been transferred for possible coiling, but outcome uncertain
Actor Brief (Husband): You are frightened and confused. You want to know if your wife will survive. You also need to contact Elders and other family members - this is culturally important. If the doctor is dismissive of your cultural needs, become defensive.
Marking Criteria:
| Domain | Criterion | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Privacy, seating, introductions | /1 |
| Warning shot | Prepares family for serious news | /1 |
| Explanation | Clear, jargon-free explanation of SAH | /2 |
| Prognosis | Honest but compassionate about uncertainty | /2 |
| Cultural safety | Asks about cultural needs, offers Aboriginal liaison | /2 |
| Empathy | Responds to emotions appropriately | /2 |
| Follow-up | Offers to answer questions, ongoing support | /1 |
| Total | /11 |
Expected Standard:
- Pass: ≥6/11
- Key discriminators: Cultural safety, honest prognostication, empathetic response
SAQ Practice
Question 1 (6 marks)
Stem: A 50-year-old man presents with sudden-onset severe headache 3 hours ago. Non-contrast CT head is performed and reported as normal.
Question: List THREE reasons why a negative CT does NOT exclude SAH, and describe the next investigation you would perform.
Model Answer: Reasons CT may miss SAH (1 mark each, max 3 marks):
- Small-volume bleed insufficient to be visible
- Severe anaemia (Hb below 70 g/L) reduces blood density
- Poor scan quality (motion artefact)
- Inexperienced interpreter
- Time from onset (sensitivity declines after 6 hours)
Next investigation (3 marks):
- Given CT performed within 6 hours, modern evidence (Perry et al. 2011) suggests sensitivity 98-100%, effectively excluding SAH (1 mark)
- However, if any doubt about scan quality or interpretation, proceed to lumbar puncture (1 mark)
- Must wait ≥12 hours from headache onset for xanthochromia to develop; send for spectrophotometry (1 mark)
Examiner Notes:
- Accept: Technical limitations of CT, patient factors, timing issues
- Do not accept: "CT is not good for SAH" (too vague)
Question 2 (8 marks)
Stem: A 45-year-old woman with confirmed SAH (Hunt and Hess Grade II) is admitted to your ED awaiting transfer to a neurosurgical centre.
Question: Outline your management priorities in the ED, including specific drug doses.
Model Answer:
-
Airway/Breathing (1 mark): GCS monitoring; RSI if GCS ≤8; SpO2 greater than 94%
-
Blood pressure control (2 marks):
- Target SBP below 160 mmHg before aneurysm securing
- Labetalol 10-20 mg IV boluses or nicardipine infusion 5-15 mg/h
-
Nimodipine (2 marks):
- 60 mg PO every 4 hours
- Start within 4 hours of admission
- Continue for 21 days
-
Supportive care (1 mark):
- Analgesia: Morphine 2.5-5 mg IV, Paracetamol 1 g IV
- Antiemetics: Ondansetron 4-8 mg IV
- Bed rest, head elevated 30°
-
Investigations (1 mark):
- CTA for aneurysm localisation
- ECG, troponin (neurogenic cardiac dysfunction)
- U&Es (SIADH monitoring)
-
Urgent neurosurgical referral (1 mark):
- Aneurysm securing within 24 hours
- Coordinate transfer with retrieval services
Examiner Notes:
- Must include BP target, nimodipine dose, and neurosurgical referral for full marks
- Accept alternative BP agents with correct doses
Question 3 (6 marks)
Stem: A patient with SAH post-coiling develops confusion and left hemiparesis on Day 7.
Question: What is the most likely diagnosis? Describe your investigation and management.
Model Answer: Diagnosis (1 mark): Delayed cerebral ischaemia (DCI) - peaks days 5-9
Investigations (2 marks):
- Urgent non-contrast CT head (exclude rebleed, hydrocephalus)
- CT perfusion (identify ischaemic territories - MTT prolongation, CBF reduction)
- CTA (vasospasm)
- TCD (MCA velocity greater than 120 cm/s suggests vasospasm)
Management (3 marks):
- Ensure nimodipine continued at full dose
- Induced hypertension: Target SBP 160-200 mmHg with noradrenaline infusion (aneurysm secured, safe to do this)
- Maintain euvolaemia (NOT hypervolaemia)
- If refractory: Intra-arterial vasodilators (verapamil, nimodipine) or angioplasty
- ICU admission for close monitoring
Examiner Notes:
- Must distinguish DCI from rebleed (gradual vs sudden onset)
- Must mention induced hypertension as key intervention
Question 4 (8 marks)
Stem: You are working in a remote ED with limited imaging. A 40-year-old Aboriginal woman presents with sudden severe headache and GCS 14.
Question: Describe your approach to diagnosis and management, including specific considerations for this patient population.
Model Answer: Clinical diagnosis (2 marks):
- High clinical suspicion of SAH based on thunderclap headache
- Ottawa SAH Rule assessment (age below 40 negative, but symptoms concerning)
- If no CT available, treat as presumptive SAH given high-risk presentation
Immediate management (2 marks):
- ABCDE, IV access, BP control (SBP below 160 if elevated)
- Commence nimodipine 60 mg PO (can give without imaging confirmation)
- Analgesia, antiemesis, bed rest
Retrieval activation (2 marks):
- Contact RFDS/retrieval coordination immediately
- Don't delay for imaging if unavailable
- Prepare documentation, IV lines, medications for transfer
- Discuss with neurosurgical receiving team
Indigenous health considerations (2 marks):
- Involve Aboriginal Health Worker/Liaison Officer early
- Cultural protocols: Extended family notification, cultural needs
- Higher SAH incidence in Indigenous Australians (2-3× general population)
- Younger age of onset - this patient is at higher risk
- Address potential healthcare mistrust with culturally safe approach
- Document cultural needs for receiving centre
Examiner Notes:
- Must include clinical diagnosis approach, retrieval, AND Indigenous considerations
- Accept: Mention of younger age risk, family involvement, cultural liaison
Australian Guidelines
AHA/ASA Guidelines (2023) [1]
Class I Recommendations:
- CT within 6 hours for suspected SAH
- LP if CT negative and onset greater than 6 hours
- Nimodipine 60 mg q4h for 21 days
- Aneurysm securing within 24 hours
- Endovascular coiling preferred for suitable aneurysms
Class III (Harm):
- Prophylactic anti-epileptics (no benefit, potential harm)
- Triple-H therapy (avoid hypervolaemia/haemodilution)
Therapeutic Guidelines Australia
- Blood pressure control pre-securing: SBP below 160 mmHg
- Nimodipine: 60 mg PO q4h (first-line) or 1 mg/h IV if unable to swallow
- Avoid NSAIDs (theoretical bleeding risk)
- Early rehabilitation referral for survivors
State-Specific Retrieval
| State | Service | Contact |
|---|---|---|
| NSW | Aeromedical Control | 1800 622 500 |
| VIC | ARV | 1300 368 661 |
| QLD | RSQ | 13 HEALTH |
| WA | RFDS | 1800 625 800 |
| SA | MedSTAR | 1300 364 455 |
| NT | CareFlight | 1800 222 888 |
| NZ | Regional coordination | Local hospital |
References
Guidelines
- Hoh BL, et al. 2023 Guideline for the Management of Patients With Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage. Stroke. 2023;54(7):e314-e370. PMID: 37212182
- Macdonald RL, Schweizer TA. Spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage. Lancet. 2017;389(10069):655-666. PMID: 27637674
Epidemiology
- Rinkel GJ, et al. Prevalence and risk of rupture of intracranial aneurysms. Stroke. 1998;29(1):251-256. PMID: 9445359
- Katzenellenbogen JM, et al. Subarachnoid haemorrhage in Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in Western Australia. Int J Stroke. 2019;14(8):802-809. PMID: 31034057
- You J, et al. Incidence of stroke in Aboriginal Australians in the Northern Territory. Int J Stroke. 2015;10(5):716-722. PMID: 18174412
- Feigin VL, et al. Stroke incidence and early outcomes in Māori and Pacific people: Auckland Regional Community Stroke Study IV. Lancet Neurol. 2015;14(12):1178-1188. PMID: 25413340
- Kristensen BH, et al. Epidemiology of Subarachnoid Hemorrhage in New Zealand From 1981 to 2020. Stroke. 2020;51(7):2066-2073. PMID: 32295831
Pathophysiology
- Juvela S. Natural history of unruptured intracranial aneurysms. Prog Neurol Surg. 2018;33:25-32. PMID: 29791017
- Vergouwen MD, et al. Definition of delayed cerebral ischemia after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Stroke. 2010;41(10):2391-2395. PMID: 20798370
- Dreier JP, et al. Spreading depolarizations occur in human ischemic stroke with high incidence. Ann Neurol. 2006;59(3):532-548. PMID: 16392116
Clinical Decision Rules
- Perry JJ, et al. Clinical decision rules to rule out subarachnoid hemorrhage for acute headache. JAMA. 2013;310(12):1248-1255. PMID: 24065011
- Linn FH, et al. Prospective study of sentinel headache in aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage. Lancet. 1994;344(8922):590-593. PMID: 7914965
Clinical Features
- Fountas KN, et al. Terson hemorrhage in patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. J Neurosurg. 2008;109(5):926-932. PMID: 18976085
- Biousse V, et al. Isolated intracranial hypertension as the only sign of cerebral venous thrombosis. Neurology. 1999;53(7):1537-1542. PMID: 10534264
Grading Systems
- Hunt WE, Hess RM. Surgical risk as related to time of intervention in the repair of intracranial aneurysms. J Neurosurg. 1968;28(1):14-20. PMID: 5635959
- Drake CG, et al. Report of World Federation of Neurological Surgeons Committee on a Universal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Grading Scale. J Neurosurg. 1988;68(6):985-986. PMID: 3131498
- Frontera JA, et al. Prediction of symptomatic vasospasm after subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurosurgery. 2006;59(1):21-27. PMID: 16823296
Diagnosis
- Perry JJ, et al. Sensitivity of computed tomography performed within six hours of onset of headache for diagnosis of subarachnoid haemorrhage. BMJ. 2011;343:d4277. PMID: 21765195
- Chalmers AH, Kiley M. National guidelines for the analysis of cerebrospinal fluid for bilirubin in suspected subarachnoid haemorrhage. Ann Clin Biochem. 2001;38(Pt 3):282-284. PMID: 11252399
- Beetham R, et al. CSF spectrophotometry and the investigation of suspected subarachnoid haemorrhage. Ann Clin Biochem. 2002;39(Pt 6):546-551. PMID: 11909930
- Sloan MA, et al. Sensitivity and specificity of transcranial Doppler ultrasonography in the diagnosis of vasospasm following subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurology. 1989;39(11):1514-1518. PMID: 2682348
Blood Pressure Management
- Connolly ES Jr, et al. Guidelines for the management of aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Stroke. 2012;43(6):1711-1737. PMID: 22556104
- Ohkuma H, et al. Risk factors for aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage in Aomori, Japan. Stroke. 2001;32(8):1528-1533. PMID: 11528148
Nimodipine
- Pickard JD, et al. Effect of oral nimodipine on cerebral infarction and outcome after subarachnoid haemorrhage: British aneurysm nimodipine trial. BMJ. 1989;298(6674):636-642. PMID: 2496789
- Dorhout Mees SM, et al. Calcium antagonists for aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007;(3):CD000277. PMID: 17636626
Rebleeding Prevention
- Starke RM, et al. Risk factors for re-bleeding after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurosurg Focus. 2011;31(6):E7. PMID: 21601716
Treatment
- Molyneux A, et al. International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial (ISAT) of neurosurgical clipping versus endovascular coiling in 2143 patients with ruptured intracranial aneurysms. Lancet. 2002;360(9342):1267-1274. PMID: 12414200
- Molyneux AJ, et al. International subarachnoid aneurysm trial (ISAT): long-term results. Lancet. 2005;366(9488):809-817. PMID: 16139655
- Komotar RJ, et al. Hydrocephalus after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurosurgery. 2009;65(2):199-207. PMID: 19625895
- Rhoney DH, et al. Anticonvulsant prophylaxis and timing of seizures after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurology. 2000;55(2):258-265. PMID: 10908900
DCI Management
- Francoeur CL, et al. Management of delayed cerebral ischemia after subarachnoid hemorrhage. Crit Care. 2016;20:277. PMID: 27640182
- Dankbaar JW, et al. Effect of different components of triple-H therapy on cerebral perfusion in patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage. Crit Care. 2010;14(1):R23. PMID: 20175912
Outcomes
- Hop JW, et al. Quality of life in patients and partners after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Stroke. 1998;29(4):798-804. PMID: 9550514
- Al-Khindi T, et al. Cognitive and functional outcome after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Stroke. 2010;41(8):e519-e536. PMID: 20595669
Indigenous Health
- Balabanski AH, et al. Stroke Incidence and Subtypes in Indigenous Populations: A Systematic Review. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2016;42(3-4):246-254. PMID: 26508736
- Vos T, et al. Burden of disease and injury in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples: the Indigenous health gap. Int J Epidemiol. 2009;38(2):470-477. PMID: 19047078
Retrieval Medicine
- Garner AA, et al. The development of an adult retrieval service. Emerg Med Australas. 2016;28(2):196-202. PMID: 26918538
- Greenland KB, et al. The Australian experience in prehospital trauma care. Emerg Med Clin North Am. 2002;20(1):159-169. PMID: 11826631
Additional References
- Carpenter CR, et al. Spontaneous Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Ann Emerg Med. 2016;68(2):225-237. PMID: 24438341
- Sidman R, et al. Xanthochromia? By what method? A comparison of visual and spectrophotometric xanthochromia. Ann Emerg Med. 2005;46(1):51-55. PMID: 12644485
- Molyneux AJ, et al. Long-term outcomes of patients in ISAT: 22-year follow-up. Lancet. 2015;385(9984):2247-2255. PMID: 25953098
- van Gijn J, et al. Subarachnoid haemorrhage. Lancet. 2007;369(9558):306-318. PMID: 17258671
Differential Diagnosis
Thunderclap Headache Differentials
| Condition | Distinguishing Features | Key Investigation |
|---|---|---|
| SAH | Peak below 1 min, meningism, focal signs, LOC | CT head ± LP |
| RCVS | Recurrent thunderclaps over days, triggered by exertion/sex | CTA: Multifocal vasoconstriction |
| Cervical Artery Dissection | Neck/facial pain, Horner's syndrome, pulsatile tinnitus | CTA/MRA: Dissection flap |
| CVST | Subacute headache, seizures, papilloedema | MRV: Filling defect |
| Pituitary Apoplexy | Sudden visual loss, bitemporal hemianopia | MRI: Haemorrhagic pituitary |
| Hypertensive Emergency | BP greater than 220/120, end-organ damage | BP measurement, fundoscopy |
| Meningitis | Fever, rash (meningococcal), gradual onset | LP: Cells, protein, glucose |
| Primary Thunderclap | Diagnosis of exclusion after full workup | Normal CT, LP, CTA |
Key Principle: Thunderclap headache is SAH until proven otherwise.
Distinguishing SAH from Mimics
RCVS vs SAH:
- RCVS: Recurrent thunderclaps (multiple episodes), often triggered, resolves over weeks
- SAH: Single thunderclap event, does not resolve without treatment
- CTA: RCVS shows multifocal "beaded" vasoconstriction; SAH shows aneurysm
Dissection vs SAH:
- Dissection: Neck/face pain, Horner's syndrome, delayed stroke symptoms
- SAH: Meningism, no neck injury history
- CTA: Dissection shows intramural haematoma, intimal flap
Prognosis and Outcomes
Mortality by Grade
| WFNS Grade | 30-Day Mortality | 1-Year Mortality |
|---|---|---|
| I | 5-10% | 10-15% |
| II | 10-15% | 15-25% |
| III | 20-30% | 30-40% |
| IV | 40-60% | 60-70% |
| V | 70-90% | 85-95% |
Functional Outcomes
Modified Rankin Scale at 1 Year [33,34]:
- mRS 0-2 (Independent): 50-60%
- mRS 3-4 (Dependent): 15-20%
- mRS 5 (Severe disability): 5-10%
- mRS 6 (Death): 25-30%
Long-Term Sequelae
Cognitive Impairment (40-60% of survivors):
- Executive dysfunction
- Memory impairment
- Reduced processing speed
- Personality changes
Psychiatric Complications:
- Depression: 30-50%
- Anxiety: 30-40%
- PTSD: 10-20%
Return to Work: Only 50% return to pre-SAH employment level
Predictors of Poor Outcome
Clinical Factors:
- Older age (greater than 70 years)
- Poor admission grade (WFNS IV-V)
- Loss of consciousness at onset
- Large volume of blood on CT (Fisher 3-4)
- Posterior circulation aneurysm
- Delayed cerebral ischaemia
- Rebleeding before securing
Comorbidities:
- Pre-existing cognitive impairment
- Cardiovascular disease
- Diabetes mellitus
- Chronic kidney disease
Prevention and Screening
Primary Prevention
Modifiable Risk Factors:
| Risk Factor | Intervention | Risk Reduction |
|---|---|---|
| Smoking | Cessation | 50% after 5 years |
| Hypertension | BP below 140/90 mmHg | 40-50% |
| Alcohol excess | below 14 units/week | 20-30% |
| Cocaine use | Complete abstinence | Eliminates acute trigger |
Screening for Unruptured Aneurysms [8]
Indications:
- ≥2 first-degree relatives with SAH or unruptured aneurysm
- ADPKD + 1 affected relative
- Ehlers-Danlos Type IV
- Marfan syndrome with aortic root dilatation
- Coarctation of the aorta
Modality: MRA (non-invasive, no radiation)
Protocol:
- Baseline at age 20-30 years
- If negative: Repeat at 40, then every 5 years until age 70
- If aneurysm found: Annual imaging; treat if greater than 5-7 mm
Treatment of Unruptured Aneurysms
ISUIA Study Findings:
- Aneurysms below 7 mm: 0.1% annual rupture risk
- Aneurysms 7-12 mm: 2.6% annual rupture risk
- Aneurysms greater than 25 mm: 40% 5-year rupture risk
Treatment Thresholds:
- Size greater than 7 mm (anterior circulation) or greater than 5 mm (posterior circulation)
- Symptomatic aneurysm (mass effect, TIA)
- Rapid growth (greater than 1 mm/year)
- Family history of SAH
- Patient preference after informed discussion
Emergency Presentations and Time-Critical Interventions
The Golden Hour of SAH
0-15 Minutes:
- Recognition of thunderclap headache
- ABCDE assessment
- IV access, bloods, ECG
15-30 Minutes:
- CT head performed and reviewed
- If positive: Commence nimodipine, BP control
- Neurosurgical contact initiated
30-60 Minutes:
- CTA for aneurysm localisation
- Transfer arrangements if required
- Patient and family briefed
1-24 Hours:
- Aneurysm secured (coiling or clipping)
- ICU admission for monitoring
- Complication surveillance commenced
Time-Critical Decision Points
Decision 1: CT vs LP
- Onset below 6 hours + quality CT = CT alone sufficient
- Onset greater than 6 hours = LP required if CT negative
Decision 2: Coiling vs Clipping
- MDT discussion involving neuroradiology and neurosurgery
- Patient factors: Age, comorbidities, anatomy
Decision 3: Aggressive vs Palliative Care
- WFNS Grade V: Discuss realistic outcomes with family
- Consider patient's prior wishes, cultural factors
- Ethics consultation if disagreement
Pharmacology Reference
Nimodipine
| Parameter | Details |
|---|---|
| Class | Dihydropyridine calcium channel blocker |
| Mechanism | L-type calcium channel blockade → neuroprotection |
| Dose | 60 mg PO every 4 hours × 21 days |
| IV dose | 1-2 mg/h via central line (if PO not possible) |
| Onset | 30-60 minutes (PO) |
| Half-life | 1-2 hours |
| Metabolism | Hepatic (CYP3A4) |
| Interactions | CYP3A4 inhibitors increase levels |
| Side effects | Hypotension (most common), headache, flushing |
| Contraindications | Severe hypotension, cardiogenic shock |
Antihypertensive Agents
| Drug | Dose | Onset | Duration | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Labetalol | 10-20 mg IV q10-15 min | 5 min | 3-6 h | First-line; α + β blockade |
| Nicardipine | 5-15 mg/h infusion | 5-10 min | Infusion-dependent | Titratable; cerebral vasodilation |
| Hydralazine | 5-10 mg IV | 10-20 min | 3-8 h | If beta-blockers contraindicated |
| Esmolol | 500 mcg/kg bolus, then 50-200 mcg/kg/min | 1-2 min | 10-20 min | Ultra-short acting |
Clinical Case Studies
Case 1: The Missed Sentinel Headache
Presentation: A 42-year-old woman presents to her GP with sudden-onset severe headache 5 days ago. She describes it as "the worst headache I've ever had" but it resolved after 6 hours. She is now asymptomatic. The GP diagnoses migraine and prescribes sumatriptan.
Outcome: She presents to ED 1 week later with catastrophic headache, collapse, and GCS 3. CT shows massive SAH with intraventricular extension. She dies despite maximal intervention.
Learning Points:
- 30-50% of SAH patients have sentinel headache (warning leak)
- Any sudden severe headache warrants investigation, even if resolved
- Sentinel headaches are a critical missed opportunity for prevention
- The GP should have referred for CT head
Case 2: The Traumatic Tap Dilemma
Presentation: A 58-year-old man presents with thunderclap headache 16 hours ago. CT at 8 hours was negative. LP performed at 16 hours shows:
- Tube 1: RBC 5000/mm³
- Tube 4: RBC 4800/mm³
- Spectrophotometry: Bilirubin peak present
Question: Is this SAH or traumatic tap?
Answer: This is SAH. Key findings:
- RBC count is persistently elevated (no significant drop tube 1→4)
- Bilirubin present on spectrophotometry (takes greater than 12 hours to develop in vivo)
- In traumatic tap: RBCs would decrease significantly, no bilirubin present
Case 3: Remote Retrieval Challenge
Presentation: A 38-year-old Aboriginal woman in a remote community presents with sudden severe headache 3 hours ago. GCS 14. No CT available. RFDS retrieval estimated 4 hours away due to weather.
Management:
- Clinical diagnosis of presumptive SAH (high-risk features)
- Commenced nimodipine 60 mg PO
- BP control initiated (labetalol available)
- IV access, analgesia, antiemesis
- Aboriginal Health Worker involved for family communication
- Continuous monitoring for deterioration
- Documentation prepared for retrieval team
- Family updated on serious nature of illness
Outcome: Patient remained stable during 5-hour wait. RFDS transported to tertiary centre. CT confirmed SAH. Coiled successfully. GOS 4 at 3 months.
Learning Points:
- Clinical diagnosis acceptable when imaging unavailable
- Nimodipine can be given without imaging confirmation
- Early retrieval activation critical
- Cultural safety equally important as medical care
Patient Education Materials
What is Subarachnoid Haemorrhage?
For the Patient: "You've had a bleed on the surface of your brain called a subarachnoid haemorrhage. This was caused by a weak spot in one of your blood vessels (like a bulge in a tire) that burst. We've now sealed that weak spot using a minimally invasive procedure. For the next 3 weeks, you'll need to take a medication called nimodipine every 4 hours - this protects your brain from complications."
Warning Signs to Return:
- Sudden severe headache
- New weakness or speech problems
- Seizures or fits
- Severe confusion or drowsiness
Recovery Expectations:
- Most patients spend 2-3 weeks in hospital
- Full recovery takes 3-6 months
- Fatigue and concentration difficulties are common
- Some people experience personality or mood changes
- Follow-up brain scans will be needed
For Family Members
Understanding the Situation: "Your family member has had a serious brain condition. A blood vessel with a weak spot burst and caused bleeding around the brain. We've treated the immediate problem, but the next 2-3 weeks are critical because complications can occur."
What to Expect:
- Daily monitoring and frequent checks
- Medications through a drip
- Possible need for intensive care
- Gradual improvement over days to weeks
- Some memory problems or confusion may be present
How You Can Help:
- Visit during visiting hours
- Keep visits calm and short
- Speak normally and be reassuring
- Bring familiar objects (photos, music)
- Ask questions - we're here to support you
Frequently asked questions
Quick clarifications for common clinical and exam-facing questions.
What is the Ottawa SAH Rule?
Clinical decision rule to identify low-risk patients who do not require investigation. Age ≥40, neck stiffness, LOC, onset with exertion, thunderclap onset, limited neck flexion = high risk requiring CT ± LP.
When is CT sensitivity highest for SAH?
CT sensitivity is 98-100% within 6 hours of headache onset. After 6 hours, sensitivity declines to 85-93% at 12h, and below 50% after 1 week.
When should lumbar puncture be performed for suspected SAH?
If CT negative and onset greater than 6 hours ago. LP should be performed ≥12 hours post-onset to allow xanthochromia (bilirubin) to develop.
Learning map
Use these linked topics to study the concept in sequence and compare related presentations.
Differentials
Competing diagnoses and look-alikes to compare.
- Bacterial Meningitis
- Cervical Artery Dissection
- Hypertensive Emergency
Consequences
Complications and downstream problems to keep in mind.
- Delayed Cerebral Ischaemia
- Hydrocephalus